Get News & Views Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Why I Believe Bush Must Go
Nixon Was Bad. These Guys Are Worse
As we enter the eighth year of the Bush-Cheney administration, I have belatedly and painfully concluded that the only honorable course for me is to urge the impeachment of the president and the vice president.
After the 1972 presidential election, I stood clear of calls to impeach President Richard M. Nixon for his misconduct during the campaign. I thought that my joining the impeachment effort would be seen as an expression of personal vengeance toward the president who had defeated me.
Today I have made a different choice.
Of course, there seems to be little bipartisan support for impeachment. The political scene is marked by narrow and sometimes superficial partisanship, especially among Republicans, and a lack of courage and statesmanship on the part of too many Democratic politicians. So the chances of a bipartisan impeachment and conviction are not promising.
But what are the facts?
Bush and Cheney are clearly guilty of numerous impeachable offenses. They have repeatedly violated the Constitution. They have transgressed national and international law. They have lied to the American people time after time. Their conduct and their barbaric policies have reduced our beloved country to a historic low in the eyes of people around the world. These are truly "high crimes and misdemeanors," to use the constitutional standard.
From the beginning, the Bush-Cheney team's assumption of power was the product of questionable elections that probably should have been officially challenged -- perhaps even by a congressional investigation.
In a more fundamental sense, American democracy has been derailed throughout the Bush-Cheney regime. The dominant commitment of the administration has been a murderous, illegal, nonsensical war against Iraq. That irresponsible venture has killed almost 4,000 Americans, left many times that number mentally or physically crippled, claimed the lives of an estimated 600,000 Iraqis (according to a careful October 2006 study from the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health) and laid waste their country. The financial cost to the United States is now $250 million a day and is expected to exceed a total of $1 trillion, most of which we have borrowed from the Chinese and others as our national debt has now climbed above $9 trillion -- by far the highest in our national history.
All of this has been done without the declaration of war from Congress that the Constitution clearly requires, in defiance of the U.N. Charter and in violation of international law. This reckless disregard for life and property, as well as constitutional law, has been accompanied by the abuse of prisoners, including systematic torture, in direct violation of the Geneva Conventions of 1949.
I have not been heavily involved in singing the praises of the Nixon administration. But the case for impeaching Bush and Cheney is far stronger than was the case against Nixon and Vice President Spiro T. Agnew after the 1972 election. The nation would be much more secure and productive under a Nixon presidency than with Bush. Indeed, has any administration in our national history been so damaging as the Bush-Cheney era?
How could a once-admired, great nation fall into such a quagmire of killing, immorality and lawlessness?
It happened in part because the Bush-Cheney team repeatedly deceived Congress, the press and the public into believing that Saddam Hussein had nuclear arms and other horrifying banned weapons that were an "imminent threat" to the United States. The administration also led the public to believe that Iraq was involved in the 9/11 attacks -- another blatant falsehood. Many times in recent years, I have recalled Jefferson's observation: "Indeed I tremble for my country when I reflect that God is just."
The basic strategy of the administration has been to encourage a climate of fear, letting it exploit the 2001 al-Qaeda attacks not only to justify the invasion of Iraq but also to excuse such dangerous misbehavior as the illegal tapping of our telephones by government agents. The same fear-mongering has led government spokesmen and cooperative members of the press to imply that we are at war with the entire Arab and Muslim world -- more than a billion people.
Another shocking perversion has been the shipping of prisoners scooped off the streets of Afghanistan to Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, and other countries without benefit of our time-tested laws of habeas corpus.
Although the president was advised by the intelligence agencies last August that Iran had no program to develop nuclear weapons, he continued to lie to the country and the world. This is the same strategy of deception that brought us into war in the Arabian Desert and could lead us into an unjustified invasion of Iran. I can say with some professional knowledge and experience that if Bush invades yet another Muslim oil state, it would mark the end of U.S. influence in the crucial Middle East for decades.
Ironically, while Bush and Cheney made counterterrorism the battle cry of their administration, their policies -- especially the war in Iraq -- have increased the terrorist threat and reduced the security of the United States. Consider the difference between the policies of the first President Bush and those of his son. When the Iraqi army marched into Kuwait in August 1990, President George H.W. Bush gathered the support of the entire world, including the United Nations, the European Union and most of the Arab League, to quickly expel Iraqi forces from Kuwait. The Saudis and Japanese paid most of the cost. Instead of getting bogged down in a costly occupation, the administration established a policy of containing the Baathist regime with international arms inspectors, no-fly zones and economic sanctions. Iraq was left as a stable country with little or no capacity to threaten others.
Today, after five years of clumsy, mistaken policies and U.S. military occupation, Iraq has become a breeding ground of terrorism and bloody civil strife. It is no secret that former president Bush, his secretary of state, James A. Baker III, and his national security adviser, Gen. Brent Scowcroft, all opposed the 2003 invasion and occupation of Iraq.
In addition to the shocking breakdown of presidential legal and moral responsibility, there is the scandalous neglect and mishandling of the Hurricane Katrina catastrophe. The veteran CNN commentator Jack Cafferty condenses it to a sentence: "I have never ever seen anything as badly bungled and poorly handled as this situation in New Orleans." Any impeachment proceeding must include a careful and critical look at the collapse of presidential leadership in response to perhaps the worst natural disaster in U.S. history.
Impeachment is unlikely, of course. But we must still urge Congress to act. Impeachment, quite simply, is the procedure written into the Constitution to deal with presidents who violate the Constitution and the laws of the land. It is also a way to signal to the American people and the world that some of us feel strongly enough about the present drift of our country to support the impeachment of the false prophets who have led us astray. This, I believe, is the rightful course for an American patriot.
