Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Mother's Day 2008: Peaceful Idealism v. Political Pragmatism
Sadly, this is the fifth Mother's Day since Casey was killed in Iraq on April 04, 2004. The people who told me that "time will heal" were wrong, or maybe it just takes more time? I have spoken to many mothers who buried their child years ago, however, that tell me it does not get any easier. I suspect the mothers who have buried children are probably right.
On this Mother's Day, though, I am reflecting on all kinds of moms. Some women never have children and it seems that their lives are complete. Some women desperately want to have children, but for some reason, cannot. Some women have lost their only child to the ravenous war machine and they somehow go on. One specific mother has her family intact and can callously sign blank checks to pay for war (that are really nothing but death warrants for other people's children) with only the life and health of her political party in her heart. Another mother can talk about "obliterating" an entire innocent country filled with mothers and children without even blinking her eyes that only shed crocodile tears at the appropriate moments.
Some of us are lucky enough to have had loving moms and some of us have had mothers who were cold and distant. Other moms are abusive, while some have been abused. Our world is made up of all kinds of women some of which are suited to be mothers some of which are suited to political life; some both: many neither.
I am a mother of four children. I planned on every one of them outliving me. When I thought of growing old, I imagined being surrounded on holidays by four children, children-in-law, grandchildren and great grandchildren. In the natural order of things, children should always bury their parents, but in our unnaturally violent, war torn world where shopping malls, schools, the streets and entire innocent nations are turned into bloodbaths, the situation is reversed and too many parents must tragically bury their children.
Today, one mother joyously watched her daughter marry at a pig farm in Crawford, TX. The mother's husband, the daughter's father, proudly looked on the scene that his actions have denied to so many of us. The daughter wore an Oscar de la Renta gown and it has been reported that there will be dancing throughout the night. Because of her father's lies and greed, too many people the daughter's age have been buried in their military dress uniforms (if there was enough of the body left to be buried) while their mothers and fathers watched in heartbroken grief as their child's body was lowered into a cold, cold grave for eternity.
Too many mothers today in Iraq will have their babies blown to bits by American bombs or an insurgent's last desperate act. If an Iraqi mother is fortunate enough to have all her children around her, she will be scraping for food, clean water and praying for a few minutes of electricity, or at least one day of peace and quiet.
Recently, I was confronted by a man at a farmer's market in San Francisco. He is not "pro war" but he is pro-Pelosi because he is a "political pragmatist." Apparently, Ms. Pelosi funding the war for another year is "politically pragmatic" because it is worth murdering tens of thousands of more innocent people so that Democrats can gain the White House and more seats in Congress. I wish I had the luxury of being a political pragmatist, but I must do everything in my power to save other mothers from the life of never ending grief that I have been condemned to by men and women some of whom are mothers and fathers who have forgotten that other people's children are precious to their parents, too.
On Mother's Day this year, while mothers all over America are being taken out to brunch or being served breakfast in bed, I would like us to take time out of our day to reflect on the mothers who have been harmed by the last six years of bloody wars that are waged by neocon-Republicans and paid for by complicit-Democrats. I want us in the US to remember that we are a nation, if not in a legal, moral or declared war: at least a violent occupation that seems like a war to those that have been adversely affected by it.
I am luckier than many mothers whose only child has been stolen from them for lies, because I will be surrounded by my three surviving children and their partners on Mother's Day and we will spend the time staring at my daughter's belly which is fat (and one week past due) with my first grandchild. My grandson will never meet his Uncle Casey but he will know him because of the love that is left in his family.
I challenge us all to reject "political pragmatism" and embrace "peaceful idealism" for the love of all the world's children.
Julia Ward Howe's Mother's Day Proclamation should be enshrined in our war-soaked national consciousness as our economy, ecology and our communities are being ravaged by the rapacious war machine:
Say firmly: "We will not have questions answered by irrelevant agencies, Our husbands will not come to us, reeking with carnage, For caresses and applause. Our sons shall not be taken from us to unlearn All that we have been able to teach them of charity, mercy and patience. We, the women of one country, Will be too tender of those of another country To allow our sons to be trained to injure theirs."
