Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Ex-Blackwater Workers May Return to Iraq Jobs
BAGHDAD - Late last month Blackwater Worldwide lost its billion-dollar contract to protect American diplomats here, but by next month many if not most of its private security guards will be back on the job in Iraq.
Private security guards working for Blackwater Worldwide participated in a firefight in the Iraqi city of Najaf in 2004. (Gervasio Sanchez/Associated Press) The same individuals will just be wearing new uniforms, working for Triple Canopy, the firm that won the State Department's contract after Iraqi officials refused to renew Blackwater's operating license, according to American diplomats, private security industry officials and Iraqi officials. Blackwater - viewed in Iraq as a symbol of American violence and impunity - lost the contract after being accused of excessive force in several instances, particularly an apparently unprovoked shooting in downtown Baghdad in 2007 in which 17 civilians were killed.
Despite the torrent of public criticism against Blackwater, American officials say they are relieved that the old guards will stay on. Otherwise, Triple Canopy, they say, would not be able to field enough qualified guards, with the proper security clearances, before the new contract goes into effect in May.
"There is just no other way to do it," said one Western diplomat, speaking on the condition of anonymity because he is not permitted to discuss the issue publicly.
Critics of Blackwater said they worried that the same people might perpetuate what they believed was a corporate culture that disregarded Iraqis' lives.
"They're really all still there, and it's back to business as usual," said Susan Burke, an American lawyer who has filed three civil rights lawsuits against Blackwater on behalf of Iraqi civilians alleged to be victims of it.
An unresolved question is whether Blackwater, recently renamed Xe (pronounced zee), or any affiliated company will profit from the deal. Speculation inside the industry and the Iraqi government has focused on whether Triple Canopy might hire as a subcontractor a company called the Falcon Group, identified in a lawsuit brought by Ms. Burke as a Blackwater affiliate.
A Blackwater spokeswoman, Anne Tyrell, said that Blackwater had no relationship with Falcon Group, whose Web site describes it as an Iraqi-owned company with interests in security and reconstruction. "The people who provide security services abroad are independent contractors," Ms. Tyrell said. "When their 60- to 90-day contracts with us expire, they can seek employment with whomever they choose."
A Triple Canopy spokesman, Jayanti Menches, declined to respond to the subcontractor issue. "We will staff this contract with qualified, vetted and trained personnel," Ms. Menches said.
The Western diplomat said that even if most of the bodyguards remained Blackwater veterans, there would be dramatic changes in their rules of engagement. One former Marine Corps colonel who worked closely with Blackwater summed up the previous rules: "No compassion for the locals who had to use the roads with the Blackwater vehicles or convoys, shoot if in doubt and keep driving, etc."
The new rules of engagement, the diplomat said, would require staff members to behave less aggressively. They had already started to take effect, he added, with Blackwater escorts ordered to negotiate traffic courteously.
After Iraq refused to renew Blackwater's contract, the State Department awarded it to Triple Canopy, one of two other firms, including DynCorp, already doing some State Department security contracting in Iraq. The five-year State Department contract, awarded March 31, is worth $977 million and goes into effect May 7. That amount represents a large proportion of Blackwater's previous worldwide business.
American officials said replacing Blackwater from scratch in just over a month would be difficult. The firm maintains a force of 600 armed men based in Baghdad's Green Zone to protect embassy and other United States government civilian employees. Their work requires security clearances when they accompany diplomats on sensitive missions, involving lengthy background checks. It is particularly difficult for non-Americans to get such clearances.
Blackwater also maintains a quick reaction force, and has a civilian air wing with helicopters, surveillance drones and other aircraft. The contract for their air operations remains in force, expiring in September.
Although Triple Canopy is an American company, most of its Iraq-based employees are former members of the military from countries with low wage scales, like Peru and El Salvador, with a much lower level of training or expertise than Western employees, and little likelihood of getting security clearances.
Many American diplomats have defended Blackwater. At least six American State Department employees have been killed since the occupation of Iraq, and Ms. Tyrell said that 27 Blackwater personnel members were killed defending their charges. "A certain number of our people are here today because Blackwater guards have been killed protecting them," said an official familiar with security arrangements for American diplomats, who did not want to be identified because he was not authorized to speak to the news media.
The Iraqis now seem prepared to accept the prospect that many or even most of the former Blackwater employees will remain on the job as Triple Canopy employees. "It doesn't matter who they are, what their names are, or what uniform they wear," said Brig. Gen. Abdul-Karim Khalaf, spokesman for the Iraqi Interior Ministry, "as long as they are subject to Iraqi law and their company follows Iraqi laws."
Tareq Maher contributed reporting.
- Posted in



16 Comments so far
Show All""There is just no other way to do it," said one Western diplomat, speaking on the condition of anonymity because he is not permitted to discuss the issue publicly."
Here's a way, get the hell out of there NOW!
Blackwater was accountable to nobody and the diplomats knew it. They should have had the sense to either make Blackwater accountable under US law and then agree to have them be under Iraqi law as soon as that court system was up and running which was a long time ago-- they trusted the Iraqis to deal with Sadam Hussain and these diplomats should have had the common sense to also trust them with fairness regarding Blackwater. As it was - there was a lawlessness that lasted for 6 years!!!
What a poor example of the US. Much hope is there in Obama and rightfully so-- Bush screwed up there as well as in so many ways. Tragic.
We removed Saddam, the dictator who answered to no one, and replaced him with Blackwater, another dictator who answers to no one. And after Iraq basically kicked Blackwater out, we're sending them back under another name. Just one more drop against the invading dogs in the overflowing well that budding terrorists will drink at.
