Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Deaths in the Desert
There are places, like the medical examiners office in Tucson, Arizona, where the human cost of migration to the United States is counted.
(Getty Images) Dr Bruce Parks, the chief medical examiner, is a tall,
thin, quiet man. He put on rubber gloves and led me over to a zippered
plastic bag sitting on a steel gurney.
"These people, we don't know who they are, and we may never know," he says, opening the container.
Dr Parks gently withdraws a skull, grey and dry, weathered by the sun and gnawed by scavengers. What's in this bag was once a man. He was found in the desert outside Tucson, along the route that migrants take from Mexico.
"I don't know his age," Dr Parks says, turning the skull slowly in his hands. "He had teeth once, but the teeth are not there anymore - evidently they have fallen out due to animal activity."
'Awful and lonely'
Dr Parks has been working long hours this month, as more and more men and women from Latin America have been found in the nearby desert, along the trails to "El Norte" - the United States.
"This year, or this particular month of the year, has been one of the worst months ever," he says wearily. "To date we have had 53 bodies made known to us and brought to this office."
The people who wind up in Dr Parks' morgue died awful and lonely deaths - suffering from thirst and heat. He's found evidence some committed suicide rather than endure that pain - corpses with their veins opened by razor blades, and a man who hung himself with his own shoelaces.
Its difficult to imagine what horror and hopelessness they felt in those last moments, alone in the wasteland, far from home, their hopes for a new and better life cruelly mocked by the relentless desert heat.
No one is certain why so many are dying just now. Some believe it is because the US government has stepped up more intensive patrols and built stronger barriers at traditional border crossing spots. As a consequence, determined migrants now must trek through the most desolate and deadly terrain along the border.
It's a grueling trip over rutted dirt roads into the heart of the desert. We travelled in an air conditioned four-wheel-drive Chevy Tahoe SUV. Migrants make the trip on foot. Most carry just a plastic jug of water-not nearly enough for a journey of five to seven days across sun-blasted, rocky wastes bristling with cactus and thorny scrub.
On the day we went into the desert, the temperature hovered around 37 degrees C. Water is what people need most there to survive. And some take it upon themselves to bring water into the wilderness.
At a series of stations along the migrant route, marked by blue flags, there are casks of water maintained by a group called Humane Borders.
Bob Cabigas, a volunteer with the group, has filled the barrels full every week for over three years. Examining one container with a water-volume measuring device, he can tell someone has come by to drink. "This one needs some water," he says. "There's about 15 gallons somebody used."
Brutal terrain
At each stop, Cabigas cups his hands around his mouth and shouts into the desert. "Do you need help?" he yells, in Spanish. "We have water. We have food." Sometimes, he says, migrants emerge from the brush and drink. Sometimes, he finds their bodies, rotting.
"It's the worst place in the world to be walking," Cabigas says. "Its just brutal, a very brutal place."
Not all of that brutality is from nature - some is man-made. Volunteers say that in recent months many of the barrels have been vandalised, and the potentially life saving water has been simply spilled out on the desert floor.
The increased vandalism appears to have coincided with the rising intensity of the debate over illegal immigration, sparked by Arizona's stringent immigration law.
"They took the barrel and then they stabbed it like this," Cabigas says, miming frenzied knife blows on a barrel. "You can see the hate. Then they shot it, then they tore the flag down."
It's possible the sabotage might have something to do with the sharp increase in migrant deaths. But we will probably never know ... because the desert keeps its secrets.
- Posted in

104 Comments so far
Show AllI am one of the few people I know, that are against this whole Mexican bashing craze. My own freinds, and associates think they should die in the desert. When I hear their responses I tell them how wrong they are , I try to teach them the whole history, and the big picture of why this has been going on for so long, and why it will keep going on. Some listen, and others just tell me I am just to soft. Well if caring about the plight of my fellow human is being a softy then I am glad that I suffer from this affliction. Human beings laugh at each other when one (even someones best friend)trips and falls,or bumps their heads we laugh almost as if it were a natural thing, and yet if our friend was really hurt we would feel terrible. What makes our first instinct to be a mean one ? Why would anyone think that it is funny or good that a desperate, poor person died such a horrible death. What is okay about that ? I just don't think that way, and I know thank goodness not everyone does, but far too many do think it's okay.
