Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Israel's Investigations of Gaza Conflict Inadequate, Say UN Experts
A United Nations committee has accused Israel of failing to investigate abuses allegedly committed during its offensive in Gaza nearly two years ago, raising the prospect of International Criminal Court indictments.
Both Israel and Hamas were instructed to conduct internal inquiries after the UN Human Rights Commission adopted a report by Richard Goldstone, a retired South African judge, accusing both of war crimes during the three-week conflict.
White phosphorus from an Israeli shell rains down over the Gaza Strip as seen from Gaza's Jabalia refugee camp on January 9, 2009. (Photo: AFP) More than 1,400 Palestinians and 13 Israelis died in the war after Israel launched a military operation in Gaza in what it said was an attempt to halt Hamas rocket fire on its towns near Gaza.
The UN investigation accused Israel of deliberately attacking civilians, firing white phospohrous shells and carring out torture during the offensive.
"The Israeli operations were carefully planned in all their phases as a deliberately disproportionate attack designed to punish, humiliate and terrorise the civilian population," the report found.
After the report was published, Israel refused to cooperate, although it carried out investigations into individual incidents.
As Israel is no longer a signatory of the statute creating the international criminal court, there is little chance of Israeli officials standing trial before it. The Jewish state has been vehemently critical of the Goldstone investigation.
Hamas was also accused of failing to mount a credible investigation of the allegations.
- Posted in
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

14 Comments so far
Show All"The Israeli operations were carefully planned in all their phases as a deliberately disproportionate attack designed to punish, humiliate and terrorise the civilian population,"
a war crime, is a war crime, is a war crime.
encourage the US government to suspend all military aid to israel and support the BDS movement in opposition to this racist regime that acts w/ impunity upon the weak and innocent.
http://bdsmovement.net/
...peace...
Also encourage the USA government to suspend all military aid to the USA miltary.
Boycott Divest and Sanction, the zionist have shown they fear BDS more than anything.
It's because they are imperial materalists hiding behind Judaism.
"Israel's Investigations of Gaza Conflict Inadequate, Say UN Experts"
_______________________
You don't say!
In all fairness, maybe Israel skimped on this one because they're diverting all of their investigators to find out what the hell actually happened to all the credit cards, luggage, and equipment pillaged by the IDF during the Gaza Flotilla caper.
Israel out of control, since 1948.
Once again, talk of "proportionality" is entirely moot, as Israel wasn't "responding" to anything. It initiated the violence, in the full knowledge of its impunity, and its ownership of the US political/media complex.
There is no supreme being that's going to deliver us from this monstrosity; we are going to have to do it ourselves.
But of course Hamas' investigation was impeccable and evenhanded, revealing that any and all crimes of war were committed by Israel.
What was Hamas' internal inquiry?
The big difference between Hamas terrorism and Israeli terrorism is Hamas takes ownership of theirs. The don't deny and twist it to fit a western-acceptable rationalization.
Then you have Israeli settler violence towards Palestinians, which can't be called terrorism because it's not for a political goals, it's really done just for sport. I suppose it's difficult to violently steal land from someone and consider them human
A lot of the munitions used during the Gaza Massacre almost certainly came from the naval weapons depot across the bay from my little town of Port Townsend, in northwest Washington.
These arms would include cluster bombs, white phosphorus, and weapons using depleted uranium.
A couple years ago, the former depot commander told local Chamber of Commerce members that "Israel is one of our best customers."
You bet. And they use U. S. taxpayer dollars for those weapons, too.
Israel gets $3.1 billion dollars in U. S. taxpayer aid yearly--more than any other country on earth--and up to 75 percent of it must be used for the purchase of U. S.-made military weapons and equipment.
Pretty sweet deal for everybody, except of course the U. S. taxpayer and those 1,400 Palestinian civilians killed by those weapons, 400 of them women and children.
Our chief executive, lawmakers and courts do nothing when we ask them to stop using our money for war crimes. The wall between U. S. citizens and our corporate-run government is as tall and thick as the wall that makes Gaza the world's biggest open-air concentration camp.
Here in Port Townsend and Jefferson County, some of us thought of a nonviolent tactic that might work better than useless voting, sending emails to our "representatives," or holding signs and chanting slogans.
We started a BDS movement.
The first thing we did was initiate a boycott proposal, asking our local food co-op board to consider a boycott of products from Israel.
