Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
- A Culture That Condones The Killing Of Children And Teaches Children To Kill
- Slaughter in Connecticut: 20 Children, 6 Adults Dead in Kindergarten Massacre
- How the Mighty (Mississippi) Has Fallen: Historic Drought Plagues US
- 'I'd Rather Fight Like Hell': Naomi Klein's Fierce New Resolve to Fight for Climate Justice
- Study: World's Mighty Giants Dying off at Alarming Rate
- A Culture That Condones The Killing Of Children And Teaches Children To Kill
- 'I'd Rather Fight Like Hell': Naomi Klein's Fierce New Resolve to Fight for Climate Justice
- Save the Children: Tears and Tragedy in Connecticut
- Thinking the Unthinkable: On Mental Health, My Son, and Gun Violence
- Remember All the Children, Mr. President
Popular content
Today's Top News
Report: States Pass Staggering Array of Anti-Choice Laws, Policies and Ballot Measures
The Center for Reproductive Rights (CRR) recently released its summary on the "major trends in anti-abortion legislation that emerged this year and of the onerous abortion restrictions enacted," according to a statement from the organization. "A First Look Back at the 2010 State Legislative Session," (PDF) details alarming trends among the states to severely restrict access to legal abortion care.
Of particular consequence this past year has been the Nelson Amendment to the health care reform bill, which is responsible for the ban on abortion coverage in the health exchanges. As mentioned above, in response to the provision, five states have already passed similar state bans with more expected. CRR notes that anti-choice proponents' argument over abortion access in federal health care reform efforts focused on outright false information about the importance of abortion access, as health care, for women in this country.
"...access to abortion is essential to women’s ability to protect their health and well-being throughout their reproductive years. It is also an extraordinarily common procedure: By the age of forty-five, approximately one in three women in this country will have had an abortion. Health organizations including the World Health Organization, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, the American Public Health Association, and the Association of Reproductive Health Professionals recognize abortion as a critical part of comprehensive reproductive health care."
As CRR notes, the amendment practically invites anti-choice legislators to push for abortion bans in their state exchanges, so it's no surprise they've taken the federal government up on the invitation.
Anti-choice restrictions in the 2011 state legislative session can not solely be attributed to the Nelson Amendment, of course. Not by a long shot. Anti-choice legislators have acted swiftly and unrelentingly to block their female residents from accessing legal abortion in a variety of ways, with harmful repercussions for both women and physicians.
Of the mandatory counseling and ultrasound requirements most popular this legislative session, CRR writes,
Ultrasound requirements are particularly demeaning to women, implying both that they do not understand their pregnancies and that they cannot make reasoned decisions without receiving information the state deems important. Women seeking abortions have carefully considered their options and life circumstances, and these requirements serve only as an attempt to shame them and make them feel guilty about their decisions.
For women who have wanted pregnancies or who have been victims of rape, incest, or abuse, these requirements can also result in unnecessary emotional suffering. These bills also interfere with the doctor/patient relationship, forcing physicians to give each woman “one size fits all” treatment, instead of allowing the physician to treat each patient individually according to his or her professional judgment.
There are certain states whose anti-choice bills are worthy of a special mention, in the CRR report, for both sheer number of bills - and their particularly onerous nature. Oklahoma has seen no less than eight attempts to block women's access to abortion care in that state during the state's 2010 legislative session. From a bill that would require physicians to "grill women" by asking them no less than 37 questions, forcing women seeking an abortion "to report their 'marital status, age, race, education, number of live births, number of miscarriages, number of induced abortions, type of abortion and reason for the abortion,'” to a bill prohibiting any claims for damages "on the basis of wrongful life or wrongful birth," Oklahoma has been relentless in their quest to criminalize women's health care. Though Oklahoma's ultrasound bill has a restraining order against it, in place, until 2011, women face a mountain of challenges when attempting to access abortion in that state still.
States from Arizona to Virginia, however, have also enacted abortion restrictions some with far-reaching consequences. In Utah, for example, a law was enacted which "imposes severe criminal penalties on pregnant women who cause the termination of their own pregnancies." Yes, you read that right. It is now potentially illegal, in that state, for women to miscarry. Notes the CRR report,
"This law targets pregnant woman in significant and unintended ways,
subjecting women who experience miscarriages to potential criminal prosecution and inflicting criminal penalties on women who are already suffering such anguishing life circumstances that they would undertake desperate and dangerous measures to end their pregnancies."
Perhaps the most puzzling and potentially harmful trend in the states in 2010 has been the push to confer personhood status upon fertilized eggs by amending state constitutions, using the ballot measure process. These initiatives - to define personhood from the moment of conception - have arisen from the Personhood movement which pushes what CRR calls an "extreme agenda" - an agenda that "would likely fail if proposed in the legislature."
The problem with these proposals - aside from the obvious intent to criminalize abortion - is that they would also ban many forms of contraception and even reproductive technology like in-vitro fertilization. More than that, one can only imagine (and many, including CRR, have) what other laws which use the term "person" would be affected by such a change to a state's constitution, creating utterly absurd but still disastrous consequences for women and their families.
