Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Latest US Solution to Iraq's Civil War: A Three-Mile Wall
BAGHDAD -- A wall U.S. troops are building around a Sunni enclave in Baghdad came under increasing criticism on Saturday, with residents calling it "collective punishment" and a local leader saying construction began without the neighborhood council's approval.The U.S. military says the wall in Baghdad is meant to secure the minority Sunni community of Azamiyah, which "has been trapped in a spiral of sectarian violence and retaliation." The area, located on the eastern side of the Tigris River, would be completely gated, with entrances and exits manned by Iraqi soldiers, the U.S. military said earlier this week.
But some residents of the neighborhood, which is surrounded by Shiite areas, complained that they had not been consulted in advance about the barrier.
"This will make the whole district a prison. This is collective punishment on the residents of Azamiyah," said Ahmed al-Dulaimi, a 41-year-old engineer who lives in the area. "They are going to punish all of us because of a few terrorists here and there."
"We are in our fourth year of occupation and we are seeing the number of blast walls increasing day after day, suffocating the people more and more," al-Dulaimi said in an interview.
U.S. and Iraqi forces have long erected cement barriers around marketplaces and coalition bases and outposts in Baghdad and other Iraqi cities such as Ramadi in an effort to prevent attacks, including suicide car bombs. But the Azamiyah project appears to be the biggest effort ever to use a lengthy wall in Baghdad to break contact, and violence, between Sunnis and Shiites.
The U.S. strategy for stabilizing Iraq now involves persuading Iraqis to live in peace and support their democratically elected government and launching a security plan in the capital that calls for 28,000 additional American troops and thousands of Iraqi soldiers.
On Saturday, one American soldier was killed and two were wounded by a roadside bomb southwest of Baghdad, the military said. A separate roadside bombing, in Diwaniyah about 80 miles south of the capital, killed a Polish soldier late Friday.
Khalid Ibrahim, 45, said the Americans were working hard to divide Baghdad's neighborhoods - something he said he wasn't sure was a good thing.
"This is good if it is temporary, to help the area with security problems. But if this wall stays for the long term, it will be a catastrophe for the residents and will restrict our movements," said Ibrahim, an Azamiyah resident who works at the Interior Ministry.
The U.S. military says it began building the barrier April 10. AP Television News footage from the site on Saturday showed small concrete blocks, piles of dirt and coils of barbed wire on a main street. Eventually, the military said, the wall will be three miles long and include sections as tall as 12 feet.
Community leaders said Saturday that construction began before they had approved an American proposal for the wall.
"A few days ago, we met with the U.S. army unit in charge of Azamiyah and it asked us, as a local council, to sign a document to build a wall to reduce killing and attacks against Iraqi and U.S. forces," said Dawood al-Azami, the acting head of the Azamiyah council.
"I told the soldiers that I would not sign it unless I could talk to residents first. We told residents at Friday prayers, but our local council hasn't signed onto the project yet, and construction is already under way."
In other violence Saturday, two bullet-riddled dead bodies were discovered in Musayyib, about 40 miles south of Baghdad, police said. One of the bodies was found floating in the Euphrates River, and the other was discovered in a deserted area. Both victims had their hands and legs bound, and showed signs of torture, police said.
Australian Defense Minister Brendan Nelson paid an unannounced visit to Iraq and met with Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki to discuss the coalition's efforts to improve security in cities such as Baghdad, the government said.
Australia has about 1,400 troops in and around the country.
Al-Maliki and Nelson met at the prime minister's office in the capital's heavily fortified Green Zone, and al-Maliki "underlined that Iraqi forces are unified in battling terrorists and outlaws, and are now fighting shoulder to shoulder throughout Iraq," especially in hard-hit areas such as Baghdad and the provinces of Anbar, west of the capital, and Diyala, to the northeast, a government statement said.
© 2007 The Associated Press.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

34 Comments so far
Show AllWalls are the wealthy's ill fated answer to violence. Don't they live in "gated communities"?
