Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
- Wealthiest Kissed, Weakest Kicked: Obama's Ugly 'New Deal' Offers to Cut Social Security
- What If All the World’s Debt Just Went Away
- Bolivia's Morales Calls for New Era of 'Peace and Unity' to Break Greed of Capitalism
- Sen. Bernie Sanders: 'Mr. President, I am Disappointed'
- Gun Lobby Speaks: We Need More Guns, Especially in Schools
- Wealthiest Kissed, Weakest Kicked: Obama's Ugly 'New Deal' Offers to Cut Social Security
- Bolivia's Morales Calls for New Era of 'Peace and Unity' to Break Greed of Capitalism
- What If All the World’s Debt Just Went Away
- Sen. Bernie Sanders: 'Mr. President, I am Disappointed'
- 8 Deficit Reducers That Are More Ethical—And More Effective—Than the 'Chained CPI'
Popular content
Today's Top News
Is This the End of Migration?
Climate change is affecting bird behaviour at a staggering rate. Some 20 billion have already changed their flight plans
It's rained three times as much as usual this winter in Andalusia, and almost every day unemployed amateur ornithologist Javier Caracuel has walked past a disused mining tower in the decaying industrial town of Linares and looked up, expecting the pair of white storks that nest there to have migrated south.
Increasing numbers of stork are staying put in European cities rather than heading south for the winter. (Photo: The Independent) Yet despite the surrounding high noise levels - the tower, some 10 metres high, is jammed between a school and a street clogged with traffic - and Andalusia's wettest winter in decades, the storks have stayed put. And they're not alone. "There have always been a couple of storks at the top of the church spire down by the railway station, but I've never seen so many across town," Mr Caracuel explains, "and there are dozens more in the villages."
The changes in storks' behaviour that Mr Caracuel has observed in one near-forgotten mining town in north-eastern Andalusia are far from uncommon. At a recent high-level congress attended by 200 migration experts, leading Spanish ornithologist Miguel Ferrer estimated that 20 billion birds have changed their migrating habits in the last few decades. The biggest single identifiable reason behind such a massive behavioural shift, involving 70 per cent of the world's migrating birds is - surprise, surprise - climate change.
"Long-distance migrators are travelling shorter distances, shorter-distance migrators are becoming sedentary," says Mr Ferrer, who works for Spain's Higher Council for Scientific Research (CSIC) in the Doñana National Park, one of the key European "stopovers" in bird migration routes. "That has a knock-on effect on almost everything they do, from breeding habits to feeding habits to their genetic diversity, which in turn affects other organisms in their food chain. It's a huge behavioural change, forced on them by rising temperatures."
"Climate change and environmental change are simultaneously forcing migratory birds to adapt extremely quickly," says Ian Newton, a Royal Society member and lifelong researcher into the subject. But if the adaption process is necessarily far faster than the last comparable geophysical phenomenon, the Ice Age, this time round it may not be anywhere near as successful.
"Fossil evidence suggests that in the Ice Age migration patterns changed, but now it's not such an easy option. The worldwide landscape is much more fragmented because of human activity. Put simply, it's not the same for a bird to try to adapt to the environment in Manhattan as it is in the Maldives."
Apart from migration changes, the birds' other option in the face of a fast-heating environment is fast-track evolution. This time there is evidence they are doing both. Reduction of wingspan sizes and changes in beak shapes have already been recorded. In another recent discovery, Francisco Pulido of the Complutense University in Madrid has ascertained that the recent shifts in migratory patterns are not necessarily temporary: rather for some birds, they're genetic.
"Pulido looked at migratory restlessness in blackcaps and warblers over a 13 year period," Professor Newton explains. "Studying a separate sample of birds each year, he found that their restlessness became progressively earlier each season. The only explanation for such a change is genetics."
Such changes are likely to become ever more common, as temperatures rise across the planet. "Average annual temperatures are moving northward at a rate of four kilometres a year," Mr Ferrer estimates, "so the normal summer temperature in your city 12 months ago is now normal four kilometres further north. It doesn't sound like a lot, but that's 20 times quicker than temperatures changed in the last Ice Age. At the same time, because birds are migrating less, one traditional path for genetic development - when they strayed from their migration paths by accident and had to adapt - is being closed off."
Scientists insist the consequences of rising temperatures have barely begun to scratch the surface of birds' behavioural patterns. But changes are becoming increasingly dramatic, with radical population shifts just one known effect. To use the example of white storks again, as long as six years ago recorded numbers in Spain had almost doubled to 32,000. Even in far-flung Tykocin, north-east Poland, they have risen by 20 per cent.
At the same time, wild geese in Doñana, once numbered in the hundreds of thousands, have plunged by 40 per cent. However, in Lake Gallocanta in Zaragoza, Spain, amateur ornithologist Javier Mañas reports that numbers of wintering cranes have increased six-fold in the past five years, from 3,000 to more than 18,000.
