Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
BigAg Ticked at Michelle Obama's Organic Garden
Michelle Obama's decision to make her new White House vegetable garden entirely organic has angered America's powerful agribusiness lobby who are urging the First Lady to consider the use of appropriate "crop protection products".
Mrs Obama started work on the kitchen garden with a gang of schoolchildren last month. Media coverage of the first White House food plot since Eleanor Roosevelt "dug for victory" in the Second World War garnered media coverage across the world.
A small patch of arugula is part of the plantings by US first lady Michelle Obama and students in the White House Kitchen Garden on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington, April 9, 2009. (REUTERS/Jonathan Ernst) But to the consernation of Big Ag, Mrs Obama has said the project will not use chemical products to tackle pests or give her plants a boost, the Times reports.
Shortly after the digging began, Mrs Obama received a letter from the Mid-America CropLife Association (MACA), which represents the companies producing the pesticides and fertilisers underpinning "conventional" American agriculture, the paper said.
Addressed to "Mrs Barack Obama", the letter congratulated the First Lady on "recognising the importance of agriculture in America". Farming is America's largest industry, generating 20 per cent of GDP and directly or indirectly employing 22 million people.
The letter avoiding the term "organic", highlights the role of technological advances - technologies that can see a single acre produce almost 20 tonnes of strawberries of 110,000 heads of lettuce in a season - in modern agriculture.
"Today, an average farmer produces enough food to feed 144 Americans who are living longer lives than many of their ancestors. Technology in agriculture has allowed for the development of much of what we know and use in our lives today," MACA wrote.
"If Americans were still required to farm to support their family's basic food and fibre needs, would the US have been leaders in the advancement of science, communication, education, medicine, transportation and the arts?
"We live in a very different world than that of our grandparents. Americans are juggling jobs with the needs of children and ageing parents. The time needed to tend a garden is not there for the majority of our citizens, certainly not a garden of sufficient productivity to supply much of a family's year-round food needs."
The carefully-worded letter also "respectfully" encourages Mrs Obama to recognise the role played by conventional agriculture in feeding America's growing population.
- Posted in
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

86 Comments so far
Show AllImagine the AMA's response if she also planted some medical marijuana.
Hell Yeah...Monsanto is the enemy of all people and they need to be treated as such. We need to wipe them out completely before they kill us all.
Maybe we should gift her with some seeds?
If one is interested in the flavor of food one should try organic.
As an experiment, take any produce or meat from a conventional grocery store, cook it. Don't eat it yet. Then take the same product from the organic department, cook it, too. Place both side by side and try the conventional product first, then the organic.
One will find the organic product far superior in taste, and quality.
The nutrition is higher too.
Food satisfaction will see you eating less, enjoying more, and loosing those added winter pounds.
I usually buy organic fruit, I think it is tastier, juicier, and it usually doesn't have wax on it. I don't buy organic meat though, it is just far too expensive for me. I don't eat all that much meat at home though, I;'m usually so tired come dinner time that I make pasta or mac n cheese instead. Oh, and all the pasta I have right now is organic and whole grain too. It was on sale for very cheap ($1 for a lb. bag or box of pasta), I just couldn't pass it up so I stocked up on it.
I think it's pretty amazing that chimpanzees can tell the difference between traditional and organic bananas:
http://www.abc.net.au/news/scitech/2003/01/item20030129100804_1.htm
Maybe they can read the stickers.;)
Would'nt a 'traditional' banana be organic?
Mrs. Obama,
As a botanist, organic gardener, and student of the techniques of permaculture, I applaud your efforts. But upon seeing the photo in this article, I'd like to suggest something: mulch! It keeps mud and soil microbes from splashing up on leaf crops, protects your investment in the soil by conserving water, and helps prevent weeds from taking over.
That being said, best of luck to you in preventing corporate microbes and their own silty kind of muck from undercutting your efforts, befouling your symbolic effort to invest in America's soil, and hijacking the whole issue like weeds--the way they did to organic standards via the USDA.