This may be why these measures have not been very successful. Even fellow anti-choice organizations are steering clear of push for personhood. According to CRR:
At the start of 2010, “personhood” ballot initiative campaigns had begun to take shape in at least nine states. However, by August, only two proposals had received enough signatures to be placed on the ballot, in Colorado for the November 2010 election, and in Mississippi for November 2011.
Notably, in 2008, Colorado was the first state to consider a personhood initiative and voters overwhelmingly rejected it, 73 percent to 27 percent.
One ballot measure, in particular however, has been successful as of late. Last week, Alaska passed a parental notification ballot measure mandating that before a young woman can have an abortion, her physician must notify at least one parent. If the young woman lives in an abusive home? CRR says that the only way to avoid the notification process is for her to seek a court order or a signed statement from a law enforcement officer. The proposal also seeks to penalize physicians, notes RH Reality Check's Pamela Merritt, "...who perform abortions on minors without notification of the minor's parents." Sadly, notes Merritt, although most teens - including Alaskan teens - already communicate with their parents, this government mandate now forces parental involvement even when there is good reason not to. Ultimately, it is the young women who fear repercussions from an abusive home environment, and take matters into their own hands, who will suffer.
It may seem as if the 2010 state legislative session floated away on a grey cloud when it comes to abortion laws, however the Center for Reproductive Rights and many pro-choice legislators and fellow advocates have been integral in successfully fighting or temporarily stopping some of the more restrictive ones.
- Posted in
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

40 Comments so far
Show AllIt is difficult to understand how so many supposedly progressive women in the democratic party voted for such a reactionary health care reform that gave the women-hating religious fanatics eveything they wanted. They gave away their rights in order to please party bosses that insisted on helping the insurance monopolies enlarge their customer base. This cowardly behavior is why the theocrats are gaining ground everyday in America which will soon be forcing women to travel to other countries in order to have reproductive rights. Both corrupt parties are now working against women.
THALIDIMIDE: To the extent, as you put it, that "supposedly progressive women in the democratic party voted for such a reactionary health care reform..." I would venture to say it once again came down to that "lesser of evils" limited choice pool that's replaced any premise of genuine representation, or democracy.
Because groups intent upon eroding women's basic reproductive rights (and we're not just talking abortion here, it's also about access to basic birth control!) are making progress in turning the tides backwards... it explains why some of us, myself included, find ourselves increasingly angry with the few Neanderthal males who come to these threads to argue that everything is cool, that women have all sorts of benefits today, that the history of sexism is irrelevant, that Obama is making positive changes, and the most comical one of all... that women own equally violent tendencies to males.
If any men had to carry another being inside of them for 9 months (not to mention be responsible for, for many years) when they preferred to play golf, go off on some military or corporate quest, or have as much sex with as many women as they pleased... you can be sure, safe birth control (and/or abortion) would be THE RULE!
The Christian theocracy wants CONTROL of women. Period.
I recently realized that the mindset I refer to as Mars rules looks upon the world primarily along these narrow lines:
Can I:
Own
Control
or
Destroy
what stands before me... whether it be a company, nation, ecosystem, or another human being.
Unless, of course the subject itself is not compelling, thus merely ignored.
These criteria fit its lockstep mindset. And being armed, intolerant and dangerous... it's spreading like a Virus.
Remember how Christians were seen as a radical, fringe sect when they first appeared on the scene, say back in ancient Rome. It took 400-odd years of persecution before they became mainstream in Rome and a few hundred years more to become mainstream in parts of Europe.
So, in theory, that might mean that today's fringe sects, or one of them at least, will become the new Christian mainstream. I suspect their "worldview" will be sourced from the Deep Green movement, and in time the idea that humanity is part of a fragile web will become the established belief. No need here to go into the tenets of this new "religion", but it does mean that what we are seeing now is the birth of a new social movement. The hatred and the agony and the slaughter we see all round the world is the old order trying to keep control on a fading system - the sand in the hand analogy.
What we are seeing is the pus in the wound bubbling to the surface. Natural healing. Here's my rather ghastly analogy. Wounds itch and throb as they heal. If the world really is an expression of life-force, then it makes sense that the pain and the hatred and the slaughter is this healing on a global scale. Of course some things propser during the healing process, much as the men who make bullets prosper in a time of war. This is natural - imagine in a wound. It's a great time to be a pus molecule - they are everywhere. They are on the rise. For a while, it might be a great time to be a white corpuscle or a red corpuscle, rallying through the veins to the site of an infection. Group solidarity. Safety in numbers. Justified aggression - defeat the invader. This is now happening on a nationwide scale. But it will change.
I would go so far therefore to suggest that the pain and the hatred and the slaughter is, dare I say this, perfectly natural and normal. It is the venting of the toxic matter within us.
I believe that how we handle this time of trial will mark the future "spiritual" development of the species. We are the perhaps the molten metal in the fire - if we deal with the global trauma with compassion and understanding - empathy - that emotion will grow. It will be forged within the fire, as it were.
Of course, I am talking about tiny groups of people here. Fringe sects. Lunatics, they will be called. But gradually, like quicksilver, the groups will coalesce as, indeed, the energy coalesces within us and across the globe.
Oh, this will happen - energy cannot help itself but be attracted to higher vibrations. It is just going to be a frikkin rough 400 years. So start now. Every little effort of compassion counts.
