Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
AARP To Kucinich: Drop Dead
AARP President Bill Novelli is a company man.
No, the company is not AARP.
Novelli doesn't give a damn about AARP or its 38 million members.
If he did, he wouldn't be selling down them down river by opposing a single payer system that would benefit not just AARP members, but everyone in the country.
Novelli doesn't give a damn about the health of the nation.
What he cares about are the health insurance companies.
Novelli - a founder of the giant Porter Novelli corporate public relations firm - jumped to AARP in 2000.
But he never shed his corporate skin.
Case in point?
On Thursday night, AARP will host a debate in Iowa on the issue of health care.
Republicans and Democrats running for President will attend.
Of all of the Democrats and Republicans in the race, guess who is the only one who would put the Novelli's buddies in the health insurance industry out of business?
Guess who is the only candidate among the Democrats and Republicans who would create a Canadian-style single payer, everybody in, nobody out, no deductibles, no co-pays, no in-network, no out-of-network, streamlined system that would save billions of dollars in administrative costs, deliver a higher quality health care system, and cover everyone?
Yes.
And guess who was not invited to confront Novelli's corporate brotherhood of profit and death?
You guessed it.
Congressman Dennis Kucinich.
Why?
Well, Kucinich would put out of business Novelli's corporate support system - including United Healthcare and Aetna.
Earlier this year, both these health care industry giants signed a contract with AARP that will net AARP a cool $4.4 billion over seven years.
Kucinich said that AARP sponsorship of the Presidential forum "is like having Haliburton or Blackwater sponsor a Presidential forum on doing away with no-bid government contracts to private contractors - or an oil company sponsoring a forum on reducing the world's dependence on oil."
"Millions of trusting AARP members have bought Medicare-supplemental and prescription drug insurance plans from AARP, believing that they were getting a good deal," Kucinich said. "It turns out, however, that AARP is taking a $4 billion cut by steering its members to profiteering private insurance companies trying to capitalize on fear and confusion."
"The fact that Senators Clinton, Obama, and former Senator Edwards are pushing plans to keep the for-profit private insurers in business and in control may explain why they are willing to participate in this fake and tainted debate," Kucinich said.
Kucinich also questioned the decision by Iowa Public Television to televise the Presidential forum and simulcast it to other PBS stations in other states.
"Profit-driven and politics-driven media conglomerates are controlling what we see on TV and what we hear on the radio. Public broadcasting should represent a higher, more ethical standard. In this case, public broadcasting will shamefully promote private interests."
We're all getting old.
But we don't have to all join AARP.
If your not a member yet, don't join.
If you are a member, call Novelli and tell him to take a hike.
Then sign on with any Presidential candidate who supports single payer.
Russell Mokhiber is editor of the Washington, D.C.-based Corporate Crime Reporter.

89 Comments so far
Show AllRebel Farmer: Good Lord, you mean to tell me that I can't even believe what I heard on progressive radio this morning, either? They said that Kucinich received an invitation, but didn't respond to it.
Thom Hartmann, I think it was on your show. I know you read this blog (but you may not be reading this one now, since it is yesterday's news...).
Sounds like Mr. Kucinich was indeed intentionally slighted.
I just renewed my AARP membership too. This will be my last year until they dump this turkey and return to their roots of supporting us retirees.
It isn't a "hike" I told him to take.
Considering that PBS's programs' showcase sponsor's such as Exxon Mobile, ADM, and Monsanto shows all you need to know about the direction of "our" Public Broadcasting Stations.
DAMN, I joined this organization just before I heard a progressive talk-show host tell us to NOT join AARP because it's nothing but an insurance scam. I didn't know.
Now this!
Each day that passes, I can't believe I can get any angrier.
Damn right I'm going to contact AARP. I'm pissed.
AARP's premise is based on the fear and insecurity of the aging. At one time I was a member until I discovered that booking a hotel room via online was a whole lot cheaper then calling up and mentioning you were a n AARP member. After several similar incidents I realized AARPs goal is to make seniors feel they are powerless and vulnerable without them. The can kiss my a$$.