-Dirt Monkey
------------------------------------------------
If you don't ask yourself why, you know nothing.
Oh, for Pete's Sake!!! Can't one single thing be done without interference from some megacorporation? Thank you, Mrs. Obama for standing up is something you believe in. The one important factor that these mega agribusiness' do not mention in their 'carefully worded' directives is the fact that they, nor their products in any way nuture the soil. Their way of feeding the multitudes relys on methods that depletes the soil of nutrients resulting in food that is less nutritious and in many cases even toxic. None of these companies address the issue of sustainability and how many more years will they be able to produce in dead soil. Organic farmers not only produce more nutritious and tasty food but they are dedicated to a vow of stewardship in preserving the land for future generations.
All these companies care about is money. They don't care about their products. Don't care if it poisons people or makes them undernourished. Just plain evil.
I hope the Obamas actually see this site from time to time. It is clear that Michelle is a very, very intelligent and savvy woman. Finally we have a team in the White House who will be responsible in all of their lives. The problems with pesticides and fertilizers and GM foods have become well known in this country, as they have in the rest of the developed world. It is wonderful to see someone of such public status planting organically. I trust she will ignore the blitherings of these agri business profit mongers. I am sure she is strong enough to smile sweetly and tell them to piss off in really nice terms. They will only be satisfied with complete surrender, and that she will never give them. All intelligent Americans love having her as our First Lady. Hmmmm. I think First Woman might be a more appropriate label ....
That arugula needs a foliar spray of liquid seaweed to deal with the phospherous defficiency that is evident in the purple tint in the leaves, as well as mulch.
"BigAg Ticked at Michelle Obama's Organic Garden"
Good!
The agri-monsters are most likely especially concerned about the high-profile organic garden at the White House because they are trying to push legislation through Congress which is scaring the BeeJeezuz out of organic gardeners and small organic farmers alike. The bills they sponsor (!!! YES, they are responsible for these sinsiter bills seeing light of day !!!) could even end up making it so the home gardener has to follow impossible restrictions, and even risk invasions by USDA on their porperty to ensure they complying with the new rules they will initiate as the bills insist tracking of produce from everyone, ostensibly under the guise of food safety- even though it is the large-scale agri-monsters whom have the worst food safety records!
Once you know about this, you will surely freak out. I hope Michelle Obama stands up against them on these important issues as well (we'll see). It's a BIG deal, HR 875; HR814- and others , check it out (and raise HELL afterwards), because when they can thoroughly control such sacred survival tools, we are doomed:(
http://www.commondreams.org/headline/2009/03/27-0
http://www.commondreams.org/newswire/2009/03/27-0
http://www.opencongress.org/bill/111-h814/show
PS: Plant Something Soon
Though seaweed spray can increase nutrient absorption and supplies potassium, micronutrients and useful enzymes, it is not a significant phosphorus source. Fishbone meal or crushed phosphate rock are good organic sources of phosphate.
As to mulch, here in western Oregon, anyway, it's good to wait till summer before application, as slugs love to hide in the stuff during the day and then come out at night to munch.
I am reminded of story from a high school friend of mine, forty years ago. He was asked if he wanted an apple, and when he said yes, the offerer sprayed the apple with a can of Raid and handed it to him. When he asked why she had done that, she replied, that is what you are normally eating.
It made a lasting impression. We just don't normally see the can of Raid.
Maybe we should start doing that in public.
This just in:
"Monsanto Sues First Lady for Restraint of Trade and Product Disparagement; Seeks Damages of $12 Trillion, Public Apology and a Big Wet Kiss"
Ah yes, listen to the complaints from BigAgribus.
I recommend you rent the movie, "King Corn" for the main course. Then for desert, watch "This American Life, Season One - "This Little Piggy Made Me Vomit".
