Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
- This Is What Happens When You Rip a Hole in the Safety Net
- So Your Groundwater's Poison and Your Tap Water's On Fire. Not to Worry: Fracking Chemicals Are Trade Secrets You Don't Need To Know About
- An Outpouring of Love and Support for Bradley Manning to Receive the Nobel Peace Prize
- Exxon Tar Sands Spill Continues to Devastate Arkansas Community
- The Treason of Intellectuals
Popular content
Today's Top News
Musharraf: Bhutto to Blame for Her Assassination
RAWALPINDI, Pakistan - Former Pakistani Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto's assassination was her own fault, the country's president, Pervez Musharraf, said in an interview on U.S. television."For standing up outside the car, I think it was she to blame alone -- nobody else. Responsibility is hers," the former general told CBS' "60 Minutes" on Sunday.
Bhutto was killed December 27 in Rawalpindi, south of the Pakistani capital Islamabad, while she was standing in an armored moving car after rallying supporters for now-postponed parliamentary elections. Her head was above the roof and unprotected at the time of the attack.
The cause of her death is not clear: a bomber blew himself up near Bhutto's limousine and videotape showed a gunman present, though no autopsy has been carried out.
Asked if Bhutto could have been shot, Musharraf said, "Yes, absolutely, yes. Possibility." He has said he welcomes an international investigation.
Musharraf, who seized power in a bloodless coup in 1999, rejected criticism that his government did not do enough to provide security to Bhutto, who was seeking to regain the post of prime minister. He noted that she had already survived one assassination attempt and "was given more security than any other person."
Asked about the hunt for al Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden, widely rumored to be in the remote border region between Pakistan and Afghanistan, Musharraf said, "There is no proof whatsoever that he's here. We are not particularly looking for him, but we are operating against this -- and al Qaeda and militant Taliban. And in the process, obviously, it is combined. Maybe we are looking for him also."
And Pakistan's ambassador to the United States, Mahmud Ali Durrani, told CNN's "Late Edition with Wolf Blitzer" that, "If we knew where he was, we would have taken him out."
Durrani added that Musharraf's comment about "not specifically looking for Osama" means that the Pakistani military is "totally focused on destroying al Qaeda and the Taliban network and not just one person."
About Bhutto's death, he noted only that the investigation is not completed "and we should not jump to conclusions."
Still, he added, "if she had not come out of the vehicle, the protected and armored vehicle, maybe we would have seen her smiling face again today."
Though Musharraf's popularity at home has plummeted, he retains support from GOP presidential contender Sen. John McCain.
"I think he's a good man," the Arizonan told NBC's "Meet the Press." "But I think he's made mistakes, don't get me wrong. And we've got to move forward with these elections and have them free and fair.
"But I can work with him. He understands the threat to his country that the Taliban and al Qaeda present. And radical Islamic extremists. He's a very smart man. He'd be one of the first to go. They've tried to kill him nine times, OK? Nine times they've tried to kill Musharraf. He's not their favorite guy."
The New York Times reported Sunday that the Bush administration is considering expanding covert operations in the western part of Pakistan to shore up support for Musharraf's government and to find bin Laden and his second in command, Ayman al-Zawahiri. Democratic presidential candidate Bill Richardson of New Mexico told CNN's "Late Edition with Wolf Blitzer" that, though he had not heard details of the plan, "it sounds like a strategy that makes sense."
He added, "We have got to take whatever action is needed."
Richardson has called for Musharraf to step down and has called for free and fair elections.
"What we need to do is ask Musharraf, push him, push him to step aside for the good of the country, because he is widely unpopular," he told CNN.
Sen. Hillary Clinton, a Democratic presidential candidate from New York, said Saturday that she would try to persuade Musharraf to share the responsibility for safeguarding his country's nuclear weapons with a delegation from the United States and perhaps Great Britain.
Meanwhile, detectives from Britain's Scotland Yard on Sunday once again examined the white Land Cruiser that Bhutto was riding in when she was assassinated, Pakistan's state-run news agency said.
The Associated Press of Pakistan said the detectives also watched videos of Bhutto's last moments three times, and looked at bird's eye view photographs of Liaqat Bagh park taken from a building that overlooks the Rawalpindi public site.
The team of five detectives arrived in Pakistan Friday after Musharraf agreed they should work alongside Pakistani agencies to determine how Bhutto was killed and who was responsible for her death.
On Saturday, the team spent more than two hours at the park.