The only half-decent email address I could find to send my scathing letter was this:
webactivist@aarp.org
...and the subject line said "For William Novelli".
AARP insulates its VPs quite nicely. Obviously, they don't want to be disturbed with phone calls and emails from members.
AARP might have started off as a good idea, and that's a big maybe, I'll never join them.
I too was a member for several years, until AARP backed the so-called Medicare drug reform program...again to benefit the insurance companies and big pharma...I quit my membership and made my reasons well known to them (meh, they don't give a ratzass).
This is outrageous that they are excluding Kucinich in this sham debate--as outrageous as the 'health reform' platforms being proposed by the media-anointed 'leading contenders', which are nothing more than insurance company welfare programs--forcing people to buy health insurance?!?!?! I don't think so!
This isn't the first time Billy has given AARP members a Corporate Cashectemy. What do America's seniors need to do to get simple healthcare? Besides hang congress and move to Cuba...
Dover September 20th, 2007 12:49 pm
Try member@aarp.org - works for me.
How do we send $ to Dennis?
I contacted AARP earlier this week, this is their response.
On July 2, 2007, Congressman Kucinich's campaign was sent a
registered letter inviting him to participate in the event. The
letter was accompanied by criteria that were set by AARP and IPTV for participation in the forum. Criteria include:
* Have filed an FEC Form F-2, "Statement of Candidacy," with the Federal Election Commission;
* Have publicly announced an intention to run for the nomination of the Republican or the Democratic Party for President of the United States;
* Have a Campaign Office inside the State of Iowa; and,
* Have employed at least one paid campaign staff representative to perform full-time campaign duties in the State of Iowa on behalf of the candidate since at least August 1, 2007.
During the weeks following his campaign's receipt of the letter of invitation, Congressman Kucinich's office had no communication with AARP or IPTV. The campaign did not acknowledge receipt of our invitation, nor did he or any of his campaign staff indicate any interest in participating in this forum. We did not hear from anyone about the forum until a story appeared in the Quad-City Times stating incorrectly, that Congressman Kucinich had not been invited to participate.
To our knowledge, Congressman Kucinich did not meet all four of the stated criteria that would enable him participate in the upcoming forum by the designated date.
My questions are
1. Did they send these letters to all the candidates?
2. Did they require all the candidates who are participating send back the information to AARP/IPTV?
3. Once they were made aware that Kucinich wanted to participate and met the 4 criteria, why couldn't they allow him to participate?
Maybe it's time us "aging baby boomers" (god, how I hate that phrase :)) started our own organization.
whatfools, you can donate to Dennis at
www.dennis4president.com
IF ypou're an American citizen. Pity that I can't help Dennis on the financial front.
I just finished a great book by John Perkins, The Secret History of American Empire. This shit goes so deep down the rabbit hole and the illussions so pervasive right is wrong and wrong right. The corporatacracy runs the global show and all the so called "progressives" bought and paid for while still rubbing elbows in and dispensing meaningless rhetoric on behalf of progressive values. Kucinich and Nader might be the only two people not in the pay system. The more things change the more they stay the same.
Enlighten yourselves about the corruption and how deep it runs by reading Perkins.
I dropped my AARP membership as soon as I read the Medicare Prescription Drug Bill. After AARP's total sellout, I had to quit. So I am surely not surprised that they continue to pander to the cruel insurance behemoths.
Now when I receive solicitations from AARP in the mail, I stuff everything they sent me into the reply envelope and mail it back.
Thank you for helping me confirm something I already suspected. I subscribed to AARP for one year and all I ever got from them was advertisements to buy insurance! I figured out they are a waste of money and a scam.
"Now when I receive solicitations from AARP in the mail, I stuff everything they sent me into the reply envelope and mail it back."
Thank you. I used to do this, but thought it was juvenile. I guess it will make me feel younger to indulge again.
I wish the Association of Retired Ammericans
(ARA) would get out do more grassroots organizing. We need a broadbased alternative
to the AARP.
