Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Wal-Mart, the US Retailer Taking Over the World by Stealth
It hardly shrieks of billion-dollar glamour. The US nerve centre of the world's largest retailer, Wal-Mart, consists of a collection of low-slung prefabricated buildings along a four-lane highway in north-western Arkansas. Wal-Mart's head office is hundreds of miles from the nearest big city. It isn't even handy for the state capital, Little Rock, which is three and half hours' drive away.
A shopper exits a Wal-Mart store during a winter storm, Saturday, Dec. 19, 2009, in Philadelphia. (AP Photo/Matt Slocum) But hopeful merchants beat a path from all corners of the world to hawk their wares here, in a series of bare Perspex rooms along a "supplier corridor". Staff work in spartan cubicles and reminders of the retailer's low-cost culture are constant – in an employee lounge an honesty box invites payment for tea and coffee with a blunt message: "Drinks are not free."
It was nearby, in the main square of the modest town of Bentonville, that Wal-Mart's founder, Sam Walton, dipped his toes into retailing with a discount store, Five and Dime, in 1951. That shop, now a museum, spawned a retail empire that spans 8,100 stores in 15 countries generating $401bn (£248bn) of revenue annually. With a market capitalisation of $210bn, Wal-Mart is worth as much as the gross domestic product of Nigeria.
Four of America's 10 richest individuals are from Wal-Mart's low-profile Walton family, which still owns a 40% controlling stake. The company's portfolio ranges from superstores in the US to neighbourhood markets in Brazil, bodegas in Mexico, the Asda supermarket chain in Britain and Japan's nationwide network of Seiyu shops. Wal-Mart gets many of its products from low-cost Chinese suppliers. The pressure group China Labour Watch estimates that if it were a country, Wal-Mart would rank as China's seventh largest trading partner, just ahead of the UK, spending more than $18bn annually on Chinese goods.
Perhaps more than any other firm in America, Wal-Mart divides opinion. Unions loathe its relentless downward pressure on wages and its refusal to allow workers to organise. The company has been accused of unfair treatment of older, more expensive, employees. It is facing one of America's largest class-action lawsuits alleging wage discrimination against women and its hypermarkets are routinely blamed for squeezing small shops out of business.
"This is a company with a record of exploitation," says Jill Cashen, spokeswoman for a pan-union campaign group, Wake Up Wal-Mart. "They have not shared their wealth globally, locally, nationally or anywhere. When you spend your money at Wal-Mart, you're contributing to the wealth of one very rich family and not very many other people."
In reply, Wal-Mart's executives say the company is "saving people money so they can live better". They trumpet the availability of Wrangler jeans for $11.50, laptops for $298 and even an entire Thanksgiving turkey dinner for eight people at $20. Wal-Mart maintains that it is on the side of hard-working families who need to save every penny they can – and the company intends to spread this message globally.
Wal-Mart spent $4.1bn on international expansion in the year to January 2009, and intends to spend between $4.2bn and $4.4bn in the current fiscal year, excluding acquisitions. About a quarter of its sales are outside the US. But oddly, few of its foreign customers are aware that they are shopping at an American multinational.
Unhappy early experiences outside American shores have prompted an outbreak of new thinking at Wal-Mart. The company has embraced something of a "stealth" approach to growth. Its stores are emblazoned with an array of different names around the world – Maxibodega in Costa Rica, Todo Dia in Brazil, Despensa Familiar in Honduras and the awkward-sounding Best Price Modern Wholesale in India.
"We learned very early in the process that you simply can't take a superstore in the US, pull it out of the ground and plant it in another country and expect that to be a successful strategy," says Mitch Slape, Wal-Mart's head of international business development.
Fresh approach
During earlier decades, the firm's approach to expansion was simple. It built US-style out-of-town discounting superstores around the world and expected shoppers to flock there for bargains. But this didn't always work. Travel patterns, family roles and shopping habits vary. Ventures into Germany and South Korea came to a sticky, unsuccessful end with expensive exits in 2006.