As far as I am concerned, those men that shot the water barrels are murderers. If you willfully do something, with the intent to do mortal harm, than you are a killer. It hardly matters wether the person is an illigal, or poor, or even Mexican. They are human beings, and they require basic needs, and no one person should decide they don't. They may be able to keep their deeds from ever being discovered by the authorities (even if they are the law) but when they meet their maker, and stand to answer for their deeds, they will be on the way to Hell.
This Country that boasts itself to be good Christian people, is full of anything but. Wars in two Countries, No medical care for their own people, willing to poisen their own water and soil, I mean we just aren't any good at all. The few that still care, and want no part of these things, are fewer and fewer everyday.
My hats of to the good people, that do put water out, for those poor people that found their lives so desperate that they would even make such a journey. Also to the Mexicans that take the journey, I am hoping one day that justice will be yours.
My recent experience engaging the public in gathering signatures to get Green candidates on the ballot has driven home one fact. The great majority of USans - particularly the comfortable suburban middle class, are a vile, callous heartless people. Thankfully, there are still a lot of people with hearts in the city neighborhoods, but that is about it.
The desperate immigrants who die in the desert seeking wort so their families don't starve?
"Tough luck; it's their own fault".
The 20,000 US citizens who die because of lack of medical insurance?
"Tough luck; it's their own fault".
The millions of unemployed with no hope of finding empowering, dignified work which will support their families?
"Tough luck; it's their own fault". (An Australian girlfriend once told me a good nickname for the USA would be ("The land of 'It's Your Fault'")
And, the tens to hundreds of thousands of meeting violent deaths in Iraq, Afghanistan, Gaza, West Bank, Lebanon?
Who cares?! God bless America!"
We can no longer simply blame our vile leaders. As Bin Laden alluded in some of his communiques the majority of the USAn people themselves are a loathsome, vile, and disgusting force of evil on our dear planet.
Blame the people who vote for our vile leaders, then.
Exactly. Blame the majority of USAns!
Yes Sabo, we know how much you hate middle-class America but I didn't know you were a follower of bin Laden.
Maybe you should be on a no-fly list.
According to the local CD conspiracy theorists, this site is probably monitored.
Bin Laden has a lot of blood on his hands (although not as much as we collectively do), but the "Bin Laden communiques", whatever their source, did have some very correct analysis in them. I treat these two things separately.
You should try to collect Pennsylvania Green party ballot signatures (or in the case of my wife, US census information) in a suburban area. Then, list some of the redeeming characteristics of typical white USAns.
"You should try to collect Pennsylvania Green party ballot signatures (or in the case of my wife, US census information) in a suburban area. Then, list some of the redeeming characteristics of typical white USAns."
You should try living your entire life in New Mexico.
Then, list some of the redeeming characteristics of typical Latinos.
P.S. Nice disassociation from bin Laden.
Woman, logic escapes you.
I took SaboCat's comment and substituted "Latino" for "whites". Again, merely to point out the hypocrisy of it all. His comment is defended while mine is deemed racist. That's why I love CD, better than Sudoku. Like I said, I hate hypocrisy.
BTW, what's the name for an anglo who wishes they were latino? I'm curious.
I've lived in southern Arizona much of my life and don't care much whether a person is a 'typical' Latino or a typical anglo. I do care if a person is an ignorant, racist, ass-hole though.
As one who hikes in the Sonora Desert around the areas that desperate Latinos use I can verify the harsh and dangerous conditions that they are subject to. I got stuck on one such trail, coming over a very tall hill or small mountain, down a dry gulch. It was very difficult and took me all morning. It was during the spring, so the temperature was not all that high, but I still felt the sun beating down on me. I could see the discarded coats and sweaters and shirts and plastic water bottles littering the 'trail' and imagine women and children trying to navigate the sharp drops in the creek bed in intense summer heat.
