EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
- Corporate Win: Supreme Court Says Monsanto Has 'Control Over Product of Life'
- Cornel West: Obama 'Is a War Criminal'
- Patent Filing Claims Solar Energy ‘Breakthrough’
- Disaster Capitalism Strikes as Hedge Funds Circle Near-Bankrupt Municipalities Like Vultures
- Ignoring Bee Crisis, EPA Greenlights New 'Highly Toxic' Pesticide
Popular content
Today's Top News
Rachel Carson's Alarm Still Echoes
T oday marks Rachel Carson's 100th birthday.
She has been dead for more than 40 years, but the environmental movement she gave life to with her seminal book "Silent Spring" has evolved from the grass-roots movement to a politically expedient force embraced by mainstream Americans.
More than a movement, though, Carson inspired real change.
In my own backyard in Northeast Portland, I wonder how my narrow slice of the ecosystem would be different if not for Carson. Here, as late afternoon sunlight threads the tall grass and spring flowers, bugs dive and weave, bird songs pierce the din of a distant lawnmower. Without Carson, the world in my own backyard would look and sound far different.
Carson, concerned about indiscriminate use of the pesticide DDT, worried about a silent world. In the first chapter of "Silent Spring," published in 1962, she imagined an entire community destroyed by "a white granular powder." Her best-selling book challenged the mid-century assumption that pesticide use was for the greater good. A shy biologist, unmarried and in her mid-50s, Carson created a public outcry with her thorough research and lyrical prose.
Change happened fast. President Kennedy appointed a science advisory committee to examine the book's conclusions. Congress debated legislation to require pesticide labels on how to avoid damage to fish and wildlife. In less than a decade, we celebrated the first Earth Day, Congress created the Environmental Protection Agency and passed the National Environmental Policy Act as well as a host of the nation's bulwark environmental laws.
Here in Oregon, where the economy has forever been intertwined with the health of natural resources, the environmental movement quickly flared. We passed the nation's first bottle bill in 1971. Looking south to California's suburban sprawl, former Gov. Tom McCall created landmark land-use planning laws. The fight about the spotted owl and logging in the late 1980s and early '90s made Oregon a flash point for a national tension that pitted urban environmentalists against the rural working class.
Clearly, debate about environmental issues isn't done: We're still grappling with land development and Measure 37, and how to protect endangered species without hurting local economies. There are fringe eco-saboteurs, some convicted just this past week in Eugene, who committed arson to raise public awareness about threats to animals and the environment.
Yet on a larger scale, caring about the environment has become the accepted norm.
Wal-Mart stocks organic produce and uses compact fluorescent lights. Energy companies accept the science about global warming and hawk green energies. Last month at least four glossy magazines, including Vanity Fair, Fortune and Elle, had "Green Issues." Al Gore's "An Inconvenient Truth" about global warming is the third-highest-grossing documentary film ever in the United States. The City of Portland's Water Bureau trucks run on biodiesel. Recycling bins are as ubiquitous as rain puddles. Hunters, farmers, corporations, schoolkids and simplicity advocates all say they care about nature.
That's a good thing because critical environmental concerns remain. When "Silent Spring" was published, Carson reported that 200 basic chemicals were created for use in killing pests, insects and weeds, sold under thousands of brand names. Today, in Oregon alone, there are 10,480 registered pesticide products with more than 500 pesticide ingredients. When we use these pesticides on our agricultural land and urban lawns and golf courses, rain and runoff carries them into our rivers. Twenty-seven pesticides have been detected in the Clackamas River Basin, and 36 pesticides appear in the Willamette River Basin, a recent U.S. Geological Survey reports. However, the USGS only tested for the presence of 86 pesticides, meaning that far more could exist in the rivers. Furthermore, the EPA hasn't established maximum contaminant standards for the vast majority of chemicals to protect fish and other aquatic life or humans who drink the water.
This failure to know all the effects of chemicals on our environment before their application is exactly what troubled Carson nearly a half-century ago. Her birthday should inspire us to question the status quo. We can begin with issues right here in our Oregon backyards. It was, of course, such a close-to-home concern that motivated Carson.
While Carson was visiting two friends, Stuart and Olga Huckins, at their two-acre private bird sanctuary in coastal Massachusetts, a plane spraying DDT to control mosquitoes flew overhead. The next morning she and her friends paddled through the estuary and saw dead and dying fish everywhere. Crayfish and crabs staggered, their nervous systems destroyed. This captured Carson's curiosity and sparked more than four years of research, which resulted in "Silent Spring."