Under the new approach, the "front end" of Wal-Mart's stores can look like enlarged family-run convenience stores. The contents, to some extent, are locally focused. Chinese stores offer live crustaceans, while south American outlets are heavy on spicy beans. But the "back end" is a duplicate of the US model.
"From the customer point of view, it might appear to be a certain brand," says Slape. "But everything that is 'back of house' – systems, processes, buying – we can leverage a lot of that globally."
Part of its pluralistic new approach comes from experience in Britain, where Wal-Mart bought Asda for £6.7bn a decade ago. The chain has been a moderate success, delivering consistent results, but Wal-Mart has been frustrated in its efforts to expand. A mooted takeover of Safeway got a thumbs-down from competition authorities five years ago and Britain's strict planning regime has hampered a roll-out of stores. Frustrated, Wal-Mart's former chief executive Lee Scott, who retired this year to make way for new incumbent Mike Duke, reportedly pondered a complete exit from the UK – but ultimately opted to stay put.
Insiders say that competing in Britain's feverishly competitive supermarket industry has taught Wal-Mart a good deal. Asda is now something of a centre for excellence for its global grocery sales. The head of global marketing for Wal-Mart is based at Asda's head office in Leeds. And, in an example of Wal-Mart's global distribution muscle, the Wall Street Journal recently reported that the best-selling wine in the whole of Japan is an own-label Asda Bordeaux.
Britain is Wal-Mart's fourth-largest overseas chain, with 368 Asda outlets, behind Mexico's 1,322 stores, Brazil's 373 sites and Japan's 371 shops. All are dwarfed by the 4,200-strong network of Wal-Marts in the US. Smaller territories include Canada with 313 stores, China at 266 and a newly acquired 238-strong chain in Chile. Russia and India are next in line for focus and Wal-Mart won't be taking half measures – the company only bothers to enter a market if it thinks it can be one of the top few players.
"It's important for us to be in one of the top three positions," says Wan Ling Martello, chief financial officer of Wal-Mart's international operation. "We have to have scale – otherwise it doesn't quite make sense."
That scale gives Wal-Mart muscle – and it is this brawn that, in the eyes of critics, can give it an unpleasantly bullying demeanour. At the very centre of the company's business model is a constant effort to drive down costs to an absolute minimum. Every pound, penny and tenth of a penny per unit of stock turns into millions in a firm of Wal-Mart's size.
"With the scale the company has, the economies of scale it can command, it basically extracts every last nickel out of its suppliers," says Michael Bride, deputy overseas organising director at the United Food & Commercial Workers Union in Washington. "If you're a Chinese supplier and Wal-Mart is pressing you down, you probably can't go and negotiate your electricity rates or your rent down. But you can cut costs when it comes to labour."
An investigation of five factories supplying Wal-Mart by China Labour Watch found "illegal and degrading conditions" according to a report released in November by the New York-based human rights group. At one plant in Dongguan, which supplies candles and Christmas tree lights, it found that workers were required to work 24-hour overtime shifts during busy periods and painted a bleak picture of pay as low as 44 cents per hour, bathrooms without running water and unsanitary canteens. Although Wal-Mart uses independent auditors to check on ethics at its suppliers, the group found evidence of workers being obliged to sign false pay receipts.
Wal-Mart responded to the report by saying it had begun an immediate probe into the factories: "We take reports like this very seriously and we will take prompt remedial action if our investigations confirm any of the findings."
Green initiatives
While imbued with an innate conservatism by its founding family, Wal-Mart moved in recent years to introduce higher environmental standards. As of 2007, it says it succeeded in cutting the amount of waste it sent to landfills by 55%. Wal-Mart also wants to be 100% driven by renewable power and recently said that it was purchasing sufficient wind energy in Texas to account for 15% of its electricity in the US.
Under a newly launched "sustainability index," Wal-Mart's suppliers must report to the company on their greenhouse gas emissions, waste reduction initiatives and ethical sourcing. The company is working towards a labelling system to inform customers of the sustainability of each and every product.
Matt Kistler, Wal-Mart's senior vice-president for sustainability, says saving on waste is a no-brainer: "At first it was a little bit of a reaction to the negative pressures as a company we'd been receiving. But very early on, from day two, there was a tremendous appetite not only from an environmental point of view but from a business point of view to do what we're doing."
