Military Sonar Blamed for Mass Dolphin Strandings
Mass strandings of dolphins and whales could be caused because the animals are
rendered temporarily deaf by military sonar, experiments have shown.
Tests on a captive dolphin have demonstrated that hearing can be lost for up
to 40 minutes on exposure to sonar. Hearing is the most important sense for
dolphins and other cetaeceans, and losing it is likely to cause them to
become disorientated and alarmed.
The finding by the Hawaii
Institute of Marine Biology may explain several strandings of dolphins
and whales in the past decade. Most strandings are still thought to be
natural events, but the tests strengthen fears that exercises by naval
vessels equipped with sonar are responsible for at least some of them.
The study also suggested, however, that dolphins and whales would usually be
able to swim away fast enough and far enough to escape any ill effects from
To induce deafness in the Atlantic bottlenose dolphin, Tursiops truncatus,
the sonar device would have to be loud, close and would need to last for at
least two minutes.
This should give the animals plenty of time to escape but in some
circumstances noises can be caught in "underwater sound traps", Aran Mooney,
of the University of Hawaii, said.
Sound can become trapped if a layer of warm water lies over cold water. When
sound created in the warm zone reaches the cold water it can bounce back
instead of travelling though it. This, Dr Mooney said, would have the effect
of trapping the sound in the warm layer, where it would bounce around "like
a ping-pong ball", giving whales and dolphins little chance of escaping it.
Similar effects could be experienced in parts of the sea with mountains and
ravines, where the sound would bounce back and forth.
Dr Mooney said that this could explain three of the best-known strandings that
have been linked to military sonar - in the Bahamas, the Canaries and Hawaii
- because all three regions had a mountainous underwater topography.
In the Bahamas in March 2000, 16 Cuvier's beaked whales and Blainville's
beaked whales and a spotted dolphin beached during a US navy exercise in
which sonar was used intensively for 16 hours.
Sound traps might also go some way to explaining why there are only a few mass
strandings compared with the frequency with which sonar is used by navy
"The big question is what causes them to strand," Dr Mooney said. "What we are
looking at are animals whose primary sense is hearing, like ours is seeing.
Their ears are the most sensitive organ they have.
"What we found was if you play sound you can cause temporary hearing loss. The
sounds have to be surprisingly loud and they have to be repeated over an
extended period of time - two to three minutes.
"In that time you would expect them to swim away as fast as possible. They
have to be within 40 metres of a ship, but when you have certain
oceanographic conditions it's hard for the animals to get out of the way."
Observations by researchers while carrying out the tests, which are reported
in the journal Biology Letters, showed that even though the dolphin
involved was well accustomed to man-made noises and disturbances, it
suffered subtle behavioural changes, which could cause further confusion.