One last caveat - this is not to pity the men who make bullets, for their role is equally defined. It is to understand their role and to smile caringly for them. Without them we could never progress. They are our teachers. It's an odd way to look at it, but doesn't that sound like the Bible - your enemy is your teacher for you learn the most from them?
So we can relax and go with the flow. Things are happening the way they are meant to. Rest assured. Breathe deep into your diaphragm. Let your lower belly swell with air. And do it again.
ONE MAN TRIBE: I thank you for taking the time to write, and certainly I have respected some of your earlier posts. I am not sure this one really resonates with the way I see things. For one thing, I do not see the frame of 400 years as that which viably depicts (or reflects) the speed of transition now underway. Secondly, I think your view of evil is rather casual. It is true that without the darkness, the light would not be discerned; however I would not take it so far as to champion what you refer to as the "pus," or its role in this difficult transition phase.
In addition, your analogy to the way the early Christians were regarded presumes a linear time line. I see time circling, and cycles repeating. That which causes intolerance in the first place is largely hinged on the idea of a deity of exclusion, not one of inclusion. Therefore, religious precepts that tend to divide rather than unify are PART of the problem. The teachings of the Indigenous, shaman, mystics, astrologers is one that seeks to understand the whole and how the parts support it... as opposed to turning one facet/group/tribe against another.
I agree that there will be, as David Korten puts it, a Great Turning... and I believe it will involve MASSIVE labor pains, some of which are already underway... so thank you for the advice on breathing. I spent time practicing that technique with Buddhist monks in Nepal. Nor has my search for a greater, more unifying basis for understanding the human condition and its relationship to the grand, mysterious cosmos, come to any conclusion. In other words, I am still breathing. And learning. And discovering. And caring. And sharing here in this forum.
SR
I would suggest to you that this is a non-event. The Obama health care bill will be defunded, repealed piece meal in any event.
Watch the democrats run from it like the cowards they are.
"If any men had to carry another being inside of them for 9 months (not to mention be responsible for, for many years) when they preferred to play golf, go off on some military or corporate quest, or have as much sex with as many women as they pleased... you can be sure, safe birth control (and/or abortion) would be THE RULE!"
HA! It would be written into law!!!!
MIGHTY: While I still maintain that our politics do not dovetail in many areas, what I find compelling about you is your basic decency. Of course, I wish it could extend to "illegal" aliens, but we're working on that, right?
Have a good day. You have always been more than kind to me. Too bad the young soldier wannabes who come to these threads can't seem to learn from you.
Could someone operate a large ship in international waters to provide 'off-shore' medical attention in this type of situation?
If every state has it's own laws. . .wouldn't it be federal statutes that dictate the laws that apply to the citizen seeking medical care in an 'international' zone?
Mind you, getting to/from the facilities would dramatically drive up the costs involved but it may be worth it to the patient. (Although, in this case, they could just go to another state it would seem.)
"Could someone operate a large ship in international waters to provide 'off-shore' medical attention in this type of situation? "
That would make no sense. The patient will still have to pay for it.
The problem is not availability. Abortions are not banned. They are still available but have to be paid for by the patient. Being elective interventions (in most cases) i agree they should not be paid for with taxpayer funds. If the patient has extra insurance by all means go ahead, she can have as many abortions as she wants.
"Being elective interventions (in most cases) i agree they should not be paid for with taxpayer funds."
So your position is that this reproductive right should be available only to the rich. This is precisely the attitude that Sioux Rose described as Neanderthal.
That's right. Opps. Forgot. Viagra is a medical necessity, paid for by insurance and birth control is evil and, therefore, an out of pocket expense.
Talk is always about "the patient" when in pregnancy there are two "patients" involved. We should have "his" insurance pay to get rid of "his" problem, and if not then "he" could be made to pay the estimated bill for the life expectancy of the product of "his" involvement, as well as a life time of baby sitting, child rearing, nurturing, and the offset of lost potential career possibilities for the soon to be mother of "his" product.
All pro-lifers should be made to register and when an abortion is denied, they should be contacted to make a "right fit" for the newborn and then be made responsible to raise that child as their own. Oh, how the rhetoric would change! Reality would come to bite those who demand every one see life the way they do. Also, the Catholic church should not be allowed to funnel any money from America and should be made to completely subsidize the afore mentioned registration and matching process as well as donating the rest to paying those denied abortions in cases where the "male" involved is nowhere to be found. This is because they are the ones holding the guns to the heads of most pro-lifers.
they are just following Hitler's shining example...if you control the uterus's (uterii?)of the nation, you control society.
Much like the congo, where rape is used as a weapon....the fanatics in the USA are also fighting to control sexual reproduction as a political means to an end.
Who are these people that are voting for these laws ? It is no bodys business what a women does with a medical procedure done by her doctor.
This Country is being run by religious fanatics, we may end up having a civil war again...the religious freaks against normal people. I wonder how that war is going to work out...lol
Sometimes I feel like I am on a Planet with nuts, that I don't even understand how they come up with their thought process ? Where does this odd ball thinking come from ? How does it spread so fast ?
Take away their money, don't educate them, and keep them afraid, do this, and you can rule the people !
I wonder if bad guys,like corrupt politicians,and C.E.O.'s,if any of these guys watch movies about the horrors of bad guys, and how what they do hurts, and affects millions of people,I wonder if they see themselves, and if so, do they ever think about what scum they are ?
