EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
- Wisconsin Bill Would Treat Organic Milk, Sharp Cheddar, Brown Eggs as "Junk Food"
- Patent Filing Claims Solar Energy ‘Breakthrough’
- Climate Change's 'Evil Twin': Ocean Acidification
- Disaster Capitalism Strikes as Hedge Funds Circle Near-Bankrupt Municipalities Like Vultures
- Ignoring Bee Crisis, EPA Greenlights New 'Highly Toxic' Pesticide
- Patent Filing Claims Solar Energy ‘Breakthrough’
- Wisconsin Bill Would Treat Organic Milk, Sharp Cheddar, Brown Eggs as "Junk Food"
- Climate Change's 'Evil Twin': Ocean Acidification
- In 'March Toward Disaster,' World Hits 400 PPM Milestone
- Ignoring Bee Crisis, EPA Greenlights New 'Highly Toxic' Pesticide
Popular content
Today's Top News
No Cow Left Behind
I'm confused. Is today Presidents' Day, or Groundhog Day? The news cycle's stuck in a wretched rut: the aftermath of yet another school shooting; another suicide bombing in Afghanistan; another story about how the FDA left a dangerous drug on the market while thousands died needlessly; oh, and yet another beef recall.
But this recall -- 143 million pounds of beef from a California meat-packing plant -- sets a new record. The previous record was a mere 35 million pounds, back in 1999.
Will the meat from the Westland Meat Packing Company in Chino make you sick? Depends on what the meaning of "sick" is. If, by "sick", you mean, will it give you mad cow disease, or E. coli, or salmonella? There's only a "remote possibility," according to Dick Raymond, undersecretary of agriculture for food safety.
If, however, by "sick," you mean nauseated by the gut-wrenching undercover video depicting Westland employees abusing "downer" cows -- i.e. those too ill or injured to stand ( and perhaps not fit to eat) -- well, then, the answer is definitely yes. The footage, brought to you courtesy of the Humane Society, shows workers "kicking cows, jabbing them near their eyes, ramming them with a forklift and shooting high-intensity water up their noses in an effort to force them to their feet for slaughter," as CNN reports.
Westland Meat's president, Steve Mendell, was naturally shocked, shocked, at the evidence of bovine water boarding and other agribiz atrocities documented by the Humane Society. When confronted about the video by the Washington Post, Mendell "expressed disbelief that employees used stun guns to get sick or injured animals on their feet for inspection:"
"That's impossible," he said, adding that "electrical prods are not allowed on the property."
Asked whether his employees use fork lifts to get moribund animals off the ground, he said: "I can't imagine that."
Asked whether water was sprayed up animals' noses to get them to stand up, he said: "That's absolutely not true."
"We have a massive humane treatment program here that we follow to the nth degree, so this doesn't even sound possible," Mendell said. "I don't stand out there all day, but to me it would be next to impossible."
Well, sure, as the head of a meat-packing plant, Mendell is too busy generating his own brand of bullshit to wade into the fecal matter coating the downer cows his company's been slaughtering and shipping off to school lunches and programs for the needy (guess they won't be getting another one of those Supplier of the Year awards for the National School Lunch Program like the one the USDA gave Westland for the 2004-2005 school year.)
With the Humane Society's video going viral faster than E. coli in a feedlot, Mendell fired the two employees identified in the video, describing their behavior as "a serious breach of our company's policies and training." California prosecutors have since filed animal cruelty charges against the two former employees, who insist, of course, that they were only following orders.
The individual who shot the footage, who's remaining anonymous in the hopes of infiltrating other slaughterhouses, told the Washington Post, "These were not rogue employees secretly doing these things...Every day, I would see downed cattle too sick or injured to stand or walk arriving at the slaughterhouse. Workers would do anything to get the cows to stand on their feet."
Although the methods exposed by the video are all forbidden by both California law and the USDA, the USDA actually lacks the authority to recall meat; all it can do is ask nicely. Westland has voluntarily agreed to pull all its raw and frozen beef products going back to February 1st, 2006, but most of that potentially downer cow-tainted meat has presumably already been downed.
USDA inspectors were at the Westland plant twice a day and saw nothing amiss, which is to say that these abuses simply constitute business as usual in America's abattoirs. But is this kind of institutionalized cruelty acceptable in our culture? Our pal Bonnie Powell over at the Ethicurean doesn't think so:
As the massive outcry in response to the Humane Society's expose of a California beef-processing plant shows, Americans are extremely sensitive to the mistreatment of animals -- even those we intend to eat. It would be nice if we showed we cared even half as much about the human-rights abuses that are epidemic in our cheap-food system.
