Most Popular This Week
- Not to Worry, Rape Victims Who Want An Abortion: We Won't Charge You With Felony Tampering With Evidence, Just Your Doctor
- The Non Zero-Sum Society: How the Rich Are Destroying the US Economy
- Obama Administration Compromise Would Implement No-Cost Birth Control
- The Right of the People, Even At the Airport
- To End Extreme Poverty, Let’s Try Ending Extreme Wealth
- The Non Zero-Sum Society: How the Rich Are Destroying the US Economy
- Don’t Put a Fork in It: On the Perils of Genetically Engineered Salmon
- Five Possibilities for the Next Great Progressive Push
- To End Extreme Poverty, Let’s Try Ending Extreme Wealth
- An Economic Alternative to Exploitative Free Market Capitalism
Popular content
Today's Top News
US Officials Peddle False Intel to Support Terror Plot Claims
WASHINGTON - Officials of the Barack Obama administration have aggressively leaked information supposedly based on classified intelligence in recent days to bolster its allegation that two higher- ranking officials from Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) were involved in a plot to assassinate Saudi Ambassador Adel al-Jubeir in Washington, D.C.
In this Sept. 22, 2011 photo, members of Iran's Revolutionary Guard march in front of the mausoleum of the late Iranian revolutionary founder Ayatollah Khomeini, just outside Tehran, Iran, during armed an forces parade marking the 31st anniversary of the start of the Iraq-Iran war. Among the many mysteries inside Iran's ruling hierarchy, the Quds Force, which sits atop the vast military and industrial network of the Revolutionary Guard, has a special place in the shadows. (AP Photo/Vahid Salemi) The media stories generated by the leaks helped divert press attention from the fact that there is no verifiable evidence of any official Iranian involvement in the alleged assassination plan, contrary to the broad claim being made by the administration.
But the information about the two Iranian officials leaked to NBC News, the Washington Post and Reuters was unambiguously false and misleading, as confirmed by official documents in one case and a former senior intelligence and counterterrorism official in the other.
The main target of the official leaks was Abdul Reza Shahlai, who was identified publicly by the Obama administration as a "deputy commander in the Quds Force" of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. Shahlai had long been regarded by U.S. officials as a key figure in the Quds Force's relationship to Moqtada al-Sadr's Mahdi Army in Iraq.
The primary objective of the FBI sting operation involving Iranian- American Manssor Arbabsiar and a Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) informant that was started last June now appears to have been to use Arbabsiar to implicate Shahlai in a terror plot.
U.S. officials had learned from the DEA informant that Arbabsiar claimed that Shahlai was his cousin.
In September 2008, the Treasury Department designated Shahlai as an individual "providing financial, material and technical support for acts of violence that threaten the peace and stability of Iraq" and thus subject to specific financial sanctions. The announcement said Shahlai had provided "material support" to the Mahdi Army in 2006 and that he had "planned the Jan. 20, 2007 attack" by Mahdi Army "Special Groups" on U.S. troops at the Provincial Coordination Center in Karbala, Iraq.
Arbabsiar's confession claims that Shahlai approached him in early spring 2011 and asked him to find "someone in the narcotics business" to kidnap the Saudi ambassador to the United States, according to the FBI account. Arbabsiar implicates Shahlai in providing him with thousands of dollars for his expenses.
But Arbabsiar's charge against Shahlai was self-interested. Arbabsiar had become the cornerstone of the administration's case against Shahlai in order to obtain leniency on charges against him.
There is no indication in the FBI account of the investigation that there is any independent evidence to support Arbabsiar's claim of Shahlai's involvement in a plan to kill the ambassador.
The Obama administration planted stories suggesting that Shahlai had a terrorist past, and that it was therefore credible that he could be part of an assassination plot.
Laying the foundation for press stories on the theme, the Treasury Department announced Tuesday that it was sanctioning Shahlai, along with Arbabsiar and three other Quds Force officials, including the head of the organisation, Maj. Gen. Qasem Soleimani, for being "connected to" the assassination plot.
But Michael Issikof of NBC News reported the same day that Shahlai "had previously been accused of plotting a highly sophisticated attack that killed five U.S. soldiers in Iraq, according to U.S. government officials and documents made public Tuesday afternoon".
Isikoff, who is called "National Investigative Correspondent" at NBC News, reported that the Treasury Department had designated Shahlai as a "terrorist" in 2008, despite the fact that the Treasury announcement of the designation had not used the term "terrorist".
