Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Report: 'Rampant Abuse in Iraq Jails'
New Amnesty International report documents wide abuse, torture and detention without trial in Iraqi prisons.
Amnesty International has said that tens of thousands of detainees are being held without trial in Iraqi prisons. In a new report, Amnesty said the prisoners face violent and psychological abuse, as well as other forms of mistreatment.
Amnesty said on Monday it believes that around 30,000 people are held in Iraqi jails, noting the case of several who died in custody, while cataloguing physical and psychological abuses against many others.
Last month’s handover of prisoners following the so-called 'end of US combat operations' have alarmed the The London-based human rights watchdog.
"Iraq's security forces have been responsible for systematically violating detainees' rights and they have been permitted to do so with impunity," said Malcolm Smart, Amnesty's director for the Middle East and North Africa.
“Yet, the US authorities, whose own record on detainees' rights has been so poor, have now handed over thousands of people detained by US forces to face this catalogue of illegality, violence and abuse, abdicating any responsibility for their human rights," he added.
Among other things, the Amnesty report documents thousands of arbitrary detentions and beatings of detainees to obtain forced confessions.
"The Iraqi authorities must take the firm and decisive action now... to show that they have the political will to uphold the human rights of all Iraqis, in accordance with their international obligations and to stop the torture and other gross abuses of detainees' rights," the report said.
File photo of Iraqi prisoners sitting in a cramped cell at a police station in the restive Diyala Province, northeast of Baghdad. Iraq and the US military have disputed claims made by Amnesty International of torture and ill treatment in Iraqi prisons, saying the country's jails abided by international standards. (AFP/David Furst) Ali al-Musawi, a media advisor to Nouri al-Maliki, the Iraqi outgoing PM has denied the claims.
He claimed Iraqi prisons are free from political prisoners, saying all detainees have been arrested for terrorism related actions or ordinary and petty crimes. He said that 4500 prisoners have been released since April for the lack of evidence.
Moving prisoners
Amnesty's 59-page report, titled "New Order, Same Abuses: Unlawful detentions and torture in Iraq," highlights the case of several men who were subjected to torture or who died in prison.
Among them was Riad Mohammed Saleh al-Oqaibi, arrested in September 2009 and held in a detention facility in Baghdad's heavily-fortified Green Zone before being transferred to a secret detention facility elsewhere in the capital.
"During interrogation, he is said to have been beaten so hard on the chest that his ribs were broken and his liver damaged," the report noted. "He died on 12 or 13 February as a result of internal bleeding."
According to the rights group, methods of torture used against detainees include beatings with cables and hose-pipes, breaking of limbs, piercing of the body with drills and psychological torture in the form of threats with rape.
In addition to the central Iraqi government, the report blamed security forces in the autonomous region of Kurdistan of also being at fault, noting one case in which a detainee had been held for more than 10 years without charge or trial. That detainee was allegedly tortured by Kurdish security police.
Iraq's fractured penal system means the ministries of justice, interior and defence all run their own prison networks, and reports of torture and mistreatment are common, the report concluded.
Human Rights Watch said in April that Iraqi men were raped, electrocuted and beaten in a "secret prison" in Baghdad, while MPs called for an independent enquiry into prison abuse in a parliamentary debate in June 2009.
Ramze Shihab Ahmed, 68, is an Iraqi refugee in the UK. He was arrested while on a visit to Iraq in 2009, and no-one knew where he was being held or what, if anything, he had been charged with. He left to Iraq in the first place, to find out the faith of his son Omar, after receiving information he was arrested by Iraqi police.
His wife Rabiha, 63, told Al Jazeera: "Ramze was very worried about Omar. We didn't know why he had been arrested, and he said he must go to Iraq to help him," Rabiha says. "He didn't think he would be in any danger at all."
Rabiha claims her husband confessed to terrorism charges under torture.
"They beat him. They put a plastic bag on his head until he lost consciousness, and then they woke him with electric shocks. They told him that if he didn't confess, they would make his son rape him. They put a wooden stick into his anus," she told Al Jazeera. "They have abused him in every way."
Prisons handover
Baghdad took over full responsibility for its prisons in July. The United States remains responsible for a small section of high-value detainees in Karkh Prison on the capital's outskirts.
At a ceremony on July 15 when Iraq took control of the last remaining US detention facility, Iraqi Justice Minister Dara Nureddine Dara said "the days of mistreatment and abuse of prisoners are gone."