Musharraf said he expected the Scotland Yard investigators to help "solve all the confusion" surrounding the case. Bhutto's husband, Asif Ali Zardari, wants a United Nations inquiry into his late wife's assassination.
The Pakistan interior ministry say the former leader died when she hit her head on the lever of her car's sunroof after ducking for cover after a suicide bomb attack on her convoy.
However, supporters of Bhutto insist she was shot prior to the explosion -- a view that some say is supported by video footage of the moments before the blast.
© 2007 CNN
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

16 Comments so far
Show AllDUH ! Of course Mushraff is going to blame Bhutto not that either one of them ever really represented most Pakistanis anyway. Besides, as long as the American people ignore the fact that their UBERcorrupt MISleadership supports these kinds of pathetically brutal dictatorships, we'll be entitled to shit like this !
I think that Mushy meant out of all those responsible for her safety - I don't think he was counting the bomber or the shooter.
Presumably, Mushy heard of a threat in that park and told Bhutto to cancel the speaking engagement. He is feeling a bit frustrated that he is getting the blame when he figured that he did all he could under the circumstance - and is basically melting down.
That said, he shouldn't be blaming a murder victim for her own murder.
Scotland Yard seems to want to be able to look at the body.
Whether Bhutto was shot or died trying to avoid the bullets (or both) - it matters that both the shooter and the bomber were trying to kill her. If she ducked as the bomb went off (which would make ballance unsteady) and hit her head - she could have died from that. Even if a bullet hit her, it could have been being shaken as she fell that caused her to die first. Depends where the bullet hit her.
Or it could have been the bullet.
I don't think that Mushy really cares how she died - only that he is being blamed for it.
He seemed visibly shaken after Bhutto's death. I wonder if it was the loss of someone he knew as an opponent or fear that he would be held responsible for it when he had nothing to do with it.
I think he is frightened because both that he doesn't want to give up office (which seems inevitable now) and because he fears what will happen to him if this gets pinned on him.
Mushy has all the appearances of a cornered rat.
So, the assissin isn't the one responsible???? Bhutto shot herself? I wonder how his assessment played in Pakistan?
Assassins - there was at least the shooter and the bomber - and the people who organised it behind the scenes.
I think that the whole thing is language semantics.
The assassins were not responsible for Bhutto's safety, because it was their mandate to undermine it. Thus, one cannot accuse them of failing to keep Bhutto safe - or of failing to take the proper precautions to insure Bhutto's safety.
If the question is who is responsible for Bhutto's death out of everyone - it is, of course, the assassins.
However, if you limit your scope to only those who failed in their responsibility for Bhutto's safety - Mushy was making the point that it wasn't him.
Maybe there was something that he could have and should have done differently. And we will probably find it.
But is Mushy the assassin?
..........
One shouldn't blame the rape victim for being raped on the way to Sev to get a gulp.
But one should not blame the husband or the or the son, or the talking house plant either - unless one can prove culpability.
...........
We will probably find that neither Mushy or Bhutto took all the safety precautions that they should have. Just like with the school shootings.
Taking proper police precautions during the Dawson College shooting was credited with limiting the carnage and not taking proper police precautions during Virginia Tech was credited with making the carnage worse that it should have otherwise been.
But, would you say that the police killed those students and teachers?!
mushy is an asshole
Sure he's an asshole, but the US government benefits if we see him as more than just the run of the mill asshole. That is the point.
Well, a lot of people blamed JFK for riding in an open convertable.
What MUSH didn't say is, "If not there, we would have gotten her to hit her head and kill herself someplace else."
As for the "security" in place at the time of the shooting/bombing, I saw the videos, and there's NO security of any import around Bhutto's car.
This was Pakistan's 9/11. Musharraf knew Bhutto was in danger all the time. But no security, nothing 2 protect her. She had 2 protect herself, and bless her for not being afraid 2 speak the truth even when there's a target on her back. Musharraf may not be responsible, but he did nothing to prevent it. And now he's muddying up any investigation that could help (9/11, remember?). No doubt Musharaff is kinda at ease that she's dead, just like 9/11 helped Bush's poll numbers and the brewing war in Iraq. 9/11 was Bush's savior, and Bhutto's assassination, Musharraf believes, is his savior.
Let there be an international investigation into this! And put minds at ease. As for Mush, he HAS to step down!!! Him and his dictator-loving buddy Bush have to step down. Step down! Pakistan doesnt want Islamic fundamentalists or military dictatorship - they want peace, human rights, and democracy! Just what Bhutto lived and died for.
