EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
- Wisconsin Bill Would Treat Organic Milk, Sharp Cheddar, Brown Eggs as "Junk Food"
- As Death Toll Rises Beyond 500, Garment Factory Disaster 'Worst in World History'
- Climate Change's 'Evil Twin': Ocean Acidification
- Patent Filing Claims Solar Energy ‘Breakthrough’
- Pregnant Anti-War Soldier Sent to Prison
- Move Over, Koch Brothers: A Bigger, Darker Rightwing Funder Is Out to Destroy Public Education
- Patent Filing Claims Solar Energy ‘Breakthrough’
- Time for Big Green to Go Fossil Free
- Wisconsin Bill Would Treat Organic Milk, Sharp Cheddar, Brown Eggs as "Junk Food"
- Climate Change's 'Evil Twin': Ocean Acidification
Popular content
Today's Top News
The Face of the Anti-War Movement Fires Back
Back when she made national news railing against the war and protesting outside the president's Texas ranch, I slammed Cindy Sheehan.
I called her misguided and said she was no Rosa Parks. I wrote about "the disingenuous way" the grieving mom had politicized the death of her son, Casey, a soldier killed in Iraq four years ago.
"Saint Sheehan," I quipped in 2005.
On Saturday, Sheehan fired back, face-to-face.
"Who misguided me?" she said with a penetrating gaze as we sat at a dining room table of her host in North Seattle. "Who said I was 'a Rosa Parks'? I never made any comparison of myself to anybody."
The temperature in the room started to rise.
"To say I'm a grieving mother is absolutely true," she said. "I will be a grieving mother until I die. But to think that a grieving mother is not intelligent, is not articulate, cannot form her own opinions is ... misguided."
She added: "That somebody like you would think that somebody has to be pulling my strings or guiding me or telling me what to say is insulting. Whatever I say, whatever I do is coming from the best possible place inside me."
It's clear to me now more than ever that Sheehan, 50, follows her own path, which is why she was in Seattle.
After fading as the face of the anti-war cause, she's on a comeback trail, running for Congress in California's 8th District, which covers most of San Francisco.
She's gunning for the seat held by Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi. To some, Pelosi symbolizes the failure of Democrats to make the most of their hard-won congressional majority.
Sheehan became disillusioned after Pelosi failed to introduce articles of impeachment against President Bush for the war and crimes against humanity. And then, she said, the Democrats gave Bush a no-strings-attached funding bill for the war.
"That was it," she said. "I left the Democratic Party."
That was last spring, and the Democrats -- a party that prides itself on civility and inclusiveness -- ripped her. "I can take it from Bill O'Reilly and Rush Limbaugh," she said, referring to the conservative pundits.
But looking back, she feels gut-punched, even used: "If anybody used, not just me, but the energy of the movement, it was the Democratic Party. They rebuffed the country and (the anti-war movement) that got them elected. They betrayed us."
Sheehan calls herself "nonpartisan." Her platform calls for single-payer, universal health care, overturning the Patriot Act, ending the war and bringing home the troops. She'd like to see a viable third political party emerge to buck the two-party system.
So far she has pooled about $170,000 for her campaign. Her goal: $600,000. She's raising it through grass-roots meetings such as the one Friday in Seattle.
What fuels her most now is the same: her son's death.
Army Spc. Casey Sheehan, 24, entered the military with hopes of becoming a chaplain's assistant, but he ended up a Humvee mechanic.
Sheehan said one of her son's military buddies recently e-mailed her. The soldier said Casey had been reluctant to go on what would be his final mission, but a sergeant was looking for troops. Casey refused, saying he was a mechanic. But he ended up going after being chewed out.
According to previous accounts, Casey was killed after volunteering for a mission. But the conflicting account from the soldier offers Sheehan solace: "Casey had told us before he left for the war that he wouldn't be able to kill anybody. I was so proud of him to find out that he was a conscientious objector at the end of his life."
Military officials posthumously praised Casey for being a fine mechanic.
