Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Once World's Bread Basket, Iraq Now a Farming Basket Case
MISHKHAB, Iraq - Once the cradle of agriculture for civilization, the Land Between Two Rivers - the Tigris and Euphrates - has become a basket case for its farmers.
Naj Habeeb and his son, Mustafa, grow rice in a field along the Euphrates River in Iraq's Mishkab village. Just ask Naji Habeeb, 85. His family has been growing rice in this village 135 miles southeast of Baghdad for generations. Thin green shoots stick out of the flat paddies, shin-deep in brown water.
The Iraqi government, he claims, still owes him half of what he's due from last year's crop. He turned it in months ago and still hasn't been paid. "Shall I suck my fingers and eat like a baby?" he shouted. "The Ministry (of Agriculture) will never know my family is hungry!"
Habeeb's family members have farmed the 538-square-foot plot next to a branch of the Euphrates River the same way for centuries. Except today they till with tractors, run water pumps with gasoline and spread artificial fertilizer. They plant seedlings by hand in June and July, irrigate and keep bugs and disease away in the summer heat, harvest by hand in October.
However, their efforts haven't helped Iraqi agriculture overcome the twin disasters of war and sanctions, which have transformed the country from one of the world's premier sources of aromatic rice and nearly 500 kinds of dates 30 years ago into a net importer of food.
Iraq now imports nearly all the food its people eat: California rice, Washington apples, Australian wheat, fruits and vegetables from its neighbors. All are staples in Iraqi groceries and on the dinner table.
The decline of the farming sector creates other problems. Agriculture accounts for half or more of Iraqi jobs and is the second-largest contributor to the gross domestic product. The prices that people and the government pay for shortfalls in what they used to grow weaken the country's economy.
For its part, Prime Minister Nouri al Maliki's office says he unveiled an "agricultural initiative" two years ago. It included $240 million to bolster farmers, including no-interest loans, guarantees to buy crops, research and development, and other plans. A deputy in the Ministry of Agriculture, Mahdi al Qaisi, said that his agency "will be happy to help farmers, who are our brothers. The time of fear has ended; there is no need to be afraid."
Iraq's agriculture faces the same problems as farmers everywhere: drought (in its fifth year), bugs, disease, salty water, red tape. Those problems are exacerbated, however, by location and history. Eight years of war with Iran, defeat in the Persian Gulf War of 1991, then 12 years of sanctions and, most recently, six years of war and U.S.-led occupation have left the country's agricultural sector in shambles.
Reliable statistics are elusive or suspect. Iraq is the only country, for example, in which the U.S. Foreign Agricultural Service estimates crop yields by using satellite data.
The available numbers, however, suggest a stagnant and backward sector.
This year's wheat harvest is expected to be 1.3 million tons, down a million tons from last season. The prized amber rice crop grown by Habeeb and popular throughout the region for its perfumed scent will be around 100,000 tons, one-third of last year's yield.
One result is that Iraq has become one of the world's biggest importers of wheat, around 3.5 million tons. Barley to feed livestock - sheep, goats and cattle - also is shipped in from other countries. The higher cost of raising livestock means that more will have to be culled.
Another result: Iraqi consumers pay more for homegrown produce than they do for some imports.
Zaineb Kemal, a mother of four in Mosul, said that Iraqi produce had become scarce and expensive. That's why "so many people prefer to buy imported goods," she said, adding that she likes Iranian watermelons, Syrian cucumbers and Egyptian oranges.
Anti-globalization groups praise the fact that Iraqi farmers reuse their own seeds season after season. That doesn't lead to robust crops, however, and farmers routinely spread twice as much seed as they ordinarily would need to ensure the reduced yields.
As in any country, agriculture is political. Unlike most nations, however, the present Iraqi government doesn't protect - let alone subsidize - many of its farmers, according to Western experts, the rice farmers in Mishkhab and consumers.
"Most farmers have been abandoned by the state," said Qasim Muhaideen, 43, who works in Mosul's central market. "How can our farmers compete in price and availability?"
Geopolitics also influences what happens to Iraq's farmers.
Turkey and Syria have built dams on the Euphrates within their borders, and they turn the spigot off and on to Iraq.
"The shortage is very effective," Awn Theyab, the director general of Iraq's National Center for Water Resources, said after Turkey reduced the flow after one week. "If it continues, we won't have enough water for the first round of the winter season, because our reservoirs are empty."
A few bright spots have sprouted. Aquaculture is emerging slowly as a food source, and 100,000 carp fingerlings were released to reservoirs in April. They'll grow to only one-fourth the size of the 25-pound monsters pulled from the Tigris, but the supply is more stable.
There's also been a boom in "hoop houses," plastic greenhouses for tomatoes using drip irrigation, not the usual field flooding.
Multinational provincial reconstruction teams report growing interest in better farming practices. Beekeepers, poultry producers and growers who want to learn modern techniques have started attending workshops. During the years of sectarian and tribal violence, they were afraid to be seen with Americans. Just this week, 175 Iraqis signed up for a soil salinity seminar.
