EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Gardens Save the Day in 'WALL-E' and America's Cities
The feature film, "WALL-E," is a must-see for urban pioneers, environmentalists, teachers and community organizers because it reflects what can happen when citizens take control of their own lives -- and plant gardens.
The film opens with a scene of a lifeless earth devastated not by war or natural disaster but by trash. The piles upon piles of trash are so overwhelming that the people have left earth to live deep in space and wait until life on earth returns. The people, who are so overweight they've forgotten how to walk, spend their days lying on floating couches and sipping liquid food while robots tend to their every need.
Meanwhile, back on earth a lonely, trash compactor, WALL-E, (the acronym for Waste Allocation Load Lifters, Earth-class) is left to clean up the mess left behind.
WALL-E is a very industrious and curious robot. When he finds an interesting item, he takes it "home" and displays it on his shelf. One day he stumbles on a small plant and puts it in an old work boot.
A spaceship lands on earth and Eve, a probe, scans the terrain. She encounters WALL-E, they fall in love and he shows Eve the plant. She immediately takes it and scurries back to her spaceship. As the ship lifts off, WALL-E attaches himself to it in order to follow Eve.
The spaceship docks on the mother ship and Eve reports to the captain that she has found a plant. The captain realizes that the ship can return to earth but he must fight off Otto (short for auto-pilot), who is programmed to keep things running "normally," as he has for the past 700 years.
Once they are back on earth, the people begin their new life by planting gardens. Their work together makes them feel good and they work together happily.
One point of the film is that while consumerism on earth made the people wasteful and negligent, the conveniences of technology in space have made them soft, purposeless and dependent. Growing food turns out to be the key to their transformation.
Over the past 20 years gardens have been sprouting in cities all over the United States as people have decided to take control of their lives and their food system. That this phenomenon should happen in Detroit, the twentieth century industrial miracle of the world where the automobile was king, is particularly significant.
Cities were formed 5,000 years ago when humans learned how to grow and store crops. They no longer had to rely on what food they gathered or hunted. Neither did they have to do everything for themselves since they were organized to perform various functions like growing food, protecting the community, praying to the gods for good harvests and making pottery and cisterns for food and water storage. Cities thrived through agriculture and grew into important centers for commerce, government, religion and culture.
The early nineteenth century changed all that when cities became industrial centers. And although industry created more wealth, it lured people away from their farms, polluted the cities and negatively affected people's health. Factories also separated families and made workers cogs in an economic system whose only purpose was the efficiency and profitability of production.
The availability of cars and cheap fuel in the twentieth century provided people with greater mobility so that by mid-century they began to abandon the cities and pave over their farmlands. Gradually, people became disconnected from nature, the land, their food and each other.
Detroit, which has lost half of its peak population of 1.5 million since 1950, is the symbol of the Rust Belt tragedy where abandoned factories, empty office buildings and gutted neighborhoods dominate the cityscape. However, in 1992 urban gardens began to appear in vacant lots and open spaces as ordinary citizens decided to form communities and friendships through their gardens.
To celebrate this regeneration of the city, every August for the past 10 years, the Detroit Agriculture Network (www.detroitagriculture.org), which coordinates several agricultural and gardening programs throughout the city, hosts an annual bus and bicycle tour to illustrate how neighborhood and backyard gardens are impacting the local food system. For example, gardens are producing thousands of pounds of fresh, nutritious produce for Detroit families through organic agriculture techniques, alternative uses of blighted spaces, creative income-generating activities and crop and product diversity. Gardens are also influencing larger social issues like reducing crime, cleaning up trash-strewn lots, connecting people to nature, nurturing leadership in citizens young and old and improving property values.
The first decade of the twenty-first century is making it evident that the era of cheap fuel is over, which definitively affects our agricultural and transportation systems. Meanwhile, as people yearn to re-connect themselves to nature and vibrant communities, they are turning to gardens as the means.
Detroit, the miracle of the industrial era and the epitome of industrial decline-is now a twenty-first century city on the mend through its urban gardens. And like the film, "WALL-E," people are committed to re-building their cities block by block by growing food -- and hope. And they are enjoying it!
Olga Bonfiglio, who grew up in Downriver Detroit and graduated from Wayne State University in Detroit, is now a professor at Kalamazoo College where she teaches a class in urban revitalization. Her website is www.OlgaBonfiglio.com and her e-mail address is olgabonfiglio@yahoo.com.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

12 Comments so far
Show AllOH, DAMN! Now the government is going to know about these gardens, and they'll make them against the law because "unregulated" food grown by us peons might be a health hazard to the public.
I read somewhere a week or so ago that these small farms where produce is grown and sold at the public markets could pose a health hazard because "it isn't known how the produce is being grown."
New Government Speak: It doesn't come from one of the foreign countries we do business with, or one of the mega farms we give the peons' tax dollars to.
Growing things is certainly a mystery, miracle, and pleasurable.
And like meditation, it is almost free, and transcendent.
"...lured people away from their farms." Nobody was 'lured', they were pushed off the land by richfilth just like the Romans did - to force them to the cities - the push the wages to the floor - TO MAKE THEM SLAVES. Vilcomin du Amerika. The Slave Empire Extraordinaire. Emigrate now while you still can. Later, President Obama may want you for the forced labor gangs. Funny that, a former black man organizing slave labor for Master. Almost ironic.