At least the animals have got the Humane Society working on their behalf to shame the USDA into action; if only the workers who are getting chewed up and spit out by the factory farms had an equally effective, well-funded watchdog looking out for them.
Powell cites a disturbing six-part expose that ran last week in the Charlotte Observer about a North Carolina poultry processor whose workers are subjected to awful conditions and routinely denied medical care. Many of the workers are here illegally and therefore afraid to speak up, making them easy to exploit. Serious injuries go unreported to OSHA, which is supposed to ensure worker safety but, according to the Observer, "is allowing employers to vastly underreport the number of injuries and illnesses their workers suffer."
The Observer's series followed a strange and scary story in the New York Times about a mystery malady afflicting a dozen workers at a Minnesota pork processing plant. The workers, who suffered a serious neurological disorder, all had one thing in common; part of their job entailed harvesting pig brains, which get shipped to China and Korea, by blasting compressed air into the pigs' skulls, which, according to the Times, turned "the brain into a slurry that squirted out through the same hole in the skull, often spraying brain tissue around and splattering the hose operator in the process."
Powell sums it up best:
The meat industry in this country is broken from start to finish. We take ruminants and feed them grain their stomachs weren't designed to eat, treating them like garbage disposals for our industrial leftovers; implant steroids so they'll grow faster; feed them antibiotics so they can survive the poor diets and crowded feedlot conditions; then ship them to slaughterhouses where they are killed and processed at speeds that practically beg for bacterial contamination and worker injuries.
Industrial livestock production relies on the systemic abuse of cows, pigs, chickens, and the workers who process them in order to bring us cheap meat. When did Americans develop such a taste for torture, anyway? I'm tired of having to read and write about this stuff; aren't you sick of eating it?
Co-founder of EatingLiberally.org, a netroots website & organization that advocates sustainable agriculture, progressive politics and a less-consumption driven way of life.
Copyright © 2008 HuffingtonPost.com, Inc.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

78 Comments so far
Show AllAmericans are extremely sensitive to the mistreatment of animals — even those we intend to eat.
Oh, that's rich. Meat-eaters don't give a damn about animals.
People, in general, don't give a damn about anything UNLESS it affects them directly.
Animals being abused for food and medicine and entertainment? Gimme a steak.
Global warming? Turn up the thermostat.
Millions around the world dying from lack of fresh water? Screw them.
Iraqis dying in an illegal war? F*ck 'em, then nuke 'em.
Poverty raging through the US? Get a job.
The paster needs a new Cadillac? Give him a donation because he prays for me.
Gee, is there a pattern here?
Upton Sinclair reported similar events some fifty years ago in his book "The Jungle." This led to major reforms being made in the meatpacking industry. Unfortunately, with the US Treasury bleeding away 3 billion dollars every week to colonize and steal the resources of another far away country, we don't have the money to pay for trivial things like meat inspection, health insurance, clean air and water and even the overall health of the country's children.
WTF
yes, it's called psychosis..........
WTF- I am inclined to agree that it is psychosis, collective psychosis.
You seem angry. That's understandable but it is a trap.
"The sight of evil kindles evil in the soul- there is no getting away from this fact…..the wickedness of others becomes our own wickedness because it kindles something evil in our own hearts. Indignation leaps up, angry cries of 'Justice!' pursue the murderer, and they are louder, more impassioned and more charged with hate the more fiercely burns the fire of evil that has been lit in our souls. True, we are innocent, we are the victims, robbed, betrayed, outraged; and yet for all that, or precisely because of it, the flame of evil glowers in our moral indignation."-C. Jung
If we project out our hostility, we participate in a feedback loop. Anger feeds evil and will never defeat it. There is but one force capable of eliminating evil. It is compassion. If you wish to combat evil, this is your only effective "weapon".
It took me 50 years to learn this-
Heat is energy. Cold is not. Cold is simply the relative absence of heat. One cannot manufacture a machine that produces cold. To make something cold, remove the heat.
Light is energy. Darkness is not. Darkness is simply the relative absence of light. One cannot manufacture a machine that produces darkness. To make something dark, remove the light.
Compassion (love) is energy. Evil is not. Evil is the relative absence of compassion. To make something evil, remove compassion.
The degree to which one lacks compassion is the degree to which one serves evil. This is true regardless of religious beliefs, political alignment or anything else.
Imagine yourself in a giant auditorium with all of the lights turned off. Total darkness. In your hand is a flashlight. A flick of the thumb sends a beam through the darkness. While the flashlights beam is not infinitely powerful, all of the darkness in the universe, if you could bring it into the auditorium, would have no effect on it whatsoever. There is no battle between darkness and light. Darkness is powerless. The battle takes place in the thumb.