Cindy Sheehan is the mother of Spc. Casey Austin Sheehan who was KIA in Iraq on 04/04/04. She is a co-founder and President of Gold Star Families for Peace and the author of two books: Not One More Mother's Child and Dear President Bush.



41 Comments so far
Show AllHappy Mother's Day, Cindy, if it ain't out of keepin' with the situation! ♥ 8) ♥
And best of luck to your daughter and incipient grandchild! I'm a procrastinator too, so I can relate to the kid. ;)
One can only hope that those "political pragmatists", aka Lesser-Evilists, will come to see that the Machiavellian technocrats they inevitably support are part of the problem, not part of the solution.
Go, Cindy! ♥
Thank you, dear Little Brother.
I think I make Jonah (my incipient grandson) listen to the news too much with me...I don't blame him for not wanting to come out.
That's why we have to challenge this evil "pragmatism" every minute of every day...for Jonah and his generation.
Love
Cindy
www.CindyforCongress.org
CINDY: Magnificent posting. You know the ground must break in order for mineralized water to enter and over time build precious stones and crystals. The human equivalent is that for many of us, the great sorrow opens us to a far more profound connection with the whole, the extended family, that IS mankind.
The loss of your precious son has expanded you, as your pain has allowed you to become a witness for pain everywhere, and justice's champion. God bless you!
It's a shame that when some people are touched by pain and loss they grow bitter and build a wall around empathy. Others open up and on the basis of their own loss work to make a world that will not mean loss for so many. They are indeed blessed as THE peacemakers! On CD, we have a good number of such souls!
Hello Cindy,
1. Where do you fit Obama and his movement in the "pragmatist vs. idealist" divide?
2. How about adressing all the morally-blind older white women supporters of Hitlerry Clinton?
More power 2 U
Hi Cindy,
May you and your family live long and prosper in a nation and world at peace.
Watched Zeitgeist again the other night. Can we manage to turn things around and survive these parasites?
Much love and many hugs this day,
Steve and Adrienne
Dear Wonder6789
Unfortunately, I put Obama squarely in the pragmatist camp. I have not seen anything from him, except empty rhetoric about "hope and change" that leads me to believe he will really bring those things...AND...I have written extensively about Hillary...(like I did in this piece)...I began questioning her motives in September '05 after my meeting with her.
More power to us all
(I "hope" Obama proves me wrong, with all my heart)
Dear Siouxrose
As always...THANK YOU!
Love
Cindy whose off to brunch, now!
Dear Cindy, I thank you for giving us of yourself on Mothers Day. Happy Mothers Day Cindy, and soon Grandmoms Day too. Casey as sure as hell will be smiling on that day of birth with his sweet too-naive smile.
Always with you doll.
VFP
Cindy,
What a beautiful article you have written for all of us, but especially for Mothers who carried us in their womb for nine months and spent the next two decades with dedication and many sacrifices raising us.
As you can see by the first few posters, you are well respected and loved. And before the clock strokes midnight, there will be many more of your fellow citizens thanking you for this compassionate piece on Mother's Day.
Please folks, send whatever you can to Cindy's campaign. Bush's friend, Nancy Pelosi, must be defeated in November and Cindy must be elected to the House of Representatives in representing San Francisco and more importantly, to mothers around the world who love their children and to not have them sacrificed to enrich the pocketbooks and portfolios of the real criminals of the world.
Your May Day speech was right from the heart, Cindy! What a gal!
Mothers of the World, Unite! Protect your kids from the Bush/Cheney Crime Family.
I wonder just how mesdames Pelosi and Clinton plan to obliterate Iranian men, women and children 'pragmatically'?
nigelUK May 11th, 2008 2:56 pm
I wonder just how mesdames Pelosi and Clinton plan to obliterate Iranian men, women and children 'pragmatically'?
Per chance Lord Nigel could I beg your enlightened view pertaining to the dire straits in Afghanistan and Iraq in order to acquire an esteemed outsiders look in? Please allow Cindy to have brunch with her surviving three children, one ripe with child so as not to be reminded of dear sweet Caseys absence.
Piss Off, the Sociopath in Chief and the Evil Doer along with their minions are the guilty treasonous pigs murdering our sons and daughters as well as Iraqi and Afghanistani civilians.