Yes, ADM, Monsanto... "Better living through chemistry", the companies that care for you.
Some members of MACA:
Aceto Agricultural Chemicals Corp
AMVAC Chemical Corp
Cheminova
Chemtura
...get the picture?
add all the big players
DOw
Dupont
Monsanto
Bayer
BASF
"Dear Mrs Barack Obama" --reflective of a mindset that is firmly entrenched in the 1950s.
go michelle !
i think its totally perverse that they should harrass someone for doing the right thing in our times of environmental awareness.
Its a fractal example of how the lobbyists push around the politicains.
good luck!
Michelle should sell the White House produce at the Capitol, with well-designed educational flyers explaining the difference between "good" produce and "bad" produce.
Proceeds from the Capitol Sale would go towards an organic gardening movement in Washington DC.
Unless I'm not aware of that particular type of arugula, the plant pictured looks an awful lot like lettuce. Maybe it's an east coast variety of arugula...
You are right, it looks more like the purple-fringed variety of romaine lettuce. The sign is for the adjoining, still empty garden bed. Like most USAns, the journalist and photographer don't know their veggies.
Anything you Western USAn's have, we had first; Arugula came from Italy. I must admit, I never heard of it until I moved out of the south to a Pittsburgh Italian neighborhood. I thought it was a kind of dandelion green the first few times I saw it in a salad.
First from Italy? Like, perhaps, tomatoes, potatoes, peppers, squash, beans,corn [maize]? All from Native America. She will feed her kids properly, despite agri mongers disputatiousness. Good for her.
The culture that supports and promotes "conventional agriculture" establishes dominion over all others by promoting dependency on what is more often soil damaging and oil consuming products.
Complete self sufficiency should be the goal of all Agro policies.
Seed Banks
Organic solutions
Local ownership
Local distribution first
Politically speaking, Arugula is a rich-liberal-yuppie veggie - associated with expensive restaurants. They probably have Raddichio and Swiss Chard in there too. Outside of eastern US urban areas with lots of Italians, few American have heard of it. Our Republican neighbors here in Pittsburgh couldn't even recognize the kale in our garden - but that might be more of a north of the mason-dixon-line-white thing.
Where's the nutritious (if you keep the ham-hock out), soul-food veggies - collards, kale, mustard greens; etc? They are better suited for the sultry DC climate, as well as the culture of 70% of DC's residents. They would also help Obama politically. He already safely has the white yuppie demographic, but blacks are increasingly wondering about him...
Personally I prefer baby salad greens to cooked greens, maybe he does too.
Greens is greens. They are all nutritious, so you can pick what you like. I think this garden is great.
Obama was raised in Hawaii, Michelle in Chicago. I am a northern white who got a love for kale, collards and even dandelion greens from my Appalachian mother. I do not think the vegetables you mention are yuppie food - heck, chard is just beet tops and arugula was grown by Italians I knew in the Bronx. It amuses me that polenta is now a fashionable food - we called it corn meal mush and considered it a food of low desirability.
I don't think the Obamas should grow collards as a political gesture to the soul-food demographic. Public transportation, affordable quality education, jobs and decent housing are more appropriate. We will have made progress when people like the Obamas decide that the public schools are good enough for their children.
Joe
I agree with all you points.
My remarks were a tongue-in-cheek comment on US political culture, not really serious. Even slightly dry homor doesn't work on internet fora very well for some reason.
You are correct - it is funny how the much of the fashionable yuppie foods on the PBS cooking shows are actually foods of the Italian poor. I discovered Arugua and dandelion greens when I moved to a distinctly um-yuppie working-class Italian neighborhood in Pittsburgh. Many of them even have grape arbors in their tiny back yard and alleyway spaces and make their own wine, although the often-poorer next generaton is not continuing this tradition.
