Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
White House Accuses Downing Street of Making 'a Mistake' Over Intelligence Claim
The White House has accused Downing Street of making "a mistake" over allegations that Britain told American intelligence agents more than a year ago that the Detroit bomber had links to extremists.
The Prime Minister's spokesman had indicated that Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab was named in a file of people based in Britain who had made contact with radical Muslim preachers. The file was said to have been sent to the US authorities in 2008.
However, White House sources disputed the Downing Street account, stating that it was "a mistake" and no such intelligence information was passed by Britain before the attempted Christmas Day attacks. The White House declined to respond officially.
The news comes as Barack Obama prepares to unveil plans aimed at thwarting future attacks as he seeks to limit political fallout from the incident.
He will outline an initial series of changes, including enhancements to the much-criticised "watchlists" of terrorism suspects, after he meets with intelligence chiefs and other top security advisers on Tuesday, first full day back from his Hawaii vacation, an administration official said.
The implication that the US failed to act could embarrass President Barack Obama, who is already under pressure after failures by US intelligence to identify the bomber.
A British official also backed claims that there appeared to have been a misunderstanding about what Downing Street had said: "There is nothing to stand up the suggestion that the UK provided information to the US that it could or should have acted upon."
Diplomatic sources said that the Prime Minister's spokesman had intended to refer to information gleaned by MI5 after the Christmas Day incident following an exhaustive examination of records going back through Abdulmutallab's time in Britain up to October 2008.
It could also add to concern over the state of the "special relationship" between Downing Street and the White House following last year's dispute over the early release of the Lockerbie bomber.
It is extremely unusual for the Prime Minister's office to comment on intelligence matters. The move could be seen as an attempt to rebuff criticism from senior American figures who claimed that Britain had nurtured Islamic extremism.
At first it was thought that MI5 gathered only limited information on Abdulmutallab and had therefore not alerted the US.
However, in an official briefing, the Prime Minister's spokesman said that British intelligence was shared with the Americans.
He said: "Clearly there was security information about this individual's activities and that was information that was shared with the US authorities. That is the key point."
The spokesman added: "We are pretty certain that he was radicalised outside the UK. He [Abdulmutallab] left the UK in October 2008.
"But it is also clear that while he was here he was attempting to make contact with people and that is the intelligence we were able to secure from the intelligence services."
Last night, a Downing Street spokesman added: "We do routinely share large quantities of intelligence with the US on a two-way basis so we can build up a picture of the potential threats we face.
In regard to the Detroit bomber, the UK and US had gathered partial information and this had been shared in the usual way. Since the incident, we have built up a fuller picture.
There is no suggestion that the US did not act on intelligence information that they received from the UK."
Questions will be asked about how much MI5 knew about Abdulmutallab and whether the information was correctly handled. Sources said he was given the attention he warranted at the time, and the fact that he associated with other extremists in this country was not surprising.
Abdulmutallab, a Nigerian, studied at University College London between 2005 and 2008. He then left the country and was thought to have travelled to Yemen.
He attempted to detonate a bomb hidden in his underwear on Northwest Airlines flight 253 to Detroit on Christmas Day.
The decision by Downing Street to give details of the shared intelligence was unlikely to be welcomed by the White House. It was the latest in a series of incidents, which have strained relations between Britain and America.
Last summer, the Americans were angered by the decision of the Scottish administration to release the Lockerbie bomber on compassionate grounds. In September, Mr Obama rebuffed five requests for a private meeting with the Prime Minister when he visited New York.
At the weekend, the Prime Minister announced a British-US initiative to tackle terrorism in Yemen. The White House then made it clear that Mr Brown had not spoken to President Obama since the Detroit bomber was apprehended. The Prime Minister was then forced to admit that it was an old programme.
Last week, it was found that the bomber had come to the attention of MI5 when he made contact with a number of individuals who were under surveillance. However, MI5 was not thought to have identified Abdulmutallab as a threat and he was not fully investigated. The bomber was therefore not placed on international watch lists and was able to board a plane from Nigeria to America, via Amsterdam last month.
Although he appeared in a number of top secret intelligence reports, Abdulmutallab was allowed to keep his American visa.
Abdulmutallab's father contacted the CIA in November to give them warning that his son was involved with fundamentalists in Yemen.
