Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Torture Orders Were Part of US Sectarian War Strategy
WASHINGTON - The revelation by Wikileaks of a U.S. military order directing U.S. forces not to investigate cases of torture of detainees by Iraqis has been treated in news reports as yet another case of lack of concern by the U.S. military about detainee abuse.
But the deeper significance of the order, which has been missed by the news media, is that it was part of a larger U.S. strategy of exploiting Shi'a sectarian hatred against Sunnis to help suppress the Sunni insurgency when Sunnis had rejected the U.S. war.
And Gen. David Petraeus was a key figure in developing the strategy of using Shi'a and Kurdish forces to suppress Sunnis in 2004-2005.
The strategy involved the deliberate deployment of Shi'a and Kurdish police commandos in areas of Sunni insurgency in the full knowledge that they were torturing Sunni detainees, as the reports released by Wikileaks show.
That strategy inflamed Sunni fears of Shi'a rule and was a major contributing factor to the rise of al Qaeda's influence in the Sunni areas. The escalating Sunni-Shi'a violence it produced led to the massive sectarian warfare of 2006 in Baghdad in which tens of thousands of civilians - mainly Sunnis - were killed.
The strategy of using primarily Shi'a and Kurdish military and police commando units to suppress Sunni insurgents was adopted after a key turning point in the war in April 2004, when Civil Defense Corps units throughout the Sunni region essentially disappeared overnight during an insurgent offensive.
Two months later, the U.S. military command issued "FRAGO [fragmentary order] 242", which provided that no investigation of detainee abuse by Iraqis was to be conducted unless directed by the headquarters of the command, according to references to the order in the Wikileaks documents.
The order came immediately after Gen. Petraeus took command of the new Multi-National Security Transition Command in Iraq (MNSTC-I). It was a clear signal that the U.S. command expected torture of prisoners to be a central feature of Iraqi military and police operations against Sunni insurgents.
Petraeus knew that it would take more than two years to build a competent Iraqi military officer corps, as he told Bing West, author of the "The Strongest Tribe", in August 2004. Meanwhile, he would have to use Shi'a and Kurdish militias.
In September 2004, Petraeus adopted a plan to establish paramilitary units within the national police.
The initial units were from non-sectarian former Iraqi special forces teams. In October, however, Petraeus embraced the first clearly sectarian Shi'a militia unit - the 2,000- man Shi'a "Wolf Brigade", as a key element of his police commando strategy, giving it two months of training with U.S. forces.
In November 2004, after 80 percent of the Sunni police defected to the insurgents in Mosul, the U.S. command dispatched 2,000 Kurdish peshmurga militiamen to Mosul, and five battalions of predominantly Shi'a troops, with a smattering of Kurds, were to police Ramadi. But a few weeks later, after the completion of its training, the Wolf Brigade was also sent to Mosul.
Hundreds of Shi'a troops from Baghdad and southern areas of the country were also sent into Samara and Fallujah.
It did not take long for the Wolf Brigade to acquire its reputation for torture of Sunni detainees. The Associated Press reported the case of a female detainee in Wolf Brigade custody in Mosul who was whipped with electric cables in order to get her to sign a false confession that she was a high-ranking local leader of the insurgency.
But an official of the U.S. command later told Richard Engel of NBC that the Wolf Brigade had been a very effective unit and had driven the insurgents out of Mosul.
The Wolf Brigade was then sent to Sunni neighborhoods in Baghdad, where the Association of Muslim Scholars publicly accused it of having "arrested imams and the guardians of some mosques, tortured and killed them, and then got rid of their bodies in a garbage dump..."
The Wolf Brigade was also deployed to other Sunni cities, including Ramadi and Samarra, always in close cooperation with U.S. military units.
The war logs released by Wikileaks include a number of reports from Samarra in 2004 and 2005 describing how the U.S. military had handed their captives over to the Wolf Brigade for "further questioning". The implication was that the Shi'a commandos would be able to extract more information from the detainees than would be allowed by U.S. rules.
Gen. Martin Dempsey, who succeeded Petraeus as the commander responsible for training Iraqi security forces in September 2005, hinted strongly in an interview with Elizabeth Vargas of ABC News three months later that the U.S. command accepted the Wolf Brigade's harsh interrogation methods as a necessary feature of using Iraqi counterinsurgency forces.