The battle is between that which is separate from all else (ego) and that which is connected to all else (spirit).
Also from C.Jung-"...modern man is forced to recognize that he is politically and morally just like everyone else. Whereas I formally believed it to be my bounden duty to call other persons to order, I now admit that I need calling to order myself."
Truth Faerie
The_truth_faerie@yahoo.com
Why do some announce that we must choose who to care for-humans or animals? This is a false dichotomy, most often used by those who wish to destroy habitat, and use "jobs, jobs, jobs" as the mantra chanted to enable the destruction.
We can, and do, care about the animals and the workers involved in industrial slaughter. It may have been funny when Lucy got a job at the chocolate factory, and couldn't keep up with the pace, but it's outrageous when animals are pushed along the assembly line and skinned and boiled while still alive.
Last week, in Common Dreams, they had an article about this video and the emphasis was on the possible harm to carnivorous Americans from the downed cow consumption, and not to the brutal methods used to get sick cows to move to the assembly line for massacre. I objected then to that emphasis. I object now to the statement that we don't care about the workers.
Except for the sadistic ones, of course. Just like I don't "support the troops" that rape, murder and steal from Iraqi civilians for the sheer psychotic fun of it.
The USDA choose not to inspect live cattle for mad cow.There are practically no inspections that fail meat, all is processed. Unless beef is grass fed to slaughter, it is unhealthy to eat. Buy local, buy grass fed, organic if possible.Grass fed beef has omega3 fats, and is healthy to eat, the other meat causes cancer, and other disease if eaten regularly.It's your choice, be informed. There's no trusting the Federal Government in any aspect of it's regulation of industry.State regulation also is suspect.Know where your food comes from, how it is grown.
Life is easier as a vegetarian. I encourage you all to join me.
Hey, Truth Faerie, I like your post.
"The meat industry in this country is broken from start to finish. We take ruminants and feed them grain their stomachs weren't designed to eat, treating them like garbage disposals for our industrial leftovers; implant steroids so they'll grow faster; feed them antibiotics so they can survive the poor diets and crowded feedlot conditions; then ship them to slaughterhouses where they are killed and processed at speeds that practically beg for bacterial contamination and worker injuries."
The first three words are the key, here: The meat industry. Actually, it's the third word: industry.
Truth_faerie wrote: You seem angry. That's understandable but it is a trap.
You are correct. I'm bloody furious.
I have read your posts and they do make sense.
But how do you explain that by adopting a nonviolent approach to animal exploiters in fact is a pro-violence stance that tolerates their blood-spilling without taking adequate measures to stop it?
In a broader context, revolution against oppressive governments means exchanging Gandhi for Machiavelli and switching principled nonviolence with the amoral (not to be confused with immoral) pragmatism that embraces liberation by any means necessary.
Indirect action means that we are the cattle being lead to the slaughterhouse.
I suggest people rent the movie "Fast Food Nation" and check out the Special Feature called "The Meatrix." It's informative, entertaining, and persuasive. People who have seen The Matrix will find it especially satirical.
In fact, people probably need to watch this educational cartoon at least once a week. I think we live in a time where common sense is trumped by daily propaganda through advertising. Look at how beef consumption goes down after mad cow outbreaks but over time beef consumption levels come back to where they were prior to the mad cow outbreak.
Allowing ourselves to be lulled back into destructive behaviors is only 1/2 the problem. In today's world "consumers" all need daily reminders of what we SHOULD be doing (walk more, eat organic, read more, watch less TV, spend more time in the real world and less time in the virtual world, get less info from MSM and more from Common Dreams). When we allow ads to convince us to make unhealthy choices like fast food, fast religion, cigarettes, meat, SUV's, coal power plants, war, and Access Hollywood, it shows that our lower impulses can easily be enlisted to steer us (no pun intended) towards physical, spiritual, and societal death.
Many of the most creative people who ever lived forego eating animals. Edison, can't think of the others. But it is a noble way of life and I admire those who adhere to it. It is the of the highest form of compassion. I am almost there myself... and the sooner the better!
Edison was vegetarian? I thought he was filming the electrocution of animals? Shaw, Pythagoros, Shelley, Byron, Spock(both Mr and Dr), Isaac Beshivis Singer, Einstein advocated vegetarianism but I dont think he was. Da Vinci was believed to be vegetarian.
This article is offensive. Humans dont treat non humans better than they treat humans. I dont have much sympathy for slaughterhouse workers anymore than I have sympathy for Nazi camp guards getting hand cramps from pulling gas chamber levers.