"We will investigate and discharge any [security official] found to have committed a wrongful act," he vowed.
Amnesty noted while Iraq had announced enquiries into cases of maltreatment, torture and death in custody, the probe results had not been made public and "those responsible for abuses have not been brought to justice."
It also criticised the United States for handing over several thousand detainees to Iraqi custody "without any guarantees against torture or ill-treatment."
Security forces in Iraq retain broad powers to arrest individuals on the basis of tip-offs from informants, and Amnesty said torture is often used to extract confessions from those being held.
US diplomats have said in the past that Iraq's judicial system remains highly dependent on confessions from suspects at this point, rather than forensics or evidence.
Source: Al Jazeera and Agencies
- Posted in
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...


32 Comments so far
Show AllYou are known by the company you keep.
A voice from the graveyard of Iraq: Saddam Hussein asks, “Miss Me Yet?”
"...Baghdad took over full responsibility for its prisons in July...
...At a ceremony on July 15 when Iraq took control of the last remaining US detention facility,"...
------------------
So does this mean that the U.S. was responsible for all Iraqi prisons prior to July 15??
If so the case listed above regarding Riad Mohammed Saleh al-Oqaibi who "died on 12 or 13 February as a result of internal bleeding" as a result of a brutal beating would seem to constitute torture that took place during Obama's watch.
This is the inevitable result of Obama choosing to "look forward, not backward" instead of demanding prosecution of torturers from the Cheney/Bush regime.
Obama is now not only guilty of participating in the cover-up of torture of the prior administration but guilty of torture himself.
America, in the twenty first century, has given a new face and depth to the horrors of EVIL!! If the US is a democracy, then the responsibility for all this murder, mayhem, torture, terrorism, theft, pillage, rape is in the hands of both the politicians and the people. Oh, what a heavy debt has been incurred and what dissolution will occur in the payment of that debt. "what ye sow, so shall ye reap" ( Jesus) It appears that the time for payment is near at hand!
KARMA is the name for it.
and we wonder why the fighting never stops. if i had to live through that kind of treatment i would definitely kill someone. that someone would be at least related to the ones who did the damage to me. after the rodney king trials in semi valley, setting the cops free, there were the so called riots in LA. those weren't riots they were an unorganized revolution. they just needed a little organization, direction and real weapons and bang a revolution.
Sounds about the same as prisoner torture and abuse in US prisons and that by a society that likes to consider itself "civilized". People who behave like this are fucken barbaric savages!
http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article8451.htm
You got that right, the USA is the land of the prison, home of the mentally ill. We have the highest numbers of prisoners and mentally ill folks in the world.
I am sure to a prisoner who is raped and beaten, it does not matter if you are in Iraq, or the US. At home or abroad, you could be renditioned to a place where more formal torture is conducted.
Geneva Conventions? How quaint
Hokey indeed, I was quoting Donald Rumsfeld. Don't you recognize sarcasm? I realize that it is the lowest form of humor, however dark times call for dark humor.
If socialism is "hokey" than what do you call liberals, conservatives and reactionaries?
I am very sorry you feel that way
It seems you aren't really paying attention if you don't recall Rumsfeld making that famously bizarre remark. Also, socialist has been commenting here for quite sometime.
thanks blessthebeasts!, I realize folks are touchy for good reason lately, but we all have to remember that at the end of the day we should unite against the duopoly status quo.
Rummy made a lot of famously bizarre remarks, especially his weird discourse on the world of known unknowns and unknown unknowns. Perhaps he also referred to the Geneva Conventions as "quaint", too.
I seem to recall, however, that the reference to the Geneva Conventions as being "quaint" originated in a written secret legal opinion letter from former White House counsel (and later Attorney General) Alberto Gonzales to President George W. Bush in late January or early February of 2002. Copies of this classified memo leaked into the public domain several months later.
It was this opinion letter which provided the legalistic gloss for treating "suspected terrorists" captured in Afghanistan as neither fish nor fowl, neither criminals subject to international legal protection nor soldier-prisoners of war subject to the restraints of the Geneva Conventions. Voila! By a George Bush presidential executive order, these people were suddenly labeled "enemy combatants", falling neatly through the cracks into a deep black hole where the sun did not shine and where their captors and jailers could make up the rules as they went along in the global war on terror.