It seems the only direction the US and Israel are willing move is towards greater and more alienating violence. Rather than resolve their conflicts with Arabs, rather than stop their own illegal occupations and land theft, rather than submit their expansionist policies to the requirements of international law, they opt for crushing, subduing, eliminating, and dismembering their "enemies"--that is, anyone who resists their myriad forms of state terrorism. This wall, like the one Israel is now using to steal even more Palestinian territory, will not work. Funny we don't hear Ronald Reagan's "tear down that wall" phrase coming out of any Republican mouths.
fedupwithpolitics April 21st, 2007 11:28 am
"Funny we don't hear Ronald Reagan's "tear down that wall" phrase coming out of any Republican mouths."
No, what we're hearing is: "Build up that wall corporate Halliburton."
"I'm a divider, not a uniter"
The Shia and Sunni are united in one respect: The majority believe the American presence is making things worse. How can we justify an occupation in the face of this. We are imposing it against the democratic will of the Iraqi people. This is an action that is fundamentally anti-democratic.
A wall, another disgraceful symbol of US mismanagement. This wall was constructed to play Sunni and Shia off one another and possibly another pathetic attempt to disrupt the "insurgency." If a side effect of the wall spikes or surges violence a bit, that's ok for the US brutalists.
Wow it must really be awful for the average Iraqi right now. If I was the average Iraqi I would study up on concrete demolition. The mafia loves rebar, cement, sand and gravel. So, for the price of a Kuwati's Ferrari, you could have 100s of average Joes in Iraq "YouTube"-ing these wonderful images of resistance (a la the Berlin Wall) for the whole world to see, and no one gets hurt. Just good ol' protest demolition.
The WALL symbolizes the Bush Administrations undeniable, abject and absolute FAILURE....
It also exemplifies the total lack of acknowledgment, understanding and interpretation of Iraq's complicated political history, if there was any attempt at all in the first instance. Since it was all about control and domination of Iraq's OIL....
Talk about ad hoc policy on the run....
It's a "bloody" disgrace....
I was laboring under the impression that military strategists are supposed to be well versed in history. I'm trying to come up with one single example of a "wall" which proved effective. Not the "Great Wall", not Hadrian's wall, Not the Berlin Wall (it was the minefields, barbed wire, machine guns and snipers that made that wall work), certainly not the U.S.-Mexico border. So after four years of horror, this is the best they can come up with...
The word Ghetto comes to mind...
Wow! What a mind-boggling step toward "victory in Iraq." George & Co. just can't come up with anything better? Apparently not. This cause was lost before it began.
The Israeli influence on the Bush Administration military strategies and foreign policies is alarming! What a shame that above the din of these two callous and criminal administrations the voices of moderate Israelis can never be heard, thank you the corporate media.
I'm sure Baghdad ghettos in addition to the Gaza ghetto will be helpful in winning the so-called war on terrorism, just keep pushing ordinary people to see how far they will go before they turn to desperate means.
It is so urgent to impeach Bush and Cheney and stop these horrors!
Please write or call your national representatives/senators at least once a week - telling them to Impeach the whole Bush regime - over and over again til those masters of horror & deception are out of our white house!
Just the latest in a series of very bad, very ineffective, unproductive ideas. So stupid. The box of rocks deserves that degree that W got from Yale. Truly, you could not do worse if I were running the country.
And then there's the MegaWall to seal off the US from Mexico--another country with brown people in it.
A couple weeks ago I read in the Mexican press that the company that built the segment going east from Tijuana was fined millions of dollars because that wall was built by--you guessed it--undocumented Mexican workers.
Everybody is laughing here in Mexico about how much the undocumented workers are going to make building the MegaWall to keep themselves out....
Join the dots....
Project Blue Beam
HAARP
Chemtrails
FEMA Prison Camps
Poisons and toxins in food and drink
So-called Vaccinations
Brain Drugs/Bad Medication
VeraChip RFID
Mind Control
Subliminal Messages
Division
Endless Wars
Corporate Greed
Raping of the planet
= The end of the world.
The mind boggles at this...
Don't believe anything but what your own minds tells you. Look at all the pieces and join them together, and this is what we faced with a small number of greed filled psychopaths leading us all to our demise.