Um, the US soldiers from Iraq are being directed to Afghanistan and more US military contractors are replacing those troops in Iraq so no surprise here.
Are there at least different laws now so these military contractors can be prosecuted.
sell this house
As a veteran of the USN, it seems to me that our government no longer has any faith in our military, therefore, private mercenaries, rather than using the military for security. I guess our government has no faith in the American people in general, therefore multi-trillion dollar bailouts for failed businesses. I still believe in my country and the people in it, and I truly believe that if our government placed faith in our people and military, then ours would be a better country. It is my opinion that the uber-rich are afraid of the common people and many of the recent immigrants to the USA, afraid that we might take a dollar from their pockets and place into our pockets, instead of the other way around.
It's more like they want to keep military casualties low. It shows that "we're winning this war". No one cares for a dead mercenary, they chose to die for a paycheck not a cause.
Iraq is a pretty good proving ground for insurgent warfare in an urban environment. At least they'll be well trained for "peacekeeping" actions here at home when the riots start.
Mercenaries-butchers should not be let out of their cages!
Before Bush started this nightmare, the Iraqis loved Americans, and it was safe for anyone to walk around anywhere in Iraq at night. And oh yes, they had a brutal dictator named Saddham running the country. Of oourse, the world is full of brutal dictators, but it was his misfortune to be living on top of our oil.
Obviously it is a horrible fate to be a poor population living in a resource rich country. And a shame to be a citizen of a rich country benefiting from that.
When the people fear their government there is tyranny,
when the government fears the people there is liberty.
~ Thomas Jefferson
Well I hear this "it's about the oil stupid" nonsense all the time. No. The major reason Bush and his Neocon cohorts orchestrated 9/11 and invaded Iraq was to steal from the American people.
The total amount of money that LEFT OUR TREASURY far exceeds any oil benefits from invading Iraq. Their goal was to steal from us not for us. We are as much the victims of Bush's crimes as anyone.
Circa 2001 the streets of California were to begin to be occupied by GM and other brands of electric powered cars. Bush and his criminal cohorts, who work to DESTROY US interests not on behalf of US interests, had nearly every last one of these cars crushed so the electric vehicle couldn't take off in the USA, even though it is very clearly in our interests. With moderate efforts we could replace most all vehicles on US roads with electric cars within a few years and even with lead acid batteries they would meet the needs of some 95 percent of the driving public of course with the latest tech there is nothing gasoline that compares to the power efficiency and speed of the electric car.
Continuing on with oil damages America. Too many people fall for the propaganda that we need petroleum to continue our lifestyle and actually repeat it as if it is true. We can have a much better time with alternative energy and vastly cleaner world. We don't need oil anymore than we need a hole in our heads. Oil serves a very few people who want to control the rest of us. These people are psychopathic idiotic mass murderers, make no mistake about it. They are unbelievably stupid and if we don't stop them we will end up losing our country and possibly the world.
Sure sure, combine enlightenment, responsibility and independence for the people, with renewable energy, and we're on our way to utopia. Notice how the first three kind of reinforce each other. The fourth is among many natural outcome, so utopia is almost automatic. The elites know it, and this is why they push the farmers to grow corn instead of hemp for example. Corn is less versatile, thus promoting mono-society of dependence instead of versatile local independent production with hemp. Look in every sector and you see the same pattern. By the way, electric cars only benefit when we chop personal transport by four in favor of public rail, chop vehicle weight by four and horsepower by eight, use series diesel-electric drive, and local ownership of vehicle and biofuel production. This follows from the well-established idea of industry standards. So the "Model T" design is placed in the public domain, and the local regulators make sure the local production is up to par. The people derive great satisfaction from local production knowing that it frees them from the fascist mega-monster.
It seems as if slavery is still the best way to profit
Using mercenaries in an occupied nation is against international law for many reasons. Strange how the US military cannot perform this role and all the other roles that have been privatized under Bush and even though Obama promised to deprivatize them he has continued the criminal privatization. Contracting out services and functions that the US military is fully capable of doing and in fact much much better than the private contractors for a fraction of the cost. This is especially terrible with our massive recession brought on by George Bush's bankster ponzi schemes. We can't afford this continuing theft of the US treasury.
This is a never ending series of criminal scams from banksters to mass murdering defense crooks. This is not the same as it has always been but it does look like George Bush continued.
I never thought Obama would be flawlessly perfect, but...
This is just ridiculous. Just another thing. It's absolutely unbelievable.
We need to UNDO what George Bush did in EVERY WAY! NOT CONTINUE IT!
No other way to do it? Just get out of Iraq!
Whatever happened to the campaign promise of out of Iraq in 5 months?
The State Department is full of shit. Right after the destruction of the World Trade Center they should have ramped up their program at Consular Operations and began training more security officers. In the past when I was in the miltary, during the 70's and 80's they were a highly respected, professional, and competent entity of the State Dept.
How in the hell did this get outsourced? When will the people involved undrstand that people whom you work with and have a direct relationship with will look out for you like family member other than a paycheck.
James Stirling, for being unbelievably stupid, they sure got away with a lot, including looting our treasury for generations to come.
Our foreign policy has always been about controlling the resources of other countries for the benefit of our corporations.
The stupid ones are the American citizens who have paid no attention to what is going on. I look around and see nothing but people hoping Obama will save them. They don't get it that we need to save ourselves. Obama made it clear he would support that. But he can't save us. This is not a one man job.
Obviously it hasn't gotten bad enough yet. But maybe nothing will be enough to get people to act. Our country is now owned by the corporations as much as it was once owned by England. And Americans just sit and take it up the tailpipe. The real American tragedy is the people.
When the people fear their government there is tyranny,
when the government fears the people there is liberty.
~ Thomas Jefferson