There are those who try to convince us that the border is being overrun by greedy and dangerous drug smugglers, but I haven't seen any such thing. I don't know what it's like in Mexico, but here around Arivaca it is very quiet. The only evidence of any 'illegal' traffic at all are these trails and occasionally a convoy of border patrol trucks hauling dozens of brown skinned people to jail after a raid on one of the gathering places where they wait to be picked up by cars and trucks and taken into the interior. And also, occasionally, a desiccated body or skeleton. I can only imagine the desperation that would cause people to attempt a border crossing out in the middle of the Sonora Desert.
Arizona is scary. Is this what the USA is becoming? This stinks to high heaven!
A boycott sounds like such a good idea right now!
AD
Arizona is scary. Is this what the USA is becoming? This stinks to high heaven!
A boycott sounds like such a good idea right now!
AD
to learn more about mexico and how involved the USA is in the country's corrupt drug war go to narconews.org.
And then there is NAFTA. Clinton the cynical narcissistic man he is, passed nafta will only full republican support. He and Hillary threatened many democrats (see Free Trade the selling of Nafta by mcarthur....clinton knew the peso was propped up and would collapse and then corporations could grab all the prizes for pennies on the peso...and the government would have to privitize....just like he and summers helped Yeltsin do that to russia...
and THEN he ramped up border security so that more people would be pushed to the fringe and die..
our recent democrat is just as bad....only mcCain and palin could be worse...
I live in the mission district in SF...and everytime I see a recent 'illegal' (yes you can tell usually between long time immigrants and recent arrivals, if you've been around and involved)...I wish that I could somehow express my anger at my corporate run govt...and also wish I could express my thanks and gratitude that they are here...and I can live among such a culturally and politically tough people.
But we only smile at each other...and regretfully the USA still does NOT have a millitant bottom up non ballot box left to even put a dent in our rogue state...our terrorist state.
Tierra y LIbertad!
I look to latin american for inspiration. Damn the USA...damn us all...
The fact that such black and reeking venality has become pandemic in the U.S. of A. seems to confirm that we live in a planet of HELL. When will the sheeple, drunken with luxury and greed, wake up? or CAN they?
More like a cancer.
>^^<
I believe the indifference with which these deaths are treated evidences the cruel underbelly of our militaristic, greedy, and power worshipping culture.
The wilful ignorance of the conditions that propel people to migrate here is another manifestation of US indifference to the suffering caused by our racism and our trade policies to those "others" who have the misfortune to live "elsewhere." They are beyond our circle of compassion. Having innoculated our population against understanding and compassion for these "others" we are now beginning to see these same attitudes extended to those within our society who no longer count: the unemployed, the homeless, the poor, the elderly, the chronically ill.
The indifference to the deaths and suffering of migrants is just the beginning.
"Culture"? WHAT "culture"?
I strongly believe that they should close the border to Mexico. On one condition, which is you close it not only to people but to resources. If you say you want to
close it to people but not resources, what you're saying, one thing, is that you're a racist asshole, but another thing you're saying is - I don't want you but I want the coffee that's grown on the land that used to be yours.
Why is this migration taking place? It's not taking place because suddenly a bunch of people from Guatemala decided they want to take an eco-tour of the strawberry fields in the San Joaquin valley. It's because their communities are being destroyed through the theft of the land. If you don't want these people moving up here then don't steal those people's lands, pretty simple solution.
The problem is really quite simple as is the solution.
The problem: El Norte is pushing them there "illegals" off of his ancestral lands so as to steal the resources that reside in Chiapas e.g.
The solution: Stop El Norte from stealing the resources of the people in Chiapas e.g.
NAFTA is merely the latest acronym-IMF the latest international syndicate-World Bank only the latest MoneyChanger in this ongoing colonial conquest.
Neither the employer or the "immigrant" are really the fundamental issue.
Qualifier: Many who do employ "immigrants" exploit them and should be themselves forced to work in the broiling hot sun for 14 hours/day or forced to do backbreakingearlydeath work in the maquiladoras.
Let the truth be the frame.
There Are No "Illegal" Human Beings.
The brown-skinned man you call "Illegal" is only heading into El Norte to take back what is rightly his. Mr. "Illegal" is only coming to find the stolen goods you see as your birthright Mr. Gringo. Mr. "Illegal" only wants to see what those pretty yellow bananas look like inside the gigantic air-conditioned food warehouse. You know all about the morning blood fruit, right Mr. Gringo? Mr. "Illegal" only walks the grueling pilgrimage towards Never-Never Land, water jugs in hand, to peer over the well-watered hedge into your morning Scottsdale Latte to see if any of his blood remains in your mug. It seems there's plenty still there- more than he had remembered. Mr. "Illegal" only comes to the Land of Milk and Honey (Did you steal that too Mr. Gringo? Where's the milk and honey?) in order to get a brief glimpse of the sweet mango-to remember the taste of the mango that used to be in his backyard until he got NAFTA-ed off his land.
To sum it up: South America has to get it's sh!t together and stop blaming the US for all their poblems.
Thanks for the geography lesson. Well then, all those countries are in the same boat.
And, no. I won't go back to where my people came from. How's that?
"Then it may very well be you that ends up dying in the desert"
Might happen, you never know. Actually I love the desert. Hiked a Death Valley canyon a few years ago and spent my a lot of my free time in the California high desert, around the Joshua Tree Nat'l park mostly. Really beautiful. Nothing like a sunset horseback ride somewhere around the CA/NV border. Let the full moon and horse's senses guide you after dark. Just relax and let go.
Most people think the desert is this dead place. Nothing farther from the truth. If you know where to look the desert is teeming with life. And at night, it lets you see the sky like city dwellers never do. Those stars are your friends, they can tell you which way to go and what time it is.
O man, I went all sentimental on you. Anyways, good luck with your support of illegal immigration. And for whoever doesn't want to end up coyote food, there several POEs that can be used to enter the US. Facilities are clean and there's running water.
"I do not support illegal immigration"
Well it looks to me that you do.
And some free advice. Stop living in the 19 Century. Wake up. It's a brand new world out there. Adapt or disappear.
She's already gone....
Wow your racist a SOB, you don't know me. I'm happy to discuss leagal and moral ramifications all day civily.
But if all you bring to the table is that worn out racist LaRaza nonsence then I can't see how any ideas can be exchanged.
>^^<
Or do what they do, if you don't like where you are, walk around till you see a place you want. Then sneak in in the middle of the night. eat their food watch some TV liedown whereever and sleep. then the next day demand they cook you breckfast, and give you money.
If you can't beat'em join'em
>^^<
Chameleon I suspect you have poor reading skills and even worse comprehension. South America is uh south of Central America and the migrants we are speaking of come from Central America (Latin America).
U.S. Interventions in Latin America- Just thought you should know about this:
1954
Jacobo Arbenz Guzmán, elected president of Guatemala, introduces land reform and seizes some idle lands of United Fruit-- proposing to pay for them the value United Fruit claimed on its tax returns. The CIA organizes a small force to overthrow him and begins training it in Honduras.
The CIA broadcasts reports detailing the imaginary advance of the "rebel army," and provides planes to strafe the capital. The army refuses to defend Arbenz, who resigns. The U.S.'s hand-picked dictator, Carlos Castillo Armas, outlaws political parties, reduces the franchise, and establishes the death penalty for strikers, as well as undoing Arbenz's land reform. Over 100,000 citizens are killed in the next 30 years of military rule.
1960
Guatemalan officers attempt to overthrow the regime of Presidente Fuentes; Eisenhower stations warships and 2000 Marines offshore while Fuentes puts down the revolt.
1960s
U.S. Green Berets train Guatemalan army in counterinsurgency techniques. Guatemalan efforts against its insurgents include aerial bombing, scorched-earth assaults on towns suspected of aiding the rebels, and death squads, which killed 20,000 people between 1966 and 1976. U.S. Army Col. John Webber claims that it was at his instigation that "the technique of counter-terror had been implemented by the army."
1961
CIA-backed coup overthrows elected Pres. J. M. Velasco Ibarra of Ecuador, who has been too friendly with Cuba.
1962
CIA engages in campaign in Brazil to keep João Goulart from achieving control of Congress.
1963
CIA-backed coup overthrows elected social democrat Juan Bosch in the Dominican Republic.
1964
João Goulart of Brazil proposes agrarian reform, nationalization of oil. Ousted by U.S.-supported military coup.
1965
A coup in the Dominican Republic attempts to restore Bosch's government. The U.S. invades and occupies the country to stop this "Communist rebellion," with the help of the dictators of Brazil, Paraguay, Honduras, and Nicaragua.
1966
U.S. sends arms, advisors, and Green Berets to Guatemala to implement a counterinsurgency campaign.
1968
Gen. José Alberto Medrano, who is on the payroll of the CIA, organizes the ORDEN paramilitary force, considered the precursor of El Salvador's death squads.
1970
Salvador Allende Gossens elected in Chile. Suspends foreign loans, nationalizes foreign companies. For the phone system, pays ITT the company's minimized valuation for tax purposes. The CIA provides covert financial support for Allende's opponents, both during and after his election.
1973
U.S.-supported military coup kills Allende and brings Augusto Pinochet Ugarte to power. Pinochet imprisons well over a hundred thousand Chileans (torture and rape are the usual methods of interrogation), terminates civil liberties, abolishes unions, extends the work week to 48 hours, and reverses Allende's land reforms.
1973
Military takes power in Uruguay, supported by U.S. The subsequent repression reportedly features the world's highest percentage of the population imprisoned for political reasons.
1980
A right-wing junta takes over in El Salvador. U.S. begins massively supporting El Salvador, assisting the military in its fight against FMLN guerrillas. Death squads proliferate; Archbishop Romero is assassinated by right-wing terrorists; 35,000 civilians are killed in 1978-81. The rape and murder of four U.S. churchwomen results in the suspension of U.S. military aid for one month.
1981
The CIA steps in to organize the contras in Nicaragua, who started the previous year as a group of 60 ex-National Guardsmen; by 1985 there are about 12,000 of them. 46 of the 48 top military leaders are ex-Guardsmen. The U.S. also sets up an economic embargo of Nicaragua and pressures the IMF and the World Bank to limit or halt loans to Nicaragua.
1981
Gen. Torrijos of Panama is killed in a plane crash. There is a suspicion of CIA involvement, due to Torrijos' nationalism and friendly relations with Cuba.
1982
A coup brings Gen. Efraín Ríos Montt to power in Guatemala, and gives the Reagan administration the opportunity to increase military aid. Ríos Montt's evangelical beliefs do not prevent him from accelerating the counterinsurgency campaign.
1983
Another coup in Guatemala replaces Ríos Montt. The new President, Oscar Mejía Víctores, was trained by the U.S. and seems to have cleared his coup beforehand with U.S. authorities.
1983
U.S. troops take over tiny Granada. Rather oddly, it intervenes shortly after a coup has overthrown the previous, socialist leader. One of the justifications for the action is the building of a new airport with Cuban help, which Granada claimed was for tourism and Reagan argued was for Soviet use. Later the U.S. announces plans to finish the airport... to develop tourism.
1984
CIA mines three Nicaraguan harbors. Nicaragua takes this action to the World Court, which brings an $18 billion judgment against the U.S. The U.S. refuses to recognize the Court's jurisdiction in the case.
1984
U.S. spends $10 million to orchestrate elections in El Salvador-- something of a farce, since left-wing parties are under heavy repression, and the military has already declared that it will not answer to the elected president.
1989
U.S. invades Panama to dislodge CIA boy gone wrong Manuel Noriega, an event which marks the evolution of the U.S.'s favorite excuse from Communism to drugs.
My point exactly. Generals killing other generals to take over, coups, insurgents. And that was happening even before your timeline started. You'd think that people have learned their lesson.
Actually, South America is also considered "Latin America", so you have to include all the US meddling down there too - Kissinger's Pinochet, the Argentine Junta, etc..
And chameleon,
Will you PLEASE read "Killing Hope - US military and CIA Interventions since world War II" by William Blum. It is not the Latin Americans people's fault they lived under brutal dictatorships until recently. The dictators were installed and massively funded and supported by the CIA and US military. To describe what you are doing as "blaming the victim" would be an understatement.
"Killing Hope - US military and CIA Interventions since world War II"
I'll give it a try. But lemme guess: US intervention = bad, Soviet intervention = good. I grew up on that kind of stuff. Didn't impress me then and I guess it won't impress me now. But as I said, I'll give it try if my local public library has it.
Your GUESS would be wrong.
Do not guess. Inform yourself.
Did you read it too?
You are wrong. Deeply wrong.
Shame on you.
Your manner of sickness knows little compassion. Your manner of ignorance is at the core of such problems.
You must be well insulated from humanity to be so indifferent to the struggles of people.
You must be completely ignorant of history to speak as you do.
I'm sure South America would love to "get it's shit together" if the robber barons and murderers from the North would quit ripping them off, attempting to recolonize them and polluting their world.
What's *your* excuse for for ignorance of the situation and the forces that caused it?
Support your local organic family farmers.
Let's not be in denial. Petty dictators, generals and colonels have been assassinating and replacing each other at the head of Latin American countries since 1492 well before the US was a superpower or even existed (almost half of current US territory was theirs and they couldn't hold on to it). That's about 450 years. Time enough for the biggest loser country to get it's sh!t together. At least for the last 50 years they have someone to scapegoat.
"How old are YOU, that you haven't got YOUR shit together?"
Old enough to know better than to try and change people's people's minds. But not smart enough to stop doing it, it seems.
Like George Carlin would say you don't want to die in the desert, then stay the f--k at home. Of course carlin was referring to iraq i just changed it a tad.
Only to the living, who stay out of deserts.
>^^<
He's clever enough not to cross the desert.
Valerie James has said of Las Madres project, it is a memorial to the loved ones and the lost and also a monument to hope. You can see the memorial at: www.lasmadresproject.org
The web page shows the visual and also gives written information about the material used in this las madres art project. I had never bought or lit a seven day candle until I saw and understood this memorial work of art but I read something that opened my heart. It is a poem by Mary Kay Landon about The Virgin of Guadalupe. It begins in Spanish: Bienvenidos, mis hijos, we are together again. At the end of the moving poem it says buy a seven day candle and let it shine upon your life, to shine from the other world, delivering light to you. Para ti. Bless you my children. I know for many this is strictly a political issue but I cannot think of it in terms of politics alone. For me it is a human issue about what is in our hearts.
This is so wrenchingly sad, that such nightmares can be part of the longing for the fulfillment of dreams.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_Good_Samaritan
The parable of the Good Samaritan is a parable told by Jesus in the Gospel of Luke (10:25-37
Also
Whatsoever you do to the least of these my brothers, you do it unto me.
Christian nation, my ass!
is it 5 or 10% of all unidentified corpses in Tucson?
edweg
and let's not forget the boat people of vietnam, cuba, dominican republic, haiti, morocco, albania, indonesia..........
Everybody is horrified by the abuse of women in Afghanistan but where was the outrage when a 9 year girl was impregnated by her father and the doctors diagnosed complication with the pregnancy and the girl could have died if she did not have an abortion. The Catholic church forbids abortion and birth control and has way too much power and control in Brazil where this girl lived. The people who broke the law to save the girls life were punished. Central and South American countries without Family Planning Clinics deny women control over their bodies and contribute to overpopulation which results in the oppression and exploitation of the increased number of poor people. The Catholic church wants America to welcome them in to America rather than allow them to have control over their reproductive right to limit their children and reduce the overpopulation that causes the poverty, that causes the need to risk their lives to cross the border into the U.S.A.
"Catholic church wants America to welcome them in to America rather than allow them to have control over their reproductive right to limit their children and reduce the overpopulation that causes the poverty, that causes the need to risk their lives to cross the border into the U.S.A."
What!!??
I guess that explains anchor babies...???
FYI, the immigrants most often bring their odd mixture of superstition and Catholicism. The church loves 'em as much as the business owners.
No, ardent. I only hate hypocrisy and pretension.
I can't help if certain groups or individuals behave as such but I will always have the right to criticize and disapprove of their behavior; just as you have the right to criticize and disapprove of us.
Unlike most CDers, PC has no meaning for me. It's just another form of hypocrisy and pretension.
See post below re: hypocrisy/pretension
I suspect that considering their more-progressive government, and their tradition of free sex and love, the Brazilians probably have much better access to birth control than USAns do.
These are some very bad problems. www.okaygoods.com dofus kamas
These are some very bad problems.www.ok1225.com