Yet even these efforts, argue critics, are modest in the context of larger questions over the globalisation of Wal-Mart's business. Wake Up Wal-Mart's campaigner, Jill Cashen, says: "It's one thing to bring in a product, ship it from the other side of the planet and stick a label on it telling customers it's sustainable. How much greener would it be if it was produced within 100 miles of where it was sold?"
In north America, Wal-Mart remains unashamedly anti-union. It vigorously opposes attempts to organise. When, in a rare case in 2005, workers at a Quebecois Wal-Mart store voted in favour of collective representation, Wal-Mart simply shut it down. The case went to Canada's supreme court, which last month accepted Wal-Mart's explanation that the location was unprofitable.
Overseas, Wal-Mart has proven more flexible – it has worked with unions in Argentina, Brazil and in China, in accordance with local laws. But there are still strong reservations in the public mind about the way Wal-Mart does business.
Back in Arkansas, the Walton family are taking a stab at posterity through the construction of an impressive $50m glass and wood art gallery, Crystal Bridges. Designed by an acclaimed Israeli architect, Moshe Safdie, the 25,000ft complex is bankrolled by Sam Walton's daughter, Alice, and is intended to put Bentonville on the cultural map with a collection of American art from colonial times to the present day.
But even on Wal-Mart's home turf, visitors are far from unanimous in their verdicts on the company. "It's a symbol of free enterprise – the success of the free enterprise system," says John Niccum, a pensioner visiting Sam Walton's original Five and Dime store, now a museum.
But Kay Heaton, an AT&T telecoms employee from Missouri, is dubious: "It's beating the heck out of the little man. It kills the little guy who offers an independent service, from an independent business."



27 Comments so far
Show AllIt is ONLY the fault of the people who continue to support the "World Takeover" by one cancerous conglomerate and no one else's. Until the hidden facts of all the abuses and the potential TOTAL loss of the "Main Street" way of life are presented in the mainstream, the killer will spread.
The significance of a one-company monopoly has not been truly realized yet. After THEY "have us all", then THEY set prices; THEY become the "company store"; THEY have no regulations in place; THEY will single-handedly kill what is left of free-economic American capitalism. And THEY will do it with their damned "smiley faces, flag-waving, and slave labor for most of the population!
BOYCOTT WALLY WORLD! (This includes "closet supporters".)
Wal-Mart is the largest private employer in more than half of the 50 states. If trustbuster Teddy Roosevelt were president today he would break up Wal-Mart.
For the past decade or more Bill Gates and Warren Buffet have been touted as the wealthiest people. If you look at family wealth, however, the Walton family is far wealthier than the Gates or Buffet families.
Wal-Mart was recently talking about opening its own bank with branches in each store. Look out if that happens.
"Wal-Mart maintains that it is on the side of hard-working families who need to save every penny they can "
well then, how about paying a living wage?
no?
Oh, didn't think so.
We need to change Walmarts mantra from: LOW PRICES ALWAYS TO: LOW WAGES ALWAYS. Walmart executive: " we are saving people money so that they can live better". Pleeease! You pay low wages so that you and your executive, cronies can live better! You exploit people with slave labor in foreign countries so that Walmart can stay in business so that YOU and the rest of your ilk can live better. Of the ten richest people in the world 4 are Waltons. I rest my case.
Walmart stands for lower quality of life in the US: lower wages, shoddy chinese goods, lower opportunity for independent business. Walmart sends billions of dollars and millions of manufacturing jobs to china, and we get double digit unemployment in the US. Only the oligarchy benefits, and they are building gated communities.
Shame anyone you know who shops at Walmart.