No that would require a conscience that most of the politicians and anti-women, gay ect group lack funny how Viagra is covered under insurance though isn't it. The most idiotric thing about all of this is that anti abortion people have no problem with killing "brown" people or endless wars and sanctions.
Falkujah is f&cked for generations. None of those women would have the right to abort a deformed fetus that our criminal military has condemmed them too. Or should I say condamned. Face it, this US is got to have some of the stupidist people ever born. I would like to go to one of those clinics and play their games just to give them some fun.
This article is enough to make you weep, scream or gnash your teeth, until the cautiously optimistic end. Like razormirror I wonder who these ugly, mean, narrow-minded people are, and it reminds me of the 'joke' a number of years ago: they call themselves the Moral Majority but they're neither. And, thank goodness, they aren't (yet) a majority.
For women who have no money for an abortion, there ought to be a national fund, paid into by people like me (now that I've stopped sending money to the Democratic Party). There must be some women's organizations who can come together and create a 'bank' which loans women the price of an abortion in the same way as micro-financing systems work in third-world countries. Most women would pay it back, gladly, even if only $5 a month is all they can spare.
Someone please pass this idea on to where it can be discussed or even, let's hope, implemented.
Note how -- as capitalism marches its entities forward to full constitutional personhood -- women are forced ever backward to total subjugation.
Coincidence?
I think not.
Just as Christianity and Islam are the direct descendants of the hitherto alien patriarchal savagery that conquered the planet by exterminating the inconceivably ancient cultural ethos we know today as Minoan, so is capitalism the direct derivative of the savagery embodied in Christian theology.
Note the progressions:
From Goddess as mother of us all to God the divine dictator, God the royal tyrant, God the heavenly Fuhrer, God the chief executive officer whose egotistic favoritism, greed, hatefulness and sadism determine even the minutia of how we live and die.
God, king, Fuhrer, CEO -- to facilitate His alien conquest and His triumphant tyranny, our human consciousness is methodically blinded: the Gaean reality of the cosmic and Earthly womb is tabooed forever; Nature is proclaimed the enemy; the physical universe once defined as the sacred living flesh of the Mother is not only purged of divinity but reduced to dead matter valued only for its profitability; the once superior female gender is not only overthrown and reduced to chattel but defined as the source of all evil.
Whether headed by priest, king, Fuhrer or CEO, God appoints the ubermenschen of His Select, the Communion of the Saved, to rule with zero tolerance over all of us He proclaims members of the Legion of the Damned. We are thus cursed as untermenschen: all of us who are pagans, rebels, heretics, agnostics, witches, scientists, abominations, revolutionaries, disabled, unemployed -- all of us who dare question His edicts.
See the connections?
See how Christianity inevitably becomes Capitalism?
See how Capitalism -- infinite greed as maximum virtue; limitless selfishness as ultimate good -- inevitably becomes Nazism?
The Third Reich was the dress rehearsal for tomorrow, crushed not for its atrocities but for its revelations of true capitalist reality.
Yeats saw it all too clearly: "And what rough beast, it's hour come round at last..."
Comes now the Fourth Reich, God's War against Woman and Nature institutionalized.
Forever.
Note how -- as capitalism completes its inevitable metamorphosis into the Fourth Reich -- women and Nature are forced ever backward to extinction.
LOREN: Powerful post.
I've been thinking a lot about Arthur Miller's play, "The Crucible" lately, and how even on these threads the HATRED towards subjects that are outside of the norms shows up. There is a fear, bordering on brutality, in some who wish to maintain the status quo. These persons would rather shoot the messenger, or assassinate his or her character than own up to what's really going on.
I met an interesting guy in Peru who has a popular blog in U.K. He sends me his newsletter now and it related an incident that ran parallel in many ways to what was done recently to set up Julian Assange. Similar tactics have been used on scientists who sound the climate alarm bells. It's insidious, the degree to which persons of conscience are being aimed at by the monstrous machine and its paid enablers.
What made the witch-hunts possible during earlier times was that the church had snitches everywhere, what BORN FREE MAN describes in these threads as some kind of stasi group stalking him. During any phase of authoritarian control, without "neighbors" doing some of the fascist dirty work, the system cannot operate effectively.
There is a facet embedded into human nature that comes out in certain eras and societies that rushes at the whistleblower making him or her the projection screen (scapegoat) for everything that is wrong, as opposed to having to face what's broken and actually take pains to fix it. Glenn Beck has mastered this dark art.
This savage animal pack behavior was related in the story/film "Sounder," and readily on view in many forms of gang violence. Its psychological correlation shows when mere accusation is enough to summon raw punishment. The modern U.S. torture camp presents another variation on this theme. Here, too, by mere suggestion that someone is guilty supplies all the "evidence" that's needed for unspeakable things to be done unto such persons.
And so, whether or not another round of McCarthy hearings begin, one can be sure that to the extent the church-state fuses, and the fear of an angry & jealous male god runs through the blood of the citizenry, more innocents will be tortured, falsely accused, charged with crimes (if they're lucky enough to hear these articulated) largely to insure that the "masses" remain in the dark as to the true causative agents behind the web of deception, destruction and darkness that passes for governance today.