On the other side of the planet, there have been similar changes in migration patterns, according to a British specialist in Japanese wildlife and author, Mark Brazil. "We see considerable annual variation now in the presence and absence of wintering birds arriving into Japan." he says.
"Some people might say to heck with biodiversity," comments Peter Marra, a research scientist at the Smithsonian Migratory Bird Centre in the USA, "but they'd be wrong. Birds are the most sensitive thermometer of environmental change we have, and if up to 20 per cent are going to become extinct, it doesn't say to me we're living in a sustainable way."
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...


14 Comments so far
Show AllNo doubt we'll be seeing a lot of changes in the animal kingdom in the coming years. I'm still waiting for my sparrows to show up. The male usually comes by mid-March to clear out the old nest lining and get everything ready. By the end of April the first batch of eggs are about ready to hatch. But so far this year I haven't seen a single sparrow anywhere. It was very strange last year when my nesting pair began mating a week before the second batch left the nest, and they must have taken those to the extended family to finish raising. Then they stayed into August raising a third batch. They've always been out by mid-July.
I wonder if the Iceland volcano has affected migration of birds to the European countries. Maybe there's something about that keeping the storks in Andalusia where they are.
"Some people might say to heck with biodiversity."
If that includes humans, to heck with humanity.
It would be the best thing that could happen to the planet and its nonhuman survivors.
A Renaissance of biodiversity and evolution--this time without the humans to spoil it. One hopes for the best.
Ah, but with no humans, there would be no Einstein, no Van Gogh, no Bach. There are things we do very well and the world would be poorer without us.
drosera, I don't think there is a single animal or plant on this planet besides us who gives a rat's ass for Bach or Einstein.
When the people fear their government there is tyranny,
when the government fears the people there is liberty.
~ Thomas Jefferson
Back and Einstein are the fruit of billions of years of evolution, 13.7 in fact. We are too. With all our flaws we're amazing, and now we have the job of getting this global shift to a low carbon footprint right.
Flies are the result of the same period of evolution, and perhaps as amazing. I prefer humans, but perhaps that's less amazing.
Canary in the mine, comes to mind.
We should improve our skills in reading the signs of our environ-"mental" behaviour reflected back at us by our surroundings. Scary as those signs are.
Smarter, me too. With one exception. When the miners took canaries into the gold mine, they were paying attention. This time, no one is (except the few being ignored). But we will all pay for it. Even the rich, who somehow think their ill gotten gains will protect them. Mother Nature bats last.
When the people fear their government there is tyranny,
when the government fears the people there is liberty.
~ Thomas Jefferson
I wonder if there has been any change in the migration pattern of 'snowbirds' to Florida and back to the northern states?
I understand the annual migration of ca$h and gold from the US to Switzerland has been increasing at an exponential rate, too.
The birds have been around a lot longer than we have. I suppose they might be survivors. Would it be worthwhile for us to change from just being bird watchers, to bird imitators?
"Some people might say to heck with biodiversity," comments Peter Marra, a research scientist at the Smithsonian Migratory Bird Centre in the USA, "but they'd be wrong. Birds are the most sensitive thermometer of environmental change we have, and if up to 20 per cent are going to become extinct, it doesn't say to me we're living in a sustainable way."
*********************************
Well, then what is anyone going to do about it? It is unsaid and pretty much unthinkable but the only thing to do is to start regulating the human population!
One thing I am sure of now and that is that animals are a lot smarter that people ever thought they were and animals, I feel real sure, will 'weather' the up and coming next ice age or as other perfer to call it, climate change, better than humans will.
I have also noticed that some robins remain in NYC all winter, which was not true for most of my life. I saw the parents tending a nest of newborn pigeons in December, which was a first. They are usually born in the spring. Change is not always bad, but if it happens too suddenly it disrupts natural relationships that have developed over thousands of years. If certain insects hatch at new times, it affects fish and birds that depend on them to feed THEIR young and so on.
Like the storks, these NYC birds are harbingers of new patterns. We can see the birds, but we are not able to see what they see, what is making them change their decisions about where to spend the year. Birds are very, very smart, observant, adaptable, mobile. They watch the stars, the animals and the vegetation. The see small things, the changes in insect population and breeding habits, leafing and flowering of trees, seeding of grasses, fungi etc. They communicate and work together to solve problems and plan survival strategies. That's what all the honking is about before geese start a migration. Birds can change habits and patterns in a generation or two. Humans, not so much.
We have gotten severely stuck in our old habits of infighting and violence over ownership and privilege. Meanwhile we are monstrously inattentive and careless about taking care of the one gift we have - the lifegiving earth. What will happen to our prolific and voracious species when oxygen providing seaweed and protein providing fish disappear because of pollution and acidification of the oceans, for instance?
Joe