The soldier who e-mailed Sheehan described Casey as "a great guy but a horrible mechanic."
"He was speaking the truth," Sheehan said with a chuckle. "Casey could not even change the oil in his own car."
She isn't surprised the brass would put the spin on her son given how Bush & Co. spun the run-up to the Iraq war.
"Our next president needs to know," Sheehan said, "that they can't get away with imperial presidential powers like George Bush."
After I pilloried her in columns, hundreds of readers said I owed Sheehan a chance to respond. She got it Saturday.
She came across as earnest, soft-spoken and sincere, not the ranting lunatic I figured she was after watching her on television news snippets. She sure has moxie challenging the government, our military and even the Democratic Party.
Maybe I did get her wrong. Sheehan isn't misguided. She's someone who follows the map of her own heart, for better or worse.
Robert L. Jamieson Jr.is a P-I columnist.
©1996-2008 Seattle Post-Intelligencer
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

25 Comments so far
Show AllFunny that Common Dreams has absolutely no mention of Kucinich's Bills of Impeachment today. What's with that? Hope you guys haven't totally sold out to the Democratic Party line.
http://chun.afterdowningstreet.org/amomentoftruth.pdf
Here's the full text of the articles of impeachment. DK is the bravest man in this reeking government!
Much of the so-called anti-war "movement" in the USA is already collapsing for fear to be called "traitor", "unpatriotic", etc. Take Obama. He recently declared that the war in Iraq was "unnecessary and should not have been started". Well, it was started and Senator Obama helped keeping it alive by feeding it funding on several occasions which is conveniently overlooked by his adulators. He is already hedging on his earlier plans for withdrawal. He will continue to ask for trillions of funding "to support our troops while they are there". He is "Slick Barak". Within one year Iraq will become known as "Obama's war" if he becomes our next president. The political reality is that the Republican minority in the Senate will not allow any bill to pass that calls for a timetable of withdrawal. The rest is wishful thinking. Remember 2006. We are almost two years later and the occupation of Iraq is still on! It is becoming clearer day-by-day that the real "anti-war movement" is in Iraq where thousands of Sunnis and Shiites demonstrate peacefully against the proposed rotten occupation pact that must replace the equally rotten UN mandate.
I have been wondering why there is no news of Dennis' articles of impeachment on CD since last night when he was live on CSPAN. I wrote an article about it called" Music to my Ears, that was not posted here, either. I think it is on afterdownstreet.org
Kudos and deep respect to Dennis.
Cindy
I too thought she was a wacko when I listened to her on TV. Reading her writing gave me a different picture, however.
Or afterdowningstreet.org
Here's a chance to vote for impeachment on the MSM
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/10562904/
It seems to me that CD does not do an hourly update sort of thing. Their site is static all day, and is then updated around 10 or 11 AM (In California, anyhow, I don't know where they are physically).
So, give CD a chance to catch up, okay? Go over to BuzzFlash if you want the minute-to-minute stuff. CD is for essays, not headlines.
God Bless Kucinich. Pray Pelosi can't figure out how to derail him. Talk about appeasement, Pelosi's the one!
Dear Orwellwasoptimist
You are correct about the op eds being only refreshed once a day, but the headlines change frequently during the day.
www.CindyforCongress.org
Cindy
Ha ha! 89% for impeachment!
Robert L. Jamieson Jr. - It is nice to see one of your ilk owning up to your mis-perceptions and setting the record straight. I do not always agree with Cindy, but I fully support her right to voice her opinion in the public forum and her right to run for political office. I hope she does defeat NP. And if she does I hope she is able to continue to fight for her principles in the "belly of the beast". There are a few examples of others who have remained true in that environment, but not many.
Cindy is 100% spot on in her view of the Democratic party. They sold the base out a long long time ago. You can not serve the good of public and serve the corporatocracy, they are diametrically opposed.
Cindy (and Casey, too) is an inspiration to me. While no one I know will outwardly express any criticism of Barack Obama - oh, maybe some insignificant mild admonishment - Cindy Sheehan is boldly going where few dare to go, she calls a spade a spade and she stands up for what is right, based on her own best analysis and her commitment to end the war.