Shirley Jackson, author of "The Lottery," fully understood this ugly latent element of human society. I don't think it's inevitable to human nature; but I think it inevitably results (as a seeming product of human nature) when beliefs are taught that are anathema to life, pleasure, beauty, love, justice, fairness, and any remote notion of equality.
Thank you for being a male who understands the roots of history, and can see where all this worship of only half the Divine force has gotten us.
There is a pro-science poster who takes issue with the concept of Mother Nature. It's not enough for him that all of the Abrahamic religions are writ in the masculine pronoun, (almost without exclusion), he would deny even this to the Great Feminine.
Thank you, Siouxrose; always good to hear from you. The above response that begins "Due to shortages of time and space..." was originally written specifically for you, with the prefatory sentence that it explains a perspective you and I take pretty much for granted but which, if new to others, might help clarify what we are talking about. Again thanks.
LOREN: Your acknowledgement is much appreciated, and also very kind of you. Your understanding is comprehensive and your knowledge goes beyond what many in this forum have ever stopped to study... or consider.
I am grateful to be in the company of a mind like yours.
As the nation turns virtually blind, recognizing others with "the sight" makes the planet less lonely, and the future more promising.
Now when I head out for tonight's bike ride, I'll carry your warm message along for the ride. Who knows, perhaps further inspiration may follow.
I hope you are well.
"Note how -- as capitalism completes its inevitable metamorphosis into the Fourth Reich -- women and Nature are forced ever backward to extinction."
Loren, thanks for the really good post but I find your conclusion overly pessimistic. This century is on the cusp of of a mega historical change due to the population explosion, resource depletion, ecological disaster and financial collapse (as debt saturation is the limit of debt money). The society that arises from the ashes and possible Dark Ages will have to live by those principles of true spirituality and respect for Mother Earth if our species is to survive the Sixth Extinction.
Thank you for the affirmative response.
Alas, like James Lovelock I rather doubt our species will survive at all.
The shibboleth expressed in what should be the most infamously telling incident of the Vietnam War -- "we had to destroy the village (and kill all the villagers) to save it (from Godless Communism)" -- is amongst the core mandates of Christianity, likewise of Islam, which are the governing credos of the capitalist Ruling Class.
What is horribly unique about this era is that the capitalist Ruling Class has made itself truly omnipotent -- as powerful as any god ever imagined.
With the destruction of the Soviet Union and the corruption of China complete, the Ruling Class is granting itself genuinely unlimited power by its mastery of technology.
This is further bolstered by stolen wealth -- the real reason the Ruling Class is looting the world economies.
As a result there is no force on Earth -- not now and not ever again -- capable of overthrowing capitalism or even successfully resisting its death-camp tyrannies.
And in the extremely unlikely possibility such force were somehow to emerge, the Ruling Class would not hesitate to push the terminal button: "We had to destroy the planet to save it from Godlessness."
LOREN: I am currently revising a script I wrote in the early l990's that's based on a bond between a boy and a dolphin. At one point the boy goes overboard from his little Florida Keys skiff, and his body is never recovered. In my story, due to his bond with a dolphin-familiar, he is transformed INTO a dolphin. I lend this event credibility (within the context of sci-fi) by suggesting that the Atlantean high priests were well aware that their lands were soon to be destroyed. Therefore they made use of their understanding of genetic technology to create a form that would hold intelligence and withstand the inevitably rising floodwaters: enter the dolphin!
When the Gulf rupture began in April, I was, of course, devastated. We are yet to undertand the impact. Meanwhile, I didn't know what to do with this script/story. About a month ago it came to me by sheer inspiration (not to mention inspiration direct from Peruvian shaman)... so now the revised ending will represent a genuine improvement over the original.
The reason I am relating this is that lately I have begun to sense what the Atlanteans in the know must have understood... how quickly lands are breaking up, weather patterns (which of course point to harvest cycles, or the lack of same) altering, calamities occurring. It makes me think, "We're all Atlanteans, now!"
The other parallel thought is how we're also becoming more like those good Germans as the uniformed guards point at Muslims and "illegal" Hispanic aliens, with Blacks always there as the default scapegoat. It's beyond tragic what passes for law, order, or justice in Amerika, today.
The dog, the same one who's enamored by all those "largers" is jone'sing for his bike ride! I believe I am teaching some language skills to him. He knows what ride means, as well as treat.
Personally I think that there are many moral issues around abortion, but I would never support the State determining the answers to these moral questions.
The state should stay out of personal and family matters.
Similarly, I oppose draconian child support and domestic violence laws as intrusion into personal and family issues.
This is about who decides the issue of reproduction in a woman's life and women are being relieved of that responsibility. And, for those that think reproduction is a personal decision, well there is a jail cell waiting for them. I didn't read what the consequences are for getting someone pregnant. It use to be that it was unconstitutional to make laws that only affect one class of people and not others.
Due to shortages of time and space I skimmed over several important points that might serve as intellectual gate-keys for newcomers. Ergo:
(1)--The transition from patriarchy through Christianity and Islam to capitalism and finally to fascism is historical proof that ideas have consequences. It is perhaps THE classic example of the idea-to-reality process in action. It is also a vivid illustration of the dynamic that fuels history – the interaction of cause and effect.