Only two years after her book's publication, Carson died of breast cancer at age 56. But her voice continues to inspire. To date, "Silent Spring" has sold more than 250,000 copies in at least 59 countries. Her birthday reminds us of what one individual can accomplish, if she only pays close attention to places she cares about and asks critical questions with a calm clear voice.
Rebecca Clarren writes about the environment for national magazines from her home in Northeast Portland. Her work is frequently supported by the Fund for Investigative Journalism. She can be reached atrclarren@yahoo.com.
©2007 The Oregonian
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

23 Comments so far
Show AllAnimals need to evolve with their habitat; not with our pesticides and pollutants.
After WWII, the bio-warfare companies turned their talents to poisoning unwanted pests. Poisoned bugs are food down the food chain.
Florida is a fascinating state topographically for indeed RIVERS run under it. This gives rise to some of the most amazing natural springs on our planet. As my companion, a nature guide has related, sadly a lot of cattle ranchers have moved up here for cheap grazing land. Their cattle do their doo-doo thing into sinkholes which then leech back into the water table, and eventually pollute the springs. That, added to severely low rain fall for 2 years and counting, has added unsightly (and dangerous) algae blooms to the local springs. This is some of the last clean water on the earth and it's being rendered toxic. Today's cattle are fed hormones and frequently injected with antibiotics, all to push growth and eventual profits. Rachel Carson knew of what she spoke, but would turn over in her grave to witness the biotech and chemical anomalies that have become part of agriculture and cattle raising since her death.
Global Cooling
To turn to a new way of thinking,
What can shake us from our destructive path?
A cool, forest pool, once a place for drinking,
evaporated, cracked dry mud, silent wrath
The bird call, now more distant--
we strain to remember what we once did know.
Time's winged chariot, more insistent,
still mankind, ever the dullard, plodding, slow.
With profit our religion, our impetus, our motive,
We lemmings see as far as the ass ahead,
Capitalism--our altar, our sanctuary, our candle votive,
Consuming our spirits, we breathe ashes of the dead.
So poet, mr. cummings, that universe,
the other place that you might go
Sad news here about our earth perverse
They don't want us, they've seen us, don't you know.
President Kennedy acted with dispatch to mitigate the damage to our fragile envirnment, when it was flagged by this courageous lady. If she were alive and active today, her credibility would be attacked by this administration and their supporters, who are still waging this dreadful war on science.
Florida terrain being like a limestone sponge makes it unique. When water is pumped out of it it collapses as a sinkhole. You might come home to a hole with a house in it, it happens that fast. Who ya going to blame?
From lake Okeechobee south has a levee system to regulate water flow to the populated east. The demand on water in Florida has increased with its booming population. The Everglades eco-system is in competition with sugar cane and people for water.
The sugar cane and tomato industry stands in between lake Okeechobee and Everglades National Park. This area; known as the sea of grass (saw grass) had a gentile flow of water (south) supporting a unique environment, found nowhere else in the world.
The Everglades are my old tromping grounds, when I go back I don't recognize the place. Too, too many people!
What is wrong with using BT which is a natural pesticide?
Life will continue to evolve long after the human species is gone from the planet. In fact, it will adapt to avoid being affected by the poisons that we have left behind. But it seems premature for the human species to leave at this time ... we are not very old. However, the disappearance of the honeybee seems to signal that our number is coming up soon. Maybe the honeybees left our world like the dolphins did in "Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy" because they knew the end is near. "Goodbye, and thanks for all the nectar."
For centuries we saw ourselves at the pinnacle of a god's creation, and now just forgotten and worthless fodder for worm factories. It was fun while it lasted. As one who has suckled at the bosom of Mother Earth, thanks for the Mammaries.
michaelpda
unfortunately, what we thought was nourishment from those glorious boobs, in actuality was that special poison from implants. one can only hope we get weaned early enough to reverse the damage.
Hee-hee. It's okay, a catastrophic collapse of the human food chain should precur and preclude complete annihilation of the biosphere. :)
For the past ten years or so I've been compelled to save the creepy critters in my domain. From the terrifying black widow spider to the pesky mosquito, and the hundreds of tiny ants that invade my home, I've swept them up; caught them in a lidded container, or at the long distance of my Dexter duster, and "relocated" them to my yard where they belong.
I've not been able to use anything that will kill a one of them, but in their world, when allowed, and along with the birds I welcome to nest in my birdhouses, the really pesky pests are kept at a minimum.
In those years, I've come to have a healthy respect for the once fearsome Widow, and keep track of where all these "ladies" reside in my yard. I've come to feel a closeness with all the various types of spiders and other small creatures that I welcome in my yard. But last year, the neighbors had exterminators come into their yard and they soaked every surface and all around.