Communications were intercepted in Yemen, which referred to a possible attack by "the Nigerian". American intelligence experts have criticised the failure to identify the potential threat and drawn comparisons with 2001, when the CIA and FBI missed warning signs of the September 11 attacks.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

17 Comments so far
Show AllLies from liars told to other liars.
Fear the governments, the real terrorists.
And which government has the greater incentive and penchant for lying?
Here are several interpretations;
Obfuscation.
Once again, the British and the U.S. were able to get it wrong - or did they? The timing of this incident was very convenient for U.S. plans in Yemen (and elsewhere). Michael Chertoff(sp?) will make a killing in profits.
Dimwitted disorientation.
So much information is being illegally gathered on ordinary, innocent people that they can't keep track of the supposed reasons they started collecting information. Not that they really give a damn anyway.
>>So much information is being illegally gathered on ordinary, innocent people that they can't keep track of the supposed reasons they started collecting information. Not that they really give a damn anyway.<<
Why "data-ming" software is the coming thing at the NSA. Maybe then the sheer volume of e-mails will no loner assure some privacy.
Gary
The decision by Downing Street to give details of the shared intelligence was unlikely to be welcomed by the White House.
-------------------
I'd put the odds in favor of the theory that some element of our government (past or present) let this guy slip through our security net and get on the airplane.
The government wishes to open up a sizable military front in Yemen and if Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab's underpants bomb successfully detonated public opposition would've been muted.
"It could also add to concern over the state of the "special relationship" between Downing Street and the White House"
A "pimp and ho" relationship ain't so "special"
Duh ! the CIA and FBI did not miss " warning signs" they gave warning signs.
As Pilger's article on Orwell in CD today states the Afghanistan invasion plans had been communicated to Pakistan prior 9/11.
I believe the Nigerian was used by the CIA, with no intention of a lethal explosion to justify already previous attacks on Yemen,
As in the day before the underwear exploded.
Detroit Bomber ---- is that like a good hitter in Baseball?
The more wedges driven between the USA and allies the better.
Ray Berthiaume
I fully agree. Nothing like fear to control citizens.
The British government was almost surely right initially, and is backtracking now due to the US Government leaning on it,
AD
Lets see....the Brits gave the USA a heads up a year ago...the guys father even ratted him out months ago...he bought his ticket in cash...one way...no visa...no luggage...gets past the bomb sniffing dogs/scans and all the other security by the word of "some man in a suit"....and has some tenuous links to Yemen..exactly where the USA wants to stage TWAT part 4.
The bomb does not go off..its a dud.
The kid is obviously a CIA stooge.
Terrorists flew planes into the WTC and they somehow collapsed.
Since Iraq was behind the 9/11 attacks we had to invade the country to take their oil.
Osama Bin Laden hates our freedom and has the superhuman ability to arrange massive terror attacks worldwide with just a cell phone call from his cave.
Despite having a Homeland Security department with 10 years of experience, being actively involved in a GWOT, and ridiculous airport security, Mr. Underpants was too clever for them to stop.
Meanwhile, Iran is building Nuclear Weapons!
We really need to make a Marriage Amendment.
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed should be executed for his dastardly deeds on 9/11 even though Saddam Hussein and Osama Bin Laden did it.
It's important to have full body scans at airports even though with all the new security, there's no less incidents at airports then there were 20 or more years ago.
We should build a wall between the US and Mexico.
I'm so tired of hearing fairy tales.
"Osama Bin Laden hates our freedom and has the superhuman ability to arrange massive terror attacks worldwide with just a cell phone call from his cave."
Hmmm...no. I have it in good authority that it was an intercave memo that did the trick.
If only all terrists were as coöperative as the xmas crotch bomber with his ready confession.
Think of all the water it would save!
Still - should we believe a man whose pants are on fire?
Good Grief...what are you all talking about???? Everyone knows it's George Bush's fault.
Oh, please! Obama should do us all a favor and shut up already.
All of our politicians, every single one of them, in office and out of office, should shut up, stop posturing, crowing, pontificating, pointing fingers, and really get to work or...
...we should fire the entire lot of them.
That's the sad reality of that.
How so very typical American: always find someone else, another country to blame. Accept blame only when nothing else works. The same when 9/11 happened: the very first country to be blamed was Canada.