Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Italy Seeks Jail for US Spies in Rendition Trial
MILAN - An Italian prosecutor called on Wednesday for 26 Americans, all but one believed to be members of the CIA, to be jailed for between 10 and 13 years each for the kidnapping of a terrorism suspect in 2003.
Public Prosecutor Armando Spataro also asked a Milan court to sentence four Italians, including the former head of Italy's Sismi secret service, to up to 13 years in prison for the abduction of Muslim cleric Hassan Mustafa Osama Nasr.
Nasr, also known as Abu Omar, was snatched from the streets of Milan six years ago and secretly flown for interrogation in Egypt, where he says he was tortured and held until 2007 without charge.
The trial is the most high profile case in Europe to challenge the extra-judicial transfers, known as 'renditions', used by the government of former President George W. Bush in its fight against terrorism.
"Democracies are founded on principles that cannot be renounced even in moments of emergency. If we give up that vision we would have partly lost the fight against terrorism," Spataro told the court in his summary of the evidence.
"This was an unbearable blow to legality and fundamental human rights, unacceptable even in the interests of security."
None of the Americans is in Italy for the trial and the United States has ruled out extraditing them, so any conviction would be purely symbolic. The longest jail term, 13 years, was requested for the ex-head of the CIA station in Rome, identified as Jeff Castelli.
Prosecutors sought 12 years for the former chief of the Milan station, identified as Robert Feldon Lady. Spataro said a verdict could be delivered by late October or early November.
Spataro dropped charges against three of the seven Italian suspects after an earlier Constitutional Court ruling made evidence against them inadmissable as it broke state secrecy.
Prosecutors had used wiretaps on the spies and questioned them on classified matters, such as relations with the CIA.
Last week, Washington said it invoked jurisdiction in the case against Colonel Joseph Romano -- believed to be the only non-CIA member on trial -- under a NATO accord. The other U.S. suspects in the Italian trial do not face prosecution in their homeland.
Under the Bush administration, the United States has said it used rendition to seize terrorism suspects around the world and deliver them for interrogation in third countries. It has not acknowledged any rendition in Italy.
Washington is currently debating the harsh interrogation of terrorism suspects who were in U.S. custody and whether to prosecute the officials responsible.
Egyptian-born Nasr, who was released from Egyptian custody in 2007, faces an arrest warrant in Italy on suspicion of terrorist activity.
- Posted in

8 Comments so far
Show AllC'mon Italy, use 'extraordinary rendition' to get those spooks out of the usa... What's with this mealy mouthed request that they be extradited, does this mean that you'll not stoop to kidnapping people to enforce the law...
Bush is waiting to see what History says about him. Let us see if we can imaging what it might be. George Bush the selected dictator of the United States of America became the worlds most despicable liar,murderer, destruction of the country, the worlds top terrorist and above all had a yellow streak down his back.
all of that made possible by al climate change gore who walked away from the office having won the election
treason has many faces - but al abandoned us to 8 years of bush and the war on terror
as far as italy goes - we have around forty bases there still - a legacy from the ww2 which ended 64 years ago
there's a timeline for the iraq withdrawal
maybe italy will have a single car accident or it could be a small plane crash - cia favorites both
Imagine what would happen to an Iran if they refused to extradite Criminals to the country where they committed their crimes. Or a Libya...or an Afghanistan...
The world makes one more step in the right direction to bring the 'lawless USA' to justice.
Convictions in Italian courts will make these criminals 'open game' for anyone who wishes to 'rendition' them to Italy to serve their sentences.
There will most likely be a 'reward offered' and if not, there could be many other ways to see that these and as many others as possible are brought to justice.
Just imagine GW Bush in 'the joint' in some other country.
He would be the 'jailhouse punk' in no time.
Famous (locally anyway) for the 'things' he will do for a candy bar---- 'after lights out'.
"If the USA were another nation the USA would invade the USA to keep the world safe; and they would be justified."
"None of the Americans is in Italy for the trial and the United States has ruled out extraditing them, so any conviction would be purely symbolic."
Maybe run that past Roman Polanski and see how he feels about it. (And from Switzerland, home of secret bank accounts for Nazi leaders and every other dictator since, of all places!) And in any event, maybe one day the US will have a real president.
Michael Parenti can be proud of the home of his ancestors.
AD
This whole case has been difficult. There are two sides to everything. I wonder why we have done nothing to Egypt- don't you?- why are they exempt and why all the focus on soldiers that were given orders? For those who have not fought as a soldier you may not understand the things you are ordered to do and what you are told before you do them. The one who gave the orders is the responsible party- why is the focus again not on them? All the way at the top.... I feel for these fellow men and understand their plight. I know if I am given orders that I follow them- that is what they are taught. They did not do the torturing. We have to ask why the right questions have not been asked. I think hanging these guys out to dry gets the focus off of the others. I think they believed in what they did. So do many soldiers who are sent out to do a job. If you have not walked in those steps be careful who you condemn.