Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Texas Hammers EPA on Science of Global Warming
In legal briefs, attorney general says science is unreliable.
Essentially putting global warming science on trial, Texas officials on Thursday expanded their arguments in a lawsuit meant to prevent the federal regulation of greenhouse gases.
In motions submitted Thursday to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott accused the federal Environmental Protection Agency of relying on faulty science for its proposals to regulate greenhouse gases.
The briefs build on a federal suit filed in February by Texas and other states against the EPA, which in December issued an endangerment finding that carbon dioxide emissions threaten the public health and welfare of current and future generations.
The endangerment finding, which opens the way to further regulations, spun out of a 2007 U.S. Supreme Court ruling that the EPA had the authority to regulate greenhouse gases.
The EPA said its scientific conclusions were based on work by three groups: the U.S. Global Climate Research Program, the United Nations' Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change and the National Research Council, which synthesize thousands of studies to convey a consensus on what scientific literature shows about climate, according to the agency.
In February, Abbott, who is seeking re-election this year, said that in relying on the U.N. panel's data, the EPA "outsourced the scientific basis for its greenhouse gas regulation to a scandal-plagued international organization that cannot be considered objective or trustworthy."
The American-Statesman's PolitiFact Texas team deemed "Barely True" Abbott's statement, which drew attention to claims that scientists for the U.N. panel from at least two universities had suppressed data that could undermine global warming work.
Since the February claim, independent reviews of work by climate scientists at East Anglia University in England and Penn State University found no evidence that they had actively suppressed or falsified data.
"By delegating its judgment on climate science to the (U.N. group) and others, EPA exposed its conclusions to the errors and biases of unaccountable volunteer scientists, and undermined the validity of the endangerment finding," reads a brief filed by the Texas attorney general's office.
The state is challenging proposals to limit emissions of greenhouse gases from light-duty-vehicle tailpipes and large industrial facilities.
Abbott and Gov. Rick Perry have said greenhouse gas rules could cripple the Texas economy.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...


58 Comments so far
Show Alldelia_darrow, maybe Texas could move to Kansas -that would raise the average IQ in both the rest of the country and Kansas.
All science has risk attached to it, but the EPA made an obvious and overdue ruling on greenhouse gases. The most unfortunate aspect of the American rights questioning of science using law, is the teaching of American youth that law somehow is more exact than science, and thus more worthy of being trusted. Most of Texas, I'll wager, is questioning whether the First Amendment actually applies to a mosque near Ground Zero. If the First Amendment can't be trusted, what hope is there for the rest of the law?
The fact is, Texas can ignore Global Warming all it wants. But when enhanced hurricanes hit East Texas as drought devours West Texas, it'll be clear who actually rules in Texas, and it ain't the law.
Immaculate DEception"
from stardust
Dear Abbot and Perry,
your brains are quite scary,
but OH, your portfolios grow!
With that oil money here,
plus those chasers with beer
your smoke- filled, back room deals show.
Our air is polluted,
Your brains are deluded,
and "crippled" your LUNGS they will go.
Perhaps as you're dyin'
you'll learn they were lyin'
Too late to fight AIR's real FOE.***
boycott anything and everything texas.
i will never hire anyone educated in texas, for instance.
i will not buy any corporate products produced by texan companies, as long as i can identify them.
Hey, Texas Instruments was a pretty good group until Japan beat them out.
Sadly, This is the same state that publishes almost all of our grade school textbooks. Troglodytes rule.
I don't think you can judge by location alone. Eastern CA and western NY are about as conservative as Texas. Do you think publishing there would change a thing?