This scared local Zionists and "Progressive-except-Palestine" liberals so much that a screaming campaign was immediately invoked in order to try to silence and shut us down.
We were repeatedly called "anti-semitic," "self-hating Jews," "racist," and other names. One person screamed at us as we were sitting at our co-op-designated table outside the co-op: "IF THERE'S EVER A HOLOCAUST HERE AND YOU'RE THE TARGET, I HOPE THEY TAKE YOU DOWN!"
Anti-boycott talking points were quickly spread around and repeated like Tea-Bagger mantras: "Why pick on Israel?" "What about China?" "Why not boycott the U. S. for its war crimes?" "Keep politics our of my co-op!" "I just want good food!" "Stop being divisive!" "If this boycott passes, I'm going to quit the co-op!"
When we held our ground, calmly trying to encourage dialogue instead of argument, shouting and threats, and began to gather a lot of supporters and media attention, Stand With Us, a national pro-Israel organization, was called in to lend support to the local anti-boycott effort.
Then it got even better. Gideon Lustig, the Deputy Consul General of Israel for the Pacific Northwest, showed up.
He gave a talk in the Sanctuary of the local Unitarian Universalist Fellowship, in which he denied that apartheid exists in Israel--in fact he said he was "offended" by the insinuation, and in his best diplomat-speak finished his talk by saying the boycott "could be perceived as anti-semitic."
Lustig also tried to meet in closed-session with the co-op board, and the board president was all in favor of that--in fact, she asked board members to convene for the meeting. But when word of the plot got out, and it was pointed out that a closed-door meeting would be a violation of co-op principles, the board president chose to meet alone with Lustig (this also in contravention of co-op principles).
The Consul General also tried to meet (and may have met) with the Port Townsend city manager, perhaps to encourage the town to "Invest Rather Than Divest," a message Lustig tried to sell during his public talk, neglecting to point out that there's a lot of private U. S. investment already going on, much of it from evangelical Christian churches, to help build and sustain the illegal armed settlements in the West Bank.
It gets even thicker.
At a quiet local free-wifi site, I witnessed, unnoticed, the Consul General and a consulate attache hunkering down over linked computers for more than an hour with the Seattle Stand With Us representative, composing a public statement and developing strategy for meetings with the board president and city manager, and arranging and rehearsing for an upcoming interview with a local reporter.
There were no local boycott opponents present at that session: it was all outsider-driven.
Bottom-line: a highly placed representative of a foreign power intervened in the political affairs of a small (8,000 pop.) northwest American town. . . .
What are they afraid of?
I think they're afraid of the truth. They want to dim or snuff out the light being shed on Israel's crimes against humanity.
Last night--surprise, surprise--the co-op board of directors voted 4-2 against the boycott, but the truth will not go away and neither will BDS--not here in Port Townsend, nor anywhere throughout the world.
BDS is a movement that is growing rapidly, and a nonviolent tactic that is vastly more powerful than phony peace talks or, for that matter, those weapons across the bay from where I'm now sitting in Port Townsend.
Karma Tenzing Wangchuk
Port Townsend Food Co-op Member-Owner
Jefferson County BDS
http://jeffcowabds.com
"Our chief executive, lawmakers and courts do nothing when we ask them to stop using our money for war crimes. "
The American government has always maintained the right of its citizens to ship arms to belligerents. President Washington, through his Secretary of State, Thomas Jefferson, and his Secretary of the Treasury, Alexander Hamilton, took this position when France protested against the sale of arms to England in 1793, the answer being that "the exporting from the United States of warlike instruments and military stores is not to be interfered with." - Theodore Roosevelt's "Fear God..."p.160
One of America's oldest foreign policies: gun running.
I think of it as The Right to Share Arms.
"The higher we soar, the smaller we appear to those who cannot fly."
It's unfortunate that you have to deal with such low grade behavior. Here's a picture of someone named Tenzing that has inspired millions:
http://www.unlockingthearchives.rgs.org/themes/everest/gallery/resource/?id=216
Correction to Website.
Jefferson County (Wash.) BDS
http://jeffcowabds.wordpress.com/
Tenzing
The "State" of Israel - the only true Kleptocracy in the Middle East
Gaza And The Warsaw Ghetto
same place
different time
while the world stands by
genocide
live