"Thanksgiving turkey dinner for eight people at $20"
an average person would (should) eat 1/2 - 1LB per sitting... 4-8LB turkey... $1.50 /LB... $9 for 6LB turkey...
veggies... fruits... breads... pie... milk... you'd be able to get under $30... (incl the 6LB turkey) and get fresh... so that might be $10 more or $1.25 per person...
so... their claim... "saving people money so they can live better". is BS... BULLSHIT... if $10 is gonna break the bank... i wouldn't invite 8 people over for dinner... and if everyone brought a dish... they'd spend about $5 each... enjoy the comraderie... and you could feed 20...
walmart does this ALL THE TIME... they put CRAP out as a LOSS LEADER... and most people end up buying something a few notches up... and those products... ARE NOT the lowest prices always... i've done it... basic stuff... from toothpaste... to tomatoes... some better... some the same... some higher... than the next local supermarket...
i never understood... parking up to a 1/2 mile from the entrance... going into a building the size of a football stadium... to buy what... cheap crap... so i'll pick up a 22 rifle while i'm getting the kids' diapers... oh yeah... throw in that popcorn and patio set too...
$50BILLION each... (a little less now since the '08 crash)... and they won't even put out the coffee...
something is SERIOUSLY WRONG with these folks... SERIOUSLY... they could DOUBLE the wages of EVERY employee tomorrow... double what they pay for EVERY product... and what... have $2BILLION less... geee... only $48BILLION each...
hmmm........ bud fox in wall street... to gordon... "how much is enough"... how many boats... houses...
what do these people see... in the mirror every night...
homeless... sick... and needy people... the world over...
but they negotiated a 2LB jar of pickles down .014 cents this afternoon...
they talk about scale... they've decimated whole communities.. it's not uncommon for them to build a supercenter... close it down 2-4 years later... and build another one 10 miles away... leaving all the local businesses out of business... and this behemoth building collecting dust...
they... years ago... got a SUBSIDY to re pave the entranceway to their HQ off the main road... from the local town or county or state...
what would jesus say...? if they really wanted "to make people's lives better"... they might try to stop destoying so many of them...
one last note... they couldn't be there... if they didn't have the customers... never bought anything in a walmart... never will.
Jesus, as I understand Him, would see the Walton family as part of the modern Pharisee establishment, and treat them accordingly.
A friend visited Wally World HQ in Bentonville many times years ago to sell them products. He likened the working conditions to a hog confinement lot. The supplier workspaces were conference rooms so small, if someone was sitting down at the conference table there wasn't enough space between the chair and wall to walk behind them. The Walmart employees cubicle were tiny and Spartan and crammed right on top of each other.
My friend said Walmart also dictates the prices that the suppliers can sell products to them. If you pitched them a price of $1.15 per widget, they would shoot back $1.00, and say in so many words to take it or else we'll find someone else who can supply it for $1.00. No wonder all the crap they sell is crappy.
Wal Mart also sells store specific goods that are of lesser quality than the same name brands that other retailers can buy. Don't believe me? Buy a pack of mens fruit of the loom underwear from Wal-Mart and compare them to the same product from any other store. You will immedialtely notice that the elastic is less in the Wal Mart brand. This is how Wal Mart undercuts and kills other retailers. This is only one example from one manufacturer. Wal Mart has been putting constant downward pressure on wages of all workers not just Wal Mart wage slaves. I don't shop at Wal Mart I tell everyone I know who shops there what a crap corp they really are. Some listen, some don't. F%$K Wal Mart!
Good example. Manufacturing cheaper, inferior products is how the suppliers meet Wal Mart's dictated prices. It's a vicious cycle. Sure your undies might cost you less at Wally than other retailers, but they won't last as long and down the road, will cost you more since you have to replace them sooner.
The problem is that people boycot Wal Mart, but then do their shopping at Target, K Mart, or another big box retailer versus their locally owned, neighborhood stores. The others big boxes might not be as evil as Wal Mart, but you're still support a huge corporation and not your own economy.
Ah, that would explain that unfortunate incident with the Underwear Bomber. Poor devil!
Question? Exactly who is forced to play there game?
General Motors has been playing the same game for years, look what it got them and the country!
One of the less brainwashing channels (can't remember which one) has a series of 1-hour programs called The Walmartization of America that shows all that. Really good to watch so you can see how they do it. Of course, the show is not critical of them, you simply have to read between the lines as you watch
They opened a store in my town, but I refuse to go in there, or spend money any other store or on any brand in any other store that would send money to the USA and help perpetuate the Evil Empire. Takes a bit of work and sacrifice to find non-US brands, but it helps me sleep better at night ( on my made in Canada matress, under my made in China covers)
The hardest part was giving up bourbon...but good old Canadian Rye does the trick just as well.