Habeeb and his partner, Abdul Abbas Muhair, 67, have never met a foreign agricultural adviser, however.
Sitting barefoot on a carpet runner in a tiled room next to their paddies, Habeeb and Muhair swapped gripes about the government. Poor or zero planning. Delayed or incomplete payments. Baksheesh - bribes - needed for the best seeds. Weak fertilizer. Weaker pesticide. Power to run water pumps for only six hours a day, so they must buy gasoline for generators.
Even worse than their litany, they said, is their loss of pride. In their fathers' day, the aromatic rice they grew was enjoyed in Egypt, Lebanon - throughout the Middle East. Now it's all sold to the government.
A rooster crowed outside as little boys in the 15-member clan slid closer and listened to their elders.
"I feel sad not to export our rice anymore," Muhair said. "It was enough for your life."
Tharp is the executive editor of the Merced (Calif.) Star-Sun. McClatchy special correspondents Laith Hammoudi and Sahar Issa contributed to this article from Baghdad.



25 Comments so far
Show AllRate the war in Iraq (and possibly also in Afghanistan) along with our second prohibition (AKA the war on drugs) as dismal failures.
A hard rain's a gonna fall, Amerika... A HARD RAIN'S A GONNA FALL!!!
( I think that line was attributed to a Nichiren Dysholan a few years back or so. )
Arghangel, Bob Dylan 1962. Who is Nichiren Dysholan?
I think Manifest Destiny is going to boomerang on us. Will serve us right. Too bad most Americans won't have a clue why it's happening. We have only ourselves to blame but I'm sure most will find some scapegoat to blame for their misfortune.
I guess that's a problem with a young country. Lots of mistakes and immature behavior. I remember King Hussein of Jordan saying a big problem for America is that just when a President learns how to govern, his time in office is over and another inexperienced leader takes over (I'm paraphrasing him to an extent, but that was his point).
When the people fear their government there is tyranny,
when the government fears the people there is liberty.
~ Thomas Jefferson
Sorry my friend, it seems to me that King Hussein of Jordan has been playing his tricks on you. This quote seems to me just a lame excuse for the limits on accountability of executive power. Yes, I think that American democracy is dysfunctional and needs a lot of fixing, but it can do without advice from any of the world's last remaining absolute monarchies, (even from so-called 'benevolent' dictatorships) !
Nichiren Dysholan was a previous flower child incarnation of Robert Zimmerman several centuries ago during the Kamakura Period in Japan. He was often confused with the renegade Buddhist monk Nichiren Daishonin whose enlightening Lotus Sutra mantra, Nam Myoho Rainge Kyo caused quite a stir in the orthodox Buddhist World at the time. Dysholan was often forced to hide from the authority of the local Shogunites which subsequently inspired him to write many a poem and ballad considered quite anti-establishment for those times.
"remember King Hussein of Jordan saying a big problem for America is that just when a President learns how to govern, his time in office is over and another inexperienced leader takes over (I'm paraphrasing him to an extent, but that was his point)."
Yeah, because a hereditary monarchy is soooo much better.
>>Iraq now imports nearly all the food its people eat: California rice, Washington apples, Australian wheat, fruits and vegetables from its neighbors. All are staples in Iraqi groceries and on the dinner table.
Mission accomplished. Now which of these OTHER countries grow their own food and need a bit of gutting so as to support Mosantos business model?
Speaking of Monsanto, get informed people! Watch the following video. You too GwNorth. Here's a link to part 1 of a 10 part video called The World According to Monsanto:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c_OJcPKEYDE
We need to know this stuff! Watch it!
Nasty. How can this company still be in business?
If people want to know why health care costs run amok in the USA this another example.
Corporations should be banned. The Concept of Limited liability is criminal.
Well! DUH! How many other countries can we add to that Haiti, Mexico... Not to mention the Blowback in SARS, SWine Flu... & who knows what's coming down the pike.
After we kill millions, lets starve out the remaining citizens while we steal their resources...
It's the American way, starting with the Native Peoples...
Life was better under Saddam. Both in Iraq and here in America.
The launching of a geo-engineering project to increase rainfall in the headwaters of the Euphrates could go a long way to solving Iraq's agricultural problems.
It would involve building systems to enhance evaporation of water from a bay in the NE corner of the Mediterranean, together with employing methods to promote condensation over the watershed.
These technologies are known--it's not "rocket science" folks. There's nothing stopping this from happening, except possibly the question: "who benefits"?
Those who would like to continue to see Iraq as a "failed-state" and remain an easy target for outside manipulation, are obviously not going to suggest or support such a project.
Technology? All it takes to increase rainfall is a massive reforestation program. Forests create their own rainfall. THAT's what is needed more than anything, your highness (referring to your extraterrestrial origin).
Fine, moon-dog-type guy--if you've got 30 years to wait!
The reforestation plan can be carried out co-currently with the geoengineering project for long-term sustainability, but the geo-engineering project can produce results in a few years, helping people who are alive today.