On Saturday, the Washington Post published a report closely paralleling the Issikof story but going even further in claiming documentary proof of Shahlai's responsibility for the January 2007 attack in Karbala. Post reporter Peter Finn wrote that Shahlai "was known as the guiding hand behind an elite militia of the cleric Moqtada al Sadr", which had carried out an attack on U.S. troops in Karbala in January 2007.
Finn cited the fact that the Treasury Department named Shahlai as the "final approving and coordinating authority" for training Sadr's militiamen in Iran. That fact would not in itself be evidence of involvement in a specific attack on U.S. forces. On the contrary, it would suggest that he was not involved in operational aspects of the Mahdi Army in Iraq.
Finn then referred to a "22-page memo that detailed preparations for the operation and tied it to the Quds Force…." But he didn't refer to any evidence that Shahlai personally had anything to do with the operation.
In fact, U.S. officials acknowledged in the months after the Karbala attack that they had found no evidence of any Iranian involvement in the operation.
Talking with reporters about the memo on Apr. 26, 2007, several weeks after it had been captured, Gen. David Petraeus conceded that it did not show that any Iranian official was linked to the planning of the Karbala operation. When a journalist asked him whether there was evidence of Iranian involvement in the Karbala operation, Petraeus responded, "No. No. No… [W]e do not have a direct link to Iran involvement in that particular case."
In a news briefing in Baghdad Jul. 2, 2007, Gen. Kevin Bergner confirmed that the attack in Karbala had been authorised by the Iraqi chief of the militia in question, Kais Khazali, not by any Iranian official.
Col. Michael X. Garrett, who had been commander of the U.S. Fourth Brigade combat team in Karbala, confirmed to this writer in December 2008 that the Karbala attack "was definitely an inside job".
Maj. Gen. Qasem Soleimani, the head of the Quds Force, is on the list of those Iranian officials "linked" to the alleged terror plot, because he "oversees the IRGC-QF officers who were involved in this plot" , as the Treasury Department announcement explained. But a Reuters story on Friday reported a claim of U.S. intelligence that two wire transfers totaling 100,000 dollars at the behest of Arbabsiar to a bank account controlled by the FBI implicates Soleimani in the assassination plot.
"While details are still classified," wrote Mark Hosenball and Caren Bohan, "one official said the wire transfers apparently had some kind of hallmark indicating they were personally approved" by Soleimani.
But the suggestion that forensic examination of the wire transfers could somehow show who had approved them is misleading. The wire transfers were from two separate non-Iranian banks in a foreign country, according to the FBI's account. It would be impossible to deduce who approved the transfer by looking at the documents.
"I have no idea what such a 'hallmark' could be," said Paul Pillar, a former head of the CIA's Counter-Terrorism Center who was also National Intelligence Officer for the Middle East until his retirement in 2005.
Pillar told IPS that the "hallmark" notion "pops up frequently in commentary after actual terrorist attacks,", but the concept is usually invoked "along the lines of 'the method used in this attack had the hallmark of group such and such'."
That "hallmark" idea "assumes exclusive ownership of a method of attack which does not really exist," said Pillar. "I expect the same could be said of methods of transferring money."
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

35 Comments so far
Show AllSadly, some people still believe government propaganda. Even sadder, those people vote, and that explains why we are, where we are.
Sadder still, the sources for that government propaganda and war promotion are very often foreign -- unless, of course, Israel is now actually considered as a U.S. state which is certainly not impossible amongst the congress critters at least.
Or maybe the statehood arrangement is the other way round. Difficult to be certain. Just hope they don't start treating Americans as Palestinians.
MSM collusion in government propaganda, helping to spread the bullshit as thick as possible. And the milling masses slurp it all up, none the wiser. If anyone ever needed more evidence - besides the mounds of it every day in broad daylight - that the US government is a fascist plutocracy, run by, of, and for the Elite powers, look no further than the sad state of our media, which exists now for the sole purpose of parroting the official state line on any and all subjects. War is peace. Slavery is freedom. Death is life. Seig Heil!
Very true . . . but it's "Sieg Heil."
Thanks for the correction :)
" Look no further than the sad state of our our media".
War is peace. Slavery is freedom; and if George Orwell were alive today, no doubt he would add: Fox News is fair and balanced!
