Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Tribal Groups, Activists Claim Victory as Vedanta Mine Plan Halted by Indian Government
Vedanta's controversial bauxite mine on tribal land stopped • Authorities say firm violated forestry and environment rules
Controversial plans to develop a bauxite mine on sacred tribal land in India have been scuppered as India's environment ministry has rejected a proposal by Vedanta Resources to mine the aluminium ore in the eastern state of Orissa.
Members of the Dongria Kondh tribe gather on top of the sacred Niyamgiri Hills. Plans by Vedanta to mine bauxite from the area have now been rejected by India's environment ministry. (Photograph: Reinhard Krause/Reuters) Campaigners, who have been backed in their fight against the mining giant's plans by Joanna Lumley and Michael Palin, described the move as a "stunning victory". Monty Python star turned professional traveller Palin expressed "absolute delight" in the news adding: "I hope it will send a signal to the big corporations that they can never assume that might is right. It's a big victory for the little people."
The project had been thrown into doubt last week when a government inquiry said that mining would destroy the way of life of the area's "endangered" and "primitive" people, the Kutia and Dongria Kondh tribes. The four-person committee also accused a local subsidiary of Vedanta of violating forest conservation and environment protection regulations.
Jairam Ramesh, the minister for environment and forests, said today that the government will issue what is termed a show-cause notice and take action against Vedanta. The news sent shares in the company down almost 6% in early trading, making it the biggest loser in the FTSE 100 index and wiping almost £300m off the value of the business.
"There are very serious violations of environment act and forest right act," Ramesh told Bloomberg. "There is no emotion, no politics, no prejudice in the decision. It is purely based on a legal approach."
Campaigners, whose supporters also include the activist Bianca Jagger, have fought long and hard to prevent the mining of bauxite in the Niyamgiri Hills. Vedanta, which can appeal against the decision, had wanted to expand its existing refinery in the area, generating a sixfold increase in capacity, and had gained approval from the local state government.
Amnesty International published a report last year claiming that a Vedanta refinery in the same area had polluted local rivers, damaged crops and disrupted the lives of the local tribe.
The project has been delayed by four years because of intense opposition from environmental and tribal rights group. At Vedanta's annual meeting in London last month its board of directors faced criticism from shareholders, celebrity activists and charities all protesting about the company's human rights and environmental record.
Meredith Alexander, head of trade and corporates at ActionAid, said: "Today the Kondh people are celebrating a massive victory in the campaign to safeguard their very existence.
"The mine would destroy the mountain they worship as a god and end their way of life forever. Vedanta could appeal this decision, but the Kondh are asking the company to respect the government's decision and their clearly expressed opposition to the mine."
Survival International, whose supporters sent more than 10,000 protest letters to the Indian government, described the decision as a "stunning victory" and "a crushing defeat for billionaire Anil Agarwal, Vedanta's majority owner and founder".
Survival campaigner Dr Jo Woodman said: "This is a victory nobody would have believed possible. The Dongria's campaign became a litmus test of whether a small, marginalised tribe could stand up to a massive multinational company with an army of lobbyists and PR firms and the ear of government.
"Incredibly, the Dongria's courage and tenacity, allied with the support of many people in India, and Survival's supporters around the world, have triumphed."
Survival's director, Stephen Corry, added: "The era when mining companies could get away with destroying those in their path with impunity is thankfully drawing to a close.
"The concerned public must remain vigilant about these so-called development projects - companies simply cannot be trusted voluntarily to abide by human rights standards, particularly when dealing with tribal peoples who can't know what they're up against."



9 Comments so far
Show AllIf this holds up, this is a spectacular, David-beats-Goliath (or an entire army of Goliaths) victory.
This article is worthy of hundreds of comments-- but most likely will receive but a handful. For whatever reason, we unfortunately often find it challenging to muster much passion or inquisitiveness for that which is beyond our ken.
There is an article by Arundhati Roy called "Walking with the Comrades" (http://www.outlookindia.com/article.aspx?264738) that is an incredible view into the world inhabited by Indian tribal peoples in this region. The pictures accompanying the piece are quite good. Ms. Roy's writing is not always to my taste, but I find her bravery in researching and publishing this piece to be exemplary. The comments are worth perusing, too. Many view the tribal movement simply as maoist terrorists, and Ms. Roy is pilloried. Things are rarely clear-cut in our world.
There is an ongoing struggle in India-- you could without exaggeration call it a civil war-- that pits tribal people against the power of the corporations, and the state. There are valuable mineral deposits in Orissa state and other places, and the people who have lived there for millennia are fighting for their survival. Because they have lived there for so long, in many cases they have no legal title to the land-- one of many ironies in their story.
What we here in the 'developed' world should remark upon is how determined these people are about defending their land and way of life. Would that our efforts against mountaintop removal and offshore drilling (not to mention global warming) be marked by similar gutsiness and common purpose. Can we use these folk as an example, and get to it?
I first heard about this issue through Roy's writing. I have found her to be quite incisive in her critiques of India and America as well, and a damn good writer and speaker to boot ...
This is good news. But... there are also more battles going on - legal as well as actual, physical confrontations, in India, especially involving tribals and mining and steel companies, including the South Korean company Posco. I hope activists can gather some much needed strength and momentum from this outcome.
What the capitalists fail to understand is that a victory for the Dongria Kondh is also a victory for them and their own descendants. We are all on this boat together, and the abusers are like somebody drilling a hole in the bottom.
I agree, lord_buckley. We are all together on this little piece of rock in the middle of a vast universe.
Joe
One for the good guys ....
Beautiful people won a great victory against a big corporation. That's not every day.
Long live the mountain people!
It is a rare event when indigenous people get a measure of justice. They have something to teach the rest of human kind bent on ecological and moral bankruptcy.
The people in Bhopal didn't die completely in vain. Their deaths warned other people of the dangers of allowing foreign corporations to take over. The Kutia and Dongria Kondh tribes have shown us what can be done. They were living OK without Vedanta, and would not have shared in the profits, but would only have had the rug pulled out from under their way of life, their environment degraded, or worse. What they have, but we do not, is clarity about how they want to live and the courage to fight for it.
This is similar to Haiti or Africa, where what is needed is the protection of traditional small scale farming, not its replacement by enterprises based outside the country. If you have a small farm and a few chickens or a goat you can survive. City life dominated by foreign corporations, or agriculture controlled by the Monsantos deprive people of opportunity and control.
Joe