There's a West Point Barber Shop, West Point Pizza and
West Point Florist.
But the U.S. Military Academy at West Point is warning a
Manlius man that his new organization West Point Graduates
Against the War better stop using the words "West
Point" in its name.
Bill Cross, a West Point graduate and Vietnam War veteran,
said he's become accustomed to some military officials
criticizing him for protesting both U.S. wars on Iraq.
But Cross never expected the government to threaten to use
trademark laws to stifle him, he said.
On April 12, just days after www.westpointgradsagainstthewar.org was launched on the Internet, a West Point lawyer
mailed Cross' organization a letter alleging it is
violating the U.S. Army's trademark.
Academy spokesman Michael D'Aquino said this dispute
is not about politics.
The military academy would have sent Cross'
organization a warning letter even if it was called "West Point Graduates For the War," D'Aquino said.
The U.S. Army registered a trademark on the words
"West Point" in 2000 to prevent anyone else from
using the mark on educational material or a wide range of
commercial goods, including golf balls, commemorative coins,
Christmas tree ornaments and paper products.
"Users must have (the Army's) permission to
incorporate these words in Web sites or organizational
titles," D'Aquino said.
When a trademark violation comes to their attention, Army
officials take action, D'Aquino said.
Cross' organization has hired Syracuse attorney Joseph
Heath to battle back against the academy, located 50 miles
north of New York City. In a letter sent Monday to West
Point, Heath questioned the academy's stance given his
client's First Amendment rights and the widespread use
of the words "West Point."
Cross, a psychology professor at Onondaga Community College
and family therapist, co-founded West Point Graduates with
his 1962 classmates Jim Ryan, of New York City, and Joe
Wojcik, of Claremont, Calif.
He said the organization has a Web site, but no assets, and
it isn't selling anything. The founders plan to
incorporate it as a nonprofit business. West Point
graduates, their spouses and their children can join for
free.
Cross estimated that about 50 people have joined since the
Web site was launched in mid-April. Through Tuesday
afternoon, there had been more than 22,000 hits on the
group's Web site.
As for barbers and florists who use the name for their
businesses, at least three interviewed Thursday said
they've never been contacted by the Army, and were
unaware the name was a trademark.
"I'm 73 years old, I've been here 50 years
and they've never bothered me," said Bill Carlton,
owner of the West Point Barber Shop in West Point, Va.
"As far as I know, anybody who wants to open (a
business) can go ahead and grab (the name)."
© 2006 The Post-Standard
###