MSM collusion in government propaganda, helping to spread the bullshit as thick as possible.
Off topic, but has anyone seen the massive MSM reporting of how dangerous vitamins are to your health?
Demon, again you said it, look no further than the sad state of our media, which exists now for the sole purpose of parroting the official state line on any and all subjects
OMG LOL ROFL... who believes this government crap any more? Are you serious? Well, I love the 70% who told Fox they agree with OWS. They are also going to be on board soon with knowing the US lied about a bunch of stuff, including 911. This is just to keep the money rolling into the MIC which also includes, now, privatized police forces to harm protestors...isn't it a crime to hurt someone when you are acting in behalf of another individual (aka: Corporation) in a violent manner and are technically off duty from your state sanctioned job? Hmm... fascist system at work here...pigs with lipstick on their ass and poop on their lips
No, no, no. You is thinking 2 much. Iran bad. Do bad things with bad mens. Must bomb bad Iran.
Maybe they have their own Maverick version of Oliver North?
Whose name is, funnily enough, Oliver North.
(lame attempt at a joke. I know the real ollie north isn't involved in this particular plot, just funning a bit and suggesting that the CIA handler is named ON)
When things get hot at home (OWS) bomb somebody. That's SOP in DC. The logic is the "We" have a short attention span and cannot walk and chew gum at the same time. These people really think "We" are stupid.
sad state of affairs. The 1% run the country and a foriegn country (Israel) runs our foreign policy. Neither one has much interest in you or I.
Israel does not run US foreign policy, the US, through US-loving puppets like Netanyahu run Israeli foreign policy.
That's not entirely true. The secret to the success of the US-Israeli relationship is that each side believes it controls the other. Both sides are wrong, of course. And right.
Israel continues to extort $3B a year in “foreign aid”, otherwise it will implement the Sampson Option (or Samson Option – Google it). If it doesn’t get the annual “tribute” it threatens to use nuclear weapons on its perceived enemies. Israel has targeted not only Arab states and cities, but also European and Russian cities for complete destruction. That’s why they violate international law with impunity and openly steal Palestinian land. Everyone else in the world knows that the Israelis are psychotic madmen with their finger literally on the nuclear trigger and are afraid to oppose Israel on just about any matter.
It’s also interesting to note that Israel claims it has “a right to exist”. In reality, there is no legal basis for the creation of the State of Israel. It was the General Assembly of the U.N., by a two-thirds vote, that agreed to a 55% annexation of Palestine. The Security Council NEVER ratified that vote. Therefore, by U.N. procedure, Israel was never fully ratified as a nation state. Further, Israel has never officially recognized its own borders. That’s why there is no written defense treaty with the U.S., their supposed ally. You can’t have a defense treaty if you can’t identify what borders you are defending.
Americans need to realize that we are under siege and occupation from the Zionist state. They control our government and foreign policy. They control the banking system. And there is sufficient evidence that, if they don’t directly control the media, by use of fanatical pressure, they are able to control what we read, see and hear. This latest alleged assignation plot is a good example.
If you dare discuss these matters you are immediately attacked as an anti-Semite. [As an anti-racist I have to be anti-Zionist.] It’s an effective method to dissuade critical thinking and conceals the fact that we are under siege. Please don’t take my word for it. Do some of your own research. And whenever you decide that you want to talk about it, watch the Hasbara go nuts.
"Israel continues to extort $3B a year in “foreign aid”, otherwise it will implement the Sampson Option (or Samson Option – Google it)."
I've read my Martin van Creveld too. :-) But don't forget that Israel serves the needs of our MIC too. Befriending Israel's neighbors at the expense of Israel doesn't keep the military contracts and adventures rolling in like antagonizing most of them, and forcing the rest of them into expensive "peace treaties" do.
And our own Stephen Harper stood up in parliament and announced these lies as truths proclaiming "Iran the greatest threat to peace in the World Today"
What an ass and what a clown. What a lying stooge. The greatest threat to World Peace is the nation that is bombing some dozen nations today and sending in its drones and agents to murder peoples. It is south of our border and Mr Harper follows along aiding and abetting those crimes.
War-mongers will always want new war. The question is whether they have the power and authority to drag the rest of us, kicking and screaming, along with them into their latest nightmare.
The equation that will set things off is Iran+nukes+terrorism. When the war-mongers connect enough dots to produce a picture that will mesmerize the sheeple into stampeding, war will explode.