NovaScotian September 20th, 2007 2:01 pm
Thanks for the address - I'l send Dennis some loonies today, from my FXC account. :-)
daveg90275,
"To our knowledge, Congressman Kucinich did not meet all four of the stated criteria that would enable him participate in the upcoming forum by the designated date."
Do you mean he DID meet the criteria?
"To our knowledge, Congressman Kucinich did not meet all four of the stated criteria that would enable him participate in the upcoming forum by the designated date."
Maybe they will let Dennis participate after the designated date? Whatever that could possibly mean?
"Have employed at least one paid campaign staff representative to perform full-time campaign duties in the State of Iowa on behalf of the candidate since at least August 1, 2007." I wonder if that's what nixed it for Dennis? I suppose with enough searching AARP could always find something to disqualify a candidate they didn't want to participate.
Dennis Kucinich doesn't seem to meet the AARP criteria, the DLC criteria, or the M$M criteria. But he meets mine, so I will vote for him.
Thanks, whatfools. You've made me feel that I have perhaps been able to help with Dennis's campaign from afar. But only through your good graces.
militantlibrarian & Dover ... tape the reply envelope to a brick/rock.
And everyone get a Kucinich bumper sticker
I am a member, I'm not sure this is still the case, but the AARP credit card they push "ONLY"
charges around 19% interest. Not what I would call looking out for people on a limited income.
I will think twice about paying for another year.
No problem NovaScotian. The loonie is worth more than Bush's brokenback dollar by now anyway. I put Dennis on my list with the Green Party, Amnisty, ACLU etc. It's just a pensioner's tithing but every little bit helps. Eh?
When AARP started, it was touted to be a strong political force and lobby for a growing class of senior citizens. Very quickly it discovered that it was much more profitable to turn itself into a huge insurance company for health, life, home owners, and auto insurance. Since then, they are part of the problem, not a solution to our countries' domestic woes.
Thank you for this article! Kucinich needs to be heard, and this is a prime example of how he has been suppressed everywhere he goes. That's what happens when a for the people, not for the 'Man', candidate voices concerns AGAINST corporate interests. Spread the word about Kucinich, and about this, yet ANOTHER attempt to keep him out of the public eye.
Peace,
TL
OK, IMAGINE THIS:
ALL CANDIDATES POST THEIR PLATFORMS WITH NO IDENTIFICATION OF THE AUTHOR.
NO WAY TO CONNECT WITH A GENDER
NO WAY TO CONNECT TO A RACE
NO WAY TO SEE WHAT THE PERSON LOOKES LIKE, HOW "ALPHA", HOW TALL, HOW GOOD LOOKING, ETC.
NO WAY EVEN TO CONNECT TO PERSONAL HISTORY
JUST PLATFORM, THAT'S ALL
DENNIS KUCINICH WOULD WIN BY A COUNTRY MILE. BUT .... OH MY .... THE MEDIA HAVE CREATED THIS MANTRA: "HE'S NOT ELECTABLE, HE'S NOT ELECTABLE, HE'S NOT ................ "
militantlibrarian, Dover,
"Now when I receive solicitations from AARP in the mail, I stuff everything they sent me into the reply envelope and mail it back."
Don't forget to wrap a brick in brown paper and then paste the return envelope to it!
Alas, I, too, joined AARP earlier this month. So I emailed them at
member@aarp.org (Thanks, whatfools!), added a link to article above, and told them to cancel my membership effective immediately (and to forward a copy of my email to William Novelli.
I haven't received my card yet, so I told them that I expected a full refund of my membership fee as soon as they receive my cut-up card. I said that I have no intention of using it and refuse to belong to any group that opposes universal single payer healthcare and tries to prevent Dennis Kucinich from participating in the upcoming IPBS debate.
The next salvo will go to Iowa PBS , , ,
Dennis Kucinich has the right position on health care, animal protection, and everything else! I joined AARP to get 10% off my hotel rooms but soon found myself the recipient of streams of junk mail, mainly from insurance companies. I realised that there was a sinister agenda at work. I am appalled that PBS would ban my hero from this debate.
Lots of misguided seniors have AARP in their wills. If you're one of them, change your will today!