I have a son in his twenties. My heart aches just to think about what it must be like to lose him to something like this illegal, brutal, viscious war, started and enabled for years by politicians on both sides of the aisle (is there still and aisle?)
Kudos to you, Cindy! Your son, Casey, would be mighty proud.
Holy crap.
Its THRIRTY-FIVE articles for impeachment people!
THIRTY-FIVE!
Wow.
And most of them would stick if Congress was honest.
Go Kucinich! Go Sheehan!
Wow, I'm still blown a bit away. THIRTY-FIVE.
You know that thing where you know something is bad, but you don't really FEEL it until its all spelled out?
That's what I'm going through at this moment.
THIRTY-FIVE "Crimes and Misdemeanors" = Worst President Ever.
Seriously go to -willybill's- link -it's your Civic Duty, buddy.
I think I can hear Democracy wimpering in the corner.
Sweet Jesus.
-matti.
I don't know the writer of this article, but it seems to me to be a pretty tepid apology for being a jerk. Thank god for the Cindy Sheehans (so rare!) of this world who were willing to stand up to the fascist BushCo. ... Good on some Grannies, too, who stood up to tanks in the street. I'll be sending Cindy Sheehan a check for her campaign. I want her to win; mostly, though, I want her to be able to keep standing up for her son, herself, and the rest of us.
Dearie June, agreed.
I have never had any illusions about Cindy Sheehan. She is not a particulary skilled writer or speaker. Her lack of knowledge and education in some areas can be obvious and even a bit awkward at times. But there is no question about her motivation, her determination or the just nature of her cause.
Sheehan is not slick. Good. We've had more than enough slickness.
"She sure has moxie challenging the government, our military and even the Democratic Party."
What really takes moxie is to support the illegal invasion of another country and perpetration of mass murder in the name of freedom and democracy.
I guess we are the home of the brave...
"Maybe I did get her wrong."
Not maybe, cheesedick. Say it like a man: you got her wrong. Period.
BTW, it's an ant-invasion movement or an anti-occupation movement, but it cannot be an "anti-war" movement, because The United States of America is not presently in a declared WAR with any nation on Earth.
Unless we're talking about Turkey, since they're still bombing Iraq, which we occupy, which makes us legally responsible for the security of the country and it's people, which means Turkey is bombing the USA.
Turkey is not bombing Iraq, they did border crosses because of the PKK, they've murdered >35,000 Turks since '86, man. It is in the Kurdish area of Iraq which borders Turkey, the PKK is Kurdish. They call themselves PJAK when they border cross into Iran and murder Iranians. Wise the hell up. So only the US can protect their borders and citizens, yeah? They live like animals and murder the same way, they are despised throughout Asia Minor, Iran and the ME. The Kurds murder daily, so piss off with those non facts. Give me a link, give me one.
Which paper says this, Hurriyet, Milliyet which one, how many say this?????? NONE, because I read 6 Turkish newspapers daily of differing Political views so give me one Franky, one.
Cindy, thanks for what you do and who you are every day. I congratulate you on the birth of your grandson and wish you would come to Philly again for an IVAW, VFP or VVAW rally. We all love you in Philly and we speak of you often with great admiration.
I find it odd that some found that Cindy sounded like a whacko on TV, I always found her to be a refreshing, honest, and practical voice.Someone who said it, just how it was.
I arrived at Camp Casey on August 28th 2006, and some guy on the shuttle between camp Casey one and camp Casey 2 was telling me that a storm was going to hit New Orleans that night that was going to totally destroy the city. My thoughts were, seems a bit far fetched, but....
Well the next morning we found out that the storm had not hit New Orleans directly, and casualties had not been as had been expected. However Cindy gave a press conference that she was going to reroute one of the buses that had been scheduled to do a certain route and end up in DC.
