Pentagon officials announced Monday that the Army has managed to achieve
its latest recruiting goals, while admitting that they have lowered some
standards that had been set to ensure the quality of the force.
But as the military continues investigations into alleged atrocities
committed by U.S. troops in Iraq, some experts worry that the Army, stretched
thin by wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and under pressure to fill its ranks,
might be signing up soldiers who should not be in the service.
Signing Them Up
The Army is on track to exceed its recruiting target for this budget year, which ends Sept. 30.
June goal: 8,600
June total: 8,756
2006 goal: 80,000
2006 so far: 51,612 |
The military's revelation last week that former Pfc. Steven Green, who
allegedly organized the rape and murder of an Iraqi girl and the killing of her
family, suffered from "anti-social personality disorder" sheds new light on the
importance of how the Army decides whom to sign up for service, say military
analysts.
"The issue is not whether they've met their quota," said Winslow Wheeler,
an expert on the U.S. military at the Center for Defense Information in
Washington. "The issue is quality ... and what concessions they are willing to
make to meet this quota."
Coincidentally, the Pentagon's announcement on recruiting came on the same
day the military identified several soldiers it accuses of participating in the
rape and murders with Green.
Green faces murder and kidnapping charges in the case. Four others,
identified as Sgt. Paul E. Cortez, Spc. James P. Barker, Pfc. Jesse V. Spielman
and Pfc. Bryan L. Howard, face similar charges, while Sgt. Anthony W. Yribe is
charged with dereliction of duty for failing to prevent or report the attack.
Army recruiters found 8,756 new recruits for active-duty service last
month, surpassing their stated target of 8,600 -- marking the 13th
consecutive month the service met or exceeded its target. The active Army now
has 51,612 new recruits, and it hopes to sign up a total of 80,000 new recruits
by the end of the 2006 budget year on Sept. 30.
The Navy in June met its goal of 3,961 recruits for that month. The Marine
Corps and the Air Force exceeded their recruiting objectives, signing up 4,357
and 2,564 service members, respectively. The Reserve and National Guard
components of the services met or surpassed their recruiting goals last month,
except for the Navy Reserve, which recruited 95 percent of its target.
To allow more recruits to join, the Army last fall amended its rule that
it can sign up no more than 2 percent of recruits who score between 15 and 30
out of 99 on the Army's aptitude test. Now, up to 4 percent of Army recruits
can score under 30 on the aptitude test, which measures such things as the
applicants' knowledge of mathematics and command of the English language, said
Lt. Col. Bryan Hilferty, an Army spokesman.
He said the Army will have "less than 4 percent" of recruits who scored
under 30 by the end of the year, but did not elaborate. In 2005, 1.8 percent of
the soldiers the Army signed up scored between 15 and 30 percent.
"We're being held up to an impossibly high standard," Hilferty said.
At the same time, in the first four months of this year, the percentage of
recruits whom the Army otherwise considers fit for service but who required
special waivers to join rose to 15.5 percent. The waivers were for misdemeanor
offenses, drug- or alcohol-related violations or medical problems, Hilferty
said. In 2004, 12 percent of recruits required such waivers; in 2005, 15
percent needed them.
Hilferty said Army recruiters have "an aggressive mental health program"
consisting of tests and checkups intended to weed out applicants with mental
health problems or personality disorders -- which Green is reported to have
-- during either recruiting or at basic training.
But not all behavioral problems can be spotted during these tests, experts
warn -- and some may only emerge under the extreme stress of war.
"It's actually very easy for people like Steven Green to get into the
military, because he is a reasonably intelligent, physically fit young man
whose emotions are not close to the surface," said Loren Thompson, a defense
analyst at the Lexington Institute in Arlington, Va.
"Many of the qualities that would make you a problem in the civilian
society are welcomed in the military. For example, a highly aggressive young
man is precisely what the Marines are looking for ... particularly in the
enlisted ranks," Thompson said.
Some experts said that regardless of how strict the criteria are during
recruiting, it is impossible to completely prevent people with personality
disorders from getting into the military.
"You're talking about weeding out 1 in half a million. That's very
difficult," said Thomas Mahnken, an expert on the military at Johns Hopkins
University.
Last year, the Army discharged 1,038 soldiers because of various
personality disorders, Hilferty said. But it is unclear how many of these
soldiers had developed the disorders before they signed up for military
service, and whether they could have been prevented from joining the Army at
the recruiting stage, he said.
Still, some critics say recruiters, pressed to fill the ranks amid wartime
shortfalls, may ignore signs that a few of their recruits fail to measure up to
military requirements.
The Southern Poverty Law Center, which monitors racist and right-wing
militia groups, reported this month that thousands of white supremacists may
have infiltrated the military, taking advantage of loosened recruiting
standards.
"Over the last several years, there has been a lot of pressure, and ...
some of the recruiters have turned a blind eye," said Mark Potok, who works at
the center. The Pentagon declared a zero-tolerance policy for racist hate
groups in 1996.
The Army has not responded to the center's report.
©2006 San Francisco Chronicle
###