Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Cities Sue Manufacturer of Weed-Killer Found in Tap Water
Federal Lawsuit Seeks Funding to Remove Atrazine from Water Supply
A coalition of communities in six Midwestern states filed a federal lawsuit Monday seeking to force the manufacturer of a widely-used herbicide to pay for its removal from drinking water.
Atrazine, a weed-killer sprayed primarily on cornfields, can run off into rivers and streams that supply municipal water systems. As the Huffington Post Investigative Fund reported in a series of articles last fall, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency failed to notify the public that atrazine had been found at levels above the federal safety limit in drinking water in at least four states.
The lawsuit was filed in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Illinois by 16 cities in Kansas, Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, Missouri, and Iowa. The communities allege that Swiss corporation Syngenta AG and its Delaware counterpart Syngenta Crop Protection, Inc. reaped billions of dollars from the sale of atrazine while local taxpayers were left with the financial burden of filtering the chemical from drinking water.
Many water utility managers told the Investigative Fund that they could not afford the expensive carbon filters that are needed to remove atrazine.
Syngenta spokesman Paul Minehart told the Investigative Fund that the company had not yet received word of a federal action, but said that current levels of atrazine in drinking water are safe.
"What Syngenta can say is that EPA re-registered atrazine in 2006, stating it would cause no harm to the general population," Minehart said. "In the current economy many organizations, including water systems, are looking for additional sources of revenue. It is not surprising that some water systems would say they cannot afford additional filtering but, for atrazine, there is no need."
Atrazine has long been a controversial product. The European Union in 2004 banned its use, saying there was not enough information to prove its safety. The EPA recently announced that it would be re-evaluating the herbicide's ability to cause cancer and birth defects, as well as its potential to disrupt the hormone and reproductive systems of humans and amphibians.
Last week, a study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Science reported that male frogs exposed to levels of atrazine below federal limits could become functional females, with the ability to mate and lay eggs.
Citizens in all sixteen of the cities named in the lawsuit get their drinking water from sources next to or surrounded by agricultural fields where farmers use atrazine. Some of these cities sell their water in bulk to other nearby towns.
According to EPA data from 2008, at least two of the cities -- Coulterville, Ill. and Monroeville, Ohio -- found atrazine in their river water at levels above 30 parts per billion (ppb). To comply with federal law, the level of atrazine in drinking water must not exceed 3ppb on annual average.
Lawyer Stephen Tillery, who is representing the sixteen cities in this complaint, said that these cities alone have spent upwards of $350 million trying to filter atrazine from their drinking water.
Investigative Fund reporter Danielle Ivory discussed atrazine last fall on the TV program Democracy Now. To watch, click here.
Illinois Class Action Complaint Against Syngenta
- Posted in

20 Comments so far
Show All"According to EPA data from 2008, at least two of the cities -- Coulterville, Ill. and Monroeville, Ohio -- found atrazine in their river water at levels above 30 parts per billion (ppb). To comply with federal law, the level of atrazine in drinking water must not exceed 3ppb on annual average"
Well if it goes down to 0 ppb for over 10 years then they'll meet the annual average. Who write these peculiar standards anyway? Oh yes, the companies.
And it turns humans into frogs, a possible improvement.
"Female" frogs. Can you imagine a plague of human-frog mutants procreating at a rate even higher than that of humans today, mutants just as set on owning Humvees and McMansions as their human progenitors. Gaea is screwed.
glenn ford, I see a way to capitalise on all this. All that hitherto fiscally useless swampland will now become prime real estate for Homo Anura and its vast swaths of frogspawn and toadies.
Buy as much real estate income trust in swamp country as you can -before Wall Street clues in.
Forget selling bridges, I have riveting swampland for sale.
All pesticides, including herbicides have "inert" ingredients, and the EPA will not divulge what those are. These can be old pesticides, benzene, toluene, and a host of other extremely toxic chemicals, basically hazardous chemical waste.
Putting them in pesticides as "inert" ingredients is not only a lie, but it exposes people to more poisons than just the one (that's all they have to name) named ingredient.
Filtering out Atrazine, even if that's possible, leaves the unknown "inert" ingredients to worry about.
We need laws banning the use of any chemical that cannot be neutralized before it's released into our air and water.