I hope I don't have a humor deficit :(
I also grew up around poor Italians and was enchanted with the grape vines, tomato plants, greens, sometimes eggplants and zucchinis they managed to fit in their tiny yards. Also trellis roses and lilacs. I have even written a short story about it. I know people are busy, but if you have a plot of land at all, how sweet is it to tend the garden on summer evenings in the warm fading light.
Perhaps the interest in arugula and such and the White House garden will help this make a comeback and take hold in more places. The velvet lawn estate look that we favor in the suburbs is high maintenance, low utility and usually low in visual interest. For heaven sakes, at least a blackberry hedge so kids can pick the warm berries in August.
Joe
Hang in there folks. In fact, start fighting back if you haven't done so already. I'm not giving up the fight against Monsanto out here in St Louis and I even wrote a strong letter to the mayor about this. I will be writing to my other local and state legislators as well. If you have a big agri company located where you live, I strongly advise doing the same and get your friends, family, neighbors, etc ... to join you in voicing your opposition to their 50 years of agri-tyranny. I used to feel sad when I left rural MO to move to St Louis but now that I am finding out that over half my neighborhood came in from rural IL and MO and are just as sick and tired of the agri-tyranny, I haven't hesitated talking to some of these people and surprisingly, even the most conservative folks have teamed up in writing letters of serious concern to our local officials. As Moondoggy and SiouxRose have helped me to realize, we can still fight to restore Mother Earth's beauty and be proud of it.
"We live in a very different world than that of our grandparents. Americans are juggling jobs with the needs of children and ageing parents. The time needed to tend a garden is not there for the majority of our citizens, certainly not a garden of sufficient productivity to supply much of a family's year-round food needs."
By trying to do the opposite, the Big Aggies point the way forward...quit the jobs, return to the world of our grandparents, and devote the time we are given to be alive to raising our own food...socializing housing is the key...that frees people from needing income, so they can get back to supporting their own needs...
We can all start planting now, then abandon the modern technologies that are killing, literally, everything, and jump to the new gardening life together on Sept. 22, 2012...that's 2-3 seasons of preparation...
Organic TRUTH is tastier, too
If they so much like like their periodic doses of neurotoxic poisons -- why doesn't big 'ol AG &
Mid-America CropLife Association (MACA), just go out and BUY their own
country,
President,
First Lady, and
White House garden ?
l thought they did, that is why big Ag can sell cheap corn to Mexico and their farmers come up here to keep our lawns cut .
It's called the "FTA" !
Millions against Monsanto - drop them a line....
Courtesy of the Organic Consumers Organization
http://www.organicconsumers.org/monlink.cfm
go michelle. I think its totally perverse that someone should be harrassed for doing the right thing in todays awareness of the environment.
Its a perfect fractal example of how the lobbyists push around the politicians.
good luck.
LeeAnnG
I'm not sure what you mean by a "fractal" example. A fractal is a geometric pattern that is repeated at ever smaller scales to produce irregular shapes and surfaces that cannot be represented by classical geometry. Fractals are used especially in computer modeling of irregular patterns and structures in nature. (For example, they are used to measure coastlines.)
However, you are right that this is a good example of how large corporations try to bully the government at every level.
Usually the smallest section of many fractals typifies the characteristics of the whole. Maybe that is what he or she means.
Joe
I like the "an average farmer produces enough food to feed 144 Americans". I guess they think that employees of big corporation farms are like family farmers.
Genetically modified plants strong enough to stand ever increasing doses of pesticide and herbicide, cloned fish, poisoned ground water, ever increasing incidence of autism and cancer. Yes, we really don't grow things like our grandparents did. Much to our own demise.
Ask the farmer who tried to grow organic, and because the Monsanto chemical his neighbors kept spraying leeched into the water supply, his plants took on the traits of the Monsanto treated plants. What did Monsanto do? They sued this real "family" farmer for producing crops with their chemicals WITHOUT PAYING THEM.