This spring I've thought a lot about Rachel Carson, and her Silent Spring, because my spring has been nearly silent. There is little buzzing around my flowers. I've yet to see a single honey bee, and fewer than half the normal number of bumble bees. Even the sparrows who've been busy as bees every spring, aren't acting normal. Two pairs have tried, going through all the motions of getting ready for a new family, but after a time, when nothing happens, they've disappeared. My hummingbird feeder goes for weeks without the level of the nectar going down. There is very little to hear from my patio swing, except for the sounds of the humans around.
It makes me very sad. I remember when I was growing up how full my world was with dozens of different kinds of birds, bees, and other little creatures I haven't seen in too many years to count.
I know that many people believe the earth will heal itself, no matter how badly we damage it. And that's true. They just don't understand that in order for her to heal herself, Mother Earth will first have to rid herself of the ravagers.
Last-Minute Message for a Time Capsule
By Philip Appleman
I have to tell you this, whoever you are:
that on one summer morning here, the ocean
pounded in on tumbledown breakers,
a south wind, bustling along the shore,
whipped the froth into little rainbows,
and a reckless gull swept down the beach
as if to fly were everything it needed.
I thought of your hovering saucers,
looking for clues, and I wanted to write this down,
so it wouldn't be lost forever --
that once upon a time we had
meadows here, and astonishing things,
swans and frogs and luna moths
and blue skies that could stagger your heart.
We could have had them still,
and welcomed you to earth, but
we also had the righteous ones
who worshipped the True Faith, and Holy War.
When you go home to your shining galaxy,
say that what you learned
from this dead and barren place is
to beware the righteous ones.
from New and Selected Poems,1956-1996
University of Arkansas Press, 1996
Rachel Carson was not only concerned about critters in back yards, but about human bodies being poisoned as well. The article appears to be smug and self satisfied.
NIMBY is part of a process of class warfare shunting poisons down on poorer people who are basically defenseless.
Carson was maligned viciously in the media.
She was considered a threat to National Security. 'The security of the arsenal of democracy would be threatened without DDT.'
She was demeaned as a woman. Science was considered a man's profession. Her credentials as a biologist were questioned.
She was attacked for encroaching on disciplines outside of her specialty.
What is most important, Rachel Carson raised the awareness that environment and personal health are inseparable. There does not seem to be this awareness in the article or most comments. Environmentalism, public health, and social justice have the same concerns and enemies.
arpip
"environmentalism, public health and social justice have the same concerns and enemies"
defining who and/or what is the enemy and then developing a strategy for countering it has been the preoccupation of progressives for decades. it isn't surprising that there seems to be a lack of consensus at the moment. the threats we face prompt a number of conflicting reactions in people - from denial to ecoterrorism to polite blogging and everything in between. short of a uniting influence, we will continue to be not much more than that oft maligned fly in the corporate soup. and every activist of supporter of the "environmental, public health and social justice" movement knows that our enemy is a carnivore! advice -
don't just hold out for better tasting soup.
become the chef!
Happy Birthday Rachel! In addition to teaching care and love beyond self, you taught regard for whole life. You exemplified and left to so many of us the wisdom and the process for how to make meaningful differences -- by standing strong for what needs to be envisioned without "ripping" and "alienating" those who have yet to see or know to see. If we are to make it through all this madness and folly we have created -- and continue to create, it will be because of our ability engage as many people as possible through partnerships. Hey, despite ourselves and our folly for power and ego -- all process is somehow interconnected and interdependent. It's how it all works -- and how we will have to work!
Thanks for the teaching and inspiration,
Jeffrey
The most dangerous environmental problem is that we the people allow companies to exploit our common good without cost and with license through legal theft with the help of the local, state and federal legislators and executives.
It is time that we legally condemn these companies and return the health and wealth to the common good whence it came.
Clear Lake: I LOVE your poem! I've been working on one for children, "Who stole the trees?" Can't believe the fools are still clear cutting here in North Florida, burning to make the ground green with grass or ready for "development." And Florida burns, and the rains don't come. The fireflies were magical this year... I felt welcomed INTO their villages as the thousands gathered for their annual reunion, holding "torches." It was a high to be inside THEIR world of pulsing electricity, the length and breadth of it along the Suwannee. So few places, often the outskirts, the final fringes, where life can still to its thing. Off Cedar Key is an island where frigate birds in their majestic wingspans fly all the way (without stopping, ain't no McDonalds along their 1000 plus mile pathway) to these offshore islands to mate, socialize and do whatever birds do. Sometimes when I bike into the forest I meet a deer or two. Look into their eyes of innocence and sometimes SAY that I apologize for what my kinid is doing to our shared world, the habitats we ALL need to live and thrive. Yes. The righteous ones in their blindness think in destroying Creation they are laying homage to their Creator, yet how easily those with sight recognize they have fallen for the counterfeit, and lay their reverence and treasure to THE destroyer. Again, thank you for sharing...