Gail Eisnitz in her Slaughterhouse book(1997) talks about workers taking their job frustrations out on their victims by gouging eyes out--a pig slaughterhouse was filmed doing this just a few weeks ago.
When it comes to the meat industry--humans are the victimizer, not the victim. When they face the consequences of their actions it is just blowback. Given the billions of non humans slaughtered every year--its a small bit of justice indeed.
An article well worth the read if you value your brain:
Could Mad Cow Disease Already be Killing Thousands of Americans Every Year?
by Michael Greger, M.D.
http://www.commondreams.org/views04/0107-07.htm
" In the United States, an unknown number of animals are infected with Mad Cow disease, causing an unknown number of human deaths from CJD. The U.S. should immediately begin testing all cows destined for human consumption, as is done in Japan, should stop feeding slaughterhouse waste to all farm animals. "
And if you want to fill your mind with information about brain eating prions, there are over 7,600 articles at:
http://www.mad-cow.org/
Bad news is that prions are nearly immortal !
And prevention is the only cure.
Here's a few more: Ghandi, H.G. Wells, Tolstoy, John Lennon, Albert Schweitzer, Bob Dylan, Coretta Scott King, Upton Sinclair (The Jungle), Thoreau, Rousseau, Isaac Newton, Ralph Waldo Emerson and Susan B Anthony.
Twenty-six years ago I worked as an overnight security guard in a slaughterhouse. As a result of that experience I do not eat meat. There is a smell in a slaughterhouse like no other, and if you have ever smelled it you will not forget it. Even now after all these years, if I sniff an uncooked steak I can still detect that smell, and it disgusts me. If you want your children to avoid eating meat just take them to a slaughterhouse for a visit (that is, if the plant owners will let you in). Better yet, schools should organize field trips to slaughterhouses, so that children can see (and smell) first-hand how it is that we treat those animals, and how meat is processed. If people really knew what went on in there they would not eat that sh*t, period.
WTF- I do not subscribe to any organized religion because I believe there is opacity to the rituals and dogma that hides the message. Many of the messages overlap-
Christianity
Luke 6
31 And as you wish that others would do to you, do so to them.
Buddhism
"Hurt not others in ways that you yourself would find hurtful" - Udanavarga
Judaism
"That which is hateful unto you, do not impose on others."-Talmud, Shabbat 31a
Hinduism
"Do naught unto others which would cause you pain if done to you."- Mahabharata 5:1517
Islam
Sunan
"No one of you is a believer until he desires for his brother that which he desires for himself."
Confucianism
"Do not unto others what you would not have them do unto you."-Analects 15:23
The following is attributed to Jesus in Matthew 5:38-41, Revised Standard Version-
"But I say to you, Do not resist one who is evil. But if anyone strikes you on the right cheek, turn to him the other also; and if anyone would sue you and take your coat, let him have your cloak as well; and if any one forces you to go one mile, go with him two miles." (attributed to Jesus in Matthew 5:38-41, Revised Standard Version)
There is a message here that is commonly interpreted as pacifism. That is not what it suggests. The explanation is longer than I should post here. Feel free to contact me via my email if you are interested.
My point is that "Turn the other cheek" is not a "pro-violence stance".
Also, Gandhi was very successful in fighting oppression, "liberation" through violence is not really liberation (its just more of the same) and there are many, many non-violent alternatives that are not at all "indirect".
The Truth Faerie
The_truth_faerie@yahoo.com
...And if you want your children to stop buying cheap throwaway junk, take them to a landfill, another sobering experience.
And thanks, Truth Faerie, for your calming words. The attitude here on CD get so hopeless and negative sometimes, I have immediately turn to DailyKos for a dose of constructive "positivity".
A good alternate to "righteous anger" is "fierce love". Rather than becoming disabled by hatred for the meatpackers, let's focus on our devotion to the physical health and moral well being of our fellow consumers... it leads to less grumbling and more action.
The next thing we need to do is stop fishing as it hurts greatly to have a fishook embedded in your throat, and if you don`t think so, try it. No one should eat any more fish until that cruel practice is stopped.
Some say cattle are skinned and boiled while still alive, which is untrue unless in a very few cases the animal recovered from being stunned to kill it. However, it is common practice to drop lobsters into boiling water while still alive, so no more lobster for any of us either.
All abuse to animals and humans is certainly to be kept watch on, so we need to remember that there are millions of humans being killed, tortured, starved, in the world with no one doing anything about that.
Some of the problems at packing plants may have developed as a result of Bush and his war using the countries resources and leaving little for regulative agencies. There are many bad things happening in the world and our country, so we need to keeep a little perspective on all of them.