(2)--The pivotal function of the god-concept in this process becomes evident only when we are able to transcend the (deliberate?) distractions of conflicts over the existence of the divine. Distancing ourselves from the associated doctrinal warfare – and warfare is precisely what it is – is extremely difficult in a de facto theocracy like the United States. But it is well worth the effort; only from such distance can we view the concept of god – any god – with enough objectivity to examine its psycho-dynamic and psycholinguistic functions. Only then can we see that – no matter whether god is objectively real or not – god is a primary art symbol, an ultimate human symbiosis, a concentrate formed by the interaction of self and other, with “other” defined to include the entire cosmos and everyone/everything within it. God is therefore both a blueprint for society and an ever-evolving summation of what that society believes to be true. Descriptions of god or divine essence – Christendom's “I am the Lord thy God; thou shalt have no other gods before Me”; Islam's “There is no God but Allah and Mohammad is His prophet”; the First Nations' concept of “Great Holy Mystery”; Asia's “the Tao that can be named is not the true Tao”; Minoan society's presumptive “In the beginning was the Mother and She gave birth” – reveal not just the principles that shape our behaviors but the direction, intent and probable destination of the societies in which we live.
(3)--History, archaeology and anthropology show humanity's original gods to have been female. The original social and familial structures were matrifocal and/or matrilineal (if not matriarchal); the original human economies were various forms of proto-communism. Because the psycho-dynamic impulses that govern human consciousness seem to have changed very little (if at all) during our species presumptive 100,000-year history, we can hypothesize a mutually sustaining relationship between god, society and individual essentially identical to that of today, with each of these elements in their characteristic albeit gradual states of flux.
Our hypothesis is confirmed by what we know of the societies in question -- information gleaned via history, anthropology, archaeology, folklore and myth. Minoan civilization is especially relevant here because of the archaeological evidence that strongly suggests it was a national fruition of the incalculably ancient tribal societies that preceded it: thus – despite intensifying censorship by the capitalist Ruling Class – Minoan civilization has emerged as a definitive archetype of its era and kind. Though capitalist archaeologists are loathe to admit it, Minoan cities had neither slums nor mansions. The structures capitalist archaeologists deceptively label as “palaces” were more likely to have been administrative offices and are in fact so catalogued by researchers who are exempt from capitalism's overpowering need to propagandize greed and hierarchy as human norms. Meanwhile the existence of a powerful, effective and definitively humanitarian Minoan administrative apparatus – exactly the sort such installations might house – is proven beyond argument by the successful evacuation of Thera.
Indeed the Minoans' matrifocal, ecocentric religion and their proto-communist infrastructure are increasingly regarded as the apex of human achievement, not merely of the Bronze Age but of all time.
Hence the duration of Minoan civilization, which is genuinely breathtaking: despite a peacefulness proven by its lack of fortifications and other military structures, the Minoan world endured well over a thousand years before its fatal weakening by an inconceivably destructive volcanic debacle – probably the worst such disaster in all human experience. And it may have extended far beyond the Mediterranean: based on a line of British poetry presumptively dated to 600 BCE – Taliesin's “I have sung before the rulers of Britain, abounding in fleets” – Bronze Age Britain may have been a Minoan commonwealth.
(4)--When we apply the same analytical principles to patriarchy – male supremacy symbolized by a male god (a concept that seems to have remained alien until the Theran debacle and its apocalyptic aftermath, which was no doubt taken as proof the goddess had failed or turned hostile) – we again see the importance and function of the god concept: how humanity defines god and how that definition shapes humanity.
Rejecting god as nurturing mother who loves us all as children of her divine womb – the goddess whose body is the universe (a concept eerily reborn in the Gaea Hypothesis) – we emerge from the tsunami-drowned and Achaean-sacked ruins of Knossos to kneel in terror before a god who has become the ultimate abusive father: the Nature-hating misogynist who loves only his Chosen (those who have proclaimed themselves his children) and so despises all the rest he condemns us to eternal damnation – psychologically the most terrifying concept ever articulated.
God the Father thus becomes god the Führer; the collective humanitarian consciousness of proto-communism is overthrown by the malevolence of greed and hierarchy (contrast the evacuation of Thera with the abandonment of New Orleans); human society is divided into the anointed (and therefore Saved) aristocracy of god's übermenschen and the damned (and therefore infinitely exploitable) slave-pen üntermenschen of everyone else.
As I described below, capitalism is the inevitable consequence – just as fascism is the inevitable fulfillment of capitalism.
LOREN: I bow before you. In fact I am going to do so right now!
I hope the individuals listed below, who have by turns terrorized and demonized me for trying to say what you just related, take heed and learn something from your post. You did an EXQUISITE, scholarly, and profound job of laying it all out. Better than I could have. (And I don't say that often. LOL.) Bravo!!!!
Are you listening. fellas....
Drosera!
Dreamjoehill.
Martian Bachelor (the vocab will probably prove far too challenging)
Shawn Berry " " "
Frederick Douglas
And whatever other screen names you resident CD misogynists make use of so regularly in these threads.
I just replied. I'm not a misogynist but fetuses have feelings too. Plenty of women think so too.