We need all the help we can get. But we should not rely on technology. We need to restore the forests and learn to live with nature, not against it. Foliage cools, humidifies, sequesters and purifies the environment. We need to bring back the foliage. I'm not saying this to negate geo-engineering. Just saying.
Moondoggy, I too have great faith in a reforestation program. In fact, I would go so far as to say that mild forms of desertification can be reversed by a carefully planned reforestation program, starting from the boundaries of the desert. Yes, it would take time - but I have seen it yield great results in parts of India (many years ago). It's important to minimize or avoid grazing by sheep and cattle in these areas until the trees take root and can stand on their own.
Rome defeated Carthage, then sowed it with salt to ensure it never rose again.
Depleted uranium will ensure the eternal destruction of Iraq.
Yet again, another reason to promote permaculture. Permaculture is the healing of the nations. Someday, maybe not in our lifetimes, permaculture will be practiced in every state and province, in every watershed and eocsystem.
When the oil runs out and the coal is gone, with the last of the bombs we'll blow the dams to smithereens, restore the rivers natural flows and begin to live in harmony with nature... and prosper, living in peace and happiness.
In my dreams? Yes, in my dreams.
Detach from the matrix and live it now, brutha.
Yeah, well, I spent the whole day harvesting and putting food by. Started the day picking kale for the market, then picked and prepped strawberries, moved onto garlic harvesting and later picked carrots, lettuce, arugula, radishes and mustard, plus a few flowers and weeds for a wholesome salad. How am I doing so far?
A couple years post-Gulf I a visitor to Baghdad found the bridge across the Euphrades had been rebuilt, electricity was available most of the time and hospitals, while out of many vital medicines, still functioning. What's more the visitor could travel throughout the city, without having to go through roadblocks or encountering more than a few soldiers, although, admittedly on these trips, minders accompanied the visitor, so that the subjects that could be discussed with Iraqis was limited. Still, the visitor got a sense that so long as people didn't openly oppose the government, especially Saddam Hussein, that there was little chance that harm would come to them. With the U.N. sanctions that were in effect back then, getting enough food was a problem for the Iraqis, since the ration of food that was allocated to each person was below the minimum daily requirement, both in calories and protein, such that, Iraqis had to somehow find a way to make up the difference. Asked to compare Iraq today with what it was like shortly after the Gulf War ti conditions in Iraq today, this same visitor said "There was no doubt that back then things were plenty bad for the Iraqis, but nothing like what they're experiencing now, what with all the suicide bombs and such."
Feinstein's California is trying to corner the world almond, walnut and pistachio markets. Middle Easterners consume large quantities of these and have traditionally provided themselves with noble occupations growing various tree foods like these that's good for our health. The diverse range of varieties grown traditionally in the Middle East are particularly nutritious and the people of the world have long depended on this polyculture diversity to inhibit crop plagues and famines. Not surprisingly, California's diversity is zippo - one variety of each species dominates, and it's not selected for nutrition, rather for yield, shelf life, and aesthetics.
The arid climate tree is quite an efficient food producer. Natural selection in arid climates makes a tree tough. It needs less inputs. And trees as large perennials nurture the shallower rooted plants, and generally yield several times more per unit area than annuals, among many more advantages. The agriculture model practiced for thousands of years in the Middle East is therefore idea for a number of reasons, something that world governments should promote and protect. The UN surely recognizes this. Unfortunately the USA continues its mission to stomp out all sustainable practices/traditions worldwide stabilized over thousands of years. USan liberals think the Pentagon is bestowing human rights on the world. The imperial steamroller rolls on.
The Habeeb family has a 538 square foot lot. And they use a tractor! Hope for their sakes this is a misprint. A 20' by 27' lot would not grow enough to feed his family never mind exporting to a hungry world.
The original article in McClatchy Newspapers has the plot size as "12-acre foot" - which is an error as well. It's most likely a 12-acre plot - which seems typical for Asian countries (Iraq IS in Asia, btw) with moderate populations. In some countries, 12-acres would be considered a pretty decent size plot for a farming family. If it's just around 12-acres or less, many farmers rent tractors, rather than own them. That is what I try to point to American "farmers" who post here on CD - that their idea of farming, farm size, economics, and especially the history are all completely different from most parts of the world (that is, outside of North & South America, Australia and parts of Africa - where huge tracts of land were there just for the "taking" by settlers).
I remember reading a report about The secret behind the Iraq sanctions. How the U.S. intentionally destroyed Iraq's water supply, by Thomas J Nagy. I believe it was in the Progressive Sept 2001. For years Iraq was not allowed to import supplies needed to clean their water and hundreds of thousands of children died painful, slow ,deaths due to polluted water. The people who went to church today, told me that nuns were taking up a collection for people in Kenya . The biggest problem is no water. Americans rightly display sympathy for an African Republic that does not have enough water,but when water was delibertly polluted in our name in Iraq, no one in our local church would listen or show any outrage. Did they not believe us or not want to help Iraqis, oh, right, it was against the law to have compassion on Iraqi children, without a gov. permit. I have heard it said that,(if the wars for oil ever end ), the next wars will be fought over water.