Some congratulations are in order here, in the midst of all the outrage and horror. You and I and our anonymous videographer and the Humane Society have succeeded in bringing the truth about the meat industry to last night's mainstream news in full color in all its stomach wrenching nastiness. Fans of NBC news now know what their children eat and how it is produced, unless of course they were able to look away in time to shut it out. This story hit CD a week ago, and instead of dying inside the circle of a few bleeding hearts in the progressive community it actually hit the fan like a ton of shit, cost the meat industry a ton of money, made the government inspection program look worse than FEMA and created god knows how many new vegetarians. Good going. I am pleased to be in your company.
Ever met a door to door meat salesman? I actually met one out in Washington one time. How weird is that? His slogan was, "Meat: It's in Your Face"
Was that supposed to be sarcasm, Kernel? Because you're damn right I don't eat lobster, precisely because they are boiled alive!
And my basic point is that we can be concerned about animals and people. It's not an either-or principle, except to those who try to minimize concern for animals by pointing to oppressed people.
Sorry. Not falling for your tactic. I care about animals who are pushed along the assembly line so fast that no one cares if they are stunned or killed before the harvest starts. And I care about the human victims of imperialism and globalization.
ecoalex: The USDA choose not to inspect live cattle for mad cow.
It's worse then that - the Federal government refused to let a small meatpacker run mad cow tests so they could sell to Japan. The government decided it would make the major meatpacking plants look bad. Consumer confidence was paramount and the way to achieve it was by refusing to allow anyone from attempting to raise the bar even for a foreign market (which mandated testing).
USDA needs teeth. They should be able to shut plants down. Can't really trust a local health department to shut down the only employer of a town. Course, the USDA would also need the will, which is likely lacking thanks to Bush.
Truth Faerie - In chapter two of The Meditations by Marcus Aurelius it says to suffer the fools as also a manifestation of the Devine.
Samual Colt was of another opinion. Something about Needs Killin.
This piece sent me to my American Heritage dictionary looking for a definition of compassion and it said....compassion is "a deep feeling of sharing the suffering of another; mercy."
We all consume what has lived. But showing compassion/mercy if one chooses to eat meat, and it is all about choice, is to purchase ethically raised animals/plants and to not support those who do otherwise. That may mean a change in your diet. All great movements start small with an increased awareness that makes change called for, preferable and finally the only option available.
@ The Truth Faerie
Please add Wiccan to your list: "Do no harm".
I understand all that you quote, which are all humanist. They, however, do not address the protection of the weak and the innocent. We can continue this off-line, but until I next write to you, I will leave you this quote from Gandhi:
The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated ... I hold that, the more helpless a creature, the more entitled it is to protection by man from the cruelty of man. - Mohandas Gandhi
I care about humans that work in these slaughter houses. It must drive them insane after awhile. There was a plant here that you could smell for miles around. A new neighbor worked there for many years. He is certifiable and has cancer. There should be worker protections.
Also, I wonder if that is the same Steve Mendall that owns restaurants. Anyway, he is incompetent and should be fired, along with most of the other people responsible for food safety and humane treatment of workers and animals in his care.
Light vs. Dark
Will someone please stand up and reveal themselves not as the personification of all that is good or all that is cynical, but as a mix of light and dark, since that is the nature of humanity? We all carry the potential for good and the potential for evil in us, everything else is "I told you so."
Kerry Trueman states: "At least the animals have got the Humane Society working on their behalf to shame the USDA into action; if only the workers who are getting chewed up and spit out by the factory farms had an equally effective, well-funded watchdog looking out for them."
Such lucky animals. The "workers" are not being led to slaughter are they? The ENTIRE INDUSTRY needs to be shut down. It has been nothing but a horror show since it's inception. And as long as people have not had to witness exctly where the meat they consume comes from, they do not care.
Over time, I have changed my attitudes about consuming meat, and now I'm a vegetarian and better off for it.
Also, I agree with Kelmer's comment.
"Industrial livestock production relies on the systemic abuse of cows, pigs, chickens, and the workers who process them in order to bring us cheap meat. When did Americans develop such a taste for torture, anyway? I'm tired of having to read and write about this stuff; aren't you sick of eating it?"
I sure am. I guess it's never too late for New Year's resolution. Mine is to begin availing myself of my local farmers and food co-ops for the food I put on my table.
Kudos to the Humane Society for their excellent work.
Greenerthanthou,
"Was that supposed to be sarcasm, Kernel? Because you're damn right I don't eat lobster, precisely because they are boiled alive!"
