Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Prop. 8 Opponents Take their Case to Fresno
SELMA, Fresno County - On a dusty patch of ground near Super Dave's Car Wash here in California's raisin capital, the next phase of the same-sex marriage movement began Saturday with a morning march - led by a Fresno lesbian mother carrying Harvey Milk's old bullhorn.
Chris Lynn of Reedley (Fresno County) marches in Selma for marriage equality. (Lance Iversen / The Chronicle) "You have got to reach into those communities that struggle to understand us," organizer Robin McGehee exhorted the people gathered there shortly before 8 a.m. for the 14 1/2-mile march to Fresno City Hall for an event called Meet in the Middle for Equality.
Those who marched say any road to a possible November 2010 ballot referendum legalizing same-sex marriage must go through California's conservative Bible Belt. They kicked off the drive with 3,000 people attending Saturday's march in the belt's geographic center, aiming to sway those who supported Proposition 8 by sharing personal stories, one on one, with friends and neighbors, just as Milk would have advised.
It will be challenging. Folks like Lew Ceja will be hard to sway.
Sitting a few blocks away from City Hall at a motorcycle club-sponsored street party, listening to a band play a Lynyrd Skynyrd song, the 66-year-old who lives in Hanford (Kings County) was asked what it would take for him to vote to legalize same-sex marriage.
He thrust forward the cross hanging around his neck. Nothing could.
"It's God's law," said Ceja, a retired law enforcement officer, who wore his motorcycle club's leather vest despite the 92-degree heat. He's the chaplain for his club, which co-sponsored RevFest in downtown Fresno; in the valley, even the motorcycle clubs are religious. He said he didn't have anything against gays. Didn't mind them marching through town. But he couldn't vote to legalize same-sex marriage.
Neither could Dick Echaniz. "Hey, my daughter's gay," the 50-year-old Fowler (Fresno County) resident said, as he admired a motorcycle for sale. If she were to get married, he'd attend. And he'd always love her. That's why he was unsure about how to vote for Prop. 8 until he got into the voting booth. Ultimately, he said, "I got to back my church, man. I couldn't vote against my pastor."
Could any campaign work here?
"You're campaigning against the Bible," said his nephew T.J. Echaniz. "And you're not going to win that battle here."
Same-sex-marriage supporters weren't harassed or bothered Saturday along their route, and there weren't counter-demonstrations of any size. The stray drag queens who milled about the crowd Saturday were anomalies; most of the crowd was dressed for the weather, sporting nothing louder than the homemade T-shirt worn by 24-year-old Kate Perry: "Central Valley Grown Queer." Even a bit of Hollywood showed up. Straight "Will & Grace" star Eric McCormack spoke briefly and Oscar winner Charlize Theron put in an appearance.
Supporters of Prop. 8 plan a response to the rally with their own gathering here tonight. Standing in the Middle for Marriage will celebrate last week's California Supreme Court decision to uphold the voter-approved initiative.
The effort at claiming the "middle" is all about seizing the minds of the undecided voters in the Central Valley. People like Layne Soares hope to help.
Soares served in the Army for three years until she was honorably discharged in the mid-1990s. She walked the march in her uniform, looking like she stepped out of a recruitment poster. Though the 35-year-old has been out to friends and family for years, she told some of her co-workers just a few days ago - before she spoke at the rally, the first time she's spoken publicly about that part of her life. In the valley, telling people you're gay is not something you do until you have to.
"I'm a firm believer in people getting to know me as a person first before I talk about that," she said. "There is more to me than that.
"There's this mind-set here that gay people are just weird," she said. "That's what we have to work to change here."
That reticence to go public is why many said Saturday that they were marching for a gay friend or family member who was reluctant to go public. Surrounded by like-minded souls - and escorted by law enforcement vehicles - Chris Lynn felt comfortable enough to wrap himself in a rainbow flag Saturday on the march. But he would never hold hands with his boyfriend after he got out of the car to go see a movie in some parts of Fresno.
"Oh, no," said Lynn, a 21-year-old Reedley College student. "You never know what might happen to your car while you were gone."
Still, Cleve Jones, a Milk associate, said, "Harvey would have loved this because he said the single most important thing you can do is come out." Jones brought the bullhorn Milk used to rally supporters during the Coors beer boycott.
This is Jones' fourth visit to Fresno in recent months, as he and many other longtime activists believe that the Central Valley is "the front lines" of this fight.
"Not the Castro or West Hollywood," he said. "To put a 'No on 8' sign in your window in San Francisco isn't a big deal. In Fresno, it is."

