Congress Pushing for Federal Reserve Audit
ATLANTA- A majority of the U.S.
House of Representatives is now in support of a historic bill by
Republican lawmaker Ron Paul to audit the Federal Reserve (the Fed),
the privately run central bank that sets monetary policy for the United
A similar bill in the
U.S. Senate was proposed by Democratic Socialist Sen. Bernie Sanders,
and has three right-wing Republican co-sponsors.
a House committee recently approved an amendment offered by
left-leaning Democrat Dennis Kucinich to a bill granting more oversight
to the Government Accountability Office, which would audit the Fed's
response to the economic crisis specifically.
Notably, the amendment passed committee unanimously, with broad bipartisan support, and now heads to the full House for action.
Fed has taken a number of extraordinary and unprecedented steps to
address the financial crisis," Kucinich told IPS in an email. "In so
doing, it has committed over one trillion dollars to the purchase and
financing of many different kinds of assets. It has selectively
intervened in certain economic sectors, while it has ignored others."
of these interventions mark a departure from traditional monetary
policy, raise significant public policy questions, and impact taxpayers
considerably," Kucinich said.
Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke is "not
revealing what they did with the two trillion dollars they created on
their books. It was loans to banks for sure. There have been several
actions under the Freedom of Information Act to get them to say who
they were to and what the terms were, but they won't do it," Ellen
Brown, author of 'Web of Debt', told IPS.
Most people in the
United States do not understand what the Federal Reserve is or what it
does, except some know the Fed sets a federal interest rate, which in
turn affects interest rates on some variable private loans.
the Fed's impact is much greater than this. Essentially, the Fed, which
is made up of private bank representatives, can determine how much
money is in the nation's money supply.
"The money supply helps
determine the general level of interest rates paid for the use of
money, employment, prices, and economic growth. Many economists believe
the money supply is the most important determinant of these variables,"
according to a 1964 Congressional report, "Money Facts," by the
Committee on Banking and Currency.
One way the Fed impacts the money supply is by taking actions that open or restrict credit.
vast majority of money in the U.S. economy was created through the
issuance of loans by private banks. "Created" might seem like a strong
word, but in fact, banks typically create money as a bookkeeping entry
that did not exist before. Because of what is called "fractional
reserve lending", banks can create up to 10 times more money than they
have on deposit with the central bank.
"How does the Federal
Reserve change the money supply?" the Congressional report notes. "By
regulations which tell the member banks the maximum amount of bank
deposits they may create per dollar of reserves."
It may seem
obscure, but author Ellen Brown argues that "reserve ratio" decisions
by the Fed may have preceded several economic crises in U.S. history,
including the Great Depression in the 1930s.
"When the Federal
Reserve raised the reserve requirements [from 10 percent] to 20 percent
right before the Depression, that's what brought on the Depression,"
"Let's say you have a reserve requirement of 10
percent, and for every 10 dollars of reserves, you've got 100 dollars
on loans. If they suddenly change the reserve requirement, they have to
call in 50 dollars of loans. That caused the Depression. They have the
power to shrink the money supply," Brown explained.
in the last year, the Fed has taken on incredible new powers, including
managing the Troubled Asset Relief Programme (TARP); purchasing parts
of new federal debt; and issuing funds to unknown parties.
is a large number of members of Congress and Americans in general who
believe that such an extraordinary and unprecedented commitment of
taxpayer money demands Congressional oversight. That is why my
amendment was adopted unanimously in committee when I introduced it in
the committee of jurisdiction of the GAO," Kucinich said.
may be necessary, but first it is critical to shine a light in the
shadows. The Fed's actions have ballooned their balance sheet from 874
billion dollars to more than two trillion dollars. This is more than
double the cost of TARP and we still do not really know where the money
went. That's unacceptable," Kucinich said.
provides 'the Congress shall have power to coin money, regulate the
value thereof,'" the Congressional report notes. "The Supreme Court
interpreted this clause, again and again over a period of 150 years, to
mean that 'whatever power there is over the currency is vested in the
Congress delegated its authority to create and
regulate money to the Federal Reserve, an independent agency it created
in 1913. The "independence" of the Fed creates two problems, according
to the report.
"Since the Federal Reserve is independent it is
not accountable to anyone for the economic policies it chooses to
pursue. But this runs counter to normally accepted democratic
principles," it says.
"The President and Congress are
responsible to the people on election day for their past economic
decisions. But the Federal Reserve is responsible, neither to the
people directly nor indirectly through the people's elected
representatives. Yet the Federal Reserve exercises great power in
controlling the money-creating activities of the commercial banks," the
"With an 'independent' Federal Reserve, Congress
and the President can be moving in one direction while the Federal
Reserve is moving in the other," it says.
Prior to 1913, the
U.S. went through several different phases of monetary policy,
including President Abraham Lincoln's decision to print whatever funds
he needed to win the U.S. Civil War, rather than relying on private
Some believe it is appropriate, even inevitable, that the Federal Reserve be nationalised again.
"Nationalising the Fed would be a great idea that would solve a lot of problems," Brown said.
they really should do is buy out the shareholders, which are private
banks. So if you bought them out at what they paid years ago, it
wouldn't cost much money," she said.
It is remarkable that the
Fed has purchased part of the federal debt in the last year, Brown
says, although the public is mostly unaware of this development.
U.S. government pays three to four percent interest to bondholders of
the federal debt, but it could borrow the money from the Fed at less
than half a percent, she said.
Brown believes a publicly-run Fed should eventually purchase the entire U.S. debt from foreign countries.
what we'll have to go to. Our banks will end up public banks. You can
have private lenders, but the fractional reserve system should be a
public system. Creating credit on the books should be a public function
because nothing backs the dollar but the full faith and credit of the
United States," Brown said.
"Private banks pretend to have money
they don't have. Public banks, they're not pretending anything, because
we are the public. We are pledging our full faith and credit of 100
dollars for you to pay it back."