EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
- Wisconsin Bill Would Treat Organic Milk, Sharp Cheddar, Brown Eggs as "Junk Food"
- Patent Filing Claims Solar Energy ‘Breakthrough’
- Climate Change's 'Evil Twin': Ocean Acidification
- Disaster Capitalism Strikes as Hedge Funds Circle Near-Bankrupt Municipalities Like Vultures
- Ignoring Bee Crisis, EPA Greenlights New 'Highly Toxic' Pesticide
- Patent Filing Claims Solar Energy ‘Breakthrough’
- Wisconsin Bill Would Treat Organic Milk, Sharp Cheddar, Brown Eggs as "Junk Food"
- Climate Change's 'Evil Twin': Ocean Acidification
- In 'March Toward Disaster,' World Hits 400 PPM Milestone
- Ignoring Bee Crisis, EPA Greenlights New 'Highly Toxic' Pesticide
Popular content
Today's Top News
How Far Should We Let Big Oil Go?
An alternative annual report for the oil company Chevron looks at the deep costs paid for the world's oil addiction
In the month since BP's oil rig exploded in the US Gulf Coast, what has struck me the most is not, unfortunately, the magnitude of the spill, the damage caused that is likely to continue for decades, the inability of BP or federal agencies to clean up – much less stop – the spill, or the revelations of BP's pre-explosion lobbying, which likely contributed greatly to the disaster taking place.
A woman in a fish costume and covered in oil lies on the sidewalk in front of BP headquarters in Houston Monday, May 24, 2010, to stage a protest against the catastrophic Gulf of Mexico oil spill. (AP Photo/Pat Sullivan) I have instead been most moved by the rapid, overwhelming and broad-based demand from people all across the US and the world for a fundamental rethinking of just how far they are willing to let Big Oil go in pursuit of the world's remaining oil.
As I prepare for the annual general meeting of the fourth largest global oil company – Chevron (BP is the third largest) – I am confronted daily by people who are looking around their own communities and out across the world with new-found attention to the deep costs paid every day for our oil addiction.
A new alternative annual report for Chevron, The True Cost of Chevron, of which I am an author and the editor, will be released at a press conference on 25 May in Houston, Texas – just a few hundred miles from the sites where oil is washing up on shore following the explosion on BP's rig. Written by dozens of authors from 16 countries and 10 states from across the US who either live in, or advocate on behalf of, communities where Chevron operates, the report criticises Chevron's record on human rights, the environment, the climate, public health, worker safety and treatment of indigenous populations.
From Chevron's coalfields in Alabama to its oil wells in Indonesia, the report examines operations mired in accusations of human rights abuse (Angola, Burma, Indonesia, Chad and Nigeria); mass environmental and human health devastation (including Ecuador, Kazakhstan and Canada); toxic abuse of its neighbours (including Alabama, California, Mississippi, Texas, Thailand and the Philippines); abuse of its workers (including Utah); threats to endangered species (including Australia and the US Gulf Coast); and, in Iraq, intensifying the violent insurgency and putting the lives of US and Iraqi service members at greater risk.
There is also a powerful silver lining. All of these authors are part of a global resistance movement bringing its message to Houston where Chevron is hosting its AGM.
It has likely been 40 years since the American public in particular, was so ready to hear and embrace this message. In 1969, a Unocal (now Chevron) oil platform off the coast of California experienced a massive blowout and the issue forced its way to the nation's attention. Activists organised against offshore drilling in their community, ultimately enlisting millions of supporters and advocates, spawning a massive environmental movement which, within just a few years, achieved the establishment of the US Environmental Protection Agency and the passage of the US Clean Air and Clean Water Acts.
The communities most directly harmed by oil's abuse are organised, networked and ready. The public is roused, angered and ready to act. The oil corporations are on notice: the true cost of their operations is simply too great to bear. For as long as we continue to use oil, the operations of its providers will be restricted, reined in, regulated and, ultimately, retired.