It seems as if Musharraf has learned a few lessons on obfuscation from Karl Rove. The bald faced ludicrousness of the claim becomes apparent if one merely applies a basic tenet of crime investigation: who profits from the act? Undoubtedly, Musharraf did, as did those in the ISI with their hands in the Taliban cookie jar. Someone should've told Musharraf that Rove has been off his game for more than a year.
Hey, if we get too pissed off at Mushy, then the US will have to go into Pakistan to maintain order.
That is what the whole thing is about.
I don't mean that the US should do nothing as far as Pakistan is concerned. Putting more troops there, or pushing Musharref aside, is not the answer though.
That will only serve the purpose of the rebels who want to inflame this siuation and are hoping the US would play into this scenario and make the US the bad guy, again, in the Middle East! They hate us enough already!
Time to do something different! There is a lot we can do diplomatically and economically! And we should....
We truly aren't welcome, so why bother (oil?); it would be, oh so smart, to keep a distance and let the Brits do the work this time.
And, in the meantime, the US can, and should, move against Pakistan in a political way - impose sanctions, withhold funds, withdraw our ambassador, if necessary, in order to show our concerns for this volatile situation.
Let's work smarter and not harder here! About time our reactionary government stopped hair trigger reactions to the issues of the rest of the world. Let the Brits do what they do best, and they were there first!
Maybe it is time to start work on the home front? (heavens forbid, there's been so many failures). Our aggressive imperialistic president needs to look at domestic issues and stop distracting the public with international concerns. (Oh, yes, if he only would!)
It's time to grow up and clean up our home front first and set an example for the rest of the world by cleaning up our own act first. (Would that this could be part of the plan!)
We do live in "intersting times", don't we?
Expanding covert operations in Pakistan would be the worst thing the US could do! Let the Brits do the investigation.
Our government needs to stay out of this one and let it play out instead of interfering again. That kind of move would really inflame an already hot issue of US military occupation in the region. There is a lot of hatred toward the US already for the situations in Afghanistan and Iraq.
Stepping in would exponentially increase this hatred - just what Al-Queda is hoping for! Duh! Wake up US....
Good - suicide - case closed. Thanks Mushy. Them opposition politicians are devious in their efforts to discredit you.
Similar thing happens to our dear leader too!
Benazir recently held an interview on British TV where she stated that OBL had been murdered by (I belive it was) "Omar Sheikh"...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UnychOXj9Tg
Maybe she was killed for letting the cat out of the bag about OBL, as well as for opposing Musharraf. Whatever the reason, she is definitley not to blame and all signs point to the current leader for her death, that would make it a suicide, although one could say that just going back to Pakistan was a suicide mission. However, Musharraf had all the motive and opportunity in the world to get Bhutto.. who else could it be to blame for her death?
Of course he's upset that everyone thinks (knows) it's him. He is supposed to be the kind and beneficent coup master in charge, not a murder suspect. I am sure this isn't the first blood on his hands.
RE: - Expanding covert operations in Pakistan would be the worst thing the US could do!
When has that ever stopped them!
RE: - However, Musharraf had all the motive and opportunity in the world to get Bhutto.. who else could it be to blame for her death? Of course he's upset that everyone thinks (knows) it's him.
Mushy made a deal with Bhutto to share power and changed the law so that Bhutto could run again because that is what the US wants. He took his uniform off because that was what the US wanted (even it it sounded a bit kinky when they said it and that wearing a business suit doesn't really change things). It was Bhutto who backed out of the deal rather than Mushy.
I would give that third place guy a motive over Mushy because he was both close by and seemed to calm about it - and capitalized too quickly on the situation by inviting Bhutto supporters to his camp. Mushy seemed upset.
Personally, I think that Mushy is fighting with Bhutto's ghost.
And if Mushy's base of power was secure, then why did he agree to the deal with Bhutto to begin with.
Mushy doesn't want to lose power, but it was slipping away before this.
Mushy did that interview because he wanted to convince the American people not to attack him.
Scotland Yard wants to examine the body. Mushy isn't the one who is stopping them.
...........
I think that Mushy had even less to do with Bhutto's death than she did - and that she didn't pull the trigger either.
If there was more that he could have done it was incompetence rather than malice which prevented him from doing so.
Mushy is an asshole, he is on the way out, and the Americans are going to use this to occupy Pakistan.
What the Americans want to do first is get their population on side or they would have done so already.