Let's join together as one and resonate our love as one to help heal the world right now, love is the only force which is capable of nurturing and growth and we owe it not just to ourselves but to our beautiful home our mother Earth and everything we co-exist here with. Love conquers all.
Everybody print a sign in 72 point bold letters for the back window of your vehicle--it should read:
Impeach Gonzalez first
Cheney, Next,
Then Bush.
Just do it and keep to the slow lane in traffic as much as possible. you will make new friends and so far I have yet to have any angry retorts and this in a place that gave Bushco very comfortable majorities in both elections. Really just do it and let's use the power of repeated exposure to a single message to galvanize public support for the removal of these crazies.
Why not just put the Sunnis in concentration camps, or how about internment camps? Better yet, why not put them in the Green Zone?
Whoever said that the Israelis couldn't teach us anything about managing conflicts was obviously quite wrong..
The cement ghetto technique. Obviously an Israeli idea.
Now all we have to do is build a wall around all loner students and another crisis will be averted.
Ninety years ago Robert Frost wrote the "Mending Wall". I read it forty years ago. Based on it I never had a wall on my property, probably never will. When I am buried there will be a fence but I am not sure why. Now the DOD has become the Dept of Da-Fence. This wall as the war is senseless.
Bill B
I would like to see a wall built completely around the United States. Not to keep the terrorists out but to keep you freaks in.
The Nazis tried something similar in Poland.
History has shown that walls do not work and have always been used to keep out undesirables or ideas that conflict with a fading empire.
The arrogance of the Americans is breathtaking. Straight out of the Israeli Army handbook for 'winning hearts and minds.' One can only ponder the American response should that nation have been invaded and occupied and subjected to the same thing. Who on earth do they think they are? Do they think at all? One begins to wonder. The level of arrogance, ignorance and incompetence demonstrated by the US from the very beginning of this exercise beggars belief. Then again, they had a reputation for the same thing during the Second World War it is just that the American myth machine has managed to paper over it. With every step the US seems to proclaim to the world that they are utter incompetents and have more power than intelligence or honour for that matter. How many bombs does it take to bring down a wall? How many bombs does it take for America to understand that no-one wants to be occupied? Sadly, probably far too many for all those of reason who believe in peace.
Ghetto is right. More precisely Warsaw ghetto. It is just a matter of time before the musicians are on the street trying to make a living. What difference a distant world war can make.
corrim.org reports that concrete walls, used extensively in warm climate residential building, consumes 12 times the fossil fuel as lumber walls. Now if you look into it, you will likely find that concrete consumption in the U.S. is rising. They are still expanding the number of freeway lanes after it has become clear that this only increases the volume of traffic. River cities that used to mix a majority percentage of river rock in their street concrete have stopped using the river rock. They vastly increased the percentage of cement, which is the ultra high energy ingredient in concrete. The river rock lobby lost the battle with the fossil fuel lobby.
Google: Prescott Bush Nazi.
I'm sure the Bush family knows where the plans for the ovens are too.
What the wall will do is create a series of checkpoints where whole squads of US and Iraqi troops can be picked off at will by the resistance. More great thinking from the people who brought you other glorious military victories such Vietnam.
More seriously, the creation of the ghetto, although a severe psychological problem, is also a huge physical threat. The Germans did not create the Warsaw Ghetto to keep the Jews in. They did it to create a mass deportation camp, and although it is not widely known the ghetto served as a concentration camp for some of the war. Israel - seemingly after receiving an historical-irony bypass - have built the wall in Palestine not to keep suicide bombers in but to control a massive civilian population in, a population that represents a potential threat because you cannot keep under occupation millions of people wthout them one day rising up (Now if you Israeli generals ahd bothered to read about the Warsaw Ghetto uprising...)
The US do not have the cold efficiency of either the nazis or the Israelis. Although I don't expect the US troops to start a pogrom against the Sunni ghetto, they also do not control the rest of Baghdad. You could have on eof any situation develop: Sunni resistance builds a new army within the heart of Baghdad, from where it is easy to create chaos; the Shia controlled government could orders the "suppression" of Sunni fighteres in the ghetto; inter-community rioting could spread into the ghetto where the population are a captive audience ready to be slaughtered; US troops suffer a 1983 Beirut style attack from the Sunni resistance and go into the ghetto in revenge. Civilians in any of those situations are trapped by the fact they are held in a ghetto. If the US military is using Israeli tactics then they might well use their Sabra and Chatilla tactics which lead to 2000 civilians being slaughtered in September 1982.