I feel the same way. I've always loved the taste of lobster, but I can't bear the thought of dropping a living thing into a pot of boiling water. A gruesome and unnecessary practice. Lobsters can be swiftly and humanely killed prior to cooking. For those who still wish to partake, ask the restaurant manager which method is used.
Part of the problem is that these places hire desperate people. Anyone else would quit or protest these barbaric practices.
My regrets to Kerry Trueman and the vegetarians and vegans commenting here, but I'm a meat-eater and have no intention of stopping just because animals have been killed in a very ugly fashion. I was born an omnivore (my teeth and my digestive system back up this claim), I was raised in a meat-eating family, and I like a mixture of meat and vegetables in what I eat. So do many, many of the other omnivore animals that inhabit this planet. I'm human, and so I'm an omnivore, and I can't change that fact. Denying it and covering it up by converting to veganism or vegetarianism just won't work for me. However, if it makes you feel better, more power to you. You have your own conscience to tend to, and that's cool by me. Allow me the same consideration.
That said, I deplore cruelty to animals, and what happened at Westland was not only cruel and ugly, but illegal, and I hope the guilty are prosecuted and held to account. I also realize that feedlots and birdyards and commercial fisheries do great damage to the environment, but even if I lived on a subsistance farm I'd probably still raise chickens at least, and I'd kill them as humanely as I could. But I wouldn't stop eating chicken; it's just not in my nature.
And sorry, but I love lobster and boiling them alive is the best cooking method we know of (I think; I'd be happy to be informed otherwise). I just can't bring myself to believe that a crustacean is a sentient creature on a par with humans, and to project the notion that a lobster is writhing in pain in the same sense that a human being would feel pain by being boiled alive is to indulge in a fantasy.
HALLMARK WESTLAND MEAT
I just don't see why people abuse an upstanding man like Mr. Mendell. They show some phony film of people torturing cows, and now he has to talk to the press. Poor guy, can't we leave him alone to hobnob with the other rich folks in Aspen (or wherever the "in" place is this year; I'm too "out" to know).
Those films are sickening. "no cattle prods on the property" indeed. I hope this company goes bankrupt over this. If the employees I saw are a representative sample, I don't give a damn about their jobs.
I have to admit, the expose by the Humane Society put me over the edge. I haven't had a bite of meat since.
I have always had periods where I was strict vegetarian, and times where I ate meat. I still eat fish. I have caught fish and killed them myself, and I don't have any problem with it. The best tasting thing I've ever had in my life is fresh Copper River red salmon that I caught and cooked myself.
I will continue to eat fish. And, in all truth, I don't have a problem with hunting. Environmentally, it was always a good thing. Look at how nice the country was when the Indians had it. And sometimes I feel that asking people to give up meat to "save the planet" is going to be about as successful as asking people to give up sex. We know how well that has always worked.
But ever since the Humane Society did this film, and one author of an article on this website described scenes from the film as showing cows with rods rammed through their skulls while leaving them alive, to be strung up on hooks, I was done.
ogf
This is social manipulation of course, these bastards do not care about humane treatment of animals or people for that matter. Cloned-genetically modified patented food is all you are going to see in the future, that is if your papers are in order.
@Forrest Prince
You must be very odd looking if you have teeth/jaw/digestive system of an omnivore, and I feel sorry for your rare condition. I hope the circus pays you well.
Human physiology is herbivorous, not omnivorous. Please get your facts right. Our teeth/jaw/digestive system are consistent with that of a herbivore. Anything else is meat-eating apologist fantasy. See this link to get the facts:
http://www.goveg.com/naturalhumandiet_physiology.asp
You know, I'm starting to see a parallel between being a vegetarian and voting for, say, a Green Party candidate:
If you don't eat meat yourself, you don't do all that much to prevent global warming or animal suffering, but if you help start a movement to encourage others to do the same, you do.
If you don't vote dem or repub yourself, you don't do all that much to change the voting system in this country, but if you help start a movement to encourage others to do the same, you do.
Forrest Prince -
I love your name but if you seriously believe you are biologically equipped for eating flesh you should go look at a cat's or dog's teeth and compare them to yours - Yikes! I hope you don't look like that! In addition, meat eating mammals have short digestive tracts about 3-4 times the length of their body to keep the meat from becoming rancid/rotten inside, while vegetarian mammals have digestive tracts more like 12 times their body length - like humans. This is why many human carnivores have distended stomachs. Check out the diet of primates, the animals we humans evolved from: fruit, nuts, roots, and fresh greens with the occasional insect binge. Yum!!