Why not use all the polluting pig shit, chicken shit, cow manure and yes, even processed human shit to fertilize our yards and farms instead of using oil derived chemicals that leave salts and poisons that destroy topsoil?
Throwing shit into our water supply, then purifying the water to drink seems like an awful waste of energy.
Also, why not recycle humans by burying them without coffins and planting a tree on top instead of loading cadavers with formaldehyde or using fossil fuels to cremate them?
Indians recycled cadavers by placing them on raised platforms as vulture food which seems better than worm food. It would be as if parts of us could fly.
Burial at sea would also be preferable. Then parts of us could swim.
In Robert Heinlein's "Strangers in a Strange Land", which became infamous because it was one of Charles Manson's favorites, cannibalizing your loved one was an honor that made him or her a part of you.
I personally would not go that far... But I think it would be nice if my loved ones could see my tree and think of me.
BTW, we really enjoyed Wall E.
Enjoyed. Will use the name Buy 'n Large a lot in the next six months. Why should I have to negatively advertise a specific monopolistic megacorp when I have a surrogate name for a benignly imaged, rapacious monopoly?
"Let them say anything they want, as long as they spell your name right."
As an urban gardener/farmer I sympathize with the intent of the article. However, I know personally what has mostly motiovated me is the skyrocketing cost of food and medicine. (Yes you can "grow" medicine--they are called medicinal herbs and many are as hearty as any weed you might ever encounter.)
Gardening is a great way to make friends (try bringing a basket or bag of tomatoes or squash to that neighbor you haven't spoken to for a while and see what I mean) and reconnect with the earth from which we have all sprung, but for a prudent investment in time and effort (an hour or two every few days once the garden gets going) you can break the habit of buying all but the most exotic of produce at the store.
" . . . industry polluted the cities and negatively affected people's health . . . "
like cities weren't polluted before industry, even tho sanitation didn't exist ?
the myth of 'progress thru agriculture' has held sway for a long time, in reality the hunter-gatherer cultures had a much easier time of it and did not overpopulate the planet the way agriculturalists do . . .
the cities did indeed arise to house the slave populations of the kings/pharaohs/demi-deities, and said slaves were fed by the surrounding agricultural areas, as the hunter-gatherers were pushed to the margins . . .
which is not to say that small scale and urban agriculture is not vitally important today, it is, because the only way out of our situation is through it . . . but we need to gain a better understanding of the coincident roots of agriculture, population density, and the diseases which can only gain traction in a sufficiently dense settlement . . .
human and much animal waste is full of pathogens and it is not safe to use on food plants unless fully treated, BUT it could certainly be diverted to methane digesters and used to create a local energy source . . .
I got a little Troy-Bilt electric cultivator this year ($200 from my economic stimulus check) and tilled up the fastest-growing area of lawn in my yard, then put in a 14x21 foot garden. Because we've had a wet year here, everything is a bit late, but I've already eaten enough fresh salad greens to recoup my seed costs for the entire garden. Pollination has been a bit of a problem with some of the squash, and the beans aren't as plentiful as I would have hoped. I've also tilled up more lawn and planted cherry bushes and a 10x10 plot of popcorn for fun.
It may take a year or two to get back the entire investment, but the time it has taken to garden is no more than the time I would have spend mowing those areas when they were lawn. The real payback is walking out and picking fresh salad fixings for dinner, rinsing off only dust (no pesticides) and eating it within 15 minutes of picking. The colors of the lettuces and greens are positively vibrant, and I know I'm not losing any vitamin content while my food sits on a truck or shelf.
ezflyer - traditional Chinese farmers collected human waste, called "night soil" for fertilizer. Not sure if it had to be aged or treated in any way to prevent spread of disease. We must start designing buildings to trap organic waste for re-use, to re-cycle water, to make use of passive heating. This does not require much in new technology or money, just consciousness.
After death I would prefer to have my ashes scattered to feed a tree or a garden or to travel the oceans, becoming part of seaweed and darting schools of fish. That beats taking up real estate and being immobilized deep underground in an airless frou-frou satin-lined coffin at a cost of thousands to my family.
Everything you mentioned is about re-cycling organic molecules so they can become incorporated into diverse forms of life This makes spiritual and scientific sense.
Chinese 'night soil' is not aged or treated in any way. This is why the Chinese do not, traditionally, eat salads. Instead, all food is cooked and served hot. Cooking kills any pathogens that were in the night soil.
Humanure, however, is basically composted night soil. The composting cooks the pathogens so you can eat salads.
I always notioned that the 'proper' use for nuclear-waste would be to embed it into large/twin-walled 'pipes' -- through which city-sewage could be pumped (on its way towards 'drying-fields' -- where it would shortly be valuable/pathogen-free fertilizer, rather than a major source of pollution/run-off into rivers/groundwater).
Such 'pipes/doughnuts' would surely be expensive/dangerous to initially-produce, but they would function, maintenance-free, over hundreds-of-years -- definitively killing everything/anything that passed through them. Minus all living-pathogens, sewage would have real/intrinsic-value (and the 'two-fer' being that nuclear-waste would finally find a 'usefulness' in short-term storage).
I'm unsure how pleasant being downwind of such drying-fields would be...but minus the smell from pathogens in human/animal-'waste' (which we instinctively find 'disgusting' -- and for evolutionary-Cause!), I'm sure there would be some fashion or Process to deal-with/reduce such a nuisance factor?
"Waste-not, want-not..."
Pipes break. Nuke waste last forever, gets into the food chain and forever increases cancers.