Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
UN Delays Action on Gaza War Report
The UN today put off action on a report criticising Israel's actions during the war in Gaza after Palestinian leaders suddenly dropped their support for a resolution, apparently under heavy US pressure.
Richard Goldstone: UN has put off action on his report. (Photograph: Ho/Reuters) The
decision marked a surprising reversal in the Palestinian position
which, until now, had backed the findings of the report by the South
African judge Richard Goldstone.
Goldstone accused both Israel and the Palestinian Islamist group Hamas of war crimes during the three-week conflict.
He was particularly critical of Israel, both for its conduct of the war and its continued occupation of Palestinian territory.
The UN human rights council in Geneva had been due to vote today on whether to pass the Goldstone report to the UN security council for further action.
That vote will now be delayed until the council meets next, in March next year.
Israel had strongly rejected the findings of the Goldstone report as biased, even though it also criticised the actions of Hamas.
The US administration said it had "very serious concerns" about Goldstone's recommendations, which included a call for the UN security council to investigate and raised the possibility of investigation by the international criminal court and judges from individual countries.
The Palestinians do not have a seat on the 47-member human rights council, but Arab and Muslim nations with council seats had been expected to push for the report to be endorsed.
The Palestinian reversal came after "intense diplomacy" by Washington, which told the Palestinians that going ahead with the vote would harm efforts to restart peace talks with the Israelis, according to diplomats quoted by news agencies.
"The Palestinians recognised that this was not the best time to go forward with this," the official said.
Some western nations, including the US, were also thought to be concerned about the precedent that would be set by such international investigations into wartime actions.
However, Imad Zuhairi, the deputy Palestinian ambassador in Geneva, said the report "remains alive" and would be debated next spring. The delay "is not a victory for Israel," he added.
It is understood that the Palestinians had helped draft a motion endorsing the Goldstone report and its recommendations, but that it became clear that the US, Japan and those European countries on the human rights council would not support the motion.
It was then decided to postpone the motion rather than have it voted down or vetoed.
Ghassan Khatib, the head of the Palestinian Authority's media centre, said the Palestinians still supported the Goldstone report.
"There is no change in the Palestinian position," he added. "Palestinian officials didn't backtrack from the position they declared, which is that they expect the human rights council to adopt the report and that the UN should do whatever it takes to ensure the implementation of its recommendations."
It appeared that the Palestinian leadership was reluctant to lose the chance to return to peace negotiations with Israel and unwilling to try other steps to put pressure on Israel such as international legal action.
Robert Blecher, an analyst with the International Crisis Group, said a similar decision had been taken last week when the Palestinians agreed to meet the Israelis in New York despite Israel's decision not to accept their call for a full halt to settlement construction.
"This is a further indication that the current Palestinian leadership is not considering any options except for negotiation and in that sense the climbdown, like the climbdown in the meeting in New York city, is not unexpected - just the speed with which it was taken," he said.
Israel refused to co-operate with Goldstone's investigations, not even granting him entry to the country.
It then launched an intense diplomatic and public relations operation against his report, particularly after efforts this week in Britain to have an arrest warrant issued against Ehud Barak, the Israeli defence minister who oversaw the Gaza war.
Yesterday, Binyamin Netanyahu, the Israeli prime minister, said an endorsement of the Goldstone report would "strike a fatal blow against the peace process" and deny Israel's "right to self-defence".
Goldstone defended his work against Netanyahu's criticism, saying: "I think he got wrong what our report is all about.
"He talked about Israel's right to self-defence. That is not what the report was about."
He said both sides in the conflict had violated international law by targeting civilians.
Earlier in the week, he had told the human rights council that he wanted a "transparent, open investigation" by both sides into the allegations made in his report.
The 575-page report found that some Israelis should face "individual criminal responsibility" and that both sides had committed war crimes and possible crimes against humanity.
The three-week war left 1,400 Palestinians and 13 Israelis dead and triggered criticism across the world.
- Posted in

11 Comments so far
Show AllSarcasm fails me.