From legalized drug pushers, to chemical pushers, to fossil fuel pushers, to "for profit" health care insurers, to the military industrial complex, this country, and the conservative greed hounds that spout their lies on Fox News are headed down a one way street. And all the money in the bank accounts of these criminals won't save us...or them.
All they ensure is that they will be the last to die...of starvation, of pestilence, of cancer and of diseases yet to be uncovered. And in doing so, they can watch their children die with us all.
There is a trinity we all must follow or we face collapse and extinction as a species.
1. Personal responsibility
2. Responsibility to others (the Golden Rule)
3. Responsibility to our mother earth, who supports all life on this planet
As was quoted in a recent major motion picture... "If the earth dies, people die. If people die, the earth lives."
Something for you who don't have a clue. A former Ct congressman, by the name of
Toby Mofett who is now an officer in the Poison Place called Monsanto was doing
all he could to destroy Ralph Nader.Mofett was a lefty in the Carter administration. Moffett's idea to cure the gas problem during the Carter administration was to raise the gas tax, 50cents a gal. Nader was right, we have been taken over by Corporate America.
I've gotten heirloom seeds and turned my house into a nursery - just with the time I could be watching TV. There's always time for a garden. Since there's no sun except in the front yard, this is a front yard garden. It's a challenge to keep it pretty, but that even makes it more fun - and there's a zinnia to brighten the table. Also the folks who walk by cheer the effort. I cheer Michelle!
Mulch with grass clippings (since of course you don't use chemicals on your lawn) and seaweed if you live close to any and oak flowers which right now are fallen in abundance. Compost everything.
Do consider a few non-heirloom seeds. A lot of breeders have worked hard to improve the old varieties and some of the improvements are definitely worthwhile. For instance, consider the beauthy of Bright Lights swiss chard in your front yard. Also, I'm no expert, but I believe some of the modern varieties of snow peas are real improvements. Good luck.
Except for the fact that I know I would have to eat again right away, I would have puked when I read that article. Everyone with a brain knows that She would never again appear in the garden unless it was for a photo op. When she was on The View shortly before the election she was telling such a preposterous, obviously fabricated anecdote that even that seriously misguided right winger (the cute blonde one) and Barbara were rolling their eyes along with the rest of the cast. And she kept stringing it out way beyond decorum. Contrasted with the article on Haiti's lack of food, it is worth ruminating on that the U.S. turns food into fuel for vehicles, and there is hardly a more obscene action than that when you know that people are starving somewhere.
Obama's wife is as phony as he is and I expect we're going to be inundated with similar nonsensical prattle as the government's PR people have a whole, fresh new world of B.S. open to them.
LeeAnnG
Moron
Yeah, right. Meanwhile, the U.s. has an unstated policy to force the farmers off the land so that agribusiness can take over and remove that bastion of freedom from the hands of farmers and have it under the control the "elite" class. What do you think Willie Nelson and John Mellencamp have those farm aid concerts for? Did anyone hear of a bailout for farmers? Or of a redistribution of farmland to get many more farmers, which is the only way to get better quality? That is, to get back to quality.
And doesn't anyone think the U.s. can afford PR people who know by now how to make a picture to tell the story they want people to waste their time talking about? Think about Dustin Hoffman and "Old Shoe".
Every time I go to the store and see the prices for sickly veggies, I return home and plant more seeds. The same amount of time wasted going to the store could have be used to plant an entire row of fresh organic greens.
Strawberries must be planted in virgin soil with no history of strawberries. The only way around that was to use soil bromide which sterilized the soil and provided huge crops. That chemical is now banned. Bromine is a member of the notorious halide group of chemicals from which most poisons are manufactured. Experiments have shown that crops planted in fumigated soil incorporated the bromide into the crops we were eating. So much for bigag.
Carniverous birds, especially black phoebes, with their incredibly sharp vision keep my garden almost free of plant pests. Pesticides kill the birds and bees.
When will the white house turn its grey water into Michele's garden?
I'm glad I don't like strawberries then.