Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
In Fight Over Credit Rules, Elizabeth Warren Wields a Plan
CAMBRIDGE - Her critics portray her as an ivory tower elitist intent on disrupting the American Dream. But to her legions of fans in the Democratic Party, Harvard law professor Elizabeth Warren is the nation's leading economic David, fighting to protect middle-class families from corporate Goliaths.
TARP chairwoman Elizabeth Warren stands in the Congressional Oversight panel's offices on Capitol Hill. (Cliff Owen/MCT) Her critique of the lending practices of big banks and mortgage companies is drawing plenty of attention, airing on everything from CNN to "The Daily Show'' and Dr. Phil, even winning a cameo in Michael Moore's latest movie, "Capitalism: A Love Story.''
And she is chief architect of a new government agency to protect consumers from predatory lenders, a central element of President Obama's efforts to avoid another economic meltdown. That makes her a big target.
"I have dubbed it the ‘Restrict the American Dream and Job Destruction Act,' '' Representative Tom Price of Georgia, chairman of the Republican Study Committee, a group of 110 GOP House members, said in an interview about Warren's proposed Consumer Financial Protection Agency. "I have no doubt that as a Northeast elite academic it is difficult for Ms. Warren to appreciate that, but that's exactly what it will do.''
Another critic, George Mason University law professor Todd Zywicki, said, "Bluntly put, she hates banks.''
Warren, whose beliefs stem in part from her upbringing in a financially pressed Oklahoma family, counters: "That is just wrong. What I hate are banks that cheat people.''
Warren, 60, has researched the issue of risky credit practices and bankruptcy for years, as she worked her way to Harvard Law School through a handful of university teaching jobs. Deceptive lending practices, she said, were at the root of the 2008 financial meltdown and have devastated the middle class.
While business groups are opposed to the consumer agency, they are even more worried about the possibility that, if it is created, Warren will be put in charge.
"We believe the most effective director would be one with real-world experience,'' said Scott Talbott, senior vice president of the Financial Services Roundtable, which represents many large banks. Warren said it is premature to discuss whether she wants to head an agency that doesn't yet exist.
Warren's proposal still faces major hurdles. Having passed through the House Financial Services Committee, led by US Representative Barney Frank of Massachusetts, a Warren friend, it must now pass the full House and then the Senate, where Republicans have threatened to filibuster against it.
The US Chamber of Commerce has launched an intensive campaign to kill the idea, using the theme: "Stop the Consumer Financial Protection Agency.''
Warren's route to the center of the nation's debate over financial regulation has taken a more complicated path than many of her backers and critics may realize.
She was once a registered Republican who believed that most families who filed for bankruptcy or had their homes foreclosed were irresponsible. It was only after years of study, she said, that she determined that many families were not primarily at fault.
The youngest of four children, Warren grew up at the edge of a wheat field in what she called a "cheap little crackerbox on the end of town'' in Norman, Okla. Her father had a series of financial reversals and became an apartment maintenance worker; her mother took telephone orders for Sears to bring in much-needed funds.
Living with three older brothers, she developed an assertive manner that led her to join her high school's debate team, which in turn led to her winning the Oklahoma debating championship and a college scholarship. Married at 19, she had a young daughter by the time she entered law school and was pregnant with a second child when she earned her degree. A stint as a work-from-home lawyer was followed by teaching positions at Rutgers School of Law, University of Texas School of Law, University of Houston Law Center, University of Michigan, and University of Pennsylvania School of Law, leading in 1992 to her initial arrival at Harvard.
But Warren left Harvard after a year, due in part to what she called a "hostile environment'' for women. Three years later, convinced that the environment had improved and desiring a bigger platform for her ideas, she returned to Harvard and has been there since.
She became a student favorite, relying on a rapid-fire version of Socratic teaching and a flair for the dramatic. In one recent class, she used some biting humor to chide a student who failed to respond correctly to her query. Casting herself as Vanna White, she pretended her blackboard was the Wheel of Fortune, twirled her arm in the air, and asked: "Do you want to buy a vowel?'' Her students appreciate the tough-love approach; one class gave her a poster that shows a comic book version of a Wonder Woman-type character who says, "If I want your opinion, I'll beat it out of you.''