Since my name was called, I will respond. I have little knowledge of Christianity but I'm already an atheist even in this religious CO Springs. I still respect people of different religions and have religious friends myself. I also believe that patriarchy alone isn't always a bad thing. Patriarchy only means that men rule. Whether they are abusers or not depends on each individual. Abusing religion and patriarchy is the problem and each is done separately. If gods were originally female, then why did they cede to the males? The answer is females knew that they depended on males and later males found out that they depended on females. But enough of this silly blame God, Mars, or males for everything. It's time for men and women to work together and make gender neutrality mainstream. If we should have a deity, please make it neuter so we can all stop this silly male vs female divide and stop blaming one gender or the other. Back to the article, fetuses have a life before life and they have feelings so women and men should be mutually responsible before women get into another baby blooper accident. If women and men would work together on bridging each gender's inequalities, abortion wouldn't be an issue. Anyway, I got to go right now and back to enjoying what I can of labor day.
It would be great for women to get in tune with their fertility cycles and for men to understand too. Then they will know better how to prevent unwanted pregnancy. There are three clues that together should provide a good idea of fertility. One involves what is called a basal thermometer, and there are non-electronic versions of those. With awareness and empowerment conveyed person to person the elites will have one less issue to abuse for further enslavement of the people. There are 129 million housing units in the USA. Everyone has to have their own private castle. With everyone pushed by elites into material gluttony and social isolation, it come as little surprise that so many want to abort their pregnancies.
There have been some marvelous comments to this article.
Sioux Rose, as always, with her insight.
Lorenbliss with her grasp of history. (If you can find a copy of "Forbidden Archeology," Cremo and Thompson, you might find it of interest.)
Onemantribe's analysis of it being an infection.
As to Theocracy, one might read Heinlein's "Revolt in 2100" to see where that could lead.
I don't have much of profundity to say here. I remember the relief felt when Roe vs Wade finally established the woman's right to her own body. Finally it had ended the situation where the wealthy went on a "vacation" to Sweden. The poor got a rusty coat hanger in a back alley.
I watch with tears the erosion of all the civil rights that we fought so hard for and "won."
A lot of rather weird association passed through my mind as I read the article and its comments. A song from Monty Python's "The Meaning of Life." "Every sperm is sacred."
Onemanstribe's infection and pus made me think of gangrene, which is the other direction an infection might go. I had a gangrenous wound years ago. The doctor would not remove the affected part as he said there was too much chance of infecting the rest of my body. I had to live with the agony and stench until it finally shriveled up and dropped off.
Gaia has been a good mother to her wayward children, but as I read and study, I find that, for instance, the amphibians such as frogs and salamanders are disappearing or mutating, apparently due to increased UV. Our various chemicals are leaching into the groundwater and into the sea. Infertility is increasing in many species. The oceans, our lifeblood, are being poisoned at an increasing rate. Arable land is being turned into housing developments. Much of what is left has been bought or leased by big oil to raise grains for ethanol, while millions starve. As the world climate continues to change, glaciers melt, ice caps diminish, sea levels rise, droughts torture the landscape worldwide, while unprecedented floods inundate others.
I greatly fear our Mother is dying and we are too stupid to figure it out, or attempt to heal Her. Instead, we look for even greater "profit" by continuing the rape and torture of Her body.
Those fortunate enough to have seen earth from orbit, or from the moon have all remarked on this beautiful blue and green marble, rolling along, all alone in the vastness of space.
Earth is our home. It is all we have. If we kill her, all the wealth in the galaxy will not prevent us from dying with her.
The fact that attempts to “confer personhood status upon fertilized eggs” have failed is a positive. The idea that from the moment of conception the legal entity usually in law called a “person” exists seems to be the essence of the claim that “life begins at conception.” It doesn’t take much thought to realize that this claim, enacted in law, would result in damaging, and ridiculous, consequences.
Science supports the belief that members of all identifiable groups of humans are endowed at conception with equal capacity to lead successful lives. This equal start is immediately negated by influences that ultimately result in persons born to blacks, Hispanics, and Native Americans – I’m speaking of the U.S., but every country has counterparts to these – being statistically much less likely to achieve success than whites and certain Asians. So, personhood doesn’t begin at conception, but discrimination does. I’ve never heard anyone in the pro-life movement take note of this, notwithstanding that such discrimination is a major reason abortions are obtained.
Three more points:
(1)--We already live under Christian theocracy – mostly theocracy cloaked in euphemisms: nullification of church/state separation, as by the malicious refusal of Christian pharmacists to sell birth control or by extension of “freedom of speech” to protect Christianity's war against science and secular society. It is theocracy protected by codas of “political correctness” – for example the taboo against speculating on the connection between Sen. Harry Reid's role in torpedoing health-care reform and his beliefs as a Mormon Elder.
No doubt this will change after 2012, when Moron Nation elects Palin/Beck and the U.S. experiment in constitutional democracy will be formally ended, probably by the same emergency decree with which President Palin declares herself the de facto Führer of the de facto Fourth Reich. Congress, by then as tautly controlled by the Teabaggers and GOPorkers as the Weimar Reichstag was controlled by the Nazis in 1933, will no doubt add its rubber-stamp of approval, at which point a New Inquisition will begin the nation's theological cleansing even as the more definitively secular Department of Homeland Security unleashes its geheimestaatspolizei on all political dissidents including the few remaining DemocRats.