She opted to send all the supplies left over from Camp Casey to Louisianna. So the camp loaded up all the supplies onto the bus. I should also note that the camp on the other side of the road from Camp Casey(the proBush group)called themselves Camp Reality.
Well the day I flew home to Oregon, August 31st, I was watching from the airport TVs as the levees broke in New Orleans flooding the city. That was Tuesday.
It was early Thursday that "Cindy's" bus made it to Lousianna and gave aid to a community hit by the hurricane.
The US government did not make until late Thursday.
I have often thought how Cindy had the situation Right On.
AND Camp Reality was a misnomer.
CINDY is right on!
Janet
Robert L. Jamieson writes - "She sure has moxie challenging the government, our military and even the Democratic Party."
That's not moxie, that's integrity. The reporter still doesn't get it.
Most news is not reporting. It's repeating, and now with McClellan we know that the lies that started from the very top were 'repeated' by all the news organizations without any challenge, collaboration of facts, or reasonable attempts to determine any other possibility of events. And now the media is saying they did a good job of asking questions.
By the way, The hundred of thousands who marched before the war weren't taken in by the lies. Why is that?
Ralph Nader for President, Cindy Sheehan for congress.
demand peace.
Turce June 11th, 2008 12:24 am
My God! We agree on something.
EarsOfTheWorld June 10th, 2008 2:40 pm
opeluboy June 10th, 2008 7:01 pm
Both of these posts are true in my opinion. When Cindy was here in Texas sitting across from the ranch, I thought, heres another Code Pink media hound looking for self gratification. I was wrong. She believes in what she says. She walks the walk. My money was sent last month. Go get em Cindy. We don't always agree, but if we did, I'd worry.
Cindy has lots of writing and speaking skills. A good knowledge of and degree in history. And a passion that is not exceeded by anyone, anywhere. I have no doubt that she would be an unrestrained, powerful voice for all true progressives in the Congress.
As for this article, Mr. Jamieson owes her a real apology, which he does not offer in this article. Her actions were not taken in "a disingenuous way." She used the tragedy of the US-government-caused death of her son to give his life meaning by opposing illegal and immoral state violence. By saying that, Mr. Jamieson accused her of a falsehood, mislabeling her motives. Saying that "Maybe I did get her wrong" is not an apology. Saying "I'm sorry" is an apology. Saying "I regret that I smeared your character by slamming your motives as disingenuous" is an apology. Saying "I won't make that mistake again against any grieving friend or family member of a person murdered by war" is an apology. I hope Mr. Jamieson at some time realizes the magnitude of the wrong in what he said to Cindy Sheehan. In this article, such a realization is not in evidence.
I always had deep respect for Cindy, even before I heard her speak in person. She is a great speaker - very inspirational and very sincere. I wish that she would move a little more to the Left. I never hear her criticize Capitalism but I support her and hope she wins the election.
The country owes a big THANK YOU to Dennis. The House just voted on his Impeachment Bill which the Dems will promptly kill. There will be no Peace until we get the dem/repubs out of office.
VOTE NADER !
Cindy Sheehan is one of my heroes. I have nothing but respect and admiration for her. I am proud we have Americans like her. Cindy has the values Jackie Robinson said we all should have to live by:
1. Courage
2. Determination
3. Teamwork
4. Persistence
5. Citizenship
6. Justice
7. Commitment
8. Excellence
Thank you Robert L. Jamieson Jr. for having the courage to admit you were wrong about Cindy.
CD is based on Maine, but even on the eastern time zone, their updates are fairly late in the day. It probably takes time to review the various sources and decise waht to publish.
Just the same, I do think that CD has hopped on the Obama/Democrat bandwagon, and that means not being friendly to any independent or Green -even independents running in 100.0% safe districts like the one Cindy Sheehan is running in. Very illogical, if one assumes CD is genuinely progressive.
One problem is that the owner and webmaster are farily wealthy individuals, and similar to Jesus's remark, it is very difficult for a wealthy person to be a genulne left-progressive. Money has a corrupting effect on even the best of us.