Does anyone have phone numbers to call Iowa PBS if it engineered the Banning of Dennis? Or Novelli's office (direct line). I expect he has an unlisted home number!
daveg90275's comment regarding AARP's requirements not being met by the Kucinich folks deserves serious attention and investigation. Having been an ardent Kucinich supporter until just recently, I believe Dennis has a number of serious faults that will ultimately be the cause of his political suicide. When I compare the current campaign with the 2004 campaign, I see (1) the same inability to hire staff who are competent and trustworthy, (2) the same tendency to seek "peace at any cost", and (3) the same stubborn resistance to accept the advice of those more knowledgeable about and courageous on certain matters (e.g. seeking the truth about 911) than he.
Never join any organization who's acronym sounds like a burp.
AARP from the beginning has looked after AARP. They rake piles of money off members who are also members of their medigap insurance, or who use any service AARP advertises.
Their support of the prescription drug act was the final straw for me. I quit. I still get renewal notices!
Their position on single payer reform has been rejected by the membership for years. Makes no difference. I'm surprised they have any members left. Almost everyone I know quit in 2003. Since they keep sending us renewal notices, I wonder if they still count us as members.
I never joined AARP because I did not see what they really had to offer me. I really turned against AARP when I felt they were too close to the pharmaceutical companies. They were pushing an Alzheimer's drug. I had done a lot of research on this because of an elderly parent. There is no good evidence that these drugs improve the quality of life for people with Alzheimer's, and there are side effects. The money is better spent giving patients support in their daily activities. But families feel desparate, and the drugs play right into this. And AARP played right into the interests of the drug companies.
It is absurd not to invite Kucinich. He is probably the one with the best plan. It is not an open forum if the only plans discussed benefit insurance companies more than people.
AARP is a for profit exploiter. A classically profitable swindle with all the advantages of corporate theft repacked and advertised as a service. Outsourcing, tax evading, profiteering and controlling bastion of organized crime. I pray the old never give another cent to these gangsters and punish them, big pharma and big banking in a crushing trifecta.
good things..come in small packages.i would cheer to see mr. dennis...win !
It tells you a lot that the other scum in the Democratic Party are attending. I would have thought it was a no-brainer to insist that all candidates in an election be invited, and any other candidate with the character worthy to be president would withdraw as soon as they heard it wasn't the case. So to me it says loads about Edwards, Obama etc that they are still showing up to this (I've known Hillary was scum of the earth for years ... no surprises there).
Add this to Edwards and Hillary being caught on mic discussing how to get other candidates excluded from debates and you start to get a picture of the manipulative scum these people are. You certainly learn very fast that the very basic concepts of free and fair elections in a government of the people, by the people and for the people mean absolutely nothing to them.
One reason why I am no longer a Democrat and flat will not vote for any member of that party is that they make it plain over and over again that winning is all that's important to them and that any scrap of integrity, honesty or principle gets tossed overboard the second it gets in the way of that goal. And they make it plain that what's good for the country also doesn't matter to them and gets discarded if it gets in the way of them winning.
What's good for the country is that we have free and fair elections and open and honest debates on the issues. When the big health care companies get to exclude people who don't support their agenda, and when the other candidates are happy to go along with this, you know all involved don't give a damn about what's good for the country. And we've elected way too many people like that already.
Why the hell is the AARP setting 'requirements' for the candidates?
It should be the other way around. The candidates and the party should have requirements for who they'll let sponser these debates. And number one at the very top of the list should be that no candidate can be excluded.
BTW, the requirement of having a paid staffer in the state is a slap at grassroots campaigns. Saying one might not be too bad, but you've opened the door to them saying 'ten' in the future and thus excluding all candidates not back by big bribes from the wealthy and corporations. A true grassroots campaign might not have any paid staff in a state. Especially not 5 months out from the election.
PBS is a better target. They should be slapped for showing a debate that isn't a true debate because not all candidates are included. And if PBS pulled their coverage, then AARP is left sponsering something seen only by the few hundred people in the room, and then other candidates would probably pull out too.
AARP isn't going to give a damn what you think. You don't have the millions of dollars to give them like United Healthcare. Instead, I'd target PBS with your emails and phone calls. Especially the local stations.