As former representative Elizabeth Holtzman, who played a key role in the Nixon impeachment proceedings, wrote two years ago, "it wasn't until the most recent revelations that President Bush directed the wiretapping of hundreds, possibly thousands, of Americans, in violation of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) -- and argued that, as Commander in Chief, he had the right in the interests of national security to override our country's laws -- that I felt the same sinking feeling in my stomach as I did during Watergate. . . . A President, any President, who maintains that he is above the law -- and repeatedly violates the law -- thereby commits high crimes and misdemeanors."
I believe we have a chance to heal the wounds the nation has suffered in the opening decade of the 21st century. This recovery may take a generation and will depend on the election of a series of rational presidents and Congresses. At age 85, I won't be around to witness the completion of the difficult rebuilding of our sorely damaged country, but I'd like to hold on long enough to see the healing begin.
There has never been a day in my adult life when I would not have sacrificed that life to save the United States from genuine danger, such as the ones we faced when I served as a bomber pilot in World War II. We must be a great nation because from time to time, we make gigantic blunders, but so far, we have survived and recovered.
© 2007 The Washington Post
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

111 Comments so far
Show AllIs it a call for morality?
George McGovern, a one-time US presidential contender, insists that Bush and Cheney are guilty of numerous impeachable offences for repeatedly violating the Constitution and transgression of national and international law. As well as nonsensical war against Iraq which has resulted into killing of some 4000 Americans and 600,000 Iraqis butchered. And that all of this has been done without the declaration of war from Congress as well as; it is in defiance of the U.N. Charter and in violation of international law. The reckless disregard for life and property in foreign lands and constitutional law, has been accompanied by the abuse of prisoners, including systematic torture, in direct violation of the Geneva Conventions of 1949.
He also claims that the conduct and their barbaric policies have reduced the image of United States to a historic low in the eyes of people around the world. Is he trying to give; morality a call?
But has he really tried to peep behind the closed doors and found the real forces at work behind this; which tends these figures like Bush and Cheney to remain on their toes all the time. This may be his; a hypocritical face not to reveal the truth; that it is in fact the policy of 'American Adventurism' at its play; which is complexity of deep seeded policies and the mind set of US of securing US hegemony in the world; that is what which should matter him the most and be point of contention for him.
American adventurism is strife; it is the fearsome agenda of all the debates held concerning the future of humanity in the entire world. The divisive policies implied in execution through deception and fallacy by US is awful. The dismantling of sovereign states and to bring the havoc in the lives of millions and millions of defence less destitute people and to dislodge them and wipe them off from the face of earth; just in pursuance of rapacious greed of US;, are the crimes against humanity?
Anarchy, mayhem in the house of adversaries and media manipulation in order to upkeep the climate of fear of terror, in our own society is the order of the day. The evidence of government sponsored terror and how they use the fear of terror to control own society is seen bursting out at the seams. This horrific climate is keeping the world in its grips; now for decades.
We find that US top political parties; Conservative as well as Democrats; both are in full agreement in pursuing this common dream of their hegemonic aspiration in the world.
Today it is Bush and Cheney's team and tomorrow we will have another set of figures; we will find that they are pushing the same evil policies forward.
* My killers they don't change; only they change their faces and flags.
*What a strenuous journey of mine; even my milestones and traversed spans; all travel with me.(Habib Jalib)
-----------------------------
Love for all, Hatred for none
mirf59,
Thanks for the compliment. My thoughts exactly on the interactions. It may be like a molecular formula.
But I have to say I'm keenly interested in the 8th cousin tracing to Obama. That suggests that these people are very deeply interested in genealogy, and my guess is that it's not because it's a fun hobby to login to Ancestry.com, they venerate their ancestors (like the Japanese and traditional cultures), etc.
When I heard this morning about the previous president of Peru now being held accountable for the numerous crimes during his term in office years earlier, I have HOPE that bush and cheney WILL see the inside of a jail cell --- and it can't be soon enough. Put on the shackles and scurry the dark ones into the chamber of doom where they have earned their permanent residence.
I agree with your sentiments, Chunga's Revenge. The empire will fall, but I never wanted to live in one either anyway. I know the US and it's complacent Americans have karma coming. And it's not good. But in another way, it IS good because we all needed to WAKE UP and stop watching 'reality' tv shows and PAY ATTENTION to what our government has been doing with our tax dollars behind our backs. NO MORE will we take this. But we all need to learn the lesson because many are still sleeping. And so the lesson shall come. Fasten your seatbelts.
Yes, the US may have survived a lot of blunders, but I am starting to believe the country may not survive disastrous wholesale re-fabrication of the country by Bush/Cheney, certainly not as the country it once was.
I lost my scholarship at a catholic college, because I wanted to establish a campaign office for George McGovern there. I supposed I should have known better. However, I, with Massachusetts, had the last laugh.
Yes, yes, impeach these creeps--then make sure we replace them with leaders that will respect and support the Constitution, embrace the Bill of Rights, and care for ALL of the people residing in this nation.
Pelosi and Reid are the face of the Democratic Party, conniving, corrupt and dishonest. A vote for a Democrat is a vote for Bush & Cheney. Wake up. VOTE SHEEHAN. VOTE THIRD PARTY.
So glad Americans have come to their senses at last - it's taken you nearly eight years.
Lets hope the next would-be champion on a white charger isn't just another Tony Blair, trumpeting an endless stream of bright ideas to Change the World, and actually delivering pretty well zilch.
Good Luck !
Country housewife, Herefordshire, England
We know what the traditional penalty is for treason. This is exactly what Dubya, Shooter, and every other past and present senior official in this administration deserve - to hang by the neck from the nearest tree ASAP.