11 Comments so far
Show AllPoor Dick Echaniz, like Abraham of old, piously decides to back his God and sacrifice his child.
I'm not mocking him; it's part of the tragedy that ostensibly "Christian" traditions drive a wedge between parent and child, and promulgate bigotry in the name of the Creator of the Universe.
It's written somewhere that the greatest of virtues is charity; it's a shame that churches are so often the greatest obstacle and hindrance to the practice of true charity.
Best of luck to those working to rescue civil rights in California from the tyranny of the majority!
· Yr Obd't Servant
The trouble with this logic is WHO, exactly, gets to determine what is "tyranny" and what is common sense. The right to life crowd believes, passionately, that life begins at conception. Therefore, ANY form of legalized abortion is killing a human being and perforce must be banned. Would you like 5 right to lifers on the US Supreme Court, who's first order of business would be to overturn California's liberal abortion laws, laws which are supported by a majority of Californians? The NRA crowd believes, passionately, that their right to keep and bear arms is enshrined in the Constitution. Would you like 5 NRA members on the Court to overturn California's strict (and stupid, albeit democratic) gun control laws, laws which are supported by the majority of Californians. Muslims and Mormons probably feel that they are oppressed because they can only marry ONE wife. Want plural marriage by judicial fiat?
All of the above groups feel as passionately about "tyranny of the majority" as you do. The question is, WHO gets to decide what is "tyranny" and what is not?
And if the majority decides that it is legal to discriminate against African Americans, I have no doubt that you would believe that that is fine too.
You have no idea how brave these folks were to march in Fresno.
Brave? Not really. They were in far less danger than pro-Prop 8 folks would have been marching in San Francisco.
???? I doubt it. Fresno is socially conservative and many citizens are sure that homosexuality is a perversion of choice -- and will say so. Loudly. It's spittin' distance from Happy Valley, where a friend and his partner were murdered by religious fanatics. Activists are right, though, that these are the areas they need to reach to tip the balance in their favor.
Right. Because homophobic bigots have been beaten to death before.
The attempt by homophobic bigots to portray themselves as discriminated against is pathetic, when it is they who are committing the violence. Your ignoring of the violence, the killings committed by homophobic bigots renders your argument bankrupt.
Nice to see Commondreams pick up a story on the Saturday march in Fresno.
The Fresno Bee's AP report by Garance Burke is worth reading too, which I think is a little more informative on the subject of Fresno.
http://www.fresnobee.com/641/story/1437410.html
I'm hopeful this march to Fresno may change the mind of outsiders in both worlds. There is a gay community in Fresno, but if it is overshadowed by local impressions of outsiders moving in on territory, you'll find an uphill battle.
Best to make the focus less overtly on a "2010" win, and more on creating a community connection. State level activist can give money and supplies, but the people working in the streets must be indigenous to the region. Otherwise you could create a stalemate that exceeds 2010.
Moving to Fresno is also an option. The downtown needs to be revitalized and every mayor back 12 years has "promised" to do so. Most of the money makers have moved to Clovis. Imagine a gay-oriented downtown development center bringing in talent to invest in Fresno. Talk about breaking down barriers.
Remember, "Freepers" founded in Fresno. I have long thought Fresno as the battleground for the West in general, not just on Prop 8. Western Regional Conservatism is approachable in Fresno, if you're willing to invest. Fresno is on the cusp of restructuring itself for the 21century and has potential... water rights, gay rights, agriculture base replaced by white/grey collar...
but, there's a much larger and complex history- generational- and to approach these subjects may be a lot more than movers and shakers for 2010 vote are interested in. Fresno County went for Obama in 2008.
There's room for development in Fresno, but think 2012-2014-2016. Bakersfield and Kern County different story, maybe 15 years or longer.
Is that photo of Obama... or his double?
I guess my eyes are gettin bad,
It is sad about the guy who was in favour of gay marriage but could not vote against his pastor - I don't really understand it. After you get gay marriage, there are other things you will have to worry about:
Pro-Israel lobbyists threaten funding for Toronto's gay pride
In Tuesday's edition of the Jewish Tribune, the political newspaper of B'nai Brith, pro-Israel lobbyists declared their intention to threaten government and corporate sponsorship of the annual Toronto Pride Festival unless the organisation banned pro-Palestinian marchers from the parade.
http://rabble.ca/blogs/bloggers/andrew-brett/2009/05/pro-israel-lobbyists-threaten-funding-torontos-gay-pride
Maybe they ought to move the gay pride parade from Toronto to Palestine, as a form of protest...