Antonia Juhasz is the author of The Tyranny of Oil: the World's Most Powerful Industry—And What We Must Do To Stop It. She is the director of The Chevron Program at Global Exchange
- Posted in
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

38 Comments so far
Show AllHow far we should let them go ?
It's more like how far do they wanna go ?
They have control over government, used US military in the middle east as they wish, and even when they commit crimes such as the latest oil spill no one can say anything to them.
I gave up a long time ago, someone please RESTORE THE REPUBLIC
Don't bamme the government. As long as USAns continue their car addiction. They will let Big Oil do absolutely anything that Big Oil wants.
I agree, everyone is to blame. I am having a difficult time dealing with myself as my job is directly related to the oil industry. What I do is all I know and I hate it. I thought that one day I would like to teach my profession but who the hell needs to know what I know about screwing up the world. I am to blame. I have always known that what I do is wrong even though it brings people great pleasure. My job is all about burning fuel for fun. I am hypocrite scum just like all the oil executives. I played the monkey see monkey do game and now I feel like an absolute idiot standing in the shadow of an offshore oil rig. My "contribution to society" has been useless and destructive. I have spent my life screwing things up for future generations. I am to blame.
I think you're being a bit hard on yourself. Your first sentence was correct. We're all bozos on this bus. I don't drive, but I take diesel burning buses, and ride in cars with friends sometimes. So I can share some of your blame. If you are in the oil business, you could possibly change careers. I know that may not be easy, but it would give you peace of mind. Please don't beat up on yourself.
I ride in cars, so I too am to blame. I'm pretty sure most of this is my fault, because I've been riding heedlessly in cars since about 1957. Even then, as a pre-teen, I should have been developing my own alternative energy transportation system and selling it to Washington to be be duplicated around the country. If I'd only not been so cynical I'm sure I would have successfully convinced our politicians to embrace and manufacture the alternative systems I was too lazy and indifferent to invent. And I can offer no excuse for not having come up with various alternative energy systems over the past 50 years to replace fossil fuels. The fault is mine alone, and I take full responsibility. I've never been in any sector of the oil business, but I've known about it, and my failure to personally eradicate it is totally culpable. Everyone should blame me for the BP "oil spill." I really don't know how I can live with myself after this.
We're all bozos on this bus, that's for sure. Squeeze the wheeze please. Many people like to.
If you're ready to put that on paper, then
sign here, over there
I don't know, I think it's still worthwhile to bamme the government.
How Far Should We Let Big Oil Go?
answer:
about as far as 6 by 8 Prison cells allow..
2 Company folks sharing space. counting their "dividends". ..in endless games of Monopoly...for the next 100 years ....each.
Big Oil isn't about to care as long as they can count on fuel inefficiency and forced demand for oil to continue up to the last drop.
Who's "we?"
As long as the liberal pundits misuse the basic adverbs they render themselves irrelevant.
Ms. Juhasz, there is NO silver lining. These rapacious and malevolent "Big Oil Bastards" are going to do as they DAM well please, and there isn't a DAM thing that'll be done about it.
reduction of any practice, whether primarily destructive, or secondarily so, will, of necessity, cost jobs...
as long as money is required for the right to live on the face of the planet, saving the planet is impossible, as the planet is, ultimately, the only source of money...
catch-22, mr. heller...
our own salvation options are limited by our forced indebtedness for the land...
we must free the land to free ourselves...private property must die, or all will...
those in power know wherein their power lies...in the land...
living land, by the way...healthy, diverse, wild...
I thought Antonia Juhasz just might get to the gist of the problem after her statement: "I am confronted daily by people who are looking around their own communities and out across the world with new-found attention to the deep costs paid every day for our oil addiction." But of course she doesn't. Ms. Juhasz is still living in denial like millions of other Americans.