Warren says she never envisioned herself as someone who would become a nemesis of corporate America. But after working on several bankruptcy studies, she concluded that most people who declare bankruptcy are undone by a combination of questionable banking practices and outsize medical expenses. She coauthored a book with her daughter, Amelia, called "The Two-Income Trap: Why Middle-Class Mothers and Fathers Are Going Broke,'' which countered the belief that many families were squandering their money on unnecessary luxuries. She argued that many such families were going bankrupt and losing their homes to foreclosure because the cost of necessities had skyrocketed to unsustainable levels even when both parents worked.
But it wasn't just statistics that shaped her view. For years, she pondered why her parents had gone from a seemingly secure middle-class existence to more difficult circumstances.
"It is a story like my own family's story, of people who had the aspirations of the middle class, who often had ‘made it,' had gotten a decent education, married, had kids, gotten good jobs, but something had gone wrong, and they were now on the economic down slope,'' Warren said. As she described her parent's financial difficulties, she said, "This comes from my heart.''
By the time Warren returned to Harvard in 1995, she had switched her political affiliation to the Democratic Party because she was convinced that "the Republican Party had left me'' and left behind the middle class. At the same time, she became an academic adviser to a congressional panel that was studying bankruptcy law. To her dismay, Congress in 1997 voted for a law that made it harder for families to declare bankruptcy. Determined to stop the measure, she met then-first lady Hillary Rodham Clinton. Using charts and forceful language, Warren won over Clinton, who got her husband to veto the bill.
But in 2005, Congress once again approved the measure, with support from many moderate Democrats, and President Bush signed the law. In Warren's view, the imposition of tougher bankruptcy laws made it more difficult for many people to forestall foreclosure on their home loans and played a role in the subsequent financial meltdown.
Warren met Obama at a fund-raiser for the future president's campaign for US Senate in Illinois. Obama had heard about Warren and approached her, greeting her with the phrase: "Predatory lending.''
Obama then spoke at length about why he wanted to go to Washington to stop financial institutions from cheating consumers. Warren sought to reassure the future president that he didn't need to convince her.
"You had me at ‘predatory lending,' '' she said.



22 Comments so far
Show AllIf the banking criminals and their legislative lapdogs are afraid of Ms. Warren, then she is the right person for the job. I saw her on the Daily Show and she made perfect sense. She is an intelligent, dedicated individual, and she is right!! You go, Ms. Warren! Kick some banker butt. While you're at it, can we hang a few of them, just for fun?
EXACTLY!!!!
GO ELIZABETH !!!
the SHARPNESS of Elizabeth Warren strikes fear in the hearts of the CRIMINALS that run the country:
normally a jingoistic statement would go unanswered and simply swallowed by the american people at large as "sufficient truth unto itself:"
"SHE HATES BANKS"...which implies to "hate america"......
but WARREN does the "unthinkable"
she comes up with a quick retort to expose the complete insufficiency and misleading character of the statement:
""that's just not true...what I hate are banks that CHEAT PEOPLE".
GO ELIZABETH!!!!
don't back down!! USE YOUR WOMANHOOD against these MALE CROOKS who run the country!
and if some WOMEN like Hillary , Condi Rice, Olympia Snow and others try to derail you -- SHOW THEM UP as "women who do the bidding of MEN CROOKS"...and who have abandoned their Mother Instincts to become "half-men"!!
Lets hope Glenn Beck doesn't start bashing her. Obama would likely 86 her like he 86'd Van Jones when Beck whined.
AND NO WONDER SHE has given sharp retorts to the "dumb down" rhetoric of the crooks:
she taught the Socratic method of inquiry!! which is to push, through "answering" questions or statements with a "question", a discussion to its final truth.
no wonder.
the more Elizabeth does this - the prettier she looks! and if she keeps up her quest - Her Children and GrandChildren will live their lives always PROUD of her. and she will be remembered as one of the 'great americans' and for her work and effort to try to remind america:
HONESTY IS STILL the best policy.