This for "whatfools" and others:
Easy. Just google on to Kucinich for President and send every single dollar you have to spare.
AFTER you ask him point-blank to explain publicly, on his own me-first website, precisely WHY he is running on the ticket of the other corporate interest party...instead of running as the peoples own candidate.
What fools indeed.
Kucinich is being deliberately blackballed because he actually makes sense. He is such a breath of fresh air when compared with the other candidates. Naturally they don't want him up there where the voters can actually hear his rational vision for this country. He might get elected!
Kucinich is going up against the evil money forces of the evil empire we live in...
I suppose you feel safe to say that "Sir" Melvin Cleo-puss, not being here as an American citizen. I recall you wish to eleminate all of the world's jews also.
I hope insurance men like Novelli finally do get their just rewards, but as the insurance industry rules the nation, that isn't very likely. Insurance firms own everythng, including the banks.
I'd like to know why Mr. Kucinich and Mr. Gravell were excluded from the Democratic candidates "steak fry" in Iowa given by Sen. Tom Harkin. What a phoney bunch of jerks. Obviously they don't believe in freedom of speech, just as their Republican masters do not.
Dennis Kucinich is "not electable?" If someone like George Bush can be "elected" and placed in the White House, ANYONE can be!
Have you ever listened to Mr. Kucinich speak? Mr. Kucinich is an intelligent, honest, and capable man. I guess that excludes him from being president of the USA.
Pat's Presidential Platform.
1. Refuse rights of personhood from all corporations located in or doing business in the United States.
2. Initiate a Universal Healthcare program.
3. Pull troops out of Iraq.
4. Appoint a Department of Peace.
5. Raise the minimum wage to a livible wage of $10 per hour.
6. Introduce a flat tax rate of 10% of gross income, regardless of whether earned or unearned, on all individuals residing in the United States.
7. Introduce a flat tax rate of 25% of gross income of businesses or corporations employing more than 100 people.
6. Introduce a flat tax rate of 15% of gross income of all businesses employing 10-99 people.
7. Repeal the No Child Left Behind Act.
8. Repeal the Defense of Marriage Act.
9. Work to repair the seperation of church and state.
10. Work to return control of education, healthcare, social welfare and the National Guard to the states, where it rightfully belongs.
11. Downsize, downsize, downsize the federal government.
12. Work to pass legislation tying the pay and benefits of the three branches of government directly to the national minimum wage.
13. Work to create publically financed campaigns and to eliminate the 2 party system.
Well, that's my platform. It is not in order of importance. There were other things I wanted to mention like returning the airwaves, the internet and all utilities to the control of the people. The need to develop a fair trade based economy and get out of NAFTA.
And of course there is the burning issue (pun intended) of global warming and how to end our dependence on fossil fuels. Finally, the need for a diplomacy based foreign policy.
So that's it.
Is there still time for me to get in the race?
Peace
Pat
Mr. Kucinich is an intelligent, honest, and capable man. I guess that excludes him from being president of the USA.
Try not to be too bummed out. It took me a long time to catch on, too. It's so counterintuitive.
GARBOTOO September 20th, 2007 6:13 pm
"Kucinich is going up against the evil money forces of the evil empire we live in…"
Yes, he is.......but if you and many other supporters can convince a few ("he can't win") friends and relatives to vote for him in the primaries, anything is possible!
We The People are getting sick and tired of the same old bullshit protection propaganda used by the politicians whose campaigns are being funded by these corporate predators.
Isn't it time that you actually vote for the person you want to see in the White House instead of saying: "He can't win"? Well, of course he can't win if you don't vote for him! And if DENNIS KUCINICH doesn't win, does it really matter which other corporate-hack Democrat does win?
How many times do you have to get screwed by empty rhetoric before you learn?
We've always resisted joining AARP inspite of their continuous mailshots. we intuitively mistrusted them and it appears we were correct.
Is it too much to hope that some member of the audience will stand up and ask the candidates, or organisers how their plans shape up against that of Kucinich - and by the way why isn't he present ?