Pesticide use is a major poisoning problem - many do not go away for centuries - - DDT is still here in its final metabolite, DDE, which is also an endocrine disrupter (causing males to have female characteristics and more).
The problem is the control Big Pharma's money has over Congress and the President. The same companies make the pesticides, make the genetically-engineered "foods" and the same companies make the pharmaceuticals that supposedly heal us when we get sick from their poison products.
Sweet deal for them.
GROW ORGANIC FOOD IN YOUR OWN YARD - get out from under corporate poisons.
Cleanearth,
You have said it all in one paragraph,
"The problem is the control Big Pharma's money has over Congress and the President. The same companies make the pesticides, make the genetically-engineered "foods" and the same companies make the pharmaceuticals that supposedly heal us when we get sick from their poison products.
Sweet deal for them.
GROW ORGANIC FOOD IN YOUR OWN YARD - get out from under corporate poisons."
People just have to stop funding Big Pharma. The only way we can do this is by doing everything we can to become (or stay) healthy.
Growing our own backyard food is really the way to go.
Good things never start from the top down - because there's too much profit involved to make any changes that will really help the people.
By this I mean changes that don't in turn become more major profit-making ventures for the Corporates.
Every day we read about communities both urban and rural, who are banding together to grow healthy food for the people.
Forget about hoping the Democrats are going to 'put the needs of the people first.'
It can never happen, because they are driven and controlled by the same Corporations who in actual fact run USA. The major profits come from USA's biggest economies, which I believe are Pharmaceuticals, Arms, Oil, Drugs, and whatever else the likes of Halliburton and their like can squeeze out of third world economies.
Forgot to mention the IMF and WTO and the like, who hold third world countries to ransom and steal their natural resources.
Sorry to be so blunt, but that's what we've got, and it's up to us to 'make the changes' from the ground up.
We have to be assertive, continue to keep our fingers on what's really happening politically, and keep spreading the word, even though there are still many many people who can still afford to live in "La La" land and are still dazzled by the political propaganda.
Common Dreams and many other online news sources show there is a huge groundswell of informed citizens, so join together and keep working at it from the bottom up.
For people who were not born Roundup Ready all these poisons have a genocidal effect. It is a real shame that our Corporate Controlled Government cares not for the American public.
"people who were not born Roundup Ready" ? Interesting concept. A challenge for Monsanto.
A great new conspiracy arises! Let it be known to have started here! It is the desired way to achieve birth control and stabilize the population. The only trouble is that it will affect us as well as the "them" or "they". We could probably gather all of the people affected as the "Collateral People".
Corporations care about the bottom line not people!
Politicians are always looking for a handout, have you ever met a politician with their hands in their own pockets.
Get a good osmotic filter for cooking and drinking folks. May not be a bad idea to stock up on filters as well.
An osmotic filter may become the hippest wedding gift for the 21st century.
Joe
Yeah, do that and allow even more corporations to profit from Atrazine use!
And if you are poor and can't afford such a syatem along with your bottled water from Fiji? Tough!
Well, we can share our quality water with them. After all, we're all in this together. Also, you can say the same thing about bottled water being an 'enabler.' Proactively, you can buy less corn products, but clean water is must for good health. Besides, they don't give a s**t one way or another unless they are forced to or it hurts their bottom line. Get a filter if you can afford one, even if you got to stop eating out or cut off your cable. Also, it will save you in the long run, if you're already drinking bottled water, not to mention reduce land fill waste. So there are two ways to look at it.
Better yet, simply outlaw atrazine (they did it long ago in the civilized part of the world), and insist on stronger drinking water regulations!
The solution to injustice of any kind is NOT to simply "BUY" your way out of it!!! Either through bottled water or expensive yuppie-greenie filters, or for that matter, moving to suburbia. Christ you liberals are clueless in your bourgeois arrogance!!!
"And if you are poor and can't afford such a syatem along with your bottled water from Fiji?"
How can they afford to import water all the way from Fiji? Do they bring it in as concentrate?
The "your" in this sentence is referring to you rich liberals and your Fiji bottled water, not the poor.
soon they're gonna send the water company to a private trust, just like it happened in bolivia a couple of years ago.
--
reseller of intex filters
Very useful info. Hope to see more posts soon!
filtered water dispensers
http://www.aquavalley.com.au/index.php
Very useful info. Hope to see more posts soon!
drinking water filter
http://www.coldwaterfilters.com/