EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
- Burning Tulsa: The Legacy of Black Dispossession
- Think Fracking Is Bad? Wait Until You Hear about the Gas Industry's "Acid Jobs"
- We’re Being Watched: How Corporations and Law Enforcement Are Spying on Environmentalists
- German Official Warns of Immediate 'Revolution' if EU Adopts US Model
- President Obama Uses a Sledgehammer Against Dissent
Popular content
Today's Top News
Holder: Closing Guantanamo Is 'Most Daunting Challenge'
America's top attorney, Eric Holder, on Wednesday night described his assignment to empty the prison camps at Guantánamo "indisputably the most daunting challenge I face as attorney general.''
President Barack Obama put Holder in charge of a Cabinet-level task force assigned to transfer each of the 240 or so war on terror captives from the camps in southeast Cuba, which the Bush administration opened in Jan. 11, 2002.
The president also set a Jan. 22 deadline to put the detention center out of business.
''This task will not be easy,'' Holder said in dissecting the assignment in embargoed remarks released by the Justice Department ahead of the speech Wednesday night at West Point's Center for the Rule of Law.
"On the contrary, it is indisputably the most daunting challenge I face as Attorney General.''
He said the challenge was to sort among the captives and divide them between three categories:
• Those who "we will likely conclude no longer pose a threat to the United States and can be released or transferred to the custody of other countries. ''
• Those the U.S. will choose to prosecute in federal court.
• The detainees who are ''too dangerous to release'' yet have ''insurmountable obstacles'' to prosecuting them in federal court.
At issue may be detainees from whom confessions were gleaned through brutal interrogations. Holder has already labeled as torture one CIA interrogation technique, waterboarding.
The CIA has confirmed that agents did this to three detainees now at Guantánamo, among the 16 former agency-held captives brought there in September 2006 from secret overseas jails. Obama has since ordered those so-called black sites closed.
Unclear is how the United States could continue to hold detainees whom it continues unable to prosecute.
Holder said "some of the brightest minds in our nation are working to answer that question and to address the ramifications that each potential answer presents.''
"I pledge that the ultimate solution will be one that is grounded in our Constitution, based on congressional enactments, in compliance with international laws of war, and consistent with the rule of law. ''
- Posted in
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

10 Comments so far
Show All"The detainees who are ''too dangerous to release'' yet have ''insurmountable obstacles'' to prosecuting them in federal court"
These insurmountable obstacles.....would this have something to do with lack of admissible evidence to convict under the standards of American justice in a civilian court of law?
"At issue may be detainees from whom confessions were gleaned through brutal interrogations."
Now this could be a problem with regard to obtaining convictions under American legal standards. What do we do with murderers, drug dealers, rapists, child molesters, corporate con artists, etc. when we lack the evidence to convict? They walk.. (I need Bill from Saginaw to help me out with this one)
Exactly. That is the only outcome from following the rule of law. A nation of laws, not men...hopefully again soon.
Save us the bullshit about "rules of law" and "anything" about upholding the Constitution Mr. Attorney General. You say that waterboarding is torture--well then, our government authorized torture, then had its lackeys carry out the order. Like your superior in the White House who's great at "talking" about justice, how about "showing" the world some.
Those goofs who run the U.S. government make lots of prisoner transfers every day. All they have to do is load all the prisoners in Guantanamo into a boat and they could have them in the 'Dome in New Orleans this afternoon.
If those morons would ever do what's right then they could also have all of their military out of Cuba in three month, and they better take all of their mines and booby-traps with them. And make sure they flush the toilet before they take that last look around.
Holder is either severely misinformed or one of the bad guys, on this issue. I still think his initial post-Obama swearing-in appearance before Congress was very impressive. I prefer to think he is misinformed and will wake up in time, he seems like a good man(did he also keep the bush minions to give him advice?).
The facts are that the 9/11 event was entirely orchestrated to give power to the Bush cabal to steal from our treasury and shred our Constitution. The techniques used in Guantanamo were specifically designed to solicit false confessions which would then be used as part of the massive effort to cover up the 9/11 orchestration. Just like Hitler's burning of the Reichstag 9/11 was such a big horrendous event so many would find it preferable to fall for the lie of the Bush administration regardless of how implausible it was from a scientific standpoint : "the terrorists did it", whereas Hitler blamed "the Communists." Hitler burned down the Reichstag and Bush and his cohorts orchestrated the timed explosives that actually brought down the towers.
We must change the rules radically to save our country
We can make vastly more money by doing good for our country, at the end of the day. Building new alternative clean and natural energy sources and getting off of oil will, in itself, supercharge our economy. We don't make money we lose money by wasting it on the defense crooks(believe me I am in favor of a strong defense and well compensated military personnel but that is not what happens we get crap and the men and women serving us get the shaft.) We need to change the rules of the USA: you do good for our country, the environment and the general welfare of our fellow brothers and sisters and you can make a good living but today the rules are if you work to destroy the environment and the interests of the USA you can make a fortune. That is how sick things have become.
We need Obama and his administration to be brave and radical to break us free of all of this and we can only do it together. So far there has been too much essential betrayal of what I worked for to get Obama into office for me to do anything but sit in dismay.
They have no intention of closing it.
Never did have.
Nor will they complete any other promise made to get elected by a bunch of suckers.
Gitmo the Hole will be filled in. But it will take HOW long? All the prisoners should be transferred Instantly, Yesterday, to a MILITARY HOSPITAL on the mainlaind where their injuries are treated. The captives should remain in this 1/2way humane facility and be accorded all amenities and access until Quick adjudication of their cases. Generous Reparations paid to the innocent and All tortured.
While Nothing could atone the horrors the US inflicted, this would alleviate some pain now, empty out the House of Horrors, and be important to the world. What would be the downside?
For all of the fuss about the 270 prisoners left at Girmo, does anybody
know what basis they used to free 500 quietly when there were 770 back in the fall? If they were all innocent, why did they have to stay for six years, and if they were guilty why were they freed?
Oh, don't you watch Fox? According to them, 61 of the released are now terrorists...the Bush administration freed terrorists who are now attacking America!
Except the DoD can only confirm one person of the hundreds released from Gitmo has gone back to terrorism. Pretty small statistic if you ask me.
The problem with not following due process of law is that they had no fucking clue who was locked up, or why, for most of them. How can anyone figure out what to do with them in those circumstances?
"The detainees who are ''too dangerous to release'' yet have ''insurmountable obstacles'' to prosecuting them in federal court."
I thought that the people who were in the previous administration were not yet locked up ?