The economic purpose of theocracy is perpetuation of the slave mentality essential to permanent submissiveness to oppression. Christian theocracy's primary weapon is fear – specifically the truly infinite fear of eternal damnation – psychologically the most abjectly terrifying concept ever articulated.
Though theocracy itself is ancient, its modern effectiveness was proven in the U.S. South, where post-Civil War experiments in governance by the Ruling Class demonstrated how Christian theocracy could provide a near-absolute barrier to humanitarian activism, whether in the workplace or society in general.
Christian churches thus became brain-police installations. The consequences include:
(A)--the South's unique history of racial bigotry, misogynistic brutality and savage resistance to organized labor (note the polite Southern euphemism for the Ku Klux Klan: “the Saturday Night Men's Bible Study Class”);
(B)--the post-King nullification of the Civil Rights Movement – note not only the emergence of national racism in the wake of the Katrina atrocities but the Palin/Beck co-optation of the Civil Rights Movement;
(C)--the nationalization of theocracy itself, proven by the spread of Christian fanaticism throughout the U.S.
Acknowledgement of the third trend was the real message in Barack the Betrayer's appointment of the rabidly misogynistic and homophobic theocrat Rick Warren to give the 2009 inaugural invocation -- the theological equivalent of the keynote address at a political convention.
(Relevant aside: Though the Left suicidally dismisses the capitalist Ruling Class as a cabal of greed-blinded dunces, history proves it to be the diametrical opposite: in truth the most diabolically cunning, selfishly malevolent, murderously adept elite ever. Now – because of its wealth, criminal skill and mastery of technology – it is empowered for the remainder of human time: that is. until our species is extinct.)
(2)--The extent of present-day theocratic oppression becomes apparent if we examine how the DemocRats' economic policies abolish Working Class reproductive freedom. While the GOPorkers openly battle reproductive freedom, the 'Rats attack it economically. The prerequisite of all U.S. reproductive rights is adequate health insurance – that is, insurance that supports female reproductive independence. The Ruling Class is ensured by its inconceivable wealth, but such insurance is available to the Working Class only as a condition of employment. Hence job-losses inflicted by the 'Rats' so-called “free market” policies are as effectively anti-choice as any outright abortion ban. Add the birth control prohibitions imposed by welfare and Obamacare plus Obamacare's implicit war on employer-provided health insurance and what emerges is a political truth the 'Rats try desperately to keep secret: the fact that despite their pro-choice rhetoric, the 'Rats' actions – welfare restrictions, free trade, Obamacare – prove them as misogynistic as any bible-thump GOPorker. Only the richest women -- those of the Ruling Class -- escape the prohibitions.
(3)--When I contemplate the history of patriarchy and its progression through Christianity to capitalism thence to fascism and ultimately to the extinction of all human life, I find myself wishing I were skilled at writing fiction, which I am not. Probably because I am dyslexic, my flights of creative imagination are limited to visual media: chiefly photography and collage. But if I were a novelist, what an epic of science fiction I could write:
Imagine a universe policed by a humanoid species unimaginably older than ourselves, inconceivably more advanced (and therefore capable of light-speed travel), but a species that for all its technological mastery is terrified by the long-term potential of any similar species emerging elsewhere across the galaxies. Indeed this Nazi-like species fears its counterparts exactly as post-Islamic-Invasion Europeans feared the inhabitants of other continents and sought to enslave these indigenous peoples as colonial subjects lest the indigents rise to invasive power exactly as the Muslims had done. Hence the Forenazis patrol the cosmos, exterminating potential rivals, and over the hundreds of thousands of years of their cosmic despotism, they perfect their Final Solution to leave no discernible trace. Eventually the Forenazis reconnoiter Earth; they see the limitless promise of humans manifest at Knossos. In retaliation the Forenazis pick a handful of tribes to vector their terminal disease of patriarchy. The Forenazis appear as gods, proclaiming their New Order. Patriarchy expands: the pains of the sword are more compelling than the pleasures of love. Finally when the time seems ripe the Forenazis engineer an apocalypse: Callisté – Thera – explodes with the force of at least two dozen H-bombs; the patriarchal legions then boil into the ruins and murder the survivors. The Minoan ethos is exterminated.
Terminal species failure begins.
The Forenazis salute one another; they have saved their cosmic Reich again.
But of course this (3) is only science fiction.
LOREN, you MALE genius, you... I am going to mention this thread on one of today's center articles as I don't think enough people caught it. The time and effort you put into your brilliant posts deserve to be recognized by those who might otherwise pass these gems by.
It gives me hope to know there are men like you and Minitrue out there... I've experienced some very savage and/or closed minds (to anything outside the realm of ego and/or the linear science equivalent) in these threads. It is SO refreshing to experience the through processes of those who truly do fly over The Cuckoo's Nest and lead the rest of the pack towards potential transcendence!
I wish you well. And then some.
Remember, many Sci-Fi writers have turned into prophets, as have other writers. George Orwell, Jack London, Robert Heinlein, Sinclair Lewis and many more.
Write the story.
Have you read "Revolt in 2100"?
I just posted a somewhat more detailed version of my earlier comments -- complete with an appropriate photograph -- on my blog, Loren Bliss: Outside Agitator's Notebook, at http://lorenbliss.typepad.com/