GO ELIZABETH!!
I love this woman. She's intelligent, focused, and tough. Unbeatable. She should be the first woman President.
Elizabeth, will you marry me?
camus13
The one thing I always noticed whenever I see Elizabeth Warren on TV is that she CARES.....ABOUT US ALL.....
She is smart but also passionate and to hear some professor say she hates banks is typical of most professors. Go alongs. But Warren is different, she been there and she through study found out why we are where we are.
Now the banks will have to again buy off congress. Oh I forgot they already have and the United States will just continue it slide into a third world country.
Maybe: Warren for President.......
somebody has to put these monsters in a cage. it might as well
be elizabeth. i would love to work for her and beat these
bastards down! there were never any fair rules by any of
the "too big to fail banks" the little mom and pops were ok
but the monsters killed america. too bad she can't rein in
the criminal 101 members like tom price.its the mindset of these bozos that caused the collapse just not the banks.
Notice that the yahoo peckerwood from Georgia has to resort to the old "Northeastern liberal elitist" smear because he lacked any criticism of real substance against a graduate professor of contract law from Harvard University Business School.
The shock of finding a business academic with a social conscience must seem like a long and nasty burst of flatulance in a crowded elevator to the neocon fascist legions in Congress from both parties. Gag on it you imbeciles, and keep raising a stink Elizabeth Warren!
This appears to be one appointment (along with the recently and regretably so) departed Van Jones that the Beige Bush got right. How does that saying go, "even a broken clock is right twice a day"?
Poet
Drive the money lenders from the temples or is it the greedy bankers from the halls of congress. How can anybody in their right minds support usury interest rates? This constant refrain from the Republicans that big business can do no wrong should be good reason to elect new congress men and women.
Why is it harder for a family to declare bankruptcy, yet taxpayer funds are used to avoid bankruptcy for BANKS, The United States of America has become a corporatocracy with no real opposition in the political relm. we need 507 more people like Elizabeth.
Thanks Rep Price (and Chamber of Commerce) for confirming that the only way to achieve the "American dream" is by lying to, cheating, and otherwise stomping on your fellow citizens.
Wall Street and the big banks are modern day Robber Barons. Like Carnegie, Rockefeller, and Morgan, they make their fortunes off of shady (read illegal, unethical, and immoral)practices.
It sounds like she would make a great Secretary of the Treasury. The crook Geithner is robbing us blind. It would be nice to have a Treasury Secretary loyal to the USA instead of Israel.
I really think this lady is great,
all she needs is a male with some guts
to stand behind her..
If she could get the president behind her?
Go get them Elizabeth!
She is doing a fine job.
Anybody think you can do better?
step up to the plate, and lets see it.
She thinks problems through, uses her brains,
and is very intelligent. She needs a promotion..
Elizabeth Warren:
Good Head and Good Heart;
Follows her Conscience;
Good example for us all.
Bless
Ms.Warren-with tears in my eyes-THANK YOU!
Elizabeth Warren seems terrific, BUT...
As with her overseeing TARP, why does anyone think that the creation of a "new" agency in the hog trough of Washington will do any more than the agencies which came before it and were systematically rendered corrupt?
Please understand, I am not opposed to large federal government which employs large numbers of people and helps large numbers of poeople. But I find it difficult to believe any new agency created by these dimwits in power will be anything more than another fraud.
I fear that her efforts will be crushed by the same crew that ran Brooksley Born out of her job in 1999. Ms Born was the head of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and tried to warn about the huge increase of unregulated credit default swaps and their potential for fraud.
Or Iris Mack. Smart women who speak the truth are rarely rewarded.
Joe
"And she is chief architect of a new government agency to protect consumers from predatory lenders, a central element of President Obama's efforts to avoid another economic meltdown. That makes her a big target."
Ha ha! ROFL! Best laugh I've had all day!