No hurry, fellas -- it's only been half century of brutally oppressive and often murderous occupation. I'm sure we can wait of few more weeks.
The Israelis threatened to stop a Palestinian phone service project if the Palestinian Authority didn't drop its support for an investigation of Israeli war crimes.
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/palestinians-cry-blackmail-over-israel-phone-service-threat-1796145.html
"Some western nations, including the US, were also thought to be concerned about the precedent that would be set by such international investigations into wartime actions."
What a disgusting statement.
It is a precedent that needs to be set.
Why not earlier, say, before Nuremberg?
Unbe-freakin-lievable!
this is like asking a rape victim to gently jerk off the rapist so he can have another more relaxed bit of fun
it is obscene
it is nwo control and nazi holocaust revisted this time thanks to zion - and they, of all folks, should know better
I'm not surprised at this.
Here's Israhells war crimes list: It's similar to what the US occupiers are doing in Iraq. Only the US is getting it up the ass.
*Attacking residential areas, water wells, rooftop water tanks, agricultural land, citrus groves, chicken farms, greenhouses, business factories and police stations.
* Using phosphorous incendiary shells on a UN compound sheltering more than 600 civilians.
* Using phosphorous and high explosive artillery shells on Al-Quds hospital. (He rejected the contention that Hamas or other militants were using the hospital.)
* Attacking a crowded mosque during evening prayers. (He rejected the contention that arms and militants were inside.)
* Using flechettes, 4-cm metal darts fired from missiles, planes or tanks "that penetrate straight through human bone and can cause serious, often fatal, injuries."
* Using Palestinians as human shields in house searches.
Abbas does not even represent the Palestinians!
Just stay quiet and you will get your bone, trust me!
Shame on the countries who would vote down an investigation of war crimes!
It was interesting that Fatah's Abbas (not Hamas' Meshal), the collaborationist faction of the Palestinian governing body, was the person invited to Washington to meet with Obama the Weak and Netanyahu the Soulless. No wonder the Palestinian people voted Fatah 'out' and Hamas 'in' 2 years ago. The people have paid heavily for that vote.
Anyone in his or her right mind would recognize that after 4 reports from major investigative agencies-- Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, B'Tselem (Israel's own human rights organization), and the UN-- that accused Israel of atrocities during its Operation Cast Lead, this withdrawal by Abbas of the Palestinian
complaint is the work of charlatans.
The US must give up its Mephistophelean dealings with Israel or risk losing any link it may still have with ethics and morality in the world community.
Yet another Holocaust denial?
Quoting from the electronic Intifada:
“The Abbas delegation to the United Nations in Geneva (officially representing the moribund Palestine Liberation Organization) abandoned a resolution requesting the Human Rights Council to forward Judge Richard Goldstone’s report on war crimes in Gaza to the UN Security Council for further action. Although the PA acted under US pressure, there are strong indications that the commercial interests of Palestinian and Gulf businessmen closely linked to Abbas also played a part.”
Read More : http://electronicintifada.net/v2/article10807.shtml
While Gideon Levi writes in Haaretz:
“Israel should thank Judge Richard Goldstone and his commission’s important report. After subjecting him to useless, automatic mudslinging, Israel suddenly realized that it should finally investigate the events of Operation Cast Lead. Why? What happened? The ground has started to tremble under the feet of a number of Israeli statesmen and officers….
….Is the world hard on Israel? Perhaps. But Israel also enjoys endless preferential treatment. The world acts differently toward us, turns a blind eye to Dimona and is silent about the occupation, and now it no longer wants to keep silent about Gaza. Why? Because this time we went too far. That is not only the world's right, it is its duty.
Goldstone began the work, Israel should continue it. In the end, the image that looks out from Goldstone's mirror is our image, not his.”
Read more: http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/1118022.html
It all reminds me of the Dylan clasic “The times they are a-changin'” Perhaps both Abbas and Netanyahu should take note:
The line it is drawn
The curse it is cast
The slow one now
Will later be fast
As the present now
Will later be past
The order is
Rapidly fadin'.
And the first one now
Will later be last
For the times they are a-changin'