LANSING, Mich. -- In a presidential election year dominated by war
and economics, environmental groups are determined to transform
such topics as clean water, forest preservation and global warming
into voting issues, especially in key electoral states like Michigan.
The problem, according to Carl Pope, national executive director
of the 700,000-member Sierra Club, will be how to be heard over
the "shouting" of multimillion-dollar television ad campaigns
sponsored by both major parties.
"We cannot break through on paid television," Pope said
in a recent visit to Michigan. Instead, Sierra Club and other groups
will use education programs and personal contacts to raise the profile
of an issue where, they contend, the public is already on their
side.
"... Our job is to point out to people that, A, we all know
what we want; and, B, we're not getting it," Pope said. "We
don't have to have sewage on our beaches. We don't have to have
mercury in our fisheries."
National polls indicate that environmental issues tend to favor
Democrats.
Pope and others say pro-industry policies promoted by the Bush administration
have ended decades of progress toward cleaner water and air.
But a spokeswoman for President George Bush's re-election campaign
said the president isn't conceding the issue.
"The environment will be an important part of this campaign
because President Bush has an impressive record on these issues,"
said Jennifer Millerwise, a deputy director of the Bush-Cheney campaign
in Michigan. "If you look at air quality, climate change, national
parks, national forests and a host of other issues, the president
has led and we've seen results."
Environmental advocates dispute those accomplishments. The president's
call for more support for national parks, for example, has gone
largely unfunded, according to the nonpartisan National Parks and
Conservation Association. And several groups say the administration's
market-based plan for reducing mercury emissions does too little
to protect public health.
Mercury is a potent toxin that can cause brain damage and birth
defects. It is released in small amounts through the burning of
coal, and ultimately tends to accumulate in fish.
Lana Pollack, head of the Michigan Environmental Council, said such
issues as mercury emissions could make a difference in several close
states, particularly if Republican environmentalists cross over
to vote for the Democratic candidate.
"I think it's going to be an issue," she said. "It
won't be as high as jobs and it won't be as high as the mismanagement
of foreign policy, but it will count."
Pollack noted that federal rules regarding tax-exempt donations
prohibit many nonprofit organizations from active political campaigning.
Instead, those tax-exempt organizations will continue the educational
programs they sponsor year round.
Noah Hall of the National Wildlife Federation said surveys indicate
that environmental protection laws are generally favored by both
Republican and Democratic voters.
A recent Michigan poll conducted for the wildlife group showed voters
rated the environment as an important issue, but did not put it
at the top of the list.
"The economy and jobs was at the top. Education was second,"
he said. "The environment, clean water and the Great Lakes
beat out concerns over everything from gay marriage to welfare reform."
Hall, of the National Wildlife Federation, said environmental protection
bipartisan support among its 4 million members is about evenly divided
along party lines. But he said the national membership is showing
frustration over Bush administration policies, especially on such
issues as wetland protection, oil and gas drilling, and mercury
emissions, which directly affect anglers and hunters.
"A large part of our constituency is hunters and anglers who
did support Bush in 2000," Hall said.
"He came into office with overwhelming support of the nation's
sportsmen. He's done all he can to lose that support. His own advisers
and pollsters are telling him that."
Hall gave the administration credit for moderating a proposed wetland
policy last year, after a group of outdoor sportsmen met with the
president.
"He recognized how important the sportsman vote is to his campaign
for re-election and he took action," Hall said. "Whether
it's too little or too late remains to be seen."
Edward Hoogterp is Michigan correspondent for Booth Newspapers.
###