Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
War is Collective Insanity
August 6th is a date that reminds us of a horrible chapter in human history. On this day 62 years ago, the U.S. launched atomic warfare when we dropped an atom bomb on Hiroshima, Japan almost immediately killing an estimated 80,000 civilians and tens of thousands more who died horrible deaths within a few years due to the radiation poisoning they experienced. On August 9, 1945 we dropped a second nuclear bomb on Nagasaki killing tens of thousands more.
Reflecting on the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, I wonder, have we learned the right lessons? We learned that nuclear weapons kill large numbers of innocent civilians, but so do so-called conventional weapons. Perhaps what we should have learned is that war is not the answer and that the world needs alternatives for solving crises. Unfortunately, the lesson the U.S. and a few other countries took away from Hiroshima and Nagasaki was that more nuclear weapons were needed. Once the atomic genie was unleashed, nuclear proliferation became the name of the game. Talk about your overkill - the U.S. eventually manufactured and deployed more than 70,000 nuclear weapons! Might, not diplomacy, was 'in'.
By the early 1960s, five nations had nuclear weapons, with the Soviet Union and the U.S. armed to the teeth and following the policy of mutual assured destruction (MAD). The leaders of these countries were indeed mad! Commenting on this situation, Army General Omar Bradley, the first chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said: "Ours is a world of nuclear giants and ethical infants. We know more about war than we know about peace, more about killing than we know about living."
Stephen Schwartz of The Brookings Institute reported the U.S. spent over $5.5 trillion (in 1996 dollars) on nuclear weapons, a large portion of the $18.7 trillion spent on the military between 1940 and 1996. And add in a few trillion dollars more since then. Contrast these amounts with the paltry sums for preventing violence and supporting agencies working on international cooperation. Moreover, in 1953 President Eisenhower reminded us of the other cost of these huge weapons expenditures when he said: "Every gun that is made, every warship launched, every rocket fired signifies, in the final sense, a theft from those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and are not clothed."
Has all this money spent on nuclear weapons and the military brought us peace and security? Or has it simply improved the killing capability of our military and enriched the merchants of death, the Congressional-military-industrial complex, at the expense of our people and worldwide peace and security? A look at the past 62 years shows that our huge and bloated nuclear-armed military has brought neither security here at home nor peace throughout the world. In fact, it appears that the U.S., by having such a powerful military, tends to turn to it first instead of trying to solve problems diplomatically. Our illegal attack on Iraq is a horrible example of our reliance on military might instead of diplomacy. The evidence is now overwhelming that the Bush administration was intent on removing Saddam Hussein and would not countenance any diplomatic resolution. Besides the huge number of Iraqi casualties and over 3600 U.S. military deaths, the image of the U.S. has further been damaged by this wanton and illegal violence. Incredibly we are now seeing a repeat of the propaganda campaign used against Iraq, this time with Iran as the target. The Bush administration is again trying to frighten us, raising the specter of an Iranian nuclear weapon. In an attempt to build more support for an attack on Iran, the Bush administration has added the unsupported claim that Iran is behind many of the attacks on U.S. forces in Iraq. Once again Bush wants to use the military instead of diplomacy. In 2003 Iran reached out to the U.S. for negotiations on all issues, but the Bush administration would not even consider this offer. Unfortunately Congress is ready and willing to support an attack on Iran. Therefore it is up to the American public to stop another war crime. If we fail to stop the attack, the consequences are likely to be disastrous for the world and for the U.S.
A quote from Seneca the Younger from almost 2000 years ago still seems to apply: "We are mad not only individually but nationally. We check manslaughter and isolated murders, but what of war and the much vaunted crime of slaughtering whole peoples?"
Ron Forthofer is a retired professor from the University of Texas School of Public Health. He ran for Congress in 2000 and for governor of Colorado in 2002 for the Green Party.

9 Comments so far
Show AllFrom a psychological perspective, warmongers often appeal to five core concerns—about issues of vulnerability, injustice, distrust, superiority, and helplessness—in order to galvanize public support for their agenda. I examine how Bush/Cheney and their neocon allies have used these particular appeals to promote the misguided and destructive Iraq war in a 10-minute online video entitled "Resisting the Drums of War" available for viewing HERE. Looking ahead, the continuing occupation of Iraq–or an attack on Iran–will likely be sold to us in much the same way.
war is the decision taken by elites that something (usually property, resources) is more important than human life. all the rest is rhetorical BS.
Manifest Insanity, indeed.
It used to be called the Department of War, but is now called the Defense Department. I guess that sounded less hostile. War or defense goes to the primal force for survival.
The war mongers will tell you that you are fighting them there so that you do not have to fight them here. Right...if they show up here, you will know it.
Killing Iraqis is NOT going to stop "them" from coming here. 9/11 showed us that a few dollars for a plane ticket solves that problem. Next it will be renting snow shoes to come across the Canadian border. I should not say that, it might give them ideas and that would not be patriotic :)
Fear is a powerful tool in the hands of the evil people that misuse it. Do not fall victim to the manipulation. Ask if we are doing all we can and if we are getting efficient use of our resources in the effort, that usually stops them cold in their tracks.
Armageddon or Bust!
I agree with jedediah zachariah jedediah springfield. - And also, war is the result allowing political entities too much autonomy in the decision making global arena. If you imagine nation states as individuals, they are warlike and paranoid and extremely violent. That's why -- in the ideal world, mind you -- having a HUMAN executive ultimately calling the shots regarding the war/no war decision isn't a bad idea. The Founders (or Founderers if you're a cynic) were onto something, yet they never imagined other than an exemplary individual becoming president. Congress was to decide war and the executive execute it. But I think they also meant that a single person, a single human judgement, was to hold sway in that fateful decision.
The fatal flaw, unforeseen by the Founders, is that presidential selection has become a process controlled by the very collective political interests they sought to remove it from, and there is no mechanism to correct it. Hence, we get George Bush -- not an idividual human at all, certainly not a consientious and judicious individual mind.
The American system WAS a good one, that combined the conservative caution of collective and idividual judgement. It is no longer. Now war can be waged by the USA, the most powerful force in the planet, by the capricous desire of greedy oligarchies and corporate interest.
If you want to do something about war, the first step is to clean up your own financial house. Pay off all your debts so they cannot enslave you further. Take out all money from the big banks and put it in smaller institutions such as local credit unions. Cut up your credit cards and only use cash or debit. Those initial steps will help you release yourself from the arms of big finance, just some of the folks making a killing on this war.
Impeach/Out of Iraq GENERAL STRIKE SEPT.11th
Buy nothing - do nothing! Bring this country to a standstill!
Pass it on. Post a sign.
Correction: War is the health of the state.