Maybe Rumsfeld and Gonzales should share credit. Feel free to correct me if my historical memory on this attribution is askew.
Bill from Saginaw
Please forgive me your Highness, I did not realize that you were a member of the neo-aristocracy. I bow down in deference. Now I understand your lack of humor and sense of irony.
Most Sincerely,
Hokey Socialist
From your posts below the reason there was a name change to "enemy combatants" nit appears to escape you. Are you defending prisoner abuse under that specific guise?
The "rampant abuse" in the Iraqi prisons at the hands of the new jailers, is because their mentors, the Amerikkkan CIA, taught them every thing they know.
Well we blew up that idea ! Now they can be homeless just like us...glad we could rescue them from their horrble lives, oh I'm sorry that's right they had ok lives before we rescued them. I am so ashamed of us :(
The thing is the article says.. they are being, and have been , well we just handed the prison over a couple weeks ago...so this was our baby, they are just doing what we have been doing...how shameful...how can Obama look at himself in the mirror ? This man is no better than G.W. boy did he lie to us, nothing about his promises during the campaign was anything but lies. At least G.W. told us his krapt ,he said the stuff he would do, and he did it ! This guy has been a lie from every word that has left his lips. I am angry that I believed him. I knew he couldn't do everything he said, but I thought he meant it, and was at least going to try...
America has the highest number of prisoners and mentally ill in the world. Many of the prisoners are mentally ill. America said it was inhumane to force people who suffer with mental illness to go to a hospital institution for treatment. Instead of improving the hospitals, liberals are blamed for not allowing the mentally ill patients to be institutionalized in treatment centers, even those who want to be off the streets and in a hospital,( Although I believe it was done to save the government and corporations money.) Who would know that people who suffer mental illness would be forced into prison institutions instead of hospitals? Torture, unjust, long, imprisonment, imprisoned for being ill. America brought that kind of democracy to Iraq at the end of a smart missile. I'm sure our fearless leaders are wondering, how they can blame Saddam Hussein for the torture of prisoners in Iraq today and their criminal injustice system but who can U.S.leaders blame for America's criminal, system? Civilization- "are we there yet?"
Yep America showed them the way ! I agree with the poster that said how can they blame Sadaam now ? We are no better than any oppressive regime we suck ! Our prisons are full of pot smokers, and poor people, many others that are borderline retarded,they keep our system big so Judges, and Lawyers have lots of jobs. There are 2 million people in Americas prisons,same as the amount of people that live in Dallas, Tx.
We crack me up, we blow up their country, kill a million of them, displace all of them ,they have very little electricity, water etc. schools are closed hospitals etc. and then our goverment says ..."Iraq has to learn how to take care of it's self ,we can't be here forever !" Well I don't recall them asking for our help, and they lived much better under Sadaam, and whoever takes over now will be just like Sadaam, because that's the way they have lived, and ruled for thousands of years. All we did was blow up their shit...what a joke ! I feel so bad for them, but I know we are not far behind,this country will fail because we have done to many things wrong, and we will have to pay for it...so enjoy life as it is now ,because this comfort we enjoy is slipping away fast !
The blood being spilled now flows over Obamas hands, it belongs to him. He is a murderer and the leader of a country that willfully tortures people. It is that simple.
When he said that we should look forward, and not prosecute Bush for Crimes Against Humanity, I knew that second that he was a bad guy too. Anybody with any sense of Justice, would realize the crimes that have been committed by the U.S. and her allies. The International Tribunal is currently looking at going after Tony Blair, for Crimes Against Humanity, and if they get him.. the other bags of shit will soon follow ,but they feel this will take so long, that all guilty parties will be dead. Better late than never. I do wish the American people would have demanded it though, it would have been good for the healing of our Country, and many others that have suffered because of our twisted leaders. Oh well....
""what ye sow, so shall ye reap" ( Jesus) It appears that the time for payment is near at hand!
replyreport this commentnew
Jeevee September 13th, 2010 7:01 pm
KARMA is the name for it."
>>>>>>
I think : Cause and Effect.
~sc
katrine.
"That's why the Justice Department under the Bush administration did away of POW status in favor of "enemy combatants."
Hegel changed 'God' to 'The Absolute'.. as Schopenhauer pointed out... the two were one and the same.
~sc