Perhaps the best reason to steer away (pun intended) from a flesh oriented diet is the horrible abuse these animals are subjected to during the entirety of their lives (yes, there are exceptions, I grew up on a family farm with happy animals). The horrendous diets and chemicals they are force-fed while being subjected to cruel and sadistic treatment are not only physically unhealthy but will lead those who eat them to spiritually stagnant and stunted lives. Sure, vegetables are harvested from their nice earthy homes before being eaten, but nobody slaps them around or anything. Up to 15% of US cattle grain feed (cows and other ruminants are supposed to eat grass, not grains) is made from - wait for it - COWS! This cannibalistic practice is what leads to the formation of prions aka Mad Cow Disease.
While compiling the list of super-achieving vegetarians you must include one of the greatest minds of all time: Nikola Tesla. His rival and former boss, Thomas Edison, was a cruel and sadistic man who routinely tortured and killed animals, even in public and on film. Edison also invented the electric chair.
Animals are for petting.
The media is treating this incident as an aberration. It's not; it's business as usual. That's how McDonald's and Burger King can offer you $1 double cheeseburgers.
Here in Ca, there are mobile killers. They drive to your farm, shoot the animal humanely, they drop with one shot, and are bled out.They are then raised up, skinned, gutted, the head cut off, and then split in half, all in a clean enviornment. No mechanical eviseration, so no coliform contamination. The halves then are hoisted into a stainless box, and taken to a cooler to hang over a week, then the halves are cut up to the order.This is the best way to humanely kill, and dress animals, out in the sunlight, with a clean competent butcher.I sell grass fed angus beef, pork, poultry, all farm dressed.I grow the feed with eco principles. My meat is consciously raised, and humanely cared for.The demand is more than what I can satisfy, even tho processing prices are absurd.People are glad to see how I raise the animals, and know I too consume them.
We consume the carcasses of creatures of like appetites, passions and organs with our own, and fill the slaughterhouses daily with screams of pain and fear. - Robert Louis Stevenson
WTF & Mouse,
Sorry, guys, but Forest Prince is right. You're both comparing the human digestive system to that of carnivores (fangs for tearing flesh; short, fast digestive tract designed to maximize protein extraction). Human beings are not carnivores. Nor are they herbivores (lack fangs of any kind; chew their food into cud; usually have two or more stomachs; very long, slow digestive tracts designed to maximize carbohydrate and plant protein extraction from cellulose-encased plant material).
Human beings are omnivores, like bears, pigs, opossums and chimpanzees, designed to consume both meat and plant material. We do not have fangs, but a more blunted version we call eye teeth. Our digestive tract is moderately long, designed to extract both proteins and carbohydrates. Our mouths are not designed to chew our food into cud in order to break down the indigestible cellulose casing. Our bodies, in fact, cannot extract the majority of the nutrients from raw plant material, and we must steam or blanch our vegetables in order to weaken the cellulose skin in order to get maximum nutritional benefit.
I think Forest Prince was very respectful of your choice to lead a vegetarian/vegan lifestyle, as am I. I applaud your motives. But please don't be so quick to dismiss the honest expression of his concern for animals, especially not with misinformation.
Forest Prince,
Well, I make no claims on the sentience of lobsters, LOL. Granted, their brain is about the same size as a housefly's, but I don't pull the wings off of houseflies, either!
Here's an excellent webpage with clear instructions on humanely dispatching a lobster:
http://secretlifeoflobsters.com/blog/2005_12_18_archive.asp
Pass the melted buttah!
Ecoalex,
Kudos to you for your eco-friendly and responsible approach. The demand for your products is testiment to a rising public awareness of the darker side of mass production. The big guys could take a lesson from you!
Saddest part is, even if this worthy effort works, thereby reducing meat eating significantly, it will only be time bought by the financial dominant to build robot attack jets with which to human slaughter.
Vegan agriculture is by far more efficient, capable of supporting 24 billion people with Earths arable land, compared with 1.3 billion people that could be supported eating the standard American diet. Which incidently, the standard American diet, is waxing popularity worldwide, increasing demand for the golden arches.
8 billion arable acres, .3 acres per person vegan diet, 1.2 acres per person required for todays worldwide average diet.
All of which means that by todays agricultural system we have maximized the carrying capacity of the planet. The best solution is a move to the by far more efficient vegan diet. The bulk of the solution chosen by the present powers, evidenced by budgetary appropriation, is mass murder by pinnacle military solutions.