Frankly silent spring has just about arrived here in Wesern new York were I have lived for 40 years. Every Spring there are fewer and fewer birds returning to my 250 acres of just old scrub land. Today i saw one Bluebird and also one red wing black bird - when I first moved here there were dozends. the bobbolink is no longer rising in the fields at all and neither is the woodcock. We have no chemicals on this place but the birds come back from long trips and do not seem to survive well. Every winter also there are fewer birds to feed. I am the only one feeding in this valley and I used to ahve the whole porch full of bird poop. Now it is just a little bit of droppings. I put catstop bibs on my two cats to stop them from nabbing birds and it works.
One success story: a pair of catbirds have lived in the same bush near our porch all those 40 years. Well it is their offsprings that come back. Also the hummingbirds show up and demand their feeder- they seem to know me I swear and they too always breed in the same wild lilac bush.
Pray for a gentler lower consumer nation! We need to do what we can to turn the ship around: I am starting a local farmers market.- to stop trucking lettuce across the continent.
Happy birthday Rachel
All these many yrs. later
I turn a parking lot
to paradise
without drugs
kool
Ken
ps
Sorry not one bee yet
I think something has changed
n'
I don't know
I just don't know
Well, if others post a poem, so will I -
The Lords of Creation
My father used to call the bees
the Lords of Creation,
a Biblical rolling sound
he learned the truth of
in some boyhood field, perhaps
bringing cows through daisies
in for milking,
or plowing dandelions under in the
spring.
They kept a hive or two,
everybody did,
out by the orchard and the berry
bushes
and got good fruit every year,
not to mention honey.
And my grandmother tended
hollyhocks and morning glories
and all the other riotous blooms she
knew
to keep them home.
The Lords of Creation, now
getting scarce, I hear,
and if I were Mother Nature
I would notice that.
And I might make my choice
of keeping or letting go
in the only possible sensible way,
by carefully considering
just who is really useful in my world,
and who is not at all.
The link for the Rachel Carson Council:
http://members.aol.com/rccouncil/ourpage/
G.R.E.A.T. Activities for Individual Action
G - Gardening R - Recycling E - Energy use A - Aquatic (water use) T - Transportation
These GREAT activities positively impact the environment and save you money!
Gardening
Plant trees; increase "natural areas"; strive to have a "sustainable yard;" retain plant cuttings / leaves on-site and compost them; plant bird and butterfly-friendly gardens.
Recycling
Recycle glass, metal, newspapers, cardboard, and plastic. Compost leaves, yard waste / table scraps (non-meat only). Purchase items containing recycled materials. Re-use and recycle other items whenever possible.
Energy
Have an energy audit done on your home; insulate your home; reduce energy use whenever possible; turn out the lights when you leave a room; when replacing appliances purchase more efficient ones that use less energy, such as Energy Star appliances; replace incandescent bulbs with compact fluorescent bulbs.
Aquatic Use
Use rain barrels in the yard; install water efficient toilets and low-flow showerheads; use water responsibly. Energy Star dishwashers and washing machines use less water as well as saving energy.
Transportation
When possible, walk or bike rather than drive to reduce car usage; try to drive smoothly using moderate speeds; give your vehicle frequent check ups; when replacing it, consider fuel efficiency and hybrid vehicles.
Today are there no other Rachel Carsons out there?
Do we actualy believe that we do not have to get involved like she did?
Well then we might as well then burn every copy of Silent Spring.
A few have posted about the Missing Honey bees. Funny you hardly hear a thing about them from the News Media anymore.
I guess that proves there are only a few Rachels left in this world, And they are getting screamed down and shut up.
Imagine, if from Silent Spring till today what this world could have been like if we would have stuck following people Like Rachel Carson?
Speaking of Pesticides have you wash and rewashed your fresh store boughten Vegetables yet?
JonathanM - thanks for the specific tips. Moaning about the situation is good for the soul (I guess) but actually doing something about it is better for Mother Nature.
But I want to make a modest suggestion - uou mention dishwashers -I have made the Great Discovery (NEW! NEW!)that washing dishes IN THE SINK is a great water and energy saver. May even burn a few calories and be actually good for me as well as for Mother Nature.