Thank you, nigel.........
VFP, DVAW, VVAW, IVAW
Good on you, Cindy.
"As men have often forsaken the plough and the anvil
At the summons of war,
Let women now leave all that may be left of home
For a great and earnest day of counsel.
Let them meet first, as women, to bewail and commemorate the dead.
Let them solemnly take counsel with each other as to the means
Whereby the great human family can live in peace…"
Works for me!
I'd also be happy to see Pelosi and Reid sent to the showers. Good luck there, you should be representin San Francisco.
Cindy, though we don't agree on the military as a whole, we certainly agree on this war and those that started it. And be sure Casey and all those other wasted lives are in our prayers and hearts.
Its a travesty that you and the others must spend Mothers day without your beloved son's and daughters while those responsible have risked nothing and enjoy it with theirs.
Dear Cindy,
Your love for Casey was a taste of the Divine, and in Casey's tragic loss, in your own "dark night of the soul", you were totally transformed to transfer this love and passion for all of humankind.
You are one of many who understand the power of the Spirit but of whom so few choose politics.
America desperately needs your spirit. God bless you.
xoxo Cindy! A sobering article on what has become another Hallmark holiday. Thank you for the reminder and as always, your inspiration. You continue to move me to be a better citizen working for peace.
"Today, one mother joyously watched her daughter marry at a pig farm in Crawford, TX."
I've got to start reading a bit slower -- I had to go back a re-read this a couple of times before the words registered on my brain the way they are written. But I guess we always see what we want to see.
Fortunately no-one thought to send a drone missile to start a fireworks display.
That was terribly moving, Cindy, and I thank you for it.
Today, as I looked at the photos of the Bush Hager wedding, I thought of you and all of the others who are not able to afford or enjoy the opulence of that "simple" wedding.
I think it is just so so typical that that wedding is in the mminds of the Bush White House a simple, down home affair. When I look at the Jenna Bush images that pop up on the internet when I've googled her, and when I inevitably see her falling down drunk, all I am able to think is, "Has this girl ever been asked to do anything in her life? Has she ever faced a responsibility, has she ever owned up to a commitment?
Has she ever sacrificed anything at all --- in fact, is she SO entitled that even the magnificence of that wedding seems to be nothing at all to her?
I am so so sorry for your cruel loss and pain. I hope at some point, Bush's priviledged offspring will one day realize the true price of their comforts, and as always, paid for by others.
Hey Cindy:
I've got a Mothers Day gift for you. This coming week, after I register in the Green Party, I will be reporting for duty at your Mission District HQ.
I first began posting messages of support for you here on Common Dreams, about a year ago when your will was weakened, and I still lived in Costa Rica.
I live in San Francisco now, and so it is my honor, obligation, and duty, to support your effort at defeating the Neo-Democons. You have given your blood, the least I can give, is my time and effort.
I encourage all Progressive Democrats to now switch to the Green Party. I am a life-long Democrat, I'm not leaving the Democrat Party, the Democrat Part left me. Fool me once shame on you. Fool me twice shame on me.
You can still vote for Obama, as a Green Party member, in the general election. But you need to send the Democrats the message, this time and finally, that your loyalty can not be taken for granted.
Nancy Pelosi became House Speaker, with a mandate from the people, to do everything she could to end the war in Iraq. She has not only failed, she has also betrayed, the people who entrusted her with that mission.
I personally like Obama, he and I share a similar life story, mixed race, funny sounding name, and a belief in America. But Cindy is right. All we have heard from him is rhetoric, inspirational speeches, and a promise for a less evil empire. I hope that he is playing it cool, and safe, in order to get elected. I may even vote for him in the general election, I voted for Nader twice, but Obama may still get my vote.
This election is not about Cindy Sheehan, Barack Obama, or me. It is about the future of our country and our planet. Contrary to what Daniel David, and many others believe, a vote for Cindy is not a wasted vote. A vote for Cindy Sheehan, will send a message to those in power, that their policies must change to reflect the will of the people. And that their continual dis-regard for the will of the people shall cost them their power.
So, Cindy, enjoy your Mothers Day. You have honored your son, your nation, and me. It is my honor to be supporting you.