Dempsey said, "We are fighting through a very harsh environment... these guys are not fighting on the streets of Bayonne, New Jersey." Contrary to the Western notion of "innocent until proven guilty", he said the view in Iraq was "close" to the "opposite".
Vargas reported, "For Dempsey, a big part of building a viable police force is learning to accept, if not embrace, the cultural differences."
A second stage of the strategy of sectarian war against the Sunnis came after the new Shi'a government's takeover of the Interior Ministry in April 2005. The Shi'a minister immediately filled the Iraqi police - especially the commando units - with Shi'a troops from the Badr Corps, the Iranian-trained forces loyal to the Islamic Supreme Council of Iraq.
Within days the Badr Corps, along with the Wolf Brigade, began a campaign of mass arrests, torture and assassination of Sunnis in Baghdad and elsewhere that was widely reported by news agencies.
The U.S. command responded to that development by issuing a new version of the previous order on what to do about Iraqi torture, according to the Wikileaks documents. On Apr. 29, 2005, the U.S. command issued FRAGO 039 requiring reports through operational channels on Iraqi abuse of prisoners using a format attached to the order. But no follow-up investigation was to be made unless directed by higher headquarters.
The former Minister of Interior, Falah al-Naquib, later told Knight-Ridder correspondent Tom Lasseter that he had personally warned Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld and other U.S. officials about the sectarian violence by Badr police commandos against Sunnis. "They didn't take us seriously," he lamented.
In fact, the U.S. military and the U.S. Embassy were well aware of the serious risk that the strategy of relying on vengeful Shi'a police commandos to track down Sunnis would exacerbate sectarian tensions between Sunnis and Shi'a. In May 2005, Ann Scott Tyson wrote in the Washington Post that U.S. military analysts did not deny that the U.S. strategy "aggravates the underlying fault lines in Iraqi society, heightening the prospects of civil strife".
In late July 2005, when Petraeus was still heading the command, an unnamed "senior American officer" at MNSTC-I was asked by John F. Burns of the New York Times whether the U.S. might end up arming Iraqis for a civil war. The officer answered, "Maybe."
The U.S.-sponsored Shi'a assault on the Sunnis gave al Qaeda a new opportunity. In mid-2005, Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, leader of al Qaeda in Iraq, announced the creation of a special unit, the Omar Brigade, to combat the Shi'a commando torture and death squads. That led to the massive sectarian bloodletting in Baghdad in 2006, when thousands of civilians were dying every month.
- Posted in
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

18 Comments so far
Show AllI am watching the ball game. They just sang God Bless America. I am with Rev Wright. Goddam us for all of the blood shed and misery we have dumped on this world. Betrayus has to be a sociopath. All of the military leaders do. To just sit back and watch helpless humans beings tortured is depraved. What a god awful country I live in. I wish I had the money to move out of this soulless waste land. And now we are going to present the Yemens with our winning of hearts and minds. When will another country put us out of our death and destructive ways? Anyone? From the beginning, the US has decimated anyone standing in the way of lands or money. GDA.
My understanding is that we also trained Sunni death squads to avenge these acts by the Shia and Kurd militias.
And .... noone evr stepped forward to claim that they had been responsible for the Masjid bombing that really started the sectarian warfare.
"noone evr stepped forward to claim that they had been responsible for the Masjid bombing that really started the sectarian warfare."
_______________*
Correct. Also, memba the English soldiers dressed as Iraqis spraying people in the streets of Iraq. When they got arrested, coalition forces stormed the prison to get them out, killing people and freeing prisoners.
I wait for the sectarian warfare in the US when the Bible-b'lievin' True Christians resume the warfare on Papists. Of course they're listening to Beck without realizing that the Mormons aren't remotely Christians . . .
yes, maybe, but Assange "has blood on his hands!"
Aha! So General David did Betray us after all. MoveOn got it right.
There is a group of Americans that are a sick bunch of torture freaks,
JuSt google gang stalking, and you will quickly realize that there is group of very wealthy and powerful well organized Americans , county by county, that have grown a nation wide stazi network of right wing religious community watch gang stalking networks. They do the dirty work for the super wealthy,mostly fascist right wing religious lunatics, and the Department of justice is well aware of this nation wide problem and do nothing.
Torture is what gang stalking is, and they destroy peoples lives, which is murder.