One soon to disappear crummy graphicless article about vegan efficience vs 500 billion dollars per year worth of blasting and melting honed to high efficience murderous weapons, deployed far and wide and so high, out of reach...
http://www.albinoblacksheep.com/flash/cowswithguns
Listen to the music.
http://www.cowswithguns.com/lyrics2/lyrics_for_public/cows_with_guns_lyrics.htmlAmFat
Cows with Guns by Dana Lyons, copyright 1996
Fat and docile, big and dumb
They look so stupid, they aren't much fun
Cows aren't fun
They eat to grow, grow to die
Die to be et at the hamburger fry
Cows well done
Nobody thunk it, nobody knew
No one imagined the great cow guru
Cows are one
He hid in the forest, read books with great zeal
He loved Che Guevera, a revolutionary veal
Cow Tse Tongue
He spoke about justice, but nobody stirred
He felt like an outcast, alone in the herd
Cow doldrums
He mooed we must fight, escape or we'll die
Cows gathered around, cause the steaks were so high
Bad cow pun
But then he was captured, stuffed into a crate
Loaded onto a truck, where he rode to his fate
Cows are bummed
He was a scrawny calf, who looked rather woozy
No one suspected he was packing an Uzi
Cows with guns
They came with a needle to stick in his thigh
He kicked for the groin, he pissed in their eye
Cow well hung
Knocked over a tractor and ran for the door
Six gallons of gas flowed out on the floor
Run cows run!
He picked up a bullhorn and jumped up on the hay
We are free roving bovines, we run free today
We will fight for bovine freedom
And hold our large heads high
We will run free with the Buffalo, or die
Cows with guns
They crashed the gate in a great stampede
Tipped over a milk truck, torched all the feed
Cows have fun
Sixty police cars were piled in a heap
Covered in cow pies, covered up deep
Much cow dung
Black smoke rising, darkening the day
Twelve burning McDonalds, have it your way
We will fight for bovine freedom
And hold our large heads high
We will run free with the Buffalo, or die
Cows with guns
The President said "enough is enough
These uppity cattle, its time to get tough"
Cow dung flung
The newspapers gloated, folks sighed with relief
Tomorrow at noon, they would all be ground beef
Cows on buns
The cows were surrounded, they waited and prayed
They mooed their last moos,
they chewed their last hay
Cows out gunned
The order was given to turn cows to whoppers
Enforced by the might of ten thousand coppers
But on the horizon surrounding the shoppers
Came the deafening roar of chickens in choppers
We will fight for bovine freedom
And hold our large heads high
We will run free with the Buffalo, or die
Cows with guns
Copyright 1996 Lyons Brothers Music (BMI)
PO Box 2627, Bellingham, WA 98227 USA
All Rights Reserved
www.cowswithguns.com
> Nikola Tesla. His rival and former boss, Thomas Edison ... invented the electric chair.
Tesla was a brilliant visionary. He hated Jews. Later in life, he arguably went insane, which is also when he became a vegetarian. I don't think going vegetarian made him insane or that only insane people become vegetarians. I just mention it because if you're going to embrace the man as one of your own, you should know what you're embracing.
Thomas Edison was invested in selling DC equipment. Tesla was into AC. Edison used AC for the electric chair to prove that Tesla's AC was inherently more deadly then Edison's DC. I doubt changing Edison's diet to raw food vegan would've changed Edison into a nicer guy.
oldgrowthforest___"Look how nice the country was when the Indians had it".
Yes it was very peaceful, except you are forgetting how they killed their buffalo. They stampeded entire herds of buffalo over a high cliff and one can imagine the suffering involved when they hit bottom.
There has always been cruelty to both animals and humans and always will be, as for example our compassionate president thinks torture is needed and acceptable and many people now are in confusion about that.
We should continue to attempt to stop all suffering everywhere but it is not necessary to let one publicized event make us paranoid and end up doing more harm than good. Do not lump all people that raise or handle animals together as abusers as it is the few that are the problem, as in most other areas.
grumpyoldlady
Clearly, you did not read the link I gave. Humans are closer to the great apes than chimps, and all the great apes are vegetarian. Gorillas have quite sharp canines, considerably moreso than the blunt things we have, so any argument about having canines entails that we eat meat is specious. Even many deer have caninies. Pandas too. Jane Goodall, whose work with chimpanzees represents the longest continuous field study of any living creature in science history, says chimpanzees often go months without eating any meat whatsoever. Indeed, she says, "The total amount of meat consumed by a chimpanzee during a given year will represent only a very small percentage of the overall diet. Chimps are opportunist meat-eaters, not hunters. Ditto humans. Whatever meat we ate was scavenged. Omnivores have minimal side-to-side jaw motion, which is quite well-developed in humans and herbivores. Our stomach acid is weak compared with carni/omnivores. I could go on. Just read the article and get back to us, OK?
Here's another good read: http://www.foodrevolution.org/askjohn/30.htm