"The public is roused, angered and ready to act." Bullshit. The one, positive act that American drivers can do to address the problems of Big Oil is to rid themselves of their fossil fuel-burning vehicles. But being the hypocrites they are, American drivers will continue to whine about gas prices and place the entire blame of the Gulf of Mexico's oil volcano on the evil oil corporations.
SaboCat (May 24th, 2010 5:07 pm) has it mostly right: "Don't bamme the government. As long as USAns continue their car addiction. They will let Big Oil do absolutely anything that Big Oil wants."
The sorry sacks of shit surrounding this issue are the executives in the board rooms of Big Oil, followed closely by the hypocrites driving on this country's roads and "free"ways.
Excuse me Al Mag, but I drive because I have no other way of getting myself to work and my kids to school. I live a greater distance from both because housing was cheaper. Still, there are one or two days a week when I could conceivably carpool, so I put my name into a pool a year ago and nobody called me. I don't commute a long distances and often take public transit when I can. I am willing to bet that this scenario applies to a huge number of the "hypocrites" you blithely write off.
The government is supposed to lead. It hasn't. Far from it, the government has actively held back fuel efficiency standards and all kinds of other energy improvements that could have saved us a lot of expense, war and environmental destruction. We're not lazy, not really even addicted and definitely not hypocritical. We just need a way to get to work; we don't need gas guzzlers or long commutes. An ironclad fuel efficiency mandate of 40 mpg, implemented 10 years ago would have saved more than every drop that has boiled out of the Gulf in the last month. They used to regulate like that (ex. the tetraethyl lead ban). They don't anymore, which is too darn bad because it works, quite well.
FINALLY!! the realization that the Auto Addiction to Happy Motoring in the Geography of Nowhere is the heart of this problem!
Electric cars are not the answer nor any sort of cars.
However we do need some way to get around - and that way is public transit, biking,
walking in liveable walkable communities.
Instead as the Gulf burns 150 cities are having their public transit cut!
New strip malls go up even as existing stores are vacant.
Making the transition to public transit, reviving Main Streets, reviving all manner of rail travel from 100 miles per hour to high-speed will create millions of jobs which
cannot be offshored. The new public transit can be powered by solar, wind and
small hydro.
Just as the personal computer led to distributed computing which unprecedented increases
in computing power over mainframes, so we need not only large centralized sources of
power for transit and other energy but to tap micro-power from small hydro flows, wind flows, solar energy on our homes and offices.
We cannot afford to wait!
The time is NOW!
To aid the transition we need to increase the gas tax significantly to levels like
$1 per gallon to fund public transit and bikeable walkable community development.
Big oil long ago went all the way with Washington. DLC Obama seems to want this disaster to just blow over so we can all get back to business as usual. We may need to attack N. Korea or something really important like that! Osama may put out another video! We need the oil by God! We need nuclear power, also! If this catastrophe continues, the catastrophe itself may save us from big oil. Then again it may just kill everything that swims on planet earth and leave big oil intact.
I have a solution. DLC Obama should federalize the rays of the sun. Claim exclusive rights to the rays shining on the USA and our territorial waters. Similar to claiming mineral rights under foot. Enter into international agreements that allow all countries to do the same. Then sell the exclusive rights to those rays to multinational corporations that are willing and able to develop solar power. With no competition, cartels will quickly develop with the ability to extract a price per kilowatt hour great enough to produce a desired R.O.I. We end up trading an oil monopoly for a solar monopoly, but the planet survives and we continue in the servitude that we have become accustomed.
I love it!
We Should Let Big Oil Go Streight To Jail - Do Not Pass GO
These are the real terrorists - not some turban clad farmers.
"For as long as we continue to use oil, the operations of its providers will be restricted, reined in, regulated and, ultimately, retired."
Where's she talking about? I'd like to go there.
I look forward to more people learning about alternatives to the carbon-fuel-based economy. We can have an abundance of low-cost, pollution free energy that's not controlled by the military-industrial complex. Solutions have existed (and have been suppressed) for over a hundred years.