Everyone here is wonderfully aware that the allegations against Iran are hogwash, and Hooray!
As a practical matter, if anyone still thinks one exists, I suggest once again that Public Law 107-40 is the key to our problem. It gave to the President the ungodly power to use the US military to prevent future terrorism (forever and ever, amen).
We need to end Public Law 107-40 before it ends us.
At the very least, can we stop ignoring it? We've ignored it for 10 years and look where we are.
They lied about al-Qaeda being an 'existential threat' to the U.S.
They lied that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction.
They lied that attacks from Afghanistan pose a threat to the U.S.
They Lie and the Corporate Media repeats it and amplifies it.
Kill your Television .
This sad episode has completely destroyed my faith in the sincerity of US intelligence agencies.
Why yes. US Intelligence agency reporting has gotten so bad that Petraeus is having the military correct CIA reports on how well the military is doing overseas. Apparently reports without military input were unduly realistic...ummmmm...pessimistic.
"False intel" has become redundant.
Will a treasonous bribe from Israel and Saudi Arabia secure re-election?
Hypocrisy reaches monumental heights. The same government that has just leaked classified information in an attempt to defraud the American people into thinking Iran was planning terrorist attacks against the US has had Bradley Manning incarcerated for years, without the benefit of any legal process, for allegedly doing the same thing. The Obama administration is so desperate to punish those who expose the inner workings of our government that it is interfering with the legal systems of two other nations in an attempt to do the same thing to Julian Assange.
The only difference is between government leakers and independent ones it that the documents allegedly leaked by Assange and Manning harmed no one while those leaked by the Obama administration had the power to cause harm to hundreds of thousands and is a gross abuse of power.
Even before this latest debacle, at least one journalist posed the question whether or not one could morally cast a vote for Obama. Surely this latest attempt at naked aggression makes it an impossibility.
This story has reeked to high heaven from day one, suspiciously smelling just like other anti-Muslim frame-up jobs the FBI regularly stages with some retarded dupe somewhere. The retarded dupe in this case being the Iranian-American used-car salesman, persuaded to confess that in his telephone conversation, when he used the word "Chevrolet," the other party understood him to mean "bomb." That's a fair description of every Chevy I've owned, I guess, but still...
Soeren Palumbo High School Speech
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CoqaNG0Ozqc
The linked speech is a moving tribute to the speaker's mentally-handicapped sister. I am being properly scolded for using the word "retarded" in a hurtful way. Point taken.
We all make mistakes. I, for example, voted for Obama.
Knock Knock , Mcfly, anybody home. Eric holder , Fast and Furious guns for drugs,.
The Iran plot for attack is a smoke screen, and you fell for it Justin.
Submitted by Michael Flood McNulty on Oct 17, 2011
Hillary Clinton to Face Heat Over Fast & Furious Gun Scandal?
" “It’s time we know the whole truth,” Issa said of this latest development in the widening scandal. “The documents this subpoena demands will provide answers to questions that Justice officials have tried to avoid since this investigation began eight months ago.” The California Republican is not a lawyer by profession, but Issa, along with his relatively small staff, has managed to go toe-to-toe with the army of lawyers spread across the federal government. "
The subpoenas were handed out the day before the alleged Iran attack false flag story was released.
Do the math Justin.
'Saudi envoy plot suspect is MKO man'
http://www.presstv.com/detail/205177.html
Kill, kill, mame, slaughter, destroy, depleted Uranium, the rich folks thrill, kill, kill, kill. We must find new lands to bomb and destroy, we must spread democracy, kill, kill, murder, destroy, torture, maim. They called us a name, kill, kill, they changed to a different curency, destroy, kill, maim, drop depleted uranium, make them suffer forever. Must kill, must destroy, create just cause, sell to media, media hungry for more death, hungry for more destruction. Kill, kill, maim destroy. We are the world super power, we will enforce our will on all. Die, die,,die?????????
WOLF!
(or is that "fire"?)
Recall:
Rafid Ahmed Alwan al-Janabi, aka "Curveball"
Ayad Allawi
Both men played into the US Administration designs for "regime change" in Iraq.
if Iranians hesitate in starting their revolution, they might face the fate of Afganestan or Iraq. only a government which represents broad masses of workers and toilers can stand firm against imperialist threats, not a theocracy which is made of corrupt mullahs and fears its own people more than foreign armies.