Ramsay Mameesh
Happy Mother's Day Cindy! This is so wonderful, having you respond back to us.
As we know, it's not all about voting. It's about being clear, guided by our intentions. The "pragmatists" have a good point in the short run, but they forget about what happens to energy and intention in the log run, for example, when they find themselves having to promote a person (or party) who has signed on to more killing in Iraq! And more corporate controlled health care, nuclear power, Patriot Act, you know what I'm saying.
What does it do to ones intentional mind, having to praise(for the sake of the lessor evil strategy) someone who signed on to have more innocent people killed in Iraq - mostly children - to cheerlead for someone who would support insurance corporations and let you die rather than fight for a single payer healthcare system that 85% of Dem voters want. You have to gleefully jump up and down about a candidate who wants to increase military spending. Well, maybe they don't have to jump up and down, but they're doing it.
How long can you pretend before you're not pretending anymore, and on the way towards "taking over the party" you yourself get sucked in to the very $sexy$ attractions and perks.
Cognitive psychology suggests that if you pretend long enough, you'll change the reality of your thinking. I live in a small, very liberal college town. Virtually all of the progressives I know are "cheerleading" for Obama, a few for Clinton. I can understand their position of wanting the Republicans out of office and thus having to hold their noses and vote for the "lesser evil." But to "cheerlead" sellouts and slam candidates who run against them, that's something else, entirely. That, in my opinion, has a profound impact on the collective, progressive mind and thus the future of the progressive movement.
Cindy,
Your wonderful article made me think of "The Ballad of Penny Evans," written by Steve Goodman. Steve sang the story 'a cappella' from the voice of "a young widow in the war that's being fought in Viet Nam." The innocence and depth of Penny's lament is summed up best in the following excerpts from the song: "...I remember I was seventeen on the day I met young Bill / At his father's grand piano, we'd play good old 'Heart and Soul' / Well, I only knew the left hand part and he the right so well / He's the only boy I ever slept with and the only one I will." [...] "And now every month I get a check from an Army bureaucrat / And it's every month I tear it up and I mail the damn thing back. / Do you think that makes it all right, do you think I'd fall for that? / You can keep your bloody money, it won't bring my Billy back. / I never cared for politics, and speeches I don't understand, / And likewise never took no charity from any living man / But tonight there's fifty thousand gone in that unhappy land / And fifty thousand 'Heart and Soul's being played with just one hand..."
If you can find Steve's song (Somebody Else's Troubles, or online) or hear Michelle Shocked's 1990 rendition, you will be moved and grounded in your beliefs... in peace and in love.
KMcG
Hi ~Cindy~. After five years it becomes less hurtful, it's easier. The wound will never fully heal and sometimes it will open for a brief period of time. I promise you, Casey is okay.
April 04, 2004 is a day that we will never forget. I think we do need peace.
Cindy you will wake tomorrow and realize our need for your maternal instinct allowing us strength from a great loss you suffered. You are honoring Casey in this way Cindy, you must know we love you.
Night....
VFP, DVAW, VVAW
Recently, I was confronted by a man at a farmer's market in San Francisco. He is not "pro war" but he is pro-Pelosi because he is a "political pragmatist."
"political pragmatist" is code for elitist, property owner, predator. The man is pro war but just can't admit it. The race between Cindy Sheehan and Madam Pelosi is a referendum on San Francisco's claim to the leftist turf. Will San Francisco residents crawl out of the right's sewer and walk the leftist walk?
~PRESENCE~ That you Nam? Hope so.
I think so.
One of the most powerful anti-war articles I've ever read. Everyone in America should read it.
Cindy, you still manage to 'hope' and I admire you for that. But Obama won't prove you wrong.
He has voted to fund this carnage and would've voted for the IWR had he been in the Senate in 2002, despite his rhetoric to the contrary. He's a Democrat.
Democrats lie better than Republicans and Obama would NOT have gotten anywhere near where he is today if he were truly anti-war. NO progressive should support Obama, not in a million years, his candidacy is one the most cynical lies ever staged by the Democratic Party. As disgusting as Hillary's voting record is (and it is repulsive) she's still less reactionary than Obama, if you can even imagine such a nightmare.
Don't be fooled by Democrats again, people.