As we learn to focus on the possibilities instead of the disasters... the changes that we are all asking for will occur. You can find more info here:
http://www.theorionproject.org/en/index.html
http://changingpower.net/articles/free-energy-documentary-producer-pitches-tv-series/
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QgQXYBRYwbg
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yh_-DUKQ4Uw&feature=related
THe USA gov. can get an accurate reading of the Gusher volume, Let Iran help plug it.
And enact a bill which fines oil companies per day for unplugged uncontrolled wells.
Plus send 100,000 troops to cleanup
"How Far Should We Let Big Oil Go?"
Not another nanometer. If the massive destruction of life in the Gulf of Mexico is out of sight it is largely a result of the Barnays marketeering on the billboards. There is also the imperial march hidden behind there, still, as is the root cause of the 9/11 blowback. "Go Shopping. Don't Ask Questions." The scary part is that most USans are still perfectly happy watching the billboards! That funky "god" thing also whacks our reverence for the planet.
It's conceivable that a nationalized oil company could become imperialistic but it clearly does not have the explicit mandate of the corporate charter to forever expand over the landscape like the great blob from hell.
It's also conceivable that a corporation can defy that horrific charter and operate at zero growth while focusing on honestly serving the true better interests of the people.
So the ideas of banning corporations and nationalizing industries are simply reactions to current human perceptions, which are dynamic of course, so the bans will eventually be rendered irrelevant by the next incarnation of godzilla.
The implication is this: A general public resistance against generic domination/oppression rackets in whatever grotesque form they may morph into is really what we need to build. The approach is extremely simple for the people to grasp, like a sledgehammer, and probably most effective of all.
One important result would be a collective demand for locally-owned/operated, small-scale, sustainable energy production for local markets.
Big oil will continue to take until it is capped,
The CEO still gets paid in billions, as we become climate trapped,
Big leaks of oil will continue go everywhere,
Gushers into the sea, and burnt carbon into the air,
but Big Oil just rakes the money and does not care.
Big Oil will not pay the cost of environment spills,
Nor suffer the life that dies as oiliness clogs lungs and gills.
As the ocean or air becomes unbreathable muck.
Big oil executives just say go yourself suck.
If the climate is now unliveable thats your bad luck.
Big oil owns the planet, and makes it go around,
Big oil owns every drop of oil under sea and ground.
Big oil drives engines and makes political wheels spin,
Big oil fuels every judges car and media hacks sin.
Big oil starts wars based on greed with excuses thin.
Big oil pays for each and every big political election,
Each current oil war started with a candidate selection.
Big Oil funding goes only to those that freely away give,
to Big Oil the right to drill, spill and kill massive.
Big oil is a serial world killer, as we lie waiting passive.
Thats is why when you watch your advertisement paid Tee Vees,
You most often see politicians fully funded by big oil fees.
As oil executives continue to get away with murder,
And business as usual will never get any wiser,
The destruction of earth will continue on much further.
We drive 250 million autos each day in the USA spewing carbon molecules of mass destruction as local distributors are fed by 36,000 miles of cross country pipelines and thousands of fuel trucks on the highways. How can we possibly think that the oil industry is going to stop drilling for oil. We are demanding it with our daily lifestyles day after day! If we cannot get a handle on our addiction, then we are choosing ecocide/suicide. It will now take a revolutionary/evolutionary break from our past habits to become serious cooperators in relocalized sufficient food and simple tool economies. Further business as usual is simply not practical, even as breaking our patterns will require tremendous commitment, discipline, and sharing. We either break our oil addiction or we choose non-existence.
You "Americans" don't give a damn about the environment.
If you did you would DO something about it.
Like start walking.
Like start riding your bikes.
Like start thinking about some other means OTHER than oil.
There is a special place in hell for you all...saturated in the oil you burn.