You can continue to call them Wally World if you like, but with the new logo, I prefer to refer to them as The Golden Anus.
I live in Bentonville. We're like everyone else--the Waltons extract wealth from us and give back a pitifully small amount in return. Their home office is a series of old factory buildings and stores spread throughout town that have been converted into cubicle farms. The congestion in our streets to serve their business needs has traffic at a standstill much of the time. Do the Waltons step up and finance new street projects to serve their business interests? Hell no. We have to wait in line for state funding for highway widening projects. This puts pressure on every person living in town, whether they work for the Golden Anus or not.
I went inside the beast and worked in the home office for four years to see if the tales were true. The horrible things you hear are merely the tip of the iceberg as far as how badly employees are treated.
Stop and think about this for a minute: With the incredible buying power and leverage that they have, shouldn't Wal-Mart be able to offer the lowest prices while paying the highest wages in the industry? Well, they could if their management didn't keep making bone-headed mistakes that cost millions and millions of dollars. Remember their video service like Netflix? Remember when they were going to sell used cars on their lots? Remember the billions they lost in Germany because they weren't able to turn a profit in a country that wouldn't let them cut the legs out from under their competition? That's just the big stuff. Inside the home office the managers make the same kinds of mistakes on a smaller scale each and every day, costing the company thousands and millions of dollars at a time through sheer ineptitude.
Why the ineptitude in management? The directors and VPs are all watching their asses and making sure that nobody comes up from under them and steals their jobs. So you have an entire hierarchy of people who are unqualified to do their jobs. To make sure of this, they move the managers to brand new departments on a regular basis (usually once a year) where they know nothing and have to be trained by the working people already in the department.
I could go on and on, but I think you get the picture.
The Golden Anus is quite appropriate, considering all the cheap shit that comes out of the place.
Wal Mart has already tried, unsuccessfully thank God, to charter itslef as a bank. Just amazing what lengths these sociopaths will go to to extract a few more dollars from the American wage slave.
Walmart = Cruel Monopoly
Walmart Employee = Exploited, Harassed Slave denied the rights under US labor law.
Any Questions?
TJ
"All tyranny needs to gain a foothold is for people of good conscience to remain silent." - Thomas Jefferson
May I highly recommend the documentary "Wal-Mart: The High Cost of Low Price". Excellent film.
Well over 50 percent of everything sold at wallmart ends up in a landfill, the actual statistics are staggering. I don't shop at Wallmart and I noticed how much better life is when you don't have to go into one of those stores.
Walmart just announced that they were going to stop selling little toy trinkets for little kids because it was discovered that said trinkets were full of heavy metals such as Cadmium! Now lets see, American shoppers keep running to Walmart, so what if Walmart keeps selling them products that eventually end up being recalled because said products posion their pets and children, their prices are cheap! (Not to mention all the people who had their new homes built with contaminated drywall)
And Walmart keeps running back to their suppliers in China because they can buy their products cheap due to slave wages and no enviromental controls. So what if they have to keep recalling their product, The American people keep coming back because they are cheap!
Yep, MORON NATION!
SAVE YOUR MONEY AND LIVE BETTER!
I cannot believe Wal Mart has 266 stores in Cuba.
They don't. I can assure you of that or my family would have surely told me about it by now.
Somebody just noticed that Wal Mart is taking over the world. Wow! Next thing you know, they'll be noticing that McDonald's is doing the same thing.
The part about Cuba having 266 stores is pure, unadulterated lies. My family (the same ones that demand my American dollars every month) would have surely told me about it by now.
Ahem . . . By "Cuba" the Guardian means "China". They are taking their time to correct it, too. Cuba, China - apparently to some people it's the same.
Wal-Mart people really know how to do business , I mean they are on a continuous expansion, unfortunately they also promote excessive consumption which is bad for people and their health , with cheap products and discounts through easysaver and huge amounts for small prices.