Using slander, coin tel pro tactics, they discredit there victims and then try to drive them crazy to the point of suicide or abject poverty.
THAT'S TORTURE, AND THEY KNOW IT, AND THIS SICK BUNCH OF UNPATRIOTIC ,UNCONSTITUTIONAL PRICKS DON'T CARE, AND NEITHER DOES THE FBI OR THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE.
YOU DONT HAVE TO WONDER WHY, JUST KNOW IT IS THE PLAN TO BUILD A STASI NETWORK. AND BUSH / CHENEY EMPOWERED THEM WITH MONEY AND THE DHS.
GOOGLE MARKUS WOLF, AND YOU WILL KNOW WHY, THANKS BUSHY YOU STASI PRICK
Ex-Stasi Spy Chief Markus Wolf Hired By Homeland Security? Prison Planet | December 6 2004. Political analyst Al Martin, who has in the past proven accurate ...
. East Germany's Ministry for State Security (MfS, commonly known as the Stasi). ... Markus Wolf died in his sleep at his Berlin home on 9 November 2006. ...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Markus_Wolf - Cached - Similar
"War is hell" is the old saying...but this article proves Gen. Patraeus and senior members of the U.S. Military command committed war crimes and enabled/directly caused atrocities while in Iraq.
Will Petraeus and other senior officers be held accountable for "developing the strategy of using Shi'a and Kurdish forces to suppress Sunnis in 2004-2005", thereby causing vast atrocities, torture, and sectarian warfare (all of which are war crimes)?????
It didn't seem as the human rights reputation of the U.S. Mil could get any lower.
"War is hell"
so why do so many religions condone it?
CrazyLiberal,
"Will Petraeus and other senior officers be held accountable.."
Maybe, but not through the u.s.'s systems.
Fear. These are cold heartless killers,
congress knows it,
Obama knows it,
Kennedy knew it,
as did King.
"For us or against us" was a global threat,
like Genghis's declarations to surrounded cities,
"Join the horde or die."
Anyone, anywhere, any time.
Global rejection is the best hope.
When the time comes, I hope a monument is erected to honor Julian Assange,
the bravest man on the planet.
The orders to torture always come from the top, as do the orders for covert death squads, the general practices to spray 360 in a crowd if any weapon is cited--all the practices of murder that would horrify us in civilian life and are so easily accepted in war, as is the desire for war itself-- it all comes from the top.
"That strategy inflamed Sunni fears of Shi'a rule and was a major contributing factor to the rise of al Qaeda's influence in the Sunni areas."
Here we have yet more proof that the U.S.'s military strategy was actually calculated - specifically - to cause an increase in Al Qaeda's power, and the US media says nothing. There is a word for it: treason. When the US Government specifically designs strategies intended to INCREASE terrorist activity, which puts Americans as well as Shia in danger, simply so that the MIC can continue its never-ending wars, it should be clear to anyone that we live in a criminal, evil nation where corporate profit and greed is more important than the nation's security itself, or human life. The official U.S. line is that we are "fighting terrorism," when in fact the U.S.' unofficial, secret line is to make terrorists as if on an assembly line, in order to have a never-ending supply of enemy terrorists we can use as an excuse to keep our never-ending wars in business.
Sick. Sick. Sick.
"When fascism comes to America, it will be wrapped in the flag, carrying a cross."
Demonstorm November 2nd, 2010 10:57 am -- You say, "it should be clear to anyone that we live in a criminal, evil nation where corporate profit and greed is more important than the nation's security itself, or human life." But evidently it isn't clear to many.
Who, among the people running the programs that provide care and feeding of the MIC, really understands what is going on, and who is simply duped by the unrelenting propaganda campaign carried out wittingly or unwittingly by the MSM and orchestrated by the captains of the MIC? How can we distinguish these people? I don't see this as a black and white situation where everyone on our side of the issue knows the truth and isn't afraid to say so, but everyone on the other side knows the truth but pretends not to.
Excellent point, thanks for bringing it up. Food for thought for me.
"When fascism comes to America, it will be wrapped in the flag, carrying a cross."
Demonstorm November 3rd, 2010 11:22 am -- Thank you. Let me know if you come up with an answer.
I marvel at your ability to compartmentalize your scrutiny of our shadow government, and the ruling class.
Signed,
Kook, Nuttier than a Squirrels' Brigade, Troofer, Toon