AS president Obama will keep troops in Iraq for eternity. Just like Korea, Japan, Europe, Israel, etc.
VOTE NADER. VOTE SHEEHAN.
Cindy, I hope you win!! (:
I'm trying to put together a mock impeachment trial of Bush & Co. for the fall. It doesn't matter WHERE, it matters that we get tens of thousands of people together to impeach Bush & Co. more for two reasons: to show that we can do our own work and not rely on elected Dems; and to educate joe & josephine q. public as to WHY he & his gang should be impeached for his treasonous actions (& tried as a war criminal, too). I need help locating interested groups, individuals, organizations; it doesn't have to cost money, we could keep it simple. e-mail: bentaurus@hotmail.com
YES, CINDY!!!
Let's learn to need them, - and please them, -
so that they have nothing to spare for making war.
By God, that woman can write!
And she has good reason to do so.
Cindy:
Just read your and Medea Benjamin's postings on CD today. Let us include the mothers and adoptive mothers of the movement toward a more humane America in our Mother's Day wishes. It's not too late, because the real, noncommercialized Mother's Day happens in June. Let us also keep Mother Earth in mind, as she tries to support her billions of human and other animal children.
Cindy, let me wish a late Happy Mother's Day. Your chance of winning that race against Nancy Pelosi is probably less with instant run off voting, as the Democrats will press hard to get people to provide a second preference vote for Pelosi by scaring the hell out of them, and the GOP will give their second preference votes to her.
But by all means, I wish you the best in that race. People just have to stop being fooled by the likes of Pelosi about those "terrible Republicans" whose policies they keep on backing. If they're so damn rotten, then these Pelosi types just have the decency not to back them, especially in a safe district such as Pelosi's in. She has no damn excuse, and all this talk about the Democrats being the governing party is BS. With all the authority W and his neo cons have with their nutty unitary presidential government theory of politics, they run this country period until we get somebody with guts with hands in high offices to just say no to these rapers of all democracy.
Cindy, I hope you are wrong about Obama too, and On the lighter side this news just came in...
Bill Clinton Switches to Obama !!
In what some Democratic Party insiders are calling a particularly ominous sign for Hillary Clinton's presidential campaign, former president Bill Clinton today became the latest superdelegate to switch from Sen. Clinton to her rival, Sen. Barack Obama (D-Ill).
Sources close to the former president said that Mr. Clinton had been mulling such a defection for weeks, as early as the night of the Iowa primary, but that he only decided to make his decision public today.
"The American people want change," Mr. Clinton said at a press conference in New York. "Lord knows I do."
The former president said that "sometimes, at the end of a race, you have to put an old horse down," adding, "I'm not speaking metaphorically."
Mr. Clinton fueled speculation that he was seeking a role in an Obama administration, saying, "I know my way around the Oval Office, and I know how the super-secret double-lock works."
The former president said he would relish a return to the White House, calling his tenure there "good times."
For her part, Sen. Clinton said that the defection of her husband would not deter her from staying in the race, adding, "To my knowledge, he's the only white voter Sen. Obama has."
The New York senator denied that she was playing the race card, arguing, "Every other member of my family is supporting me, and by the way, they're white."
Elsewhere, a defiant John McCain said that his wife will not release her tax returns, "and neither will my girlfriend."
My gosh ~Jim~ don't scare me like that. I'm a old man.
Cindy is not wrong about Obama.
Don't make me feel so good this early in the morning. "Hep me!" Kem "my man," you wrong about Hilary "3AM I need to nuke somebody" Klanton.
Hey Cindy, Hang in there, it isn't going to get easier; but, the toughest parts will get a little shorter.
In your oblique references to Pelosi and Bush you are presuming that they would act differently if it were their children being killed. They would not! The love of money, and the perversion of the human spirit that it entails, will assure that their actions remain the same. Avarice has no legitimate children.
You be very careful of yourself and get someone to watch your back. As soon as you get to be a threat to their goals, the lice at the head of our government will have you silenced. Get competent help.
Regards, Spike
Cindy - I'm waiting for my stimulus check so I can send you $$$ for your campaign. Waiting...
jclientelle,
I'm still waiting for my peace dividend check from the 20th Century.