There is an interesting article about walls/fences in National Geographic this month. It talks mainly about the fences being built in Calif., Arizona and Texas to keep out immigrants. Although it is not really about the Baghdad wall, it talks about how the border fences are inherently flawed - it compares it to the Great Wall of China, The Israeli Apartheid wall, the Berlin wall and Australia's rabbit-proof fence. It compares it closely to the stupidity of Israel's Apartheid fence - "it is designed to control people, but it faces the problems of all walls - rockets can go over it, tunnels can go under it. It offends people, it comforts people, it fails to deliver security. And it keeps expanding."
I like the last comment - these fences keep expanding and not just literally. The IDEA of fences and walls - the anathema of freedom not even a single generation ago - is now expanding in the post 9/11 world, becoming the cure-for-all. It is the perfect crystallised paradign of what it looks like when someone takes a completely useless, failed, disasterous idea and says, "Hey this great! Let's use it everywhere: Palestine, Baghdad, Texas." After all, it kept half of Australia free of rabbits, saved Communism and stopped Hamas as a political force...
There's an interesting in this month's National Geographic about walls and fences, with specific reference to the US border fences in Texas, Arizona and California. It compares them with the Great Wall of China, , the Berlin Wall, Israel's Apartheid Wall, Australia's Rabbit-Proof Fence. These were ultimately failures, according to the article. (I don't agree that the Chinese Great Wall was a failure as it was not designed to keep invaders out, but to stop raids by bandit armies, the wall itself being designed to stop robber groups bringing plunder OUT of China) Even less than a generation ago the Wall was seen as an anathema to freedom.
The article compares The American border fence closely with the failed Israel Apartheid Wall – "it is designed to control the movement of people, but it faces the problem of all walls – rockets can go over it, tunnels can go under it. It offends people, it comforts people, it fails to deliver security. And it keeps expanding."
I find the last sentence particularly interesting. Fences and walls ARE expanding - as a tactic used by power elites. It is a tactic which should give us all hope because it is the perfectly crystallised paradigm of taking an idea that is failed, useless and disastrous and saying "Hey this is a great idea! Let's use it everywhere!" After all, it saved Communism, kept half of Australia free of rabbits, has stopped 100% of immigration into the States from Mexico and stopped Hamas as a political force, right?
Almost 30 yeas ago, Ronald Reagan stood at the Brandenburg Gate in Berlin and famously said, "Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall!" Today we have Israel Building a wall to keep people in and out of the stolen territory by Israel. In the USA, we have the ridiculous idea of a 700 mile long wall being built to keep people out.
One would think that a country devoted to the virtues of a free market and democracy should feel should believe that individual movement should be governed by the market. That is the most recent excuse for the invasion, anyway. What they really believe is that capitol and goods should move freely, not people.
As for their effectiveness, walls are effective in the short run to keep many, but not all, people in or out. But in the middle run, walls are politically charged symbols and magnify injustice and so prolong the problem rather than solve anything. One thing that can be said about walls is that they are neither friendly nor a sign of freedom. I don't remember Saddam Hussein building any walls.
Chalk it up as just one more in a long string of dumb ideas from the Bush administration.
First they build the ghettoes, then they liquidate the ghettoes. Everything in history happens twwiece, the first time as tragedy, the second as farce . . .
There are many Iraqis including those in our puppet regime who want a united Iraq. How can that be accomplished if it is composed of walled off ghettoes? Apparently a united Iraq is no longer what the US supports.
Look at the social conservative: stolid, unimaginative, untrustworthy, guilty of everything she professes to despise in others, compared to liberals not very intelligent. Who would choose such an existence?
22poor, I think the gated community is another tactical error as the rest of us can go along in the middle of the night and brick up all the entrances.