I saw an interview with someone that said this well could be stopped immediately simply by blowing it up with a lot of explosives. I have not heard another word about using this technique anywhere. He indicated that its been done before in deep water.
It seems logical that explosives would close the well hole.
This would end the use of this well completely.
It seems just as logical to me that explosives might blow that well wide open.
Actually well placed shaped charges would easily be able to collapse the well. Possibly the shock wave would cause damage to all nearby pipelines, etc? Of course if its all that fragile then we really are in trouble... I lived in SE Louisiana back in the late eighties and have been to Grand Isle many times, it really hurts to see what is slowly becoming a MAJOR environmental and a MAJOR economic catastrophe! And this year has the makings to be a bad Hurricane year too!
We all have to take some responsibility though. But if everyone pummels their "so-called" representatives with calls, etc. then maybe we can at least use this Gulf coast catastrophe as a wake-up call and really get things moving. We are talking about major economic damage here for at LEAST a decade!
This is the end to capitalism based on limitless growth.
One way or the other...
David
"How Far Should We Let Big Oil Go?"
Nine feet is the drop on a standard gallows.
You know, like the one used by the US to execute their former Iraqi patsy Saddam Hussein...
http://img.timeinc.net/time/daily/2007/facelift/a_saddam_hanging0103.jpg
CARBON REDUCTION--NO OPTIONS
The current Gulf of Mexico tragedy is only another event that underscores the crucial need to reduce our carbon footprint.
Through extensive lobbying and fabricated science, the energy cartels have impeded progress in carbon reduction, as well as safety regulations. Their alligations that such measures would cripple our economy has been their classic claim for decades.
In reality, carbon reduction can only improve our economy. There are no reasons why we cannot expeditiously employ our idle work force and assembly plants here to fabricate wind turbines, solar panels, etc--rather than outsourcing this work as is the current trend. Even if subsidies were required to keep the work here, their costs would be eclipsed by the resulting benefits in employment, our security, and our environment.
Our planet cannot sustain its billions of inhabitants undercurrent trends. As the nation most responsible for global warming, we have a mandated duty to reduce our wasteful contributions of these toxins, which can only increase the divide between nations most responsible for warming and those most harmed by it.
Robert Settgast
San Rafael
415-492-1747
A Borrower and a Lender Be
GOOD Magazine: The Neighborhoods Issue > Nikhil Swaminathan on April 12, 2010 at 7:00 am PDT
Could the threat of a peaking oil supply lead to a hyperlocal revolution? A group of Portlanders thinks so.
Normally, when you need compost for your garden, you drive to the nearest Home Depot and pick up a couple of bags. It seems straightforward enough, but for some back-to-basics Portlanders, that would be a foolish way to accomplish such an errand. Instead, they log onto an online social network called Bright Neighbor to locate someone in their neighborhood who might have some compost on offer. If everything works out, they will walk their wheelbarrow down the street and return with it piled high with fertilizer. At what cost? It could be free. Or it might cost a few tomatoes from their garden. Or a complimentary kayaking lesson.
Bright Neighbor began in early 2008 as a “virtual commune,” allowing Portland, Oregon, residents to connect with their neighbors to set up ride shares, learn about community events, and barter goods and services—anything from astrological readings to chicken feed to household items. Its mission was never quite so simple, however. According to Tod Sloan, a Bright Neighbor member and a faculty member in the Department of Counseling Psychology at Lewis & Clark College, the site is facilitating the teaching of “real skills that are still intact in much of the world that we’re having to relearn, such as gardening and sharing tools.”
But why would those of us in the developed world need the skills obviated by modern conveniences? In February, a group of British businessmen led by the Virgin Group CEO Sir Richard Branson sounded the alarm for peak oil—the point at which the world’s oil supply will begin dwindling, bringing about economic calamities like soaring energy and food prices. If we take seriously the forecasts that it will occur in 2015, then our reliance on those modern conveniences needs to be rethought.
More at: http://www.good.is/post/a-borrower-and-a-lender-be1/
The point is that Amerika didn't start making 40 mpg cars when Jimmy Carter was President.
And the Amerikan government still has not build mass transit in a big way. The Government of not just Amerika but most of the world have SUPPORTED BIG OIL.
The government and especially the people didn't really know then. Or you might say they didn't want to think much about it.
After all 'Amerika was the best God fearing kick ass country in the whole world. Even most of us Hippy types had a lot of Patriotism in us.
We stopped the war in Vietnam didn't we? (After killing about 3 million Vietnamese and maybe another 2 million Lao/Cambodia people)
Big Ships transporting lots of plastic stuff are a big part of the global warming problem.
We should have started 30 years ago: For sure 15 years ago.
So my point is that it is just NOW becoming completely OBVIOUS, that we must greatly reduce our use of Fossil fuels.
I drive a mini bus that I often use like a Truck. I have been trying to save enough money to buy a Wind generator and solar panels for about 5 years now.
And I am now more determined to find a way to do so.
I am lucky that we have a extra piece of land that I can sell soon.
BUT I ask you- Is not the real culprit here the Government for continuing to support goal powered electric plants?
And WHO is responsible for the WARS? Answer - WASHINGTON DC. ETC. ETC.
In the state of Fascism corporations and government are one combined entity.
Into Volume 2 now: Objections of Non-Signers of the Constitution. Eye-popping reading.
It is dawning on me that ALL our problems were prophesied by the Anti-Federalists. Arguments were ignored, during the Constitutional Convention, that it was crazy to put so much power into a central government that could at any time just tell the people to phuck off.
Luther Martin Rep from Maryland:
"This government proposed, I apprehend, so far from removing will greatly encrease those complaints, since grasping in its all powerful hand the citizens of the respective states , it will be the imposition of the variety of taxes, imposts, stamps, excises, and other duties, squeeze from them the little money they may acquire, the hard earnings of their industry, as you would squeeze the juice from an orange, till not a drop more can be extracted, and then let loose upon them their private creditors, to whose mercy it consigns them, by whom their property is to be seized upon and sold in this scarcity of specie at a sheriff's sale, where nothing but ready cash can be received, for a tenth of its value, and themselves and their families to be consigned to indigence and distress, without their governments having a power to give them one moment's indulgence however necessary it might be, and however desirous to grant them aid. - Luther Martin, Ratification debate - Maryland 1788
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Complete_Anti-Federalist
It's way past time to dig up the past, and find out how to unplug this Monster Federal Government and it's Monster Monopolies. Whether you know it or not, we are all being secretly bankrupted by a huge stealth War Tax and huge stealth Bank Tax greater than all the other taxes combined.
TJ
"A standing military force, with an overgrown Executive will not long be safe companions to liberty. The means of defense against foreign danger, have been always the instruments of tyranny at home. Among the Romans it was a standing maxim to excite a war, whenever a revolt was apprehended.
Throughout all Europe, the armies kept up under the pretense of defending, have enslaved the people." - James Madison, speech at the Constitutional Convention, June 29, 1787
"Of all the enemies to public liberty war is, perhaps, the most to be dreaded, because it comprises and develops the germ of every other. War is the parent of armies; from these proceed debts and taxes; and armies, and debts, and taxes are the known instruments for bringing the many under the domination of the few. In war, too, the discretionary power of the Executive is extended; its influence in dealing out offices, honors, and emoluments is multiplied; and all the means of seducing the minds, are added to those of subduing the force, of the people.
The same malignant aspect in republicanism may be traced in the inequality of fortunes, and the opportunities of fraud, growing out of a state of war, and in the degeneracy of manners and of morals, engendered by both. No nation
could preserve its freedom in the midst of continual warfare."
